arXiv subjects

M. Cervino

Publications and source records attributed to M. Cervino.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

arXiv2006

Progress report: probabilistic and statistical bases of surface brightness fluctuations

The surface brightness fluctuations (SBF) method is a statistical method applied on image pixels in different bands. This contribution aims to distinguish between the observational (statistical) method and the theoretical (probabilistic) method based on stellar population synthesis and needed for the calibration of observational SBF. We find that the commonly used SBF theoretical definition as the "mean luminosity-weighted luminosity of the stellar population" is only compatible with the observational method under quite strong hypotheses, and that it is not compatible with stellar population theory results.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2006

From deterministic to probabilistic population synthesis (why synthesis models are not what we thought they were, and how they can be much more than that)

For a number of reasons, the properties of integrated stellar populations are distributed. Traditional synthesis models usually return the mean value of such distribution, and a perfect fitting to observational data is sought for to infer the age and metallicity of observed stellar populations. We show here that, while this is correct on average, it is not in individual cases because the mean may not be representative of actual values. We present a simple mathematical formalism to derive the shape of the population's luminosity distribution function (pLDF), and an abridged way to estimate it without computing it explicitly. This abridged treatment can be used to establish whether, for a specific case, the pLDF is Gaussian and the application of Gaussian tools, such as the chi^2 test, is correct. More in general, our formalism permits to compute weights to be attributed to different properties (spectral features or band luminosities) in the fitting process. We emphasize that our formalism does not supersede the results of traditionaly synthesis models, but permits to reinterpret and extend them into more powerful tools. The reader is referred to the original paper for further details.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2006

Confidence limits of evolutionary synthesis models. IV Moving forward to a probabilistic formulation

Synthesis models predict the integrated properties of stellar populations. Several problems exist in this field, mostly related to the fact that integrated properties are distributed. To date, this aspect has been either ignored (as in standard synthesis models, which are inherently deterministic) or interpreted phenomenologically (as in Monte Carlo simulations, which describe distributed properties rather than explain them). We approach population synthesis as a problem in probability theory, in which stellar luminosities are random variables extracted from the stellar luminosity distribution function (sLDF). We derive the population LDF (pLDF) for clusters of any size from the sLDF, obtaining the scale relations that link the sLDF to the pLDF. We recover the predictions of standard synthesis models, which are shown to compute the mean of the sLDF. We provide diagnostic diagrams and a simplified recipe for testing the statistical richness of observed clusters, thereby assessing whether standard synthesis models can be safely used or a statistical treatment is mandatory. We also recover the predictions of Monte Carlo simulations, with the additional bonus of being able to interpret them in mathematical and physical terms. We give examples of problems that can be addressed through our probabilistic formalism. Though still under development, ours is a powerful approach to population synthesis. In an era of resolved observations and pipelined analyses of large surveys, this paper is offered as a signpost in the field of stellar populations.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2005

Revisiting and assessing uncertainties in stellar populations synthesis models

In this review we address the uncertainties implicit in evolutionary synthesis model computations. After describing the general structure of synthesis codes, we discuss several source of uncertainties that may affect their results. In particular, we discuss the uncertainties arising in the computation of isochrones from evolutionary tracks; those related to atmosphere models; those that are a consequence of the incompleteness of the input ingredients; and those associated with the computational aspect used in synthesis codes. We also discuss the issue of the inclusion of distributed properties in synthesis models; as a paradigm of this case, we illustrate the difficulties implied by the inclusion of tracks with rotation in synthesis models. Finally, we describe several examples of the statistical approach to population synthesis. We report on the failure of the fuel consumption theorem (FCT) and the isochrone synthesis code to produce mutually consistent results. However, we argue that FCT and isochrone synthesis results are reliable for application to real systems in the wavelength range where they coincide. On the constructive side, we derive several useful survival strategies to bypass uncertainties. We show that single stellar populations at the turn-off ages of the tabulated tracks can be safely compared, as they are scarcely affected by the interpolation scheme used to compute isochrones. Finally, we suggest to use derivative quantities, such as the SN-rate, as bug detectors. On the recommendation side, we advocate for greater transparency and more documentation in synthesis modeling. We also ask stellar model makers to think of us and include more mass values in the tracks.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2004

New estimates of the contribution of Wolf--Rayet stellar winds to the Galactic 26Al

