SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Michel Tallon

Publications and source records attributed to Michel Tallon.

17 recordsLinked to original sources

Optimization of adaptive optics correction during observations: Algorithms and system parameters identification in closed-loop

The adaptive optics (AO) on the European Extremely Large Telescope, as well as earlier pathfinders like the Adaptive Optics Facility, at the Very Large Telescope in 2014, will no longer be stationary systems. AO is no longer isolated on a bench; some elements are directly in the optical train of the telescope, suffering environment and constrains changes during the observations. To guarantee good performance at any observing time, we investigate a self-calibration strategy. We focus here on one of the most challenging aspects: the identification of system parameters during closed-loop observations without introducing any additional disturbance. Such problem is known in the identification theory to be difficult to solve. We have recently presented (B\'echet et al., AO4ELT2 Conference, 2011) an identification method for this, with promising results obtained in simulations. To consolidate these advances, we come back in the present paper to the equations and provide a theoretical analysis to justify the choice of the algorithm. We highlight the benefit of using incremental data and commands to decorrelate the disturbance. We also present 2 implementations of the method, currently studied at the European Southern Observatory.

astro-ph.IM

Self-calibration of adaptive optics systems. Application to the THEMIS solar telescope

The interaction matrix models the effects of deformable mirror (DM) commands as perceived by the wavefront sensor (WFS) and is the cornerstone of the Adaptive Optics (AO) control. Difficulties to calibrate this matrix arise due to the number of degrees of freedom, the non-linearity, and temporal evolution of the AO system. An affine approximation of the unknown mapping between the DM commands and the WFS measurements is considered. Optimal estimators of the parameters of this affine model are obtained by fitting, in the weighted least squares sense, WFS data acquired with random probe commands sent to the DM. Several calibration methods are being considered depending on whether the model is directly fit to the WFS data or to the differences between successive WFS data. We derive closed-form expressions of the estimators of the components of the model. The proposed calibration methods can be applied under different conditions: before observing, on an internal source, or on-sky in open- or closed-loop. By introducing forgetting factors to reduce the weight of data as they age, we show that the model can be learned continuously using simple recurrence rules. The low computational complexity of these rules makes them suitable for real-time at the same frequency as the AO loop. We derive simple expressions for the mean squared errors (MSE) of the proposed estimators. We apply the proposed calibration methods to real telemetry data from the AO system of the THEMIS solar telescope. Our results show that the simple differences method is the method of choice: not only does it produce estimators with the least MSE, but it is also very simple to implement compared to the push-pull method which is widely used in AO systems.

astro-ph.IM

SAXO+, the second-stage adaptive optics for SPHERE: NCPA compensation and dark-hole loop with a pyramid wavefront sensor

The SAXO+ upgrade of the VLT/SPHERE adaptive optics system introduces a second-stage near-infrared pyramid wavefront sensor to improve high-contrast imaging, making accurate calibration of non-common path aberrations (NCPAs) essential to fully exploit its performance. This work refines the expected level of NCPAs in SAXO+ and presents the calibration procedures developed for static NCPA compensation and focal-plane dark-hole control. Monte Carlo simulations based on an updated Zemax optical model were used to estimate the NCPA error budget. These simulations are in good agreement with previous measurements on SPHERE and with the assumptions adopted in earlier performance studies. We also propose a calibration strategy that offloads most static aberration correction to the first-stage deformable mirror while preserving the second-stage mirror stroke for high-speed adaptive optics correction. These results validate the expected SAXO+ optical quality and establish the calibration framework required for efficient NCPA compensation and focal-plane wavefront control during future on-sky operations.

astro-ph.IM

Upgrading SPHERE with the second stage AO system SAXO+: frequency-based data-driven controller for adaptive optics

