arXiv subjects

Matthew W. Kunz

Publications and source records attributed to Matthew W. Kunz.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

arXiv2023

Cosmic ray transport in large-amplitude turbulence with small-scale field reversals

The nature of cosmic ray (CR) transport in the Milky Way remains elusive. The predictions of current micro-physical CR transport models in magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence are drastically different from what is observed. These models usually focus on MHD turbulence with a strong guide field and ignore the impact of turbulent intermittency on particle propagation. This motivates our studying the alternative regime of large-amplitude turbulence with $δB/B_0 \gg 1$, in which intermittent small-scale magnetic field reversals are ubiquitous. We study particle transport in such turbulence by integrating trajectories in stationary snapshots. To quantify spatial diffusion, we use a setup with continuous particle injection and escape, which we term the turbulent leaky box. We find that particle transport is very different from the strong-guide-field case. Low-energy particles are better confined than high-energy particles, despite less efficient pitch-angle isotropization at small energies. In the limit of weak guide field, energy-dependent confinement is driven by the energy-dependent (in)ability to follow reversing magnetic field lines exactly and by the scattering in regions of ``resonant curvature", where the field line bends on a scale that is of order the local particle gyro-radius. We derive a heuristic model of particle transport in magnetic folds that approximately reproduces the energy dependence of transport found numerically. We speculate that CR propagation in the Galaxy is regulated by the intermittent field reversals highlighted here and discuss the implications of our findings for CR transport in the Milky Way.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

On hydromagnetic wave interactions in collisionless, high-$β$ plasmas

We describe the interaction of parallel-propagating Alfvén waves with ion-acoustic waves and other Alfvén waves, in magnetized, high-$β$ collisionless plasmas. This is accomplished through a combination of analytical theory and numerical fluid simulations of the Chew-Goldberger-Low (CGL) magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations closed by Landau-fluid heat fluxes. An asymptotic ordering is employed to simplify the CGL-MHD equations and derive solutions for the deformation of an Alfvén wave that results from its interaction with the pressure anisotropy generated either by an ion-acoustic wave or another, larger-amplitude Alfvén wave. The difference in timescales of acoustic and Alfvénic fluctuations at high-$β$ means that interactions that are local in wavenumber space yield little modification to either mode within the time it takes the acoustic wave to Landau damp away. Instead, order-unity changes in the amplitude of Alfvénic fluctuations can result after interacting with frequency-matched acoustic waves. Additionally, we show that the propagation speed of an Alfvén-wave packet in an otherwise homogeneous background is a function of its self-generated pressure anisotropy. This allows for the eventual interaction of separate co-propagating Alfvén-wave packets of differing amplitudes. The results of the CGL-MHD simulations agree well with these predictions, suggesting that theoretical models relying on the interaction of these modes should be reconsidered in certain astrophysical environments. Applications of these results to weak Alfvénic turbulence and to the interaction between the compressive and Alfvénic cascades in strong, collisionless turbulence are also discussed.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Local models of two-temperature accretion disc coronae. I. Structure, outflows, and energetics

We use local stratified shearing-box simulations to elucidate the impact of two-temperature thermodynamics on the thermal structure of coronae in radiatively efficient accretion flows. Rather than treating the coronal plasma as an isothermal fluid, we use a simple, parameterized cooling function that models the collisional transfer of energy from the ions to the rapidly cooling leptons. Two-temperature models naturally form temperature inversions, with a hot, magnetically dominated corona surrounding a cold disc. Simulations with net vertical flux (NF) magnetic fields launch powerful magnetocentrifugal winds that would enhance accretion in a global system. The outflow rates are much better converged with increasing box height than analogous isothermal simulations, suggesting that the winds into two-temperature coronae may be sufficiently strong to evaporate a thin disc and form a radiatively inefficient accretion flow under some conditions. We find evidence for multiphase structure in the corona, with broad density and temperature distributions, and we propose criteria for the formation of a multiphase corona. The fraction of cooling in the surface layers of the disc is substantially larger for NF fields compared to zero net-flux configurations, with moderate NF simulations radiating ${\gtrsim}30$ per cent of the flow's total luminosity above two midplane scale-heights. Our work shows that NF fields may efficiently power the coronae of luminous Seyfert galaxies and quasars, providing compelling motivation for future studies of the heating mechanisms available to NF fields and the interplay of radiation with two-temperature thermodynamics.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Magnetogenesis in a collisionless plasma: from Weibel instability to turbulent dynamo

