arXiv subjects
Publications and source records attributed to Giovanni Amelino-Camelia.
The spectroscopic regularities of modern empirical data on the non-strange mesons up to 2.4 GeV can be summarized as a systematic clustering of states near certain values of energy. It is getting evident that some unknown X-symmetry triggers the phenomenon. We review the experimental status of this symmetry and recent theoretical attempts put forward for explanation of broad degeneracy.
"Doubly-special relativity" (DSR), the idea of a Planck-scale Minkowski limit that is still a relativistic theory, but with both the Planck scale and the speed-of-light scale as nontrivial relativistic invariants, was proposed (gr-qc/0012051) as a physics intuition for several scenarios which may arise in the study of the quantum-gravity problem, but most DSR studies focused exclusively on the search of formalisms for the description of a specific example of such a Minkowski limit. A novel contribution to the DSR physics intuition came from a recent paper by Smolin (hep-th/0501091) suggesting that the emergence of the Planck scale as a second nontrivial relativistic invariant might be inevitable in quantum gravity, relying only on some rather robust expectations concerning the semiclassical approximation of quantum gravity. I here attempt to strengthen Smolin's argument by observing that an analysis of some independently-proposed Planck-scale particle-localization limits, such as the "Generalized Uncertainty Principle" often attributed to string theory in the literature, also suggests that the emergence of a DSR Minkowski limit might be inevitable. I discuss a possible link between this observation and recent results on logarithmic corrections to the entropy-area black-hole formula, and I observe that both the analysis here reported and Smolin's analysis appear to suggest that the examples of DSR Minkowski limits for which a formalism has been sought in the literature might not be sufficiently general. I also stress that, as we now contemplate the hypothesis of a DSR Minkowski limit, there is an additional challenge for those in the quantum-gravity community attributing to the Planck length the role of "fundamental length scale".
Gamma-ray bursts and ultra-high-energy cosmic rays provide an important testing ground for fundamental physics. A simple-minded analysis of some gamma-ray bursts would lead to a huge estimate of the overall energy emitted, and this represents a potential challenge for modelling the bursts. Some cosmic rays have been observed with extremely high energies, and it is not easy to envision mechanisms for the acceleration of particles to such high energies. Surprisingly some other aspects of the analysis of gamma-ray bursts and ultra-high-energy cosmic rays, even before reaching a full understanding of the mechanisms that generate them, can already be used to explore new ideas in fundamental physics, particularly for what concerns the structure of spacetime at short (Planckian) distance scales.
In several approaches to the quantum-gravity problem evidence has emerged of the validity of a "GUP" (a Generalized position-momentum Uncertainty Principle) and/or a "MDR" (a modification of the energy-momentum dispersion relation), but very little is known about the implications of GUPs and MDRs for black-hole thermodynamics, another key topic for quantum-gravity research. We investigate an apparent link, already suggested in an earlier exploratory study involving two of us, between the possibility of a GUP and/or a MDR and the possibility of a log term in the area-entropy black-hole formula. We then obtain, from that same perspective, a modified relation between the mass of a black hole and its temperature, and we examine the validity of the "Generalized Second Law of black-hole thermodynamics" in theories with a GUP and/or a MDR. After an analysis of GUP- and MDR-modifications of the black-body radiation spectrum, we conclude the study with a description of the black-hole evaporation process.
An insightful argument for a linear relation between the entropy and the area of a black hole was given by Bekenstein using only the energy-momentum dispersion relation, the uncertainty principle, and some properties of classical black holes. Recent analyses within String Theory and Loop Quantum Gravity describe black-hole entropy in terms of a dominant contribution, which indeed depends linearly on the area, and a leading log-area correction. We argue that, by reversing the Bekenstein argument, the log-area correction can provide insight on the energy-momentum dispersion relation and the uncertainty principle of a quantum-gravity theory. As examples we consider the energy-momentum dispersion relations that recently emerged in the Loop Quantum Gravity literature and the Generalized Uncertainty Principle that is expected to hold in String Theory.
After a brief review of the first phase of development of Quantum-Gravity Phenomenology, I argue that this research line is now ready to enter a more advanced phase: while at first it was legitimate to resort to heuristic order-of-magnitude estimates, which were sufficient to establish that sensitivity to Planck-scale effects can be achieved, we should now rely on detailed analyses of some reference test theories. I illustrate this point in the specific example of studies of Planck-scale modifications of the energy/momentum dispersion relation, for which I consider two test theories. Both the photon-stability analyses and the Crab-nebula synchrotron-radiation analyses, which had raised high hopes of ``beyond-Plankian'' experimental bounds, turn out to be rather ineffective in constraining the two test theories. Examples of analyses which can provide constraints of rather wide applicability are the so-called ``time-of-flight analyses'', in the context of observations of gamma-ray bursts, and the analyses of the cosmic-ray spectrum near the GZK scale.