This study introduces a novel frequency-based data-driven controller for adaptive optics, using power spectral density for optimization while ensuring stability criteria. It addresses disturbance rejection, command amplitude constraints and system transfer functions through convex optimization to obtain an optimal control in an infinite input response filter form. Evaluated within the SAXO+ project, it demonstrates efficacy under diverse atmospheric conditions and operational scenarios. The proposed controller is tested in both standard and disentangled adaptive optics schemes, showcasing its adaptability and performance. Experimental validation is conducted using the COMPASS simulation tool, affirming the controller's promise for enhancing adaptive optics systems in real-world applications.

eess.SY

Upgrading SPHERE with the second stage AO system SAXO+: non-common path aberrations estimation and correction

SAXO+ is a planned enhancement of the existing SAXO, the VLT/ SPHERE adaptive optics system, deployed on ESO's Very Large Telescope. This upgrade is designed to significantly enhance the instrument's capacity to detect and analyze young Jupiter-like planets. The pivotal addition in SAXO+ is a second-stage adaptive optics system featuring a dedicated near-infrared pyramid wavefront sensor and a second deformable mirror. This secondary stage is strategically integrated to address any residual wavefront errors persisting after the initial correction performed by the current primary AO loop, SAXO. However, several recent studies clearly showed that in good conditions, even in the current system SAXO, non-common path aberrations (NCPAs) are the limiting factor of the final normalized intensity in focal plane, which is the final metric for ground-based high-contrast instruments. This is likely to be even more so the case with the new AO system, with which the AO residuals will be minimized. Several techniques have already been extensively tested on SPHERE in internal source and/or on-sky and will be presented in this paper. However, the use of a new type of sensor for the second stage, a pyramid wavefront sensor, will likely complicate the correction of these aberrations. Using an end-to-end AO simulation tool, we conducted simulations to gauge the effect of measured SPHERE NCPAs in the coronagraphic image on the second loop system and their correction using focal plane wavefront sensing systems. We finally analyzed how the chosen position of SAXO+ in the beam will impact the evolution of the NCPAs in the new instrument.

astro-ph.IM

Numerical simulations for the SAXO+ upgrade: Performance analysis of the adaptive optics system

SPHERE, operating at the VLT since 2014, is currently one of the high-contrast instruments with a higher performance. Its adaptive optics system, known as SAXO, will be upgraded to SAXO+, which features the addition of a second stage of adaptive optics. This stage will use a near-infrared pyramid wavefront sensor to record images of fainter exoplanets around redder stars. In this work, we compare the performance of SAXO and SAXO+. We look for the optimal values of the key system parameters of SAXO+ for various science cases and turbulence conditions. We performed numerical simulations using COMPASS, an end-to-end adaptive optics simulation tool. We simulated perfect coronagraph images of an on-axis point source, and we minimized the residual starlight intensity between 3 and 5 $λ/D$ as a performance criterion. The explored parameter space includes science cases, turbulence conditions, and key system parameters. In every science case and turbulence condition, SAXO+ reduces the residual starlight intensity inside the correction zone of the second stage by a factor of ten compared to SAXO. The optimal first stage gain is lower for SAXO+ than for SAXO alone. We quantified the gain in performance of SAXO+ when changing the second stage frequency from 2 kHz to 3 kHz, and we conclude that 2 kHz may be sufficient for most realistic conditions. We give the optimal first stage gain as well as the first and second stage frequencies for every seeing, coherence time, and science case. Finally, we find that a 2 ${λ_{\mathrm{WFS}}}/D$ pyramid modulation radius is a good trade-off between performance and robustness against varying turbulence conditions. This study shows that the future SAXO+ system will outperform the current SAXO system in all studied cases.

astro-ph.IM

Beyond FRiM, ASAP: a family of sparse approximation for covariance matrices and preconditioners

The FRiM fractal operator belongs to a family of operators, called ASAP, defined by an ordered selection of nearest neighbors. This generalization provides means to improve upon the good properties of FRiM. We propose a fast algorithm to build an ASAP operator mimicking the fractal structure of FRiM for pupils of any size and geometry and to learn the sparse coefficients from empirical data. We empirically show the good approximation by ASAP of correlated statistics and the benefits of ASAP for solving phase restoration problems.

