arXiv subjects
Publications and source records attributed to George Barmpalias.
These open problems were presented in the Problem Sessions held during the Tianyuan Workshop on Definability and Computation, June 22-26, 2026. The problems are organized into sections named after their contributors, in the order of their presentations during the workshop. Notes were taken and compiled by Wei Dai, Xiangxi Hu, Yingying Jiang, Ruiwen Li, Tianhao Wang, Xu Wang, and Jie Zou.
An approximation of a real is a sequence of rational numbers that converges to the real. An approximation is left-c.e. if it is computable and nondecreasing and is d.c.e. if it is computable and has bounded variation. A real is computably approximable if it has some computable approximation, and left-c.e. and d.c.e. reals are defined accordingly. An approximation $\{a_s\}_{s \in ω}$ is speedable if there exists a nondecreasing computable function $f$ such that the approximation $\{a_{f(s)}\}_{s \in ω}$ converges in a certain formal sense faster than $\{a_s\}_{s \in ω}$. This leads to various notions of speedability for reals, e.g., one may require for a computably approximable real that either all or some of its approximations of a specific type are speedable. Merkle and Titov established the equivalence of several speedability notions for left-c.e. reals that are defined in terms of left-c.e. approximations. We extend these results to d.c.e. reals and d.c.e. approximations, and we prove that in this setting, being speedable is equivalent to not being Martin-Löf random. Finally, we demonstrate that every computably approximable real has a computable approximation that is speedable.
Arranging the bits of a random string or real into k columns of a two-dimensional array or higher dimensional structure is typically accompanied with loss in the Kolmogorov complexity of the columns, which depends on k. We quantify and characterize this phenomenon for arrays and trees and its relationship to negligible classes.
We study the complexity of deterministic and probabilistic inversions of partial computable functions on the reals.
A major open problem in computational complexity is the existence of a one-way function, namely a function from strings to strings which is computationally easy to compute but hard to invert. Levin (2023) formulated the notion of one-way functions from reals (infinite bit-sequences) to reals in terms of computability, and asked whether partial computable one-way functions exist. We give a strong positive answer using the hardness of the halting problem and exhibiting a total computable one-way function.
These open problems were presented in the Problem Sessions held during the Tianyuan Workshop on Computability Theory and Descriptive Set Theory, June 16-20, 2025. The problems are organized into sections named after their contributors, in the order of their presentations during the workshop. Notes were taken and compiled by Wei Dai, Feng Li, Ruiwen Li, Ming Xiao, Xu Wang, Víctor Hugo Yañez Salazar, and Yang Zheng.
We study the compressibility of enumerations in the context of Kolmogorov complexity, focusing on strong and weak forms of compression and their gain: the amount of auxiliary information embedded in the compressed enumeration. The existence of strong compression and weak gainless compression is shown for any computably enumerable (c.e.) set. The density problem of c.e. sets with respect to their prefix complexity is reduced to the question of whether every c.e. set is well-compressible, which we study via enumeration games.
Oneway real functions are effective maps on positive-measure sets of reals that preserve randomness and have no effective probabilistic inversions. We construct a oneway real function which is collision-resistant: the probability of effectively producing distinct reals with the same image is zero, and each real has uncountable inverse image.
A tree is pathwise-random if all of its paths are Martin-Lof random. We show that (a) no weakly 2-random real computes a perfect pathwise-random tree; it follows that the class of perfect pathwise-random trees is null, with respect to any computable measure; (b) there exists a positive-measure pathwise-random tree which does not compute any complete extension of Peano arithmetic; and (c) there exists a perfect pathwise-random tree which does not compute any tree of positive measure and finite randomness deficiency. We then obtain models of second-order arithmetic that separate compactness principles below weak Konigs lemma, answering questions by Chong et al.(2019).
We study effective randomness-preserving transformations of path-incompressible trees. Some path-incompressible trees with infinitely many paths do not compute perfect path-random trees with computable oracle-use. Sparse perfect path-incompressible trees can be effectively densified, almost surely. We characterize the branching density of path-random trees.
Leonid Levin (arxiv.org/abs/cs/0503039v14, p.7) published a new (and very nice) proof of Gács-Kučera's theorem that occupies only a few lines when presented in his style. We try to explain more details and discuss the connection of this proof with image randomness theorems, making explicit some result (see Proposition 4) that is implicit in Levin's exposition. Then we review the previous work about the oracle use when reducing a given sequence to another one, and its connection with algorithmic dimension theory.
We show that degrees containing a complete extensions of arithmetic have the random join property: they are the supremum of any random real they compute, with another random real. The same is true for the truth-table and weak truth-table reducibilities.
