arXiv subjects
Publications and source records attributed to Jesper Lykke Jacobsen.
We formulate $Q$-systems for the closed XXZ, open XXX and open quantum-group-invariant XXZ quantum spin chains. Polynomial solutions of these $Q$-systems can be found efficiently, which in turn lead directly to the admissible solutions of the corresponding Bethe ansatz equations.
We prove that physical solutions to the Heisenberg spin chain Bethe ansatz equations are exactly obtained by imposing two zero-remainder conditions. This bridges the gap between different criteria, yielding an alternative proof of a recently devised algorithm based on $QQ$ relations, and solving its minimality issue.
The "bootstrap determination" of the geometrical correlation functions in the two-dimensional Potts model proposed in a paper [arXiv:1607.07224] was later shown in [arXiv:1809.02191] to be incorrect, the actual spectrum of the model being considerably more complex than initially conjectured. We provide in this paper a geometrical interpretation of the four-point functions built in [arXiv:1607.07224], and explain why the results obtained by these authors, albeit incorrect, appeared so close to those of their numerical simulations of the Potts model. Our strategy is based on a cluster expansion of correlation functions in RSOS minimal models, and a subsequent numerical and algebraic analysis of the corresponding $s$-channel spectrum, in full analogy with our early work on the Potts model [arXiv:1809.02191]. Remarkable properties of the lattice amplitudes are uncovered, which explain in particular the truncation of the spectrum of [arXiv:1809.02191] to the much simpler one of the RSOS models, and which will be used in a forthcoming paper to finally determine the geometric four-point functions of the Potts model itself.
We present percolation thresholds calculated numerically with the eigenvalue formulation of the method of critical polynomials; developed in the last few years, it has already proven to be orders of magnitude more accurate than traditional techniques. Here we report the result of large parallel calculations to produce what we believe may become the reference values of bond percolation thresholds on the Archimedean lattices for years to come. For example, for the kagome lattice we find $p_{\rm c}=0.524\,404\,999\,167\,448\,20 (1)$, whereas the best estimate using standard techniques is $p_{\rm c}=0.524\,404\,99(2)$. We further provide strong evidence that there are two classes of lattices: one for which the first three scaling exponents characterizing the finite-size corrections to $p_{\rm c}$ are $Δ=6,7,8$, and another for which $Δ=4,6,8$. We discuss the open questions related to the method, such as the full scaling law, as well as its potential for determining critical points of other models.
We compute lattice correlation functions for the model of critical dense polymers on a semi-infinite cylinder of perimeter $n$. In the lattice loop model, contractible loops have a vanishing fugacity whereas non-contractible loops have a fugacity $α\in(0,\infty)$. These correlators are defined as ratios $Z(x)/Z_0$ of partition functions, where $Z_0$ is a reference partition function wherein only simple arcs are attached to the boundary of the cylinder. For $Z(x)$, the boundary is also decorated with simple arcs, but it also has two positions $1$ and $x$ where the boundary condition is different. We investigate two such kinds of boundary conditions: (i) there is a single node at each of these points where a long arc is attached, and (ii) there are pairs of adjacent nodes at these points where two long arcs are attached. We find explicit expressions for these correlators for finite $n$ using the representation of the enlarged periodic Temperley-Lieb algebra in the XX spin chain. The resulting asymptotics as $n\to\infty$ are expressed as simple integrals that depend on the parameter $τ=\frac{x-1}n\in(0,1)$. For small $τ$, the leading behaviours are proportional to $τ^{1/4}$, $τ^{1/4}\log τ$, $\logτ$ and $\log^2τ$. We interpret the lattice results in terms of ratios of conformal correlation functions. We assume that the corresponding boundary changing fields are highest weight states in irreducible, Kac or staggered Virasoro modules, with central charge $c=-2$ and conformal dimensions $Δ= -\frac18$ or $Δ=0$. We obtain differential equations satisfied by the conformal correlators, solve these equations, and find a perfect agreement with the lattice results. We compute structure constants and ratios thereof which appear in the operator product expansions of the boundary condition changing fields. The fusion of these fields is found to be non-abelian.
