Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Nagayoshi Ohashi

Publications and source records attributed to Nagayoshi Ohashi.

At least 91 records · Page 5Linked to original sources

Unveiling the Evolutionary Sequence from Infalling Envelopes to Keplerian Disks around Low-Mass Protostars

We performed SMA observations in the C18O (2-1) emission line toward six Class 0 and I protostars, to study rotational motions of their surrounding envelopes and circumstellar material on 100 to 1000 AU scales. C18O (2-1) emission with intensity peaks located at the protostellar positions is detected toward all the six sources. The rotational velocities of the protostellar envelopes as a function of radius were measured from the Position-Velocity diagrams perpendicular to the outflow directions passing through the protostellar positions. Two Class 0 sources, B335 and NGC 1333 IRAS 4B, show no detectable rotational motion, while L1527 IRS (Class 0/I) and L1448-mm (Class 0) exhibit rotational motions with radial profiles of Vrot ~ r^{-1.0+/-0.2} and ~ r^{-1.0+/-0.1}, respectively. The other Class I sources, TMC-1A and L1489 IRS, exhibit the fastest rotational motions among the sample, and their rotational motions have flatter radial profiles of Vrot ~ r^{-0.6+/-0.1} and ~ r^{-0.5+/-0.1}, respectively. The rotational motions with the radial dependence of ~ r^{-1} can be interpreted as rotation with a conserved angular momentum in a dynamically infalling envelope, while those with the radial dependence of ~ r^{-0.5} can be interpreted as Keplerian rotation. These observational results demonstrate categorization of rotational motions from infalling envelopes to Keplerian-disk formation. Models of the inside-out collapse where the angular momentum is conserved are discussed and compared with our observational results.

astro-ph.SR↗

The circumstellar disk of AB Aurigae: evidence for envelope accretion at late stages of star formation?

The circumstellar disk of AB Aurigae has garnered strong attention owing to the apparent existence of spirals at a relatively young stage and also the asymmetric disk traced in thermal dust emission. However, the physical conditions of the spirals are still not well understood. The origin of the asymmetric thermal emission is unclear. We observed the disk at 230 GHz (1.3 mm) in both the continuum and the spectral line ^12CO J=2-1 with IRAM 30-m, the Plateau de Bure interferometer, and the Submillimeter Array to sample all spatial scales from 0.37" to about 50". To combine the data obtained from these telescopes, several methods and calibration issues were checked and discussed. The 1.3 mm continuum (dust) emission is resolved into inner disk and outer ring. Molecular gas at high velocities traced by the CO line is detected next to the stellar location. The inclination angle of the disk is found to decrease toward the center. On a larger scale, based on the intensity weighted dispersion and the integrated intensity map of ^12CO J=2-1, four spirals are identified, where two of them are also detected in the near infrared. The total gas mass of the 4 spirals (M_spiral) is 10^-7 < M_spiral < 10^-5 M_sun, which is 3 orders of magnitude smaller than the mass of the gas ring. Surprisingly, the CO gas inside the spiral is apparently counter-rotating with respect to the CO disk, and it only exhibits small radial motion. The wide gap, the warped disk, and the asymmetric dust ring suggest that there is an undetected companion with a mass of 0.03 M_sun at a radius of 45 AU. Although an hypothetical fly-by cannot be ruled out, the most likely explanation of the AB Aurigae system may be inhomogeneous accretion well above or below the main disk plane from the remnant envelope, which can explain both the rotation and large-scale motions detected with the 30-m image.

astro-ph.GA↗

Is FS Tau B Driving an Asymmetric Jet?

