Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Gil Kalai

Publications and source records attributed to Gil Kalai.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Möbius-Pseudorandomness for Algebraic Circuits

We define a notion of Möbius-pseudorandomness for integer sequences generated by multivariate polynomials computed by small and simple algebraic circuits. This mirrors a related definition of Kalai that concerns boolean functions computed by small boolean circuits. We then prove Möbius-pseudorandomness results for polynomials computed by algebraic circuits with few multiplication gates (of any depth), for polynomials with small-dimensional partial derivative space, and for the determinant and permanent. We conjecture that these results hold in general for polynomial-size algebraic circuits.

cs.CC↗

Analysis of asymmetric errors in NISQ experiments

This paper continues our analysis of NISQ experiments and especially the Google 2019 ``quantum supremacy" experiment. In arXiv:2008.05177 we proposed statistical tools to analyze symmetric and asymmetric readout errors, and the symmetric case was extensively developed and studied in arXiv:2404.00935, where we used Fourier methods combined with statistical tools. Here we extend and complement our earlier study and analyze asymmetric readout errors for data from experiments and simulations. Our study was further motivated by a paper by Fefferman et al. arXiv:2306.16659, who showed that the effect of amplitude damping gate errors is to have larger fractions of zeroes in the samples produced by the quantum computer. We show that this effect of gate errors is not observed in the Google experimental data, where, for the entire range of the number of qubits, $12 \le n \le 53$, the fraction of zeroes and ones reflects only the asymmetry of reported readout errors, and report on simulations with $n=12,14$ using IBM's and Google's simulators.

quant-ph↗

The Fully Depolarizing Noise Conjecture for Entangled Physical States: A Twenty-Year Perspective

In this paper I revisit my 2006 conjecture on correlated errors in entangled physical qubits, originally proposed as a potential obstruction to quantum fault tolerance. The conjecture asserts that, in any physical implementation of a quantum computer, the effective noise channel acting on entangled physical qubits contains a joint fully depolarizing component, with a rate comparable to that of two-qubit gate errors. This hypothesized structural constraint goes beyond standard noise models and, if valid, would pose a significant challenge to scalable quantum fault tolerance. The conjecture remains open, but recent advances in experimental quantum computing bring it within reach of empirical testing on current devices. I also discuss two related directions in my critical study of quantum computation: the role of noise sensitivity and computational complexity in noisy intermediate-scale quantum systems, and the statistical analysis of experimental claims of quantum advantage. Finally, since this paper is written for a volume honoring Yuri Gurevich, I include some reflections on the ways in which my scientific and personal trajectory became intertwined with Yuri's.

quant-ph↗

Further Statistical Study of NISQ Experiments

We revisit and extend some topics that we studied in our previous works (Rinott, Kalai and Shoham 2022; Kalai, Rinott and Shoham, 2023,2024) regarding the Google 2019 "quantum supremacy" experiment. We extend our analysis of the prediction based on Google's digital error model (Formula (77)), based on more detailed data provided by Google. We also provide some preliminary analysis for a few other NISQ experiments.

quant-ph↗

Unimodality for Radon partitions of random vectors

Consider the (almost surely) unique Radon partition of a set of $n$ random Gaussian vectors in $\mathbb R^{n-2}$; choose one of the two parts of this partition uniformly at random, and for $0 \le k \le n$, let $p_k$ denote the probability that it has size $k$. In this paper, we prove strong unimodality results for the distribution $(p_0,\dots,p_n)$.

math.CO↗

On Shapley Values and Threshold Intervals

Let $f\colon \{0,1\}^n\to \{0,1\}$ be a monotone Boolean functions, let $ψ_k(f)$ denote the Shapley value of the $k$th variable and $b_k(f)$ denote the Banzhaf value (influence) of the $k$th variable. We prove that if we have $ψ_k(f) \le t$ for all $k$, then the threshold interval of $f$ has length $\displaystyle O \left(\frac {1}{\log (1/t)}\right)$. We also prove that if $f$ is balanced and $b_k(f) \le t$ for every $k$, then $\displaystyle \max_{k} ψ_k(f) \le O\left(\frac {\log \log (1/t)}{\log(1/t)}\right) $.

math.CO↗

A Dense Model Theorem for the Boolean Slice

The (low soundness) linearity testing problem for the middle slice of the Boolean cube is as follows. Let $\varepsilon>0$ and $f$ be a function on the middle slice on the Boolean cube, such that when choosing a uniformly random quadruple $(x,y,z ,x\oplus y\oplus z)$ of vectors of $2n$ bits with exactly $n$ ones, the probability that $f(x\oplus y \oplus z) = f(x) \oplus f(y) \oplus f(z)$ is at least $1/2+\varepsilon$. The linearity testing problem, posed by David, Dinur, Goldenberg, Kindler and Shinkar, asks whether there must be an actual linear function that agrees with $f$ on $1/2+\varepsilon'$ fraction of the inputs, where $\varepsilon' = \varepsilon'(\varepsilon)>0$. We solve this problem, showing that $f$ must indeed be correlated with a linear function. To do so, we prove a dense model theorem for the middle slice of the Boolean hypercube for Gowers uniformity norms. Specifically, we show that for every $k\in\mathbb{N}$, the normalized indicator function of the middle slice of the Boolean hypercube $\{0,1\}^{2n}$ is close in Gowers norm to the normalized indicator function of the union of all slices with weight $t = n\pmod{2^{k-1}}$. Using our techniques we also give a more general `low degree test' and a biased rank theorem for the slice.

