arXiv subjects

John van de Wetering

Publications and source records attributed to John van de Wetering.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

A Complete and Natural Rule Set for Multi-Qudit Clifford Circuits in All Odd Prime Dimensions

We present a complete set of $16$ rewrite rules for multi-qudit Clifford circuits in all odd prime dimensions. Completeness means that any two Clifford circuits representing the same linear map can be rewritten into each other using these rules. Each rule involves at most three qudits and admits an intuitive interpretation. To establish completeness, we first work at the symplectic level, using the isomorphism between the symplectic group $\mathrm{Sp}(2n,\mathbb{Z}_p)$ and the quotient of the Clifford group by the Pauli group. We construct a circuit normal form that captures the stabiliser tableau of a Clifford operator and is unique up to Pauli correction. Using this normal form, we derive a complete set of symplectic relations, which we then lift to Clifford relations by incorporating Pauli corrections. We also formally verify completeness in the Agda proof assistant.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

SpiderCSS: Scalable Fault-Tolerant CSS State Preparation

Fault-tolerant preparation of logical states is a critical primitive for the realization of large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computing. This paper introduces SpiderCSS, a scalable compilation pipeline that generates highly-optimized, fault-tolerant state preparation circuits for arbitrary Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes. Starting from an idealized specification of a CSS state, we use the ZX-calculus and fault-equivalent rewrites to construct a diagram that prepares the given state while preserving the fault tolerance of the initial ideal ZX-diagram. From this diagram, SpiderCSS constructs a fault-tolerant CSS-state preparation circuit using a modular construction that is CNOT-minimal both within each component and also in the way these components are connected together. By only using fault-equivalent rewrites, the final circuit is provably fault-tolerant without needing expensive verification. Monte Carlo simulations across a variety of CSS codes up to distance 15 show that SpiderCSS scales efficiently and constructs circuits with substantially reduced depth and qubit footprint compared to existing scalable and heuristic methods, while simultaneously achieving an average decrease of 33.7% in logical error rate and an increase of 9.5% in acceptance rate.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

Self-duality and Jordan structure of quantum theory follow from homogeneity and pure transitivity

Quantum theory satisfies the mathematically powerful property of self-duality, meaning that its state and effect spaces are made isomorphic by an inner product. This is why both quantum states and effects can be represented by positive Hermitian operators. The seminal Koecher-Vinberg theorem shows that self-duality is a rather special property: any system that is self-dual and also homogeneous, meaning that the group of symmetries of its cone of unnormalised states acts transitively on the strictly positive states, must be isomorphic to a Euclidean Jordan algebra. EJAs have been classified and are known to be just a slight generalisation of quantum systems. This is why the Koecher-Vinberg theorem, and hence self-duality and homogeneity, have been used in several reconstructions of quantum theory from first principles. While homogeneity has an operational derivation from the ability to steer states, self-duality currently lacks such a clear operational motivation. In this paper we prove an alternative to the Koecher-Vinberg theorem, substituting for self-duality the more operational property of pure transitivity: symmetries of the normalised state space act transitively on the pure states. We show that any system that is homogeneous and satisfies pure transitivity must be self-dual, and hence isomorphic to an EJA. Together with various ways of singling out the complex matrix algebras from among EJAs, and known ways of ruling out classicality in these, this yields several new and concise reconstructions of quantum theory. For example, quantum systems, classical systems, and composites of these are the only ones that are homogeneous, satisfy pure transitivity, and allow locally tomographic composites; fully quantum systems are the only ones that are homogeneous, have continuous pure transitivity, and allow a correspondence between observables and generators of reversible transformations.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

ABSTRACTS: Amsterdam Benchmark Suite for the Time and Resource Analysis of Clifford+T Simulators