In the quantum-gravity literature there has been interest in the possibility that quantum properties of spacetime might affect the energy/momentum dispersion relation. The most used test theory for data analysis is based on a modification of the laws of propagation proposed in astro-ph/9712103 [Nature 393,763], and the present best limit on the quantum-gravity scale was obtained in gr-qc/9810044 [Phys.Rev.Lett.83,2108]. I derive an improved limit using recent experimental information on absorption by the infrared diffuse extragalactic background of $γ$-rays emitted by blazars. Foreseeable more accurate determinations of the absorption levels could achieve Planck-scale sensitivity. As a corollary I also show that, contrary to the recent claim of astro-ph/0208507v3, the test theory here considered does not allow decays of photons into electron-positron pairs, and I expose the limitations of phenomenological proposals, such as the one reported in astro-ph/0212190, in which one attempts to infer limits on the kinematic theory here considered through the ad hoc introduction of a dynamical framework.
In the recent quantum-gravity literature there has been strong interest in the possibility of Planck-scale departures from Lorentz symmetry, including possible modifications of the energy/momentum dispersion relation. I stress that a meaningful characterization of the progress of experimental bounds on these Planck-scale effects requires the analysis of some reference test theories, and I propose to focus on two ``minimal'' test theories, a pure-kinematics test theory and an effective-field-theory-based test theory. I illustrate some features of the phenomenology based on these test theories considering some popular strategies for constraining Planck-scale effects, and in particular I observe that sensitivities that are already in the Planck-scale range for some parameters of the two test theories can be achieved using observations of TeV photons from Blazars, both using the so-called ``gamma-ray time-of-flight analyses'' and using the now robust evidence of absorption of TeV photons. Instead the Crab-nebula synchrotron-radiation analyses, whose preliminary sensitivity estimates raised high hopes, actually do not lead to any bound on the parameters of the two ``minimal'' test theories. The Crab-nebula synchrotron-radiation analyses do however constrain some possible generalizations of one of the minimal test theories. As an example of forthcoming data which could provide extremely stringent (beyond-Planckian) limits on the two minimal test theories I consider the possibility of studies of the GZK cutoff for cosmic-rays.
We examine some alternative possibilities for an action functional for $κ$-Minkowski noncommutative spacetime, with an approach which should be applicable to other spacetimes with coordinate-dependent commutators of the spacetime coordinates ($[x_μ,x_ν]=f_{μ,ν}(x)$). Early works on $κ$-Minkowski focused on $κ$-Poincaré covariance and the dependence of the action functional on the choice of Weyl map, renouncing to invariance under cyclic permutations of the factors composing the argument of the action functional. A recent paper (hep-th/0307149), by Dimitrijevic, Jonke, Moller, Tsouchnika, Wess and Wohlgenannt, focused on a specific choice of Weyl map and, setting aside the issue of $κ$-Poincaré covariance of the action functional, introduced in implicit form a cyclicity-inducing measure. We provide an explicit formula for (and derivation of) a choice of measure which indeed ensures cyclicity of the action functional, and we show that the same choice of measure is applicable to all the most used choices of Weyl map. We find that this ``cyclicity-inducing measure'' is not covariant under $κ$-Poincaré transformations. We also notice that the cyclicity-inducing measure can be straightforwardly derived using a map which connects the $κ$-Minkowski spacetime coordinates and the spacetime coordinates of a ``canonical'' noncommutative spacetime, with coordinate-independent commutators.
We explore a possible connection between two aspects of Loop Quantum Gravity which have been extensively studied in the recent literature: the black-hole area-entropy law and the energy-momentum dispersion relation. We observe that the original Bekenstein argument for the area-entropy law implicitly requires information on the energy-momentum dispersion relation. Recent results show that in first approximation black-hole entropy in Loop Quantum Gravity depends linearly on the area, with small correction terms which have logarithmic or inverse-power dependence on the area. Preliminary studies of the Loop-Quantum-Gravity dispersion relation reported some evidence of the presence of terms that depend linearly on the Planck length, but we observe that this possibility is excluded since it would require, for consistency, a contribution to black-hole entropy going like the square root of the area.
I give a brief overview of some Quantum-Gravity-Phenomenology research lines, focusing on studies of cosmic rays and gamma-ray bursts that concern the fate of Lorentz symmetry in quantum spacetime. I also stress that the most valuable phenomenological analyses should not mix too many conjectured new features of quantum spacetime, and from this perspective it appears that it should be difficult to obtain reliable guidance on the quantum-gravity problem from the analysis of synchrotron radiation from the Crab nebula and from the analysis of phase coherence of light from extragalactic sources. Forthcoming observatories of ultra-high-energy neutrinos should provide several opportunities for clean tests of some simple hypothesis for the short-distance structure of spacetime. In particular, these neutrino studies, and some related cosmic-ray studies, should provide access to the regime $E>\sqrt{m E_p}$.