We report on a first-principles numerical and theoretical study of plasma dynamo in a fully kinetic framework. By applying an external mechanical force to an initially unmagnetized plasma, we develop a self-consistent treatment of the generation of ``seed'' magnetic fields, the formation of turbulence, and the inductive amplification of fields by the fluctuation dynamo. Driven large-scale motions in an unmagnetized, weakly collisional plasma are subject to strong phase mixing, which leads to the development of thermal pressure anisotropy. This anisotropy triggers the Weibel instability, which produces filamentary ``seed'' magnetic fields on plasma-kinetic scales. The plasma is thereby magnetized, enabling efficient stretching and folding of the fields by the plasma motions and the development of Larmor-scale kinetic instabilities such as the firehose and mirror. The scattering of particles off the associated microscale magnetic fluctuations provides an effective viscosity, regulating the field morphology and turbulence. During this process, the seed field is further amplified by the fluctuation dynamo until they reach energy equipartition with the turbulent flow. By demonstrating that equipartition magnetic fields can be generated from an initially unmagnetized plasma through large-scale turbulent flows, this work has important implications for the origin and amplification of magnetic fields in the intracluster and intergalactic mediums.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Microphysically modified magnetosonic modes in collisionless, high-$β$ plasmas

With the support of hybrid-kinetic simulations and analytic theory, we describe the nonlinear behaviour of long-wavelength non-propagating (NP) modes and fast magnetosonic waves in high-$β$ collisionless plasmas, with particular attention to their excitation of, and reaction to, kinetic micro-instabilities. The perpendicularly pressure balanced polarization of NP modes produces an excess of perpendicular pressure over parallel pressure in regions where the plasma $β$ is increased. For mode amplitudes $δB/B_0 \gtrsim 0.3$, this excess excites the mirror instability. Particle scattering off these micro-scale mirrors frustrates the nonlinear saturation of transit-time damping, ensuring that large-amplitude NP modes continue their decay to small amplitudes. At asymptotically large wavelengths, we predict that the mirror-induced scattering will be large enough to interrupt transit-time damping entirely, isotropizing the pressure perturbations and morphing the collisionless NP mode into the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) entropy mode. In fast waves, a fluctuating pressure anisotropy drives both mirror and firehose instabilities when the wave amplitude satisfies $δB/B_0 \gtrsim 2β^{-1}$. The induced particle scattering leads to delayed shock formation and MHD-like wave dynamics. Taken alongside prior work on self-interrupting Alfvén waves and self-sustaining ion-acoustic waves, our results establish a foundation for new theories of electromagnetic turbulence in low-collisionality, high-$β$ plasmas such as the intracluster medium, radiatively inefficient accretion flows, and the near-Earth solar wind.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Kinetic Turbulence in Collisionless High-Beta Plasmas

We present results from three-dimensional hybrid-kinetic simulations of Alfvénic turbulence in a high-beta, collisionless plasma. The key feature of such turbulence is the interplay between local wave--wave interactions between the fluctuations in the cascade and the non-local wave-particle interactions associated with kinetic micro-instabilities driven by anisotropy in the thermal pressure (namely, firehose, mirror, and ion-cyclotron). We present theoretical estimates for, and calculate directly from the simulations, the effective collisionality and plasma viscosity in pressure-anisotropic high-beta turbulence, demonstrating that, for strong Alfvénic turbulence, the effective parallel-viscous scale is comparable to the driving scale of the cascade. Below this scale, the kinetic-energy spectrum indicates an Alfvénic cascade with a slope steeper than $-5/3$ due to the anisotropic viscous stress. The magnetic-energy spectrum is shallower than $-5/3$ near the ion-Larmor scale due to fluctuations produced by the firehose instability. Most of the cascade energy (80-90%) is dissipated as ion heating through a combination of Landau damping and anisotropic viscous heating. Our results have implications for models of particle heating in low-luminosity accretion onto supermassive black holes, the effective viscosity of the intracluster medium, and the interpretation of near-Earth solar-wind observations.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2022