astro-ph.IM

Closing the loop as an inverse problem: the real-time control of THEMIS adaptive optics

We have taken advantage of the implementation of an adaptive optics system on the Themis solar telescope to implement innovative strategies based on an inverse problem formulation for the control loop. Such an approach encompassing the whole system implies the estimation of the pixel variances of the Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor, a novel real-time method to extract the wavefront slopes as well as their associated noise covariance, and the computation of pseudo-open loop data. The optimal commands are computed by iteratively solving a regularized inverse problem with spatio-temporal constraints including Kolmogorov statistics. The latency of the dedicated real-time control software with conventional CPU is shorter than 300 $μ$s from the acquisition of the raw 400 x 400 pixel wavefront sensor image to the sending of the commands.

astro-ph.IM

SAXO+ upgrade : second stage AO system end-to-end numerical simulations

SAXO+ is a proposed upgrade to SAXO, the AO system of the SPHERE instrument on the ESO Very Large Telescope. It will improve the capabilities of the instrument for the detection and characterization of young giant planets. It includes a second stage adaptive optics system composed of a dedicated near-infrared wavefront sensor and a deformable mirror. This second stage will remove the residual wavefront errors left by the current primary AO loop (SAXO). This paper focuses on the numerical simulations of the second stage (SAXO+) and concludes on the impact of the main AO parameters used to build the design strategy. Using an end-to-end AO simulation tool (COMPASS), we investigate the impact of several parameters on the performance of the AO system. We measure the performance in minimizing the star residuals in the coronagraphic image. The parameters that we study are : the second stage frequency, the photon flux on each WFS, the first stage gain and the DM number of actuators of the second stage. We show that the performance is improved by a factor 10 with respect to the current AO system (SAXO). The optimal second stage frequency is between 1 and 2 kHz under good observing conditions. In a red star case, the best SAXO+ performance is achieved with a low first stage gain of 0.05, which reduces the first stage rejection.

astro-ph.IM

Analytical modelling of adaptive optics systems: Role of the influence function

Context. Adaptive optics (AO) is now a tool commonly deployed in astronomy. The real time correction of the atmospheric turbulence that AO enables allows telescopes to perform close to the diffraction limit at the core of their point spread function (PSF). Among other factors, AO-corrected PSFs depend on the ability of the wavefront corrector (WFC), generally a deformable mirror, to fit the incident wavefront corrugations. Aims. In this work, we focus on this error introduced by the WFC, the so-called fitting error. To date, analytical models only depend on the WFC cut-off frequency, and Monte Carlo simulations are the only solution for studying the impact of the WFC influence function shape on the AO-corrected PSF. We aim to develop an analytical model accounting for the influence function shape. Methods. We first obtain a general analytical model of the fitting error structure function. With additional hypotheses, we then derive an analytical model of the AO-corrected power spectral density. These two analytical solutions are compared with Monte Carlo simulations on different ideal profiles (piston, pyramid, Gaussian) as well as with real hardware (DM192 from ALPAO). Results. Our analytical predictions show a very good agreement with the Monte Carlo simulations. We show that in the image plane, the depth of the correction as well as the transition profile between the AO-corrected area and the remaining turbulent halo depend on the influence functions of the WFC. We also show that the generally assumed hypothesis of stationarity of the AO correction is actually not met. Conclusions. As the fitting error is the intrinsic optimal limit of an AO system, our analytical model allows for the assessment of the theoretical limits of extreme AO systems limited by the WFC in high-contrast imaging through a context where other errors become comparable.

astro-ph.IM

Inverse problem approach in Extreme Adaptive Optics: analytical model of the fitting error and lowering of the aliasing