Recent years have seen a rapid growth in literature presenting new methods for simulating non-Clifford quantum circuits with classical hardware. These methods span a range of approaches, including stabiliser decomposition and tensor contraction techniques, varying in efficiency depending on circuit class, depth, non-Clifford gate count, and other metrics. A notable limitation of this literature is the lack of a standardised approach to benchmarking, with each new paper outlining its own specification, simulating its own set of circuits on the authors' own hardware. This paper seeks to address this issue by presenting a standardised and canonical benchmark suite and infrastructure for quantifying the efficiency of non-Clifford classical simulators, with a consistent dataset of circuits and providing consistent (virtual) hardware, thereby enabling a fair comparison of results.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

From Tensor Networks to Tractable Circuits, and back

Tensor networks and circuits are widely used data structures to represent pseudo-Boolean functions. These two formalisms have been studied primarily in separate communities, and this paper aims to establish equivalences between them. We show that some classes of tensor networks that are appealing in practice correspond to classes of circuits with specific properties that have been studied in knowledge compilation as \emph{tractable circuits}. In particular, we prove that matrix product states (tensor trains) coincide with nondeterministic edge-valued decision diagrams and that tree tensor networks exactly correspond to structured-decomposable circuits. These correspondences enable direct transfer of structural and algorithmic results; for example, canonicity and tractability guarantees known for circuits yield analogous guarantees for the associated tensor networks, and vice versa.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

ZX-Flow: A Flexible Criterion for Deterministic Computation with ZX-Diagrams

Flow criteria are used to efficiently extract computations, either in the form of measurement patterns or quantum circuits, from ZX-diagrams. Existing criteria such as causal flow, generalised flow, and Pauli flow, were all originally formulated for graph states, so they require ZX-diagrams to be in a very particular graph-state-like form. This form is easily broken by applying basic ZX rules and makes establishing some desirable properties very complicated. Here, we introduce a new "ZX-native" flow criterion called ZX-flow, formulated using a new type of decoration of a ZX-diagram we call Pauli semiwebs. These are a generalisation of Pauli webs, which have recently been used extensively in reasoning about fault-tolerant computations in the ZX-calculus. We show that ZX-flow is straightforwardly preserved by all Clifford rewrites and furthermore that a ZX-diagram has ZX-flow if and only if it is Clifford-equivalent to a graph-like ZX-diagram with Pauli flow. Finally, we show that any diagram with ZX-flow can be readily interpreted either as a deterministic measurement-based computation or as a Clifford isometry followed by a sequence of Pauli exponentials. The latter can then be efficiently extracted to a quantum circuit.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2026

SpiderCat: Optimal Fault-Tolerant Cat State Preparation

The ability to fault-tolerantly prepare CAT states, also known as multi-qubit GHZ states, is an important primitive for quantum error correction. It is required for Shor-style syndrome extraction, and can also be used as a subroutine for doing fault-tolerant state preparation of CSS codewords. Existing approaches to fault-tolerant CAT state preparations have been found using computationally expensive heuristics involving SAT solving, reinforcement learning, or exhaustive analysis. In this paper, we constructively find optimal circuits for CAT states in a more scalable way. In particular, we derive formal lower bounds on the number of CNOT gates required for circuits implementing $n$-qubit CAT states that do not spread errors of weight at most $t$ for $1\leq t \leq 5$. We do this by using fault-equivalent rewrites of ZX-diagrams to reduce it to a problem of characterising certain 3-regular simple graphs. We then provide families of such optimal graphs for infinitely many values of $n$ and $t\leq5$. By encoding the construction of optimal graphs as a constraint satisfaction problem we find explicit constructions for circuits that match this lower bound on CNOT count for all $n\leq50$ and $t \leq 5$ and for nearly all pairs $(n,t)$ with $n\leq 100$ and $t\leq 5$ or $n\leq 50$ and $t\leq 7$, significantly extending the regimes that were achievable by previous methods and improving the resource counts for existing constructions. We additionally show how to trade CNOT count against depth, allowing us to construct constant-depth fault-tolerant implementations using $O(n)$ ancilla and $O(n)$ CNOT gates.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2025