Synchrotron Firehose Instability

We demonstrate using linear theory and particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations that a synchrotron-cooling collisionless plasma acquires pressure anisotropy and, if the plasma beta is sufficiently high, becomes unstable to the firehose instability, in a process that we dub the synchrotron firehose instability (SFHI). The SFHI channels free energy from the pressure anisotropy of the radiating, relativistic electrons (and/or positrons) into small-amplitude, kinetic-scale magnetic-field fluctuations, which pitch-angle scatter the particles and bring the plasma to a near-thermal state of marginal instability. The PIC simulations reveal a nonlinear cyclic evolution of firehose bursts interspersed by periods of stable cooling. We compare the SFHI for electron-positron and electron-ion plasmas. As a byproduct of the growing electron-firehose magnetic field fluctuations, magnetized ions gain a pressure anisotropy opposite to that of the electrons. If these ions are relativistically hot, we find that they also experience cooling due to collisionless thermal coupling with the electrons, which we argue is mediated by a secondary ion-cyclotron instability. We suggest that the SFHI may be activated in a number of astrophysical scenarios, such as within ejecta from black-hole accretion flows and relativistic jets, where the redistribution of energetic electrons from low to high pitch angles may cause transient bursts of radiation.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2022

Tearing instability and current-sheet disruption in the turbulent dynamo

Turbulence in a conducting plasma can amplify seed magnetic fields in what is known as the turbulent, or small-scale, dynamo. The associated growth rate and emergent magnetic-field geometry depend sensitively on the material properties of the plasma, in particular on the Reynolds number ${\rm Re}$, the magnetic Reynolds number ${\rm Rm}$, and their ratio ${\rm Pm}\equiv{\rm Rm}/{\rm Re}$. For ${\rm Pm} > 1$, the amplified magnetic field is gradually arranged into a folded structure, with direction reversals at the resistive scale and field lines curved at the larger scale of the flow. As the mean magnetic energy grows to come into approximate equipartition with the fluid motions, this folded structure is thought to persist. Using analytical theory and high-resolution MHD simulations with the Athena++ code, we show that these magnetic folds become unstable to tearing during the nonlinear stage of the dynamo for ${\rm Rm}\gtrsim 10^4$ and ${\rm Re}\gtrsim 10^3$. An ${\rm Rm}$- and ${\rm Pm}$-dependent tearing scale, at and below which folds are disrupted, is predicted theoretically and found to match well the characteristic field-reversal scale measured in the simulations. The disruption of folds by tearing increases the ratio of viscous-to-resistive dissipation. In the saturated state, the magnetic-energy spectrum exhibits a sub-tearing-scale steepening to a slope consistent with that predicted for tearing-mediated Alfvénic turbulence. Its spectral peak appears to be independent of the resistive scale and comparable to the driving scale of the flow, while the magnetic energy resides in a broad range of scales extending down to the field-reversal scale set by tearing. Emergence of a degree of large-scale magnetic coherence in the saturated state of the turbulent dynamo may be consistent with observations of magnetic-field fluctuations in galaxy clusters and recent laboratory experiments.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2022

Turbulent regimes in collisions of 3D Alfvén-wave packets

Using 3D gyrofluid simulations, we revisit the problem of Alfven-wave (AW) collisions as building blocks of the Alfvenic cascade and their interplay with magnetic reconnection at magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) scales. Depending on the large-scale nonlinearity parameter $χ_0$ (the ratio between AW linear propagation time and nonlinear turnover time), different regimes are observed. For strong nonlinearities ($χ_0\sim1$), turbulence is consistent with a dynamically aligned, critically balanced cascade--fluctuations exhibit a scale-dependent alignment $\sinθ_k\propto k_\perp^{-1/4}$, a $k_\perp^{-3/2}$ spectrum and $k_\|\propto k_\perp^{1/2}$ spectral anisotropy. At weaker nonlinearities (small $χ_0$), a spectral break marking the transition between a large-scale weak regime and a small-scale $k_\perp^{-11/5}$ tearing-mediated range emerges, implying that dynamic alignment occurs also for weak nonlinearities. At $χ_0<1$ the alignment angle $θ_{k_\perp}$ shows a stronger scale dependence than in the $χ_0\sim1$ regime, i.e. $\sinθ_k\propto k_\perp^{-1/2}$ at $χ_0\sim0.5$, and $\sinθ_k\propto k_\perp^{-1}$ at $χ_0\sim0.1$. Dynamic alignment in the weak regime also modifies the large-scale spectrum, scaling roughly as $k_\perp^{-3/2}$ for $χ_0\sim0.5$ and as $k_\perp^{-1}$ for $χ_0\sim0.1$. A phenomenological theory of dynamically aligned turbulence at weak nonlinearities that can explain these spectra and the transition to the tearing-mediated regime is provided; at small $χ_0$, the strong scale dependence of the alignment angle combines with the increased lifetime of turbulent eddies to allow tearing to onset and mediate the cascade at scales that can be larger than those predicted for a critically balanced cascade by several orders of magnitude. Such a transition to tearing-mediated turbulence may even supplant the usual weak-to-strong transition.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2022