We study the problem of whether a betting-strategy can be decomposed into an equivalent set of simpler betting-strategies, such as betting-strategies that bet on a restricted set of stages or bet on a restricted of favorable outcomes. We show that the class of effectively enumerable betting-strategies has irreducible members which cannot be decomposed into an equivalent set of simpler betting-strategies. We answer questions of Kastermans and Hitchcock by constructing a real on which no kastergale (which is a left-c.e. supermartingale whose favorable outcomes are effectively determined) succeeds, but some unrestricted left-c.e. supermartingale succeeds on it. We generalize a result of Muchnick by showing that there is a non-1-random real such that no muchgale (which is a left-c.e. supermartingale who does not bet on certain stages) succeeds on it. Our methodology is then used to obtain further irreducibility results, strongly supporting a conjecture that if a natural class of left-c.e. supermartingales defines 1-randomness, then a single member of that class can do so. In another word, the class of left-c.e. supermartingales cannot be reduced to a simpler, natural subclass of it. For example, we show that there is a non-1-random real such that no kastergale or muchgale succeeds on it.
Muchnik's paradox says that enumerable betting strategies are not always reducible to enumerable strategies whose bets are restricted to either even rounds or odd rounds. In other words, there are outcome sequences x where an effectively enumerable strategy succeeds, but no such parity-restricted effectively enumerable strategy does. We characterize the effective Hausdorff dimension of such $x$, showing that it can be as low as 1/2 but not less. We also show that such reals that are random with respect to parity-restricted effectively enumerable strategies with packing dimension as low as $\log\sqrt3$. Finally we exhibit Muchnik's paradox in the case of computable integer-valued strategies.
In a casino where arbitrarily small bets are admissible, any betting strategy M can be modified into a savings strategy that, not only is successful on each casino sequence where M is (thus accumulating unbounded wealth inside the casino) but also saves an unbounded capital, by permanently and gradually withdrawing it from the game. Teutsch showed that this is no longer the case when a fixed minimum wager is imposed by the casino, thus exemplifying a savings paradox where a player can win unbounded wealth inside the casino, but upon withdrawing a sufficiently large amount out of the game, he is forced into bankruptcy. We study the potential for saving under a shrinking minimum wager rule (granularity) and its dependence on the rate of decrease (inflation) as well as timid versus bold play.
Suppose that the outcomes of a roulette table are not entirely random, in the sense that there exists a successful betting strategy. Is there a successful `separable' strategy, in the sense that it does not use the winnings from betting on red in order to bet on black, and vice-versa? We study this question from an algorithmic point of view and observe that every strategy $M$ can be replaced by a separable strategy which is computable from $M$ and successful on any outcome-sequence where $M$ is successful. We then consider the case of mixtures and show: (a) there exists an effective mixture of separable strategies which succeeds on every casino sequence with effective Hausdorff dimension less than 1/2; (b) there exists a casino sequence of effective Hausdorff dimension 1/2 on which no effective mixture of separable strategies succeeds. Finally we extend (b) to a more general class of strategies.
According to Kolmogorov complexity, every finite binary string is compressible to a shortest code -- its information content -- from which it is effectively recoverable. We investigate the extent to which this holds for infinite binary sequences (streams). We devise a new coding method which uniformly codes every stream $X$ into an algorithmically random stream $Y$, in such a way that the first $n$ bits of $X$ are recoverable from the first $I(X\upharpoonright_n)$ bits of $Y$, where $I$ is any partial computable information content measure which is defined on all prefixes of $X$, and where $X\upharpoonright_n$ is the initial segment of $X$ of length $n$. As a consequence, if $g$ is any computable upper bound on the initial segment prefix-free complexity of $X$, then $X$ is computable from an algorithmically random $Y$ with oracle-use at most $g$. Alternatively (making no use of such a computable bound $g$) one can achieve an oracle-use bounded above by $K(X\upharpoonright_n)+\log n$. This provides a strong analogue of Shannon's source coding theorem for algorithmic information theory.
We introduce the \emph{idemetric} property, which formalises the idea that most nodes in a graph have similar distances between them, and which turns out to be quite standard amongst small-world network models. Modulo reasonable sparsity assumptions, we are then able to show that a strong form of idemetricity is actually equivalent to a very weak expander condition (PUMP). This provides a direct way of providing short proofs that small-world network models such as the Watts-Strogatz model are strongly idemetric (for a wide range of parameters), and also provides further evidence that being idemetric is a common property. We then consider how satisfaction of the idemetric property is relevant to algorithm design. For idemetric graphs we observe, for example, that a single breadth-first search provides a solution to the all-pairs shortest paths problem, so long as one is prepared to accept paths which are of stretch close to 2 with high probability. Since we are able to show that Kleinberg's model is idemetric, these results contrast nicely with the well known negative results of Kleinberg concerning efficient decentralised algorithms for finding short paths: for precisely the same model as Kleinberg's negative results hold, we are able to show that very efficient (and decentralised) algorithms exist if one allows for reasonable preprocessing. For deterministic distributed routing algorithms we are also able to obtain results proving that less routing information is required for idemetric graphs than the worst case in order to achieve stretch less than 3 with high probability: while $Ω(n^2)$ routing information is required in the worst case for stretch strictly less than 3 on almost all pairs, for idemetric graphs the total routing information required is $O(nlog(n))$.