A Complete and Natural Rule Set for Multi-Qutrit Clifford Circuits

We present a complete set of rewrite rules for n-qutrit Clifford circuits where n is any non-negative integer. This is the first completeness result for any fragment of quantum circuits in odd prime dimensions. We first generalize Selinger's normal form for n-qubit Clifford circuits to the qutrit setting. Then, we present a rewrite system by which any Clifford circuit can be reduced to this normal form. We then simplify the rewrite rules in this procedure to a small natural set of rules, giving a clean presentation of the group of qutrit Clifford unitaries in terms of generators and relations.

cs.LO↗

arXiv2025

Optimal compilation of parametrised quantum circuits

Parametrised quantum circuits contain phase gates whose phase is determined by a classical algorithm prior to running the circuit on a quantum device. Such circuits are used in variational algorithms like QAOA and VQE. In order for these algorithms to be as efficient as possible it is important that we use the fewest number of parameters. We show that, while the general problem of minimising the number of parameters is NP-hard, when we restrict to circuits that are Clifford apart from parametrised phase gates and where each parameter is used just once, we *can* efficiently find the optimal parameter count. We show that when parameter transformations are required to be sufficiently well-behaved, the only rewrites that reduce parameters correspond to simple 'fusions'. Using this we find that a previous circuit optimisation strategy by some of the authors [Kissinger, van de Wetering. PRA (2019)] finds the optimal number of parameters. Our proof uses the ZX-calculus. We also prove that the standard rewrite rules of the ZX-calculus suffice to prove any equality between parametrised Clifford circuits.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

Scalable Spider Nests (...Or How to Graphically Grok Transversal Non-Clifford Gates)

This is the second in a series of "graphical grokking" papers in which we study how stabiliser codes can be understood using the ZX-calculus. In this paper we show that certain complex rules involving ZX-diagrams, called spider nest identities, can be captured succinctly using the scalable ZX-calculus, and all such identities can be proved inductively from a single new rule using the Clifford ZX-calculus. This can be combined with the ZX picture of CSS codes, developed in the first "grokking" paper, to give a simple characterisation of the set of all transversal diagonal gates at the third level of the Clifford hierarchy implementable in an arbitrary CSS code.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

Optimising quantum circuits is generally hard

In order for quantum computations to be done as efficiently as possible it is important to optimise the number of gates used in the underlying quantum circuits. In this paper we find that many gate optimisation problems for approximately universal quantum circuits are NP-hard. In particular, we show that optimising the T-count or T-depth in Clifford+T circuits, which are important metrics for the computational cost of executing fault-tolerant quantum computations, is NP-hard by reducing the problem to Boolean satisfiability. With a similar argument we show that optimising the number of CNOT gates or Hadamard gates in a Clifford+T circuit is also NP-hard. Again varying the same argument we also establish the hardness of optimising the number of Toffoli gates in a reversible classical circuit. We find an upper bound to the problems of T-count and Toffoli-count of $\text{NP}^{\text{NQP}}$. Finally, we also show that for any non-Clifford gate $G$ it is NP-hard to optimise the $G$-count over the Clifford+$G$ gate set, where we only have to match the target unitary within some small distance in the operator norm.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