Plasma physics of the intracluster medium

This Chapter provides a brief tutorial on some aspects of plasma physics that are fundamental to understanding the dynamics and energetics of the intracluster medium (ICM). The tutorial is split into two parts: one that focuses on the thermal plasma component -- its stability, viscosity, conductivity, and ability to amplify magnetic fields to dynamical strengths via turbulence and other plasma processes; and one that focuses on the non-thermal population of charged particles known as cosmic rays -- their acceleration, re-acceleration, and transport throughout the cluster volume. Observational context is woven throughout the narrative, from constraints on the strength and geometry of intracluster magnetic fields and the effective viscosity of the ICM, to examples of radio halos, radio relics, and cluster shocks that can test theories of particle acceleration. The promise of future X-ray missions to probe intracluster turbulence and discover the impact of small-scale plasma physics, coupled with sensitive, high-resolution radio observations of synchrotron-emitting plasma that reveal the properties of intracluster magnetic fields and particle-acceleration mechanisms, are likely to establish galaxy clusters as the premier cosmic laboratories for deciphering the fundamental physics of hot, dilute plasmas.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2022

High-frequency heating of the solar wind triggered by low-frequency turbulence

The fast solar wind's high speeds and nonthermal features require that significant heating occurs well above the Sun's surface. Two leading theories seem incompatible: low-frequency "Alfvénic" turbulence, which transports energy outwards and is observed ubiquitously by spacecraft but struggles to explain the observed dominance of ion over electron heating; and high-frequency ion-cyclotron waves (ICWs), which explain the nonthermal heating of ions but lack an obvious source. Here, we argue that the recently proposed "helicity barrier" effect, which limits electron heating by inhibiting the turbulent cascade of energy to the smallest scales, can unify these two paradigms. Our six-dimensional simulations show how the helicity barrier causes the large-scale energy to grow in time, generating small parallel scales and high-frequency ICW heating from low-frequency turbulence. The resulting turbulence and ion distribution function also closely match in-situ measurements from Parker Solar Probe and other spacecraft, explaining, among other features, the decades-long puzzle of the steep "transition range" observed in magnetic fluctuation spectra. The theory predicts a causal link between plasma expansion and the ion-to-electron heating ratio. Given the observational association between wind speed and expansion, we argue that the helicity barrier could play a key role in regulating the bimodal speed distribution of the solar wind.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2022

Triggering tearing in a forming current sheet with the mirror instability

We study the time-dependent formation and evolution of a current sheet (CS) in a magnetized, collisionless, high-beta plasma using hybrid-kinetic particle-in-cell simulations. An initially tearing-stable Harris sheet is frozen into a persistently driven incompressible flow so that its characteristic thickness gradually decreases in time. As the CS thins, the strength of the reconnecting field increases, and adiabatic invariance in the inflowing fluid elements produces a field-biased pressure anisotropy with excess perpendicular pressure. At large plasma beta, this anisotropy excites the mirror instability, which deforms the reconnecting field on ion-Larmor scales and dramatically reduces the effective thickness of the CS. Tearing modes whose wavelengths are comparable to that of the mirrors then become unstable, triggering reconnection on smaller scales and at earlier times than would have occurred if the thinning CS were to have retained its Harris profile. A novel method for identifying and tracking X-points is introduced, yielding X-point separations that are initially intermediate between the perpendicular and parallel mirror wavelengths in the upstream plasma. These mirror-stimulated tearing modes ultimately grow and merge to produce island widths comparable to the CS thickness, an outcome we verify across a range of CS formation timescales and initial CS widths. Our results may find their most immediate application in the tearing disruption of magnetic folds generated by turbulent dynamo in weakly collisional, high-beta, astrophysical plasmas.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2022