We initiate a study of the boundary version of the square-lattice $Q$-state Potts antiferromagnet, with $Q \in [0,4]$ real, motivated by the fact that the continuum limit of the corresponding bulk model is a non-compact CFT, closely related with the $SL(2,\mathbb{R})_k/U(1)$ Euclidian black-hole coset model. While various types of conformal boundary conditions (discrete and continuous branes) have been formally identified for the the $SL(2,\mathbb{R})_k/U(1)$ coset CFT, we are only able in this work to identify conformal boundary conditions (CBC) leading to a discrete boundary spectrum. The conformal boundary conditions (CBC) we find are of two types. The first is free boundary Potts spins, for which we confirm an old conjecture for the generating functions of conformal levels, and show them to be related to characters in a non-linear deformation of the $W_\infty$ algebra. The second type of CBC - which corresponds to restricting the values of the Potts spins to a subset of size $Q_1$, or its complement of size $Q-Q_1$, at alternating sites along the boundary - is new, and turns out to be conformal in the antiferromagnetic case only. Using algebraic and numerical techniques, we show that the corresponding spectrum generating functions produce all the characters of discrete representations for the coset CFT. The normalizability bounds of the associated discrete states in the coset CFT are found to have a simple interpretation in terms of boundary phase transitions in the lattice model. For $\sqrt{Q} = 2 \cos \fracπ{k}$, with $k \ge 3$ integer, we show also how our boundary conditions can be reformulated in terms of a RSOS height model. The spectrum generating functions are then identified with string functions of the compact $SU(2)_{k-2} / U(1)$ parafermion theory (with symmetry $Z_{k-2}$). The new alt conditions are needed to cover all the string functions.
Two-dimensional sigma models on superspheres $S^{r-1|2s} \cong OSp(r|2s)/OSp(r - 1|2s)$ are known to flow to weak coupling $g_σ \to 0$ in the IR when $r - 2s < 2$. Their long-distance properties are described by a free 'Goldstone' conformal field theory (CFT) with $r - 1$ bosonic and $2s$ fermionic degrees of freedom, where the $OSp(r|2s)$ symmetry is spontaneously broken. This behavior is made possible by the lack of unitarity. The purpose of this paper is to study logarithmic corrections to the free theory at small but non-zero coupling $g_σ$. We do this in two ways. On the one hand, we perform perturbative calculations with the sigma model action, which are of special technical interest since the perturbed theory is logarithmic. On the other hand, we study an integrable lattice discretization of the sigma models provided by vertex models and spin chains with $OSp(r|2s)$ symmetry. Detailed analysis of the Bethe equations then confirms and completes the field theoretic calculations. Finally, we apply our results to physical properties of dense loop soups with crossings.
We obtain the ground state magnetization of the Heisenberg and XXZ spin chains in a magnetic field $h$ as a series in $\sqrt{h_c-h}$, where $h_c$ is the smallest field for which the ground state is fully polarized. All the coefficients of the series can be computed in closed form through a recurrence formula that involves only algebraic manipulations. The radius of convergence of the series in the full range $0<h\leq h_c$ is studied numerically. To that end we express the free energy at mean magnetization per site $-1/2\leq \langle σ^z_i\rangle\leq 1/2$ as a series in $1/2-\langle σ^z_i\rangle$ whose coefficients can be similarly recursively computed in closed form. This series converges for all $0\leq \langle σ^z_i\rangle\leq 1/2$. The recurrence is nothing but the Bethe equations when their roots are written as a double series in their corresponding Bethe number and in $1/2-\langle σ^z_i\rangle$. It can also be used to derive the corrections in finite size, that correspond to the spectrum of a free compactified boson whose radius can be expanded as a similar series. The method presumably applies to a large class of models: it also successfully applies to a case where the Bethe roots lie on a curve in the complex plane.