FS Tau B is one of the few T Tauri stars that possess a jet and a counterjet as well as an optically-visible cavity wall. We obtained images and spectra of its jet-cavity system in the near-infrared H and K bands using Subaru/IRCS and detected the jet and the counterjet in the [Fe II] 1.644 μm line for the first time. Within the inner 2" the blueshifted jet is brighter, whereas beyond ~ 5" the redshifted counterjet dominates the [Fe II] emission. The innermost blueshifted knot is spectrally resolved to have a large line width of ~ 110 km/s, while the innermost redshifted knot appears spectrally unresolved. The velocity ratio of the jet to the counterjet is ~ 1.34, which suggests that FS Tau B is driving an asymmetric jet, similar to those found in several T Tauri Stars. Combining with optical observations in the literature, we showed that the blueshifted jet has lower density and higher excitation than the redshifted counterjet. We suggest that the asymmetry in brightness and velocity is the manifestation of a bipolar outflow driving at different mass-loss rates, while maintaining balance of linear momentum. A full explanation to the asymmetry in the FS Tau B system awaits detail modeling and further investigation of the kinematic structure of the wind-associated cavity walls.

astro-ph.SR↗

Kinematics and Physical Conditions of the Innermost Envelope in B335

We made C18O (2-1) and CS (7-6) images of the protostellar envelope around B335 with a high spatial dynamic range from ~10000 to ~400 AU, by combining the Submillimeter Array and single-dish data. The C18O emission shows an extended (~10000 AU) structure as well as a compact (~1500 AU) component concentrated at the protostellar position. The CS emission shows a compact (~900 AU) component surrounding the protostar, plus a halo-like (~3000 AU) structure elongated along the east-west direction. At higher velocities (|dV| >~0.3 km s^-1), the CS emission is stronger and more extended than the C18O emission. Physical conditions of the envelope were examined through an LVG model. At |dV| >~0.3 km s^-1, the gas temperature is higher (>40 K) than that at |dV| <~0.3 km s^-1, whereas the gas density is lower (<10^6 cm^-3). We consider that the higher-temperature and lower-density gas at |dV| >~0.3 km s^-1 is related to the associated outflow, while the lower-temperature and higher-density gas at |dV| <~0.3 km s^-1 is the envelope component. From the inspection of the positional offsets in the velocity channel maps, the radial profile of the specific angular momentum of the envelope rotation in B335 was revealed at radii from ~10^4 down to ~10^2 AU. The specific angular momentum decreases down to the radius of ~370 AU, and then appears to be conserved within that radius. A possible scenario of the evolution of envelope rotation is discussed.

astro-ph.SR↗

Millimeter Observations of the Transition Disk around HD135344B (SAO 206462)

We present \sim1" resolution 1.3 millimeter dust continuum and spectral line (12CO and 13CO J=2-1) observations of the transitional disk system HD 135344B obtained with the Submillimeter Array. The disk shows a Keplerian rotation pattern with an inclination of \sim11°, based on the spatially and spectrally resolved 12CO and 13CO emission. The data show clear evidence for both dust and gas surface density reductions in the inner region of the disk (radius \lesssim 50 AU) from the continuum and 13CO J=2-1 data, respectively. The presence of this inner cavity in both the dust and gas is more consistent with clearing by giant planet formation than by photoevaporation or by grain growth. There is also an indication of global CO gas depletion in the disk, as the mass estimated from 13CO emission (\sim3.8 \times 10^(-4) M\odot) is about two orders of magnitude lower than that derived from the 1.3 mm continuum (\sim2.8 \times 10^(-2) M\odot).

astro-ph.SR↗

Carbon-Chain and Organic Molecules around Very Low-Luminosity Protostellar Objects of L1521F-IRS and IRAM 04191+1522