The vertical shear instability in poorly ionised, magnetized protoplanetary discs

Protoplanetary discs should exhibit a weak vertical variation in their rotation profiles. Typically this `vertical shear' issues from a baroclinic effect driven by the central star's radiation field, but it might also arise during the launching of a magnetocentrifugal wind. As a consequence, protoplanetary discs are subject to a hydrodynamical instability, the `vertical shear instability' (VSI), whose breakdown into turbulence could transport a moderate amount of angular momentum and facilitate, or interfere with, the process of planet formation. Magnetic fields may suppress the VSI, however, either directly via magnetic tension or indirectly through magnetorotational turbulence. On the other hand, protoplanetary discs exhibit notoriously low ionisation fractions, and non-ideal effects, if sufficiently dominant, may come to the VSI's rescue. In this paper we develop a local linear theory that explores how non-ideal MHD influences the VSI, while also launching additional diffusive shear instabilities. We derive a set of analytical criteria that establish when the VSI prevails, and then show how it can be applied to a realistic global model of a protoplanetary disc. Our calculations suggest that within ~10au the VSI should have little trouble emerging in the main body of the disk, but beyond that, and in the upper regions of the disc, its onset depends sensitively on the size of the preponderant dust grains.

astro-ph.EP↗

arXiv2021

Spontaneous magnetization of collisionless plasma through the action of a shear flow

We study in a fully kinetic framework the generation of seed magnetic fields through the Weibel instability driven in an initially unmagnetized plasma by a large-scale shear force. We develop an analytical model that describes the development of thermal pressure anisotropy via phase mixing, the ensuing exponential growth of magnetic fields in the linear Weibel stage, and its saturation when the seed magnetic fields become strong enough to instigate gyromotion of particles and thereby inhibit their free-streaming. The predicted scaling dependencies of the saturated seed fields on key parameters (e.g., ratio of system scale to electron skin depth, the forcing amplitude) are confirmed by 3D and 2D particle-in-cell simulations using an electron-positron plasma. This work demonstrates the spontaneous magnetization of a collisionless plasma through large-scale motions as simple as a shear flow, and therefore has important implications for magnetogenesis in dilute astrophysical systems.

physics.plasm-ph↗

arXiv2021

Formation and evolution of protostellar accretion discs. II. From 3D simulation to a simple semi-analytic model of Class 0/I discs

We use a 3D radiative non-ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation to investigate the formation and evolution of a young protostellar disc from a magnetized pre-stellar core. The simulation covers the first ${\sim}10~{\rm kyr}$ after protostar formation, and shows a massive, weakly magnetized disc with radius that initially grows and then saturates at ${\sim}30~{\rm au}$. The disc is gravitationally unstable with prominent large-amplitude spiral arms. We use our simulation results and a series of physical arguments to construct a predictive and quantitative physical picture of Class 0/I protostellar disc evolution from several aspects, including (i) the angular-momentum redistribution in the disc, self-regulated by gravitational instability to make most of the disc marginally unstable; (ii) the thermal profile of the disc, well-approximated by a balance between radiative cooling and accretion heating; and (iii) the magnetic-field strength and magnetic-braking rate inside the disc, regulated by non-ideal magnetic diffusion. Using these physical insights, we build a simple 1D semi-analytic model of disc evolution. We show that this 1D model, when coupled to a computationally inexpensive simulation for the evolution of the surrounding pseudodisc, can be used reliably to predict disc evolution in the Class 0/I phase. The predicted long-term evolution of disc size, which saturates at ${\sim}30~{\rm au}$ and eventually shrinks, is consistent with a recent observational survey of Class 0/I discs. Such hierarchical modelling of disc evolution circumvents the computational difficulty of tracing disc evolution through Class 0/I phase with direct, numerically converged simulations.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

On stochastic heating and its phase-space signatures in low-$β$ kinetic turbulence