We investigate six types of two-point boundary correlation functions in the dense loop model. These are defined as ratios $Z/Z^0$ of partition functions on the $m\times n$ square lattice, with the boundary condition for $Z$ depending on two points $x$ and $y$. We consider: the insertion of an isolated defect (a) and a pair of defects (b) in a Dirichlet boundary condition, the transition (c) between Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions, and the connectivity of clusters (d), loops (e) and boundary segments (f) in a Neumann boundary condition. For the model of critical dense polymers, corresponding to a vanishing loop weight ($β= 0$), we find determinant and pfaffian expressions for these correlators. We extract the conformal weights of the underlying conformal fields and find $Δ= -\frac18$, $0$, $-\frac3{32}$, $\frac38$, $1$, $\tfrac θπ(1+ \tfrac{2θ}π)$, where $θ$ encodes the weight of one class of loops for the correlator of type f. These results are obtained by analysing the asymptotics of the exact expressions, and by using the Cardy-Peschel formula in the case where $x$ and $y$ are set to the corners. For type b, we find a $\ln|x-y|$ dependence from the asymptotics, and a $\ln (\ln n)$ term in the corner free energy. This is consistent with the interpretation of the boundary condition of type b as the insertion of a logarithmic field belonging to a rank two Jordan cell. For the other values of $β= 2 \cos λ$, we use the hypothesis of conformal invariance to predict the conformal weights and find $Δ= Δ_{1,2}$, $Δ_{1,3}$, $Δ_{0,\frac12}$, $Δ_{1,0}$, $Δ_{1,-1}$ and $Δ_{\frac{2θ}λ+1,\frac{2θ}λ+1}$, extending the results of critical dense polymers. With the results for type f, we reproduce a Coulomb gas prediction for the valence bond entanglement entropy of Jacobsen and Saleur.
We develop an efficient method to compute the torus partition function of the six-vertex model exactly for finite lattice size. The method is based on the algebro-geometric approach to the resolution of Bethe ansatz equations initiated in a previous work, and on further ingredients introduced in the present paper. The latter include rational $Q$-system, primary decomposition, algebraic extension and Galois theory. Using this approach, we probe new structures in the solution space of the Bethe ansatz equations which enable us to boost the efficiency of the computation. As an application, we study the zeros of the partition function in a partial thermodynamic limit of $M \times N$ tori with $N \gg M$. We observe that for $N \to \infty$ the zeros accumulate on some curves and give a numerical method to generate the curves of accumulation points.
We revisit in this paper the problem of connectivity correlations in the Fortuin-Kasteleyn cluster representation of the two-dimensional $Q$-state Potts model conformal field theory. In a recent work [M. Picco, S. Ribault and R. Santachiara, SciPost Phys. 1, 009 (2016); arXiv:1607.07224], results for the four-point functions were obtained, based on the bootstrap approach, combined with simple conjectures for the spectra in the different fusion channels. In this paper, we test these conjectures using lattice algebraic considerations combined with extensive numerical studies of correlations on infinite cylinders. We find that the spectra in the scaling limit are much richer than those proposed in [arXiv:1607.07224]: they involve in particular fields with conformal weight $h_{r,s}$ where $r$ is dense on the real axis.
We present a new and efficient method for deriving finite-size effects in statistical physics models solvable by Bethe Ansatz. It is based on the study of the functional that maps a function to the sum of its evaluations over the Bethe roots. A simple and powerful constraint is derived when applying this functional to infinitely derivable test functions with compact support, that generalizes then to more general test functions. The method is presented in the context of the simple spin-$1/2$ XXZ chain for which we derive the finite-size corrections to leading eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian for any configuration of Bethe numbers with real Bethe roots. The expected results for the central charge and conformal dimensions are recovered.
The supersymmetric reformulation of physical observables in the Chalker-Coddington model (CC) for the plateau transition in the integer quantum Hall effect leads to a reformulation of its critical properties in terms of a 2D non-compact loop model or a 1D non-compact $gl(2|2)$ spin chain. Following a proposal by Ikhlef, Fendley and Cardy, we define and study a series of truncations of these loop models and spin chains, involving a finite and growing number of degrees of freedom per site. The case of the first truncation is solved analytically using the Bethe-ansatz. It is shown to exhibit many of the qualitative features expected for the untruncated theory, including a quadratic spectrum of exponents with a continuous component, and a normalizable ground state below that continuum. Quantitative properties are however at odds with the results of simulations on the CC model. Higher truncations are studied only numerically. While their properties are found to get closer to those of the CC model, it is not clear whether this is a genuine effect, or the result of strong finite-size corrections.
Percolation, a paradigmatic geometric system in various branches of physical sciences, is known to possess logarithmic factors in its correlators. Starting from its definition, as the $Q\rightarrow1$ limit of the $Q$-state Potts model with $S_Q$ symmetry, in terms of geometrical clusters, its operator content as $N$-cluster observables has been classified. We extensively simulate critical bond percolation in two and three dimensions and determine with high precision the $N$-cluster exponents and non-scalar features up to $N \! =\! 4$ (2D) and $N \! =\! 3$ (3D). The results are in excellent agreement with the predicted exact values in 2D, while such families of critical exponents have not been reported in 3D, to our knowledge. Finally, we demonstrate the validity of predictions about the logarithmic structure between the energy and two-cluster operators in 3D.