We present new yields of 26Al from Wolf--Rayet stellar winds based on rotating stellar models which account well for numerous observed properties of massive stars. We study the impacts on the yields of a change of initial mass, metallicity and initial rotation velocity. We also consider the effects of a change of mass loss rates during the Wolf--Rayet phase. We show that for surface rotation velocities during the core H--burning phase matching to the observed ones, the quantity of 26Al ejected by a star of a given initial mass and metallicity is roughly doubled when the effects of rotation are taken into account. The metallicity dependence of the yield is, on the other hand, very similar to that obtained from non--rotating models. We estimate that at least about 20% to 50% (e.g. 0.6 --1.4 Msun) of the live 26Al detected in the Milky--Way originates from Wolf--Rayet stellar winds. We show the importance of a good knowledge of the present metallicity gradient and star formation rate in our galaxy for modeling both the variation of the 26Al surface density with the galactocentric distance and the global contribution of the Wolf--Rayet stellar winds to the present galactic mass of 26Al.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

26Al yields from rotating Wolf--Rayet star models

We present new $^{26}$Al stellar yields from rotating Wolf--Rayet stellar models which, at solar metallicity, well reproduce the observed properties of the Wolf-Rayet populations. These new yields are enhanced with respect to non--rotating models, even with respect to non--rotating models computed with enhanced mass loss rates. We briefly discuss some implications of the use of these new yields for estimating the global contribution of Wolf-Rayet stars to the quantity of $^{26}$Al now present in the Milky Way.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

Physical limits to the validity of synthesis models: The Lowest Luminosity Limit

(abriged) In this paper we establish a Lowest Luminosity Limit (LLL) for the use of synthesis codes. The limit is defined by the following statement: The total luminosity of the cluster modeled must be larger than the individual contribution of any of the stars included in the assumed isochrones. This limit is independent of the assumptions on the IMF and almost independent on the star formation history. We have obtained the LLL for a wide range of ages (5 Myr to 20 Gyr) and metallicities (Z=0 to Z=0.019) from Girardi et al. (2002) isochrones. Using the LLL and the results of evolutionary synthesis models we have also obtained the minimal cluster mass, Mmin, for which the results of synthesis models may suffer from a severe bias in the computation of colors. We show that the results of synthesis models for clusters with mass equal to Mmin have a relative dispersion about or larger than 32% (i.e. a dispersion of 0.35 mag) in the corresponding photometric bands. This effect is more important for near infrared bands (except in the case where Asymptotic Giant Branch stars dominate the luminosity in optical bands). In particular, Mmin takes values between 10^4 and 10^5 Mo for the K band. From the observational point of view, we show that in surveys that reach luminosities near the LLL, the color distributions will be skewed toward the color with lower effective sources (toward the red in general), and that the skewness is a signature of the distribution of initial cluster masses in the survey. We also apply the LLL to Globular Clusters showing that sampling effects are relevant in these clusters and that they can explain (at least partially) the bias of the observed colors with respect to the predictions of synthesis models.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

On emission-line spectra obtained from evolutionary synthesis models I. Dispersion in the ionising flux and Lowest Luminosity Limits

(abriged) Stellar clusters with the same general physical properties (e.g., total mass, age, and star-formation mode) may have very different stellar mass spectra due to the incomplete sampling of the underlying mass function; such differences are especially relevant in the high-mass tail due to the smaller absolute number of massive stars. The dispersion in the number of massive stars also produces a dispersion in the properties of the corresponding ionising spectra. In this paper, we lay the bases for the future analysis of this effect by evaluating the dispersion in the ionising fluxes of synthetic spectra. As an important consequence, we found that the intensities of synthetic fluxes at different ionisation edges are strongly correlated, a fact suggesting that no additional dispersion will result from the inclusion of sampling effects in the analysis of diagnostic diagrams; this is true for HII regions on all scales. Additionally, we find convincing suggestions that the He II lines are strongly affected by sampling, and so cannot be used to constrain the evolutionary status of stellar clusters. We also establish the range of applicability of synthesis models set by the Lowest Luminosity Limit for the ionising flux, that is the lowest limit in cluster mass for which synthesis models can be applied to predict ionising spectra. This limit marks the boundary between the situations in which the ionising flux is better modeled with a single star as opposed to a star cluster; this boundary depends on the metallicity and age, ranging from 10^3 to more than 10^6 Mo. As a consequence, synthesis models should not be used to try to account for the properties of clusters with smaller masses.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

The effect of collisional enhancement of Balmer lines on the determination of the primordial helium abundance