We revisit the theory of stochastic heating of ions and investigate its phase-space signatures in kinetic turbulence of relevance to low-$β$ portions of the solar wind. We retain a full scale-dependent approach in our treatment, and consider the case in which electric-field fluctuations can be described by a generalized Ohm's law that includes Hall and thermo-electric effects. These two electric-field terms provide the dominant contributions to stochastic ion heating when the ion-Larmor scale is much smaller than the ion skin depth, $ρ_{\mathrm{i}}\ll d_{\mathrm{i}}$, which is the case at $β{\ll}1$. Employing well-known spectral scaling laws for Alfvén-wave and kinetic-Alfvén-wave turbulent fluctuations, we obtain scaling relations characterizing the field-perpendicular particle-energization rate and energy diffusion coefficient associated with stochastic heating in these two regimes. Phase-space signatures of ion heating are then investigated using 3D hybrid-kinetic simulations of continuously driven Alfvénic turbulence at low $β$. In these simulations, energization of ions parallel to the magnetic field is sub-dominant compared to its perpendicular counterpart ($Q_{\parallel,\mathrm{i}}\ll Q_{\perp,\mathrm{i}}$), and the fraction of turbulent energy that goes into ion heating is ${\approx}75$\% at $β_{\mathrm{i}}=0.3$ and ${\approx}40$\% at $β_{\mathrm{i}}{\simeq}0.1$. The phase-space signatures of ion energization are consistent with Landau-resonant collisionless damping and a ($β$-dependent) combination of ion-cyclotron and stochastic heating. We demonstrate good agreement between our theory and various signatures associated with the stochastic portion of the heating. We discuss the effect of intermittency on stochastic heating and the implications of our work for the interpretation of stochastic heating in solar-wind spacecraft data.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

Formation and evolution of protostellar accretion discs. I. Angular-momentum budget, gravitational self-regulation, and numerical convergence

We investigate the formation and early evolution of a protostellar disc from a magnetized pre-stellar core using non-ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations including ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic dissipation. The dynamical contraction of the pre-stellar core ultimately leads to the formation of a first hydrostatic core, after ambipolar diffusion decouples the magnetic field from the predominantly neutral gas. The hydrostatic core accumulates angular momentum from the infalling material, evolving into a rotationally supported torus; this `first hydrostatic torus' then forms an accreting protostar and a rotationally supported disc. The disc spreads out by gravitational instability, reaching $\sim$30 au in diameter at $\sim$3 kyr after protostar formation. The total mass and angular momentum of the protostar-disc system are determined mainly by accretion of gas from an infalling pseudo-disc, which has low specific angular momentum because of magnetic braking; their removal from the protostar-disc system by outflow and disc magnetic braking are negligible, in part because the magnetic field is poorly coupled there. The redistribution of angular momentum within the protostar-disc system is facilitated mainly by gravitational instability; this allows formation of relatively large discs even when the specific angular momentum of infalling material is low. We argue that such discs should remain marginally unstable as they grow (with Toomre $Q\sim 1$-$2$), an idea that is broadly consistent with recent observational estimates for Class 0/I discs. We discuss the numerical convergence of our results, and show that properly treating the inner boundary condition is crucial for achieving convergence at an acceptable computational cost.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2020

Production and persistence of extreme two-temperature plasmas in radiative relativistic turbulence

Turbulence is a predominant process for energizing electrons and ions in collisionless astrophysical plasmas, and thus is responsible for shaping their radiative signatures (luminosity, spectra, and variability). To better understand the kinetic properties of a collisionless radiative plasma subject to externally driven turbulence, we investigate particle-in-cell simulations of relativistic plasma turbulence with external inverse Compton cooling acting on the electrons. We find that ions continuously heat up while electrons gradually cool down (due to the net effect of radiation), and hence the ion-to-electron temperature ratio $T_i/T_e$ grows in time. We show that $T_i/T_e$ is limited only by the size and duration of the simulations (reaching $T_i/T_e \sim 10^3$), indicating that there are no efficient collisionless mechanisms of electron-ion thermal coupling. This result has implications for models of radiatively inefficient accretion flows, such as observed in the Galactic Center and in M87, for which so-called two-temperature plasmas with $T_i/T_e \gg 1$ have been invoked to explain their low luminosity. Additionally, we find that electrons acquire a quasi-thermal distribution (dictated by the competition of turbulent particle energization and radiative cooling), while ions undergo efficient nonthermal acceleration (acquiring a harder distribution than in equivalent non-radiative simulations). There is a modest nonthermal population of high-energy electrons that are beamed intermittently in space, time, and direction; these beamed electrons may explain rapid flares in certain high-energy astrophysical systems (e.g., in the Galactic Center). These numerical results demonstrate that extreme two-temperature plasmas can be produced and maintained by relativistic radiative turbulence.

astro-ph.HE↗