A formal framework for higher-order spin models via hypergraphs, polymatroids, and the Tutte polynomial
We develop a rigorous mathematical framework for statistical mechanics models on hypergraphs, and give conditions for lifting the classical connection between Potts model partition functions and the Tutte polynomial from graphs to hypergraphs. We define hypergraphical models and their associated partition functions, and extend these to special classes of models induced by families of interaction functions. For boolean interaction families, whose interaction functions map to $\{0,1\}$, we show that the partition function is determined by a combinatorial rank function, and we establish sufficient conditions for a hypergraph deletion-contraction recurrence and for when the rank function defines a polymatroid. We illustrate the theory by applying it to three hypergraph interaction families: Parity Ising, Delta Potts, and And Ising. The induced hypergraphical models are not isomorphic to each other, but the first two reduce to the same graphical Ising models. We identify three polymatroids naturally associated with hypergraphs for these models: respectively, the binary matroid of the incidence matrix over $\mathbb{F}_2$, the hypergraphical polymatroid, and the boolean polymatroid. For graphs, the first two reduce to the classical graphical matroid, and their partition functions recover the multivariate Tutte polynomial. The Tutte polynomial thus admits at least two distinct generalizations for hypergraphs, both satisfying a deletion-contraction recurrence: the Tutte polynomial of the binary matroid of the hypergraph incidence matrix, and a multivariate version of the Poincaré polynomial of the hypergraphical polymatroid. The partition functions of And Ising models are likewise multivariate versions of the Poincaré polynomial, here of the boolean polymatroid. These examples illustrate the much greater range of hypergraphical models and underscore the need for the unifying theory.