We present the results obtained with an end-to-end simulator of an Extreme Adaptive Optics (XAO) system control loop. It is used to predict its on-sky performances and to optimise the AO loop algorithms. It was first used to validate a novel analytical model of the fitting error, a limit due to the Deformable Mirror (DM) shape. Standard analytical models assume a sharp correction under the DM cutoff frequency, disregarding the transition between the AO corrected and turbulence dominated domains. Our model account for the influence function shape in this smooth transition. Then, it is well-known that Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensors (SH-WFS) have a limited spatial bandwidth, the high frequencies of the wavefront being seen as low frequencies. We show that this aliasing error can be partially compensated (both in terms of Strehl ratio and contrast) by adding priors on the turbulence statistics in the framework of an inverse problem approach. This represents an alternative to the standard additional optical filter used in XAO systems. In parallel to this numerical work, a bench was aligned to experimentally test the AO system and these new algorithms comprising a DM192 ALPAO deformable mirror and a 15x15 SH-WFS. We present the predicted performances of the AO loop based on end-to-end simulations.

astro-ph.IM

Adaptive Optics system of the Evanescent Wave Coronagraph (EvWaCo): optimised phase plate and DM characterisation

The Evanescent Wave Coronagraph (EvWaCo) is an achromatic coronagraph mask with adjustable size over the spectral domain [600nm, 900nm] that will be installed at the Thai National Observatory. We present in this work the development of a bench to characterise its Extreme Adaptive Optics system (XAO) comprising a DM192 ALPAO deformable mirror (DM) and a 15x15 Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor (SH-WFS). In this bench, the turbulence is simulated using a rotating phase plate in a pupil plane. In general, such components are designed using a randomly generated phase screen. Such single realisation does not necessarily provide the wanted structure function. We present a solution to design the printed pattern to ensure that the beam sees a strict and controlled Kolmogorov statistics with the correct 2D structure function. This is essential to control the experimental conditions in order to compare the bench results with the numerical simulations and predictions. This bench is further used to deeply characterise the full 27 mm pupil of the ALPAO DM using a 54x54 ALPAO SH-WFS. We measure the average shape of its influence functions as well as the influence function of each single actuator to study their dispersion. We study the linearity of the actuator amplitude with the command as well as the linearity of the influence function profile. We also study the actuator offsets as well as the membrane shape at 0-command. This knowledge is critical to get a forward model of the DM for the XAO control loop.

astro-ph.IM

The wavefront sensing making-of for THEMIS solar telescope

An adaptive optics system with a single deformable mirror is being implemented on the THEMIS 90cm solar telescope. This system is designed to operate in the visible and is required to be as robust as possible in order to deliver the best possible correction in any atmospheric conditions, even if wavefronts are sensed on some low-contrast solar granulation. In extreme conditions, the images given by the subapertures of the Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor get randomly blurred in space, in the set of subapertures, and the distribution of blurred images is rapidly changing in time, some of them possibly fading away. The algorithms we have developed for such harsh conditions rely on inverse problem approach. As an example, with the gradients of the wavefronts, the wavefront sensor also estimates their errors, including their covariance. This information allows the control loop to promptly optimize itself to the fast varying conditions, both in space (wavefront reconstruction) and in time. A major constraint is to fit the calculations in a low-cost multi-core CPU. An overview of the algorithms in charge of implementing this strategy is presented, focusing on wavefront sensing.

astro-ph.IM

CHARA Array adaptive optics: complex operational software and performance

The CHARA Array is the longest baseline optical interferometer in the world. Operated with natural seeing, it has delivered landmark sub-milliarcsecond results in the areas of stellar imaging, binaries, and stellar diameters. However, to achieve ambitious observations of faint targets such as young stellar objects and active galactic nuclei, higher sensitivity is required. For that purpose, adaptive optics are developed to correct atmospheric turbulence and non-common path aberrations between each telescope and the beam combiner lab. This paper describes the AO software and its integration into the CHARA system. We also report initial on-sky tests that demonstrate an increase of scientific throughput by sensitivity gain and by extending useful observing time in worse seeing conditions. Our 6 telescopes and 12 AO systems with tens of critical alignments and control loops pose challenges in operation. We describe our methods enabling a single scientist to operate the entire system.