math.CO↗

Random Circuit Sampling: Fourier Expansion and Statistics

Considerable effort in experimental quantum computing is devoted to noisy intermediate scale quantum computers (NISQ computers). Understanding the effect of noise is important for various aspects of this endeavor including notable claims for achieving quantum supremacy and attempts to demonstrate quantum error correcting codes. In this paper we use Fourier methods combined with statistical analysis to study the effect of noise. In particular, we use Fourier analysis to refine the linear cross-entropy fidelity estimator. We use both analytical methods and simulations to study the effect of readout and gate errors, and we use our analysis to study the samples of Google's 2019 quantum supremacy experiment.

quant-ph↗

The success probability in Levine's hat problem, and independent sets in graphs

Lionel Levine's hat challenge has $t$ players, each with a (very large, or infinite) stack of hats on their head, each hat independently colored at random black or white. The players are allowed to coordinate before the random colors are chosen, but not after. Each player sees all hats except for those on her own head. They then proceed to simultaneously try and each pick a black hat from their respective stacks. They are proclaimed successful only if they are all correct. Levine's conjecture is that the success probability tends to zero when the number of players grows. We prove that this success probability is strictly decreasing in the number of players, and present some connections to problems in graph theory: relating the size of the largest independent set in a graph and in a random induced subgraph of it, and bounding the size of a set of vertices intersecting every maximum-size independent set in a graph.

math.CO↗

Questions and Concerns About Google's Quantum Supremacy Claim

In October 2019, Nature published a paper [6] describing an experimental work that was performed at Google. The paper claims to demonstrate quantum (computational) supremacy on a 53-qubit quantum computer. Since then we have been involved in a long-term project to study various statistical aspects of the Google experiment. In [30] we studied Google's statistical framework that we found to be very sound and offered some technical improvements. This document describes three main concerns (based on statistical analysis) about the Google 2019 experiment. The first concern is that the data do not agree with Google's noise model (or any other specific model). The second concern is that a crucial simple formula for a priori estimation of the fidelity seems to involve an unexpected independence assumption, and yet it gives very accurate predictions. The third concern is about statistical properties of the calibration process.

quant-ph↗

Google's Quantum Supremacy Claim: Data, Documentation, and Discussion

In October 2019, Nature published a paper describing an experiment that took place at Google. The paper claims to demonstrate quantum (computational) supremacy on a 53-qubit quantum computer. Since September 2019 we have been involved in a long-term project to study various statistical aspects of the Google experiment. We have been trying to gather the relevant data and information in order to reconstruct and verify those parts of the Google experiment that are based on classical computations (except when the required computation is too heavy), and to perform a statistical analysis on the data. This document describes the available data and information for the Google experiment, some main questions in the evaluation of the experiment, and some of our results and plans.

quant-ph↗

Conjecture C Still Stands

More than ten years ago the author described a parameter $K(ρ)$ for the complexity of $n$-qubit quantum state $ρ$ and raised the conjecture (referred to as "Conjecture C") that when this parameter is superpolynomial in $n$, the state $ρ$ is not experimentally feasible (and will not be experimentally achieved without quantum fault-tolerance). Shortly afterward [6] (arXiv:1204.3404), Steve Flammia and Aram Harrow claimed that the simple easy-to-construct $W$ states are counterexamples to "Conjecture C." We point out that Flammia and Harrow's argument regarding $W$-states is incomplete. Moreover, the emergent picture from experimental progress of the past decade on noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) computers suggests that $W$-states, as simple as they appear, cannot be achieved experimentally by NISQ computers, and can not be constructed without quantum fault-tolerance.

quant-ph↗

On symmetric intersecting families

We make some progress on a question of Babai from the 1970s, namely: for $n, k \in \mathbb{N}$ with $k \le n/2$, what is the largest possible cardinality $s(n,k)$ of an intersecting family of $k$-element subsets of $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ admitting a transitive group of automorphisms? We give upper and lower bounds for $s(n,k)$, and show in particular that $s(n,k) = o (\binom{n-1}{k-1})$ as $n \to \infty$ if and only if $k = n/2 - ω(n)(n/\log n)$ for some function $ω(\cdot)$ that increases without bound, thereby determining the threshold at which `symmetric' intersecting families are negligibly small compared to the maximum-sized intersecting families. We also exhibit connections to some basic questions in group theory and additive number theory, and pose a number of problems.

math.CO↗

Helly-type Problems

In this paper, we present a variety of problems in the interface between combinatorics and geometry around the theorems of Helly, Radon, Carathéodory, and Tverberg. Through these problems we describe the fascinating area of Helly-type theorems, and explain some of its main themes and goals.

math.CO↗