This paper describes a new determination of the primordial helium abundance (Y_P), based on the abundance analysis of five metal-poor extragalactic HII regions. For three regions of the sample (SBS 0335-052, I Zw 18, and H29) we present tailored photoionization models based on improved calculations with respect to previous models. In particular, we use the photoionization models to study quantitatively the effect of collisional excitation of Balmer lines on the determination of the helium abundance (Y) in the individual regions. This effect is twofold: first, the intensities of the Balmer lines are enhanced with respect to the pure recombination value, mimicking a higher hydrogen abundance; second, the observed reddening is larger than the true extinction, due to the differential effect of collisions on different Balmer lines. In addition to these effects, our analysis takes into account the following features of HII regions: (i) the temperature structure, (ii) the density structure, (iii) the presence of neutral helium, (iv) the collisional excitation of the HeI lines, (v) the underlying absorption of the HeI lines, and (vi) the optical thickness of the HeI lines. The object that shows the highest increase in Y after the inclusion of collisional effects in the analysis is SBS 0335-052, whose helium abundance has been revised by Delta Y = +0.0107. The revised Y values for the five objects in our sample yield an increase of +0.0035 in Y_P, giving Y_P = 0.2391 +/- 0.0020.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

Physical conditions in NGC 6543 from ISO and HST data and the pitfalls of temperature maps

We determine the physical conditions in NGC 6543, obtaining two different estimates of the electron temperature (T_e) and one estimate of the electron density (N_e). The electron temperature is computed by means of the [O III] ratio lambda 5007/lambda 4363, and of the diagnostic diagram combining lambda 5007 to the [O III] infrared lines 52m and 88m. The continuum intensity measured on slit spectra is much higher than theoretically predicted under the simplest assumptions. After considering several possibilities, we suggest enhanced 2-photon emission as the most probable source of the additional continuum. While T_e and N_e derived from the diagnostic diagram agree with the most recent determination, T_e derived from lambda 5007/lambda 4363 is smaller than previously published values, probably due to the bias in lambda 4363 introduced by the uncertainty in the continuum. Our main conclusion is that it is not possible, with present-day data, to derive accurate temperature maps of photoionized nebulae.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

Statistical Synthesis Models

In this contribution we evaluate the minimal cluster mass for which the effects of an incomplete sampling of the Initial Mass Function (IMF) cannot be neglected. This minimal cluster mass corresponds to the situation in which the integrated luminosity of the cluster modeled equals the luminosity of the most luminous individual star included in the model, and it takes values between 3x10^2 and 6x10^5 Mo depending on the age and the observed band. We show different examples for young (t < 10 Myr) and old (t up to 10 Gyr) stellar populations. We also make here a first release of the spectral energy distribution (SED) from 160 mic. (1.8x10^12 Hz) to 25 keV (6.0x10^18 Hz) for star-forming regions with ages between 0.1 and 10 Myr, and metallicities between Z=0.001 and Z=0.040. The SEDs are available at our WWW server and include the corresponding quantities for the evaluation of sampling effects. These SEDs can be directly used to obtain colors (including the X-rays ones), as input of photoionization codes, or for chi^2 fitting with observed data taking into account the intrinsic uncertainty of the models due to the IMF sampling.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2003

Physical conditions in the O++ zone from ISO and HST data. NGC 6543 revisited

We revise the physical conditions in the O++ zone of the planetary nebula NGC 6543, obtaining two different estimates of the electron temperature (Te) and one estimate of the electron density (Ne). The electron temperature is computed by means of two independent methods, the nebular-to-auroral ratio [O III] 5007/4363, and the diagnostic diagram that combines 5007 to the [O III] infrared lines 52m and 88m. The optical and infrared fluxes have been obtained from archive HST/WFPC2 images and ISO LWS spectra respectively, and the continuum intensity in the optical has been measured from narrow-slit spectra obtained with the Isaac Newton Telescope at La Palma. The measured continuum intensity is higher than predicted by recombination theory under the hypothesis that all the Ly-alpha photons either escape or are destroyed. This fact can be explained in terms of an enhancement of the 2-photon continuum due to Ly-alpha conversion, a process that depends strongly on the local structure of the nebula. Alternative possibilities, outside the framework of recombination theory, have also been considered: e.g., the optical tail in the X-ray emission of a very hot plasma, and dust scattering of stellar radiation, but these hypotheses are not supported by quantitative estimates. While the electron temperature and density derived from the diagnostic diagram agree with the most recent determination, the temperature derived from 5007/4363,, Te(O++)_opt, is somewhat smaller than previously published values. We discuss several technical issues that contribute to the overall uncertainty in our results, focusing on the instrumental effects that might bias the [O III] 4363 intensity. We also discuss the effects of the collisional de-excitation of the O++ ground terms on the relation between Te(O++)_opt and Te(O++)_IR.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

A multiwavelength vision of star forming regions: What does lambda_1 know about lambda_2?