astro-ph.IM

Science cases for a visible interferometer

High spatial resolution is the key for the understanding various astrophysical phenomena. But even with the future E-ELT, single dish instruments are limited to a spatial resolution of about 4 mas in the visible. For the closest objects within our Galaxy most of the stellar photosphere remains smaller than 1 mas. With the success of long baseline interferometry these limitations were soom overcome. Today low and high resolution interferometric instruments on the VLTI and CHARA offer an immense range of astrophysical studies. Combining more telescopes and moving to visible wavelengths broadens the science cases even more. With the idea of developing strong science cases for a future visible interferometer, we organized a science group around the following topics: pre-main sequence and main sequence stars, fundamental parameters, asteroseismology and classical pulsating stars, evolved stars, massive stars, active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and imaging techniques. A meeting was organized on the 15th and 16th of January, 2015 in Nice with the support of the Action Specific in Haute Resolution Angulaire (ASHRA), the Programme National en Physique Stellaire (PNPS), the Lagrange Laboratory and the Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur, in order to present these cases and to discuss them further for future visible interferometers. This White Paper presents the outcome of the exchanges. This book is dedicated to the memory of our colleague Olivier Chesneau who passed away at the age of 41.

astro-ph.SR

Development of an ELT XAO testbed using a Mach-Zehnder wavefront sensor: calibration of the deformable mirror

(abridged) Extreme adaptive optics (XAO) encounters severe difficulties to cope with the high speed (>1kHz), high accuracy and high order requirements for future extremely large telescopes. An innovative high order adaptive optics system using a self-referenced Mach-Zehnder wavefront sensor (MZWFS) allows counteracting these limitations. This sensor estimates very accurately the wavefront phase at small spatial scale by measuring intensity differences between two outputs, with a $λ/4$ path length difference between its two legs, but is limited in dynamic range due to phase ambiguity. During the past few years, such an XAO system has been studied by our team in the framework of 8-meter class telescopes. In this work, we report on our latest results with the XAO testbed recently installed in our lab, and dedicated to high contrast imaging with 30m-class telescopes (such as the E-ELT or the TMT). After reminding the principle of a MZWFS and describing the optical layout of our experiment, we will show the results of the assessment of the woofer-tweeter phase correctors, i.e., a Boston Micromachine continuous membrane deformable mirror (DM) and a Boulder Nonlinear Systems liquid crystal spatial light modulator (SLM). In particular, we will detail the calibration of the DM using Zygo interferometer metrology. Our method consists in the precise measurement of the membrane deformation while applying a constant deformation to 9 out of 140 actuators at the same time. By varying the poke voltage across the DM operating range, we propose a simple but efficient way of modeling the DM influence function using a Gaussian model. Finally, we show the DM flattening on the MZWFS allowing to compensate for low order aberrations.

astro-ph.IM

Fast minimum variance wavefront reconstruction for extremely large telescopes

We present a new algorithm, FRiM (FRactal Iterative Method), aiming at the reconstruction of the optical wavefront from measurements provided by a wavefront sensor. As our application is adaptive optics on extremely large telescopes, our algorithm was designed with speed and best quality in mind. The latter is achieved thanks to a regularization which enforces prior statistics. To solve the regularized problem, we use the conjugate gradient method which takes advantage of the sparsity of the wavefront sensor model matrix and avoids the storage and inversion of a huge matrix. The prior covariance matrix is however non-sparse and we derive a fractal approximation to the Karhunen-Loeve basis thanks to which the regularization by Kolmogorov statistics can be computed in O(N) operations, N being the number of phase samples to estimate. Finally, we propose an effective preconditioning which also scales as O(N) and yields the solution in 5-10 conjugate gradient iterations for any N. The resulting algorithm is therefore O(N). As an example, for a 128 x 128 Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor, FRiM appears to be more than 100 times faster than the classical vector-matrix multiplication method.

math-ph