The idea of a role for DSR (doubly-special relativity) in quantum gravity finds some encouragement in a few scenarios, but in order to explore some key conceptual issues it is necessary to find a well-understood toy-quantum-gravity model that is fully compatible with the DSR principles. Perhaps the most significant source of encouragement comes from the recent proposal of a path for the emergence of DSR in Loop Quantum Gravity, which however relies on a few assumptions on the results of some computations that we are still unable to perform. Indications in favor of the possibility of using some elements of $κ$-Poincaré Hopf algebras (and of the related $κ$-Minkowski noncommutative spacetime) for the construction of a DSR theory have been discussed extensively, but a few stubborn open issues must still be resolved, especially in the two-particle sector. It has been recently observed that certain structures encountered in a formulation of 2+1-dimensional classical-gravity models would fit naturally in a DSR framework, but some key elements of these 2+1-dimensional models, including the description of observers, might be incompatible with the DSR principles.
Some recent studies of the properties of D-particles suggest that in string theory a rather conventional description of spacetime might be available up to scales that are significantly smaller than the Planck length. We test this expectation by analyzing the localization of a space-time event marked by the collision of two D-particles. We find that a spatial coordinate of the event can indeed be determined with better-than-Planckian accuracy, at the price of a rather large uncertainty in the time coordinate. We then explore the implications of these results for the popular quantum-gravity intuition which assigns to the Planck length the role of absolute limit on localization.
Investigations of the possibility that some novel ``quantum" properties of spacetime might induce a modification dispersion relation focused at first on scenarios with Planck-scale violations of Lorentz symmetry. More recently several studies have considered the possibility of a ``doubly special relativity", in which the modification of the dispersion relation emerges from a framework with both the Planck scale and the speed-of-light scale as characteristic scales of a deformation of the Lorentz transformations. For the schemes with broken Lorentz symmetry at the Planck scale there is a large literature on the derivation of experimental limits. We provide here a corresponding analysis for the doubly-special-relativity framework. We find that the analyses of photon stability, synchrotron radiation, and threshold conditions for particle production in collision processes, the three contexts which are considered as most promising for constraining the broken-Lorentz-symmetry scenario, cannot provide significant constraints on doubly-special-relativity parameter space. However, certain types of analyses of gamma-ray bursts are sensitive to the symmetry deformation. A key element of our study is an observation that removes a possible sign ambiguity for the doubly-special-relativity framework. This result also allows us to characterize more sharply the differences between the doubly-special-relativity framework and the framework of k-Poincare Hopf algebras, two frameworks which are often confused with each other in the literature.
We construct a Dirac equation that is consistent with one of the recently-proposed schemes for a "doubly-special relativity", a relativity with both an observer-independent velocity scale (still naturally identified with the speed-of-light constant) and an observer-independent length/momentum scale (possibly given by the Planck length/momentum). We find that the introduction of the second observer-independent scale only induces a mild deformation of the structure of Dirac spinors. We also show that our modified Dirac equation naturally arises in constructing a Dirac equation in the kappa-Minkowski noncommutative spacetime. Previous, more heuristic, studies had already argued for a possible role of doubly-special relativity in kappa-Minkowski, but remained vague on the nature of the consistency requirements that should be implemented in order to assure the observer-independence of the two scales. We find that a key role is played by the choice of a differential calculus in kappa-Minkowski. A much-studied choice of the differential calculus does lead to our doubly-special relativity Dirac equation, but a different scenario is encountered for another popular choice of differential calculus.
I briefly review some scenarios for the role of the Planck length in quantum gravity. In particular, I examine the differences between the schemes in which quantum gravity is expected to introduce a maximum acceleration and the schemes in which the Planck length sets the minimum value of wavelengths (maximum value of momentum). I also comment on some pictures for the structure of spacetime at the Planck scale, such as spacetime discretization and spacetime noncommutativity. I stress that some of these proposals can have significant implications in astrophysics and cosmology.
I give a brief non-technical review of "Quantum Gravity Phenomenology" and in particular I describe some studies which should soon allow to establish valuable data-based constraints on the short-distance structure of spacetime.
We consider the two most studied proposals of relativity theories with observer-independent scales of both velocity and length/mass: the one discussed by Amelino-Camelia as illustrative example for the original proposal (gr-qc/0012051) of theories with two relativistic invariants, and an alternative more recently proposed by Magueijo and Smolin (hep-th/0112090). We show that these two relativistic theories are much more closely connected than it would appear on the basis of a naive analysis of their original formulations. In particular, in spite of adopting a rather different formal description of the deformed boost generators, they end up assigning the same dependence of momentum on rapidity, which can be described as the core feature of these relativistic theories. We show that this observation can be used to clarify the concepts of particle mass, particle velocity, and energy-momentum-conservation rules in these theories with two relativistic invariants.