We have observed dense gas around the Very Low-Luminosity Ob jects (VeLLOs) L1521F-IRS and IRAM 04191+1522 in carbon-chain and organic molecular lines with the Nobeyama 45 m telescope. Towards L1521F-IRS, carbon-chain lines of CH3CCH (50-40), C4H (17/2-15/2), and C3H2 (212-101) are 1.5 - 3.5 times stronger than those towards IRAM 04191+1522, and the abundances of the carbon-chain molecules towards L1521F-IRS are 2 to 5 times higher than those towards IRAM 04191+1522. Mapping observations of these carbon-chain molecular lines show that in L1521F the peak positions of these carbon-chain molecular lines are different from each other and there is no emission peak towards the VeLLO position, while in IRAM 04191+1522 these carbon-chain lines are as weak as the detection limits except for the C3H2 line. The observed chemical differentiation between L1521F and IRAM 04191+1522 suggests that the evolutionary stage of L1521F-IRS is younger than that of IRAM 04191+1522, consistent with the extent of the associated outflows seen in the 13CO (1-0) line. The non-detection of the organic molecular lines of CH3OH (6-2-7-1 E) and CH3CN (60-50) implies that the warm (~ 100 K) molecular-desorbing region heated by the central protostar is smaller than ~ 100 AU towards L1521F-IRS and IRAM 04191+1522, suggesting the young age of these VeLLOs. We propose that the chemical status of surrounding dense gas can be used to trace the evolutionary stages of VeLLOs.

astro-ph.GA↗

High Resolution Observations of Dust Continuum Emission at 340 GHz from the Low-mass T Tauri Star FN Tauri

FN Tau is a rare example of very low-mass T Tauri stars that exhibits a spatially resolved nebulosity in near-infrared scattering light. To directly derive the parameters of a circumstellar disk around FN Tau, observations of dust continuum emission at 340 GHz are carried out with the Submillimeter Array (SMA). A point-like dust continuum emission was detected with a synthesized beam of ~ 0.7" in FWHM. From the analysis of the visibility plot, the radius of the emission is estimated to be <= 0.29", corresponding to 41 AU. This is much smaller than the radius of the nebulosity, 1.85" for its brighter part at 1.6 micron. The 340 GHz continuum emission observed with the SMA and the photometric data at lambda <= 70 micron are explained by a power-law disk model whose outer radius and mass are 41 AU and (0.24 - 5.9) x 10^{-3} M_{sun}, respectively, if the exponent of dust mass opacity (beta) is assumed to be 0-2. The disk model cannot fully reproduce the flux density at 230 GHz obtained with the IRAM 30-meter telescope, suggesting that there is another extended "halo" component that is missed in the SMA observations. By requiring the halo not to be detected with the SMA, the lower limit to the size of the halo is evaluated to be between 174 AU and 574 AU, depending on the assumed beta value. The physical nature of the halo is unclear, but it may be the periphery of a flared circumstellar disk that is not described well in terms of a power-law disk model, or a remnant of a protostellar envelope having flattened structure.

astro-ph.GA↗

High-Velocity Jets and Slowly Rotating Envelope in B335

We have performed detailed imaging and analyses of SMA observations in 230 GHz continuum, 12CO (2-1), 13CO (2-1), and C18O (2-1) emission toward B335, a Bok globule with an embedded Class 0 source (Lbol ~ 1.5 Lsun). We report the first discover of high-velocity 12CO jets with a size of ~ 900 AU x 1500 AU along the E-W direction in B335. The estimated mass-loss rate (~ 2.3 x 10^-7 Msun yr^-1) and the momentum flux (~ 3.7 x 10^-5 Msun yr^-1 km s^-1) of the 12CO jets in B335 are one order of magnitude lower than those of other 12CO jets in more luminous sources such as HH 211 (Lbol ~ 3.6 Lsun) and HH 212 (Lbol ~ 14 Lsun). The weaker jet activity in B335 could be due to the lower active accretion onto the central protostar. The C18O emission shows a compact (~ 1500 AU) condensation associated with the central protostar, and it likely traces the protostellar envelope around B335. The envelope exhibits a velocity gradient from the east (blueshifted) to west (redshifted) that can be interpreted as an infalling motion. The estimated central stellar mass, the mass infalling rate, and the accretion luminosity are 0.04 Msun, 6.9 x 10^-6 Msun yr^-1, and 2.1 Lsun, respectively. On the other hand, there is no clear velocity gradient perpendicular to the outflow axis in the C18O envelope, suggesting little envelope rotation on a hundred-AU scale. The upper limits of the rotational velocity and specific angular momentum were estimated to be 0.04 km s^-1 and 7.0 x 10^-5 km s^-1 pc at a radius of 370 AU, respectively. The specific angular momentum and the inferred Keplerian radius (~ 6 AU) in B335 are 1 - 2 orders of magnitude smaller than those in other more-evolved sources. Possible scenarios to explain the lower specific angular momentum in B335 are discussed.