We study the antiferromagnetic 3-state Potts model on general (periodic) plane quadrangulations $Γ$. Any quadrangulation can be built from a dual pair $(G,G^*)$. Based on the duality properties of $G$, we propose a new criterion to predict the phase diagram of this model. If $Γ$ is of self-dual type (i.e., if $G$ is isomorphic to its dual $G^*$), the model has a zero-temperature critical point with central charge $c=1$, and it is disordered at all positive temperatures. If $Γ$ is of non-self-dual type (i.e., if $G$ is not isomorphic to $G^*$), three ordered phases coexist at low temperature, and the model is disordered at high temperature. In addition, there is a finite-temperature critical point (separating these two phases) which belongs to the universality class of the ferromagnetic 3-state Potts model with central charge $c=4/5$. We have checked these conjectures by studying four (resp. seven) quadrangulations of self-dual (resp. non-self-dual) type, and using three complementary high-precision techniques: Monte-Carlo simulations, transfer matrices, and critical polynomials. In all cases, we find agreement with the conjecture. We have also found that the Wang-Swendsen-Kotecky Monte Carlo algorithm does not have (resp. does have) critical slowing down at the corresponding critical point on quadrangulations of self-dual (resp. non-self-dual) type.
The six-vertex model with domain-wall boundary conditions is one representative of a class of two-dimensional lattice statistical mechanics models that exhibit a phase separation known as the arctic curve phenomenon. In the thermodynamic limit, the degrees of freedom are completely frozen in a region near the boundary, while they are critically fluctuating in a central region. The arctic curve is the phase boundary that separates those two regions. Critical fluctuations inside the arctic curve have been studied extensively, both in physics and in mathematics, in free models (i.e., models that map to free fermions, or equivalently to determinantal point processes). Here we study those critical fluctuations in the interacting (i.e., not free, not determinantal) six-vertex model, and provide evidence for the following two claims: (i) the critical fluctuations are given by a Gaussian Free Field (GFF), as in the free case, but (ii) contrarily to the free case, the GFF is inhomogeneous, meaning that its coupling constant $K$ becomes position-dependent, $K \rightarrow K({\rm x})$. The evidence is mainly based on the numerical solution of appropriate Bethe ansatz equations with an imaginary extensive twist, and on transfer matrix computations, but the second claim is also supported by the analytic calculation of $K$ and its first two derivatives in selected points. Contrarily to the usual GFF, this inhomogeneous GFF is not defined in terms of the Green's function of the Laplacian $Δ= \nabla \cdot \nabla$ inside the critical domain, but instead, of the Green's function of a generalized Laplacian $Δ= \nabla \cdot \frac{1}{K} \nabla$ parametrized by the function $K$. Surprisingly, we also find that there is a change of regime when $Δ\leq -1/2$, with $K$ becoming singular at one point.
We provide a new criterion based on graph duality to predict whether the 3-state Potts antiferromagnet on a plane quadrangulation has a zero- or finite-temperature critical point, and its universality class. The former case occurs for quadrangulations of self-dual type, and the zero-temperature critical point has central charge $c=1$. The latter case occurs for quadrangulations of non-self-dual type, and the critical point belongs to the universality class of the 3-state Potts ferromagnet. We have tested this criterion against high-precision computations on four lattices of each type, with very good agreement. We have also found that the Wang-Swendsen-Kotecký algorithm has no critical slowing-down in the former case, and critical slowing-down in the latter.
We study the phase diagram of the triangular-lattice $Q$-state Potts model in the real $(Q,v)$-plane, where $v=e^J-1$ is the temperature variable. Our first goal is to provide an obviously missing feature of this diagram: the position of the antiferromagnetic critical curve. This curve turns out to possess a bifurcation point with two branches emerging from it, entailing important consequences for the global phase diagram. We have obtained accurate numerical estimates for the position of this curve by combining the transfer-matrix approach for strip graphs with toroidal boundary conditions and the recent method of critical polynomials. The second goal of this work is to study the corresponding $A_{p-1}$ RSOS model on the torus, for integer $p=4,5,\ldots,8$. We clarify its relation to the corresponding Potts model, in particular concerning the role of boundary conditions. For certain values of $p$, we identify several new critical points and regimes for the RSOS model and we initiate the study of the flows between the corresponding field theories.