In this contribution I show the physical limitations to the application of standard synthesis models from 0 to 10 Gyr. I also present the multiwavelength spectrum (from gamma-rays to radio) of young star forming regions based on evolutionary population synthesis models that takes into account the stochasticity of the star formation proces. I show how the correlation of different observables can allow to establish a better understanding of the star formation processes. Finally I compare the spectral energy distribution of AGNs and star forming regions and I show the possible connection of Star Forming Galaxies with Seyfert 2 AGNs.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

On the self-consistency of evolutionary synthesis models

Evolutionary synthesis models have been used to study the physical properties of unresolved populations in a wide range of scenarios. Unfortunately, their self-consistency are difficult to test and there are some theoretical open questions without an answer: (1) The change of the homology relations assumed in the computation of isochrones due to the effect of stellar winds (or rotation) and the discontinuities in the stellar evolution are not considered. (2) There is no a consensus about how the isochrones must be integrated. (3) The discreteness of the stellar populations (that produce an intrinsic statistical dispersion) usually are not taken into account, and model results are interpreted in a deterministic way instead a statistical one... The objective of this contribution is to present some inconsistencies in the computation and some cautions in the application of the results of such codes.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

On biases in the predictions of stellar population synthesis models

Sampling fluctuations in stellar populations give rise to dispersions in observables when a small number of sources contribute effectively to the observables. This is the case for a variety of linear functions of the spectral energy distribution (SED) in small stellar systems, such as galactic and extragalactic HII regions, dwarf galaxies or stellar clusters. In this paper we show that sampling fluctuations also introduce systematic biases and multi-modality in non-linear functions of the SED, such as luminosity ratios, magnitudes and colours. In some cases, the distribution functions of rational and logarithmic quantities are bimodal, hence complicating considerably the interpretation of these quantities in terms of age or evolutionary stages. These biases can be only assessed by Monte Carlo simulations. We find that biases are usually negligible when the effective number of stars, Neff, which contribute to a given observable is larger than 10. Bimodal distributions may appear when Neff is between 10 and 0.1. Predictions from any model of stellar population synthesis become extremely unreliable for small Neff values, providing an operational limit to the applicability of such models for the interpretation of integrated properties of stellar systems. In terms of stellar masses, assuming a Salpeter Initial Mass Function in the range 0.08 -- 120 Mo, Neff=10 corresponds to about 10**5 Mo (although the exact value depends on the age and the observable). This bias may account, at least in part, for claimed variations in the properties of the stellar initial mass function in small systems, and arises from the discrete nature of small stellar populations.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

On the effect of discrete numbers of stars in chemical evolution models

We examine the impact of discrete numbers of stars in stellar populations on the results of Chemical Evolution Models. We explore the resulting dispersion in the true yields and their possible relation with the dispersion in observational data based on a Simple Closed-Box model. In this framework we find that the dispersion is larger for the less evolved or low abundance regions. Thus, the age-metallicity relation may be a tracer of the Star Formation History of our Galaxy. This theoretical dispersion is especially high for the relative abundance log(N/O) in regions where the total number of stars created is still low. This may explain part of the scatter in the N/O ratio observed in star forming galaxies. We have also found a first order theoretical estimation for the goodness of a linear fit of the Helium abundance vs. 12 + log (O/H) with values of the regression coefficient between 0.9 and 0.7 (independent of sampling effects). We conclude that it is necessary to include these sampling effects in a more realistic Chemical Evolution Model in order that such a model reproduces, at the same time, the mean value and the dispersion of observed abundances.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

Evolutionary synthesis models of starbursts IV. Soft X-ray emission

In this work we investigate the evolution of the X-ray emission of a cluster of single young massive stars with different metallicities. We have considered the X-ray contribution originated by the diffuse gas heated by the mechanical energy released by stellar winds and SN explosions as well as the X-ray contribution from SN remnants. The resulting ionizing spectrum (i.e. lambda < 912 A) has been used to compute the expected intensity of the nebular He II 4686 A. The observational ratio He II/Hbeta could be reproduced by the models assuming that a fraction of the mechanical energy produced by the star-formation episode is reprocessed by interaction with the ISM as soft X-ray radiation, contributing to the He ionization. However, the discreteness of the stellar populations affects the ionizing flux and may be responsible for the observed dispersion of the ratio. We have finally used the synthesis models to estimate the contribution of circumnuclear star-forming regions to the multiwavelength energy distribution in Active Galactic Nuclei, finding that the UV to soft X-ray continuum in many Seyfert 2 galaxies seems to be dominated by star-formation processes.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2002

Resolved and unresolved populations: statistics and synthesis models

In this contribution, I present the 90% confidence limits on the diagnostic diagrams of EW(WR bump) and L(WR bump)/L(Hb) ratio vs. EW(Hb) resulting from evolutionary synthesis models that include the statistical dispersion due to finite stellar populations in real star forming regions.

astro-ph↗