Reply to E. Shuryak's Comments on "Three regimes of QCD"
In his recent Comments E. Shuryak reiterates old, unfortunately misleading arguments in favor of deconfined Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) immediately above the chiral restoration pseudocritical temperature. In a Comment devoted to our view of QCD at high temperatures he does not address and even mention the essence of our arguments. In recent years a new "hidden" symmetry in QCD was discovered. It is a symmetry of the electric sector of QCD, that is higher than the chiral symmetry of the QCD Lagrangian as the whole. This symmetry was clearly observed above T_c in spatial correlators and very recently also in time correlators. The latter correlators are directly related to observable spectral density. Then in a model-independent way we conclude that degrees of freedom in QCD above T_c, but below roughly 3T_c, are chirally symmetric quarks bound by the chromoelectric field into color-singlet compounds without the chromomagnetic effects. This regime of QCD has been referred to as a Stringy Fluid since such objects are very reminiscent of strings.At higher temperatures there is a very smooth transition to the partonic degrees of freedom, i.e. to the QGP regime. Here we will address some of the points made by Shuryak.