Exact Synthesis of Multiqutrit Clifford-Cyclotomic Circuits

It is known that the matrices that can be exactly represented by a multiqubit circuit over the Toffoli+Hadamard, Clifford+$T$, or, more generally, Clifford-cyclotomic gate set are precisely the unitary matrices with entries in the ring $\mathbb{Z}[1/2,ζ_k]$, where $k$ is a positive integer that depends on the gate set and $ζ_k$ is a primitive $2^k$-th root of unity. In the present paper, we establish an analogous correspondence for qutrits. We define the multiqutrit Clifford-cyclotomic gate set of degree $3^k$ by extending the classical qutrit gates $X$, $CX$, and $CCX$ with the Hadamard gate $H$ and the $T_k$ gate $T_k=\mathrm{diag}(1,ω_k, ω_k^2)$, where $ω_k$ is a primitive $3^k$-th root of unity. This gate set is equivalent to the qutrit Toffoli+Hadamard gate set when $k=1$, and to the qutrit Clifford+$T_k$ gate set when $k>1$. We then prove that a $3^n\times 3^n$ unitary matrix $U$ can be represented by an $n$-qutrit circuit over the Clifford-cyclotomic gate set of degree $3^k$ if and only if the entries of $U$ lie in the ring $\mathbb{Z}[1/3,ω_k]$.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

A Graphical #SAT Algorithm for Formulae with Small Clause Density

We study the counting version of the Boolean satisfiability problem #SAT using the ZH-calculus, a graphical language originally introduced to reason about quantum circuits. Using this, we generalize #SAT to a weighted variant we call #SAT+-, which is complete for the class GapP. We show there is an efficient linear-time reduction from #SAT to #2SAT+-, unlike previous reductions from #SAT to #2SAT which blow up the size of the formula by a polynomial factor. Our main conceptual contribution is that introducing weights to #SAT allows for more efficient translations, and we use this to remove the dependence on clause width k in this case. We observe that DPLL-style algorithms for #2SAT can be adapted to #2SAT+- directly and hence the best-known upper bounds for #2SAT apply. Applying an upper bound for #2SAT in terms of variables gives us upper bounds for #SAT in terms of clauses and variables that are better than O*(2^n) for small clause densities of m/n < 2.25, and improve on previous average-case and worst-case bounds for k >= 6 and k >= 4, respectively. Applying a similar bound in terms of clauses produces a bound of O*(1.1740^L) in terms of the length of the formula. These are, to our knowledge, the first non-trivial upper bounds for #SAT that is independent of clause size, and in terms of formula length, respectively. Based on a result of Kutzkov, we find an improved bound on #3SAT for 1.2577 < m/n <= 7/3. Finally, we use this technique to find an upper bound on the complexity of calculating amplitudes of quantum circuits in terms of the total number of gates. Our results demonstrate that graphical reasoning can lead to new algorithmic insights, even outside the domain of quantum computing that the calculus was intended for.

cs.CC↗

arXiv2024

Catalysing Completeness and Universality

A catalysis state is a quantum state that is used to make some desired operation possible or more efficient, while not being consumed in the process. Recent years have seen catalysis used in state-of-the-art protocols for implementing magic state distillation or small angle phase rotations. In this paper we will see that we can also use catalysis to prove that certain gate sets are computationally universal, and to extend completeness results of graphical languages to larger fragments. In particular, we give a simple proof of the computational universality of the CS+Hadamard gate set using the catalysis of a $T$ gate using a CS gate, which sidesteps the more complicated analytic arguments of the original proof by Kitaev. This then also gives us a simple self-contained proof of the computational universality of Toffoli+Hadamard. Additionally, we show that the phase-free ZH-calculus can be extended to a larger complete fragment, just by using a single catalysis rule (and one scalar rule).

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

Quantum Circuit Optimization with AlphaTensor

A key challenge in realizing fault-tolerant quantum computers is circuit optimization. Focusing on the most expensive gates in fault-tolerant quantum computation (namely, the T gates), we address the problem of T-count optimization, i.e., minimizing the number of T gates that are needed to implement a given circuit. To achieve this, we develop AlphaTensor-Quantum, a method based on deep reinforcement learning that exploits the relationship between optimizing T-count and tensor decomposition. Unlike existing methods for T-count optimization, AlphaTensor-Quantum can incorporate domain-specific knowledge about quantum computation and leverage gadgets, which significantly reduces the T-count of the optimized circuits. AlphaTensor-Quantum outperforms the existing methods for T-count optimization on a set of arithmetic benchmarks (even when compared without making use of gadgets). Remarkably, it discovers an efficient algorithm akin to Karatsuba's method for multiplication in finite fields. AlphaTensor-Quantum also finds the best human-designed solutions for relevant arithmetic computations used in Shor's algorithm and for quantum chemistry simulation, thus demonstrating it can save hundreds of hours of research by optimizing relevant quantum circuits in a fully automated way.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2023

