Finite-Precision Symmetric Krylov Methods: Exact Rounding Examples, Block Paige Identities,and a Variable-Block Lanczos Model
Short-recurrence Krylov methods that are equivalent in exact arithmetic often diverge in floating-point arithmetic. To illustrate this, we provide an exactly representable two-cycle for steepest descent with a recursively updated residual. A complementary convergence theorem gives a sufficient condition under which the stored residual decreases geometrically. We then show that a second positive definite family yields different outcomes for a Hestenes--Stiefel Conjugate Gradient (CG) implementation and a direct Lanczos--Galerkin approach. CG finds the exact solution after four updates, whereas the two-step projected system becomes inconsistent. Under stated perturbation and transfer hypotheses, a common spectral enclosure gives comparable convergence bounds. For a dense, left-to-right evaluation order, we prove a sufficient precision bound for a prescribed backward error within $n$ updates for an $n\times n$ matrix, together with a computable stopping test and specified exponent-range assumptions. We use polynomial estimates and numerical experiments to examine the trade-off between working precision and the number of CG iterations needed to achieve a prescribed backward error. We also compare results on inexact matrix-vector products and preconditioning with the frameworks of Paige and Greenbaum. For block Lanczos, we analyze Householder orthogonalization and singular-value truncation as the block size changes. Under componentwise and normwise error bounds, the computed coefficients satisfy a controlled local recurrence and an exact block Lanczos relation for a nearby symmetric problem in a larger space. A block form of Paige's identity bounds the overlap with a Ritz vector along its residual coordinate direction. An inter-block recurrence describes the evolution of overlap, and a Gram-matrix argument gives a count of additional nearby Ritz values.