Building Qutrit Diagonal Gates from Phase Gadgets

Phase gadgets have proved to be an indispensable tool for reasoning about ZX-diagrams, being used in optimisation and simulation of quantum circuits and the theory of measurement-based quantum computation. In this paper we study phase gadgets for qutrits. We present the flexsymmetric variant of the original qutrit ZX-calculus, which allows for rewriting that is closer in spirit to the original (qubit) ZX-calculus. In this calculus phase gadgets look as you would expect, but there are non-trivial differences in their properties. We devise new qutrit-specific tricks to extend the graphical Fourier theory of qubits, resulting in a translation between the 'additive' phase gadgets and a 'multiplicative' counterpart we dub phase multipliers. This enables us to generalise the qubit notion of multiple-control to qutrits in two ways. The first type is controlling on a single tritstring, while the second type applies the gate a number of times equal to the tritwise multiplication modulo 3 of the control qutrits.We show how both types of control can be implemented for any qutrit Z or X phase gate, ancilla-free, and using only Clifford and phase gates. The first requires a polynomial number of gates and exponentially small phases, while the second requires an exponential number of gates, but constant sized phases. This is interesting, because such a construction is not possible in the qubit setting. As an application of these results we find a construction for emulating arbitrary qubit diagonal unitaries, and specifically find an ancilla-free emulation for the qubit CCZ gate that only requires three single-qutrit non-Clifford gates, provably lower than the four T gates needed for qubits with ancilla.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2023

The Qudit ZH-Calculus: Generalised Toffoli+Hadamard and Universality

We introduce the qudit ZH-calculus and show how to generalise all the phase-free qubit rules to qudits. We prove that for prime dimensions d, the phase-free qudit ZH-calculus is universal for matrices over the ring Z[e^2(pi)i/d]. For qubits, there is a strong connection between phase-free ZH-diagrams and Toffoli+Hadamard circuits, a computationally universal fragment of quantum circuits. We generalise this connection to qudits, by finding that the two-qudit |0>-controlled X gate can be used to construct all classical reversible qudit logic circuits in any odd qudit dimension, which for qubits requires the three-qubit Toffoli gate. We prove that our construction is asymptotically optimal up to a logarithmic term. Twenty years after the celebrated result by Shi proving universality of Toffoli+Hadamard for qubits, we prove that circuits of |0>-controlled X and Hadamard gates are approximately universal for qudit quantum computing for any odd prime d, and moreover that phase-free ZH-diagrams correspond precisely to such circuits allowing post-selections.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2023

The Qupit Stabiliser ZX-travaganza: Simplified Axioms, Normal Forms and Graph-Theoretic Simplification

We present a smorgasbord of results on the stabiliser ZX-calculus for odd prime-dimensional qudits (i.e. qupits). We derive a simplified rule set that closely resembles the original rules of qubit ZX-calculus. Using these rules, we demonstrate analogues of the spider-removing local complementation and pivoting rules. This allows for efficient reduction of diagrams to the affine with phases normal form. We also demonstrate a reduction to a unique form, providing an alternative and simpler proof of completeness. Furthermore, we introduce a different reduction to the graph state with local Cliffords normal form, which leads to a novel layered decomposition for qupit Clifford unitaries. Additionally, we propose a new approach to handle scalars formally, closely reflecting their practical usage. Finally, we have implemented many of these findings in DiZX, a new open-source Python library for qudit ZX-diagrammatic reasoning.

quant-ph↗