astro-ph.SR↗

Millimeter Dust Emission in the GQ Lup System

We present Submillimeter Array observations of the GQ Lup system at 1.3 millimeters wavelength with $0\farcs4$ ($\sim$60 AU) resolution. Emission is detected from the position of the primary star, GQ Lup A, and is marginally resolved. No emission is detected from the substellar companion, GQ Lup B, $0\farcs7$ away. These data, together with models of the spectral energy distribution, suggest a compact disk around GQ Lup A with mass $\sim 3$ M$_{Jup}$, perhaps truncated by tidal forces. There is no evidence for a gap or hole in the disk that might be the signature of an additional inner companion body capable of scattering GQ Lup B out to $\sim100$ AU separation from GQ Lup A. For GQ Lup B to have formed {\it in situ}, the disk would have to have been much more massive and extended.

astro-ph.SR↗

First Confirmed Detection of a Bipolar Molecular Outflow from a Young Brown Dwarf

Studying the earliest stages in the birth of stars is crucial for understanding how they form. Brown dwarfs with masses between that of stars and planets are not massive enough to maintain stable hydrogen-burning fusion reactions during most of their lifetime. Their origins are subject to much debate in recent literature because their masses are far below the typical mass where core collapse is expected to occur. We present the first confirmed evidence that brown dwarfs undergo a phase of molecular outflow that is typical of young stars. Using the Submillimeter Array, we have obtained a map of a bipolar molecular outflow from a young brown dwarf. We estimate an outflow mass of 1.6 x 10^-4 M_Sun and a mass-loss rate of 1.4 x 10^-9 M_Sun. These values are over two orders of magnitude smaller than the typical ones for T Tauri stars. From our millimiter continuum data and our own analysis of Spitzer infrared photometry, we estimate that the brown dwarf has a disk with a mass of 8 x 10^-3 M_Sun and an outer disk radius of 80 AU. Our results demonstrate that the bipolar molecular outflow operates down to planetary masses, occurring in brown dwarfs as a scaled-down version of the universal process seen in young stars.

astro-ph↗

Millimeter- and Submillimeter-Wave Observations of the OMC-2/3 Region. III. An Extensive Survey for Molecular Outflows

Using the ASTE 10 m submillimeter telescope and the 1.4 m Infrared Survey Facility (IRSF), we performed an extensive outflow survey in the Orion Molecular Cloud -2 and -3 region. Our survey, which includes 41 potential star-forming sites, has been newly compiled using multi-wavelength data based on millimeter- and submillimeter-continuum observations as well as radio continuum observations. From the CO (3-2) observations performed with the ASTE 10 m telescope, we detected 14 CO molecular outflows, seven of which were newly identified. This higher detection rate, as compared to previous CO (1-0) results in the same region, suggests that CO (3-2) may be a better outflow tracer. Physical properties of these outflows and their possible driving sources were derived. Derived parameters were compared with those of CO outflows in low- and high-mass starforming regions. We show that the CO outflow momentum correlates with the bolometric luminosity of the driving source and with the envelope mass, regardless of the mass of the driving sources. In addition to these CO outflows, seven sources having NIR features suggestive of outflows were also identified.

astro-ph↗

The CO Molecular Outflows of IRAS 16293-2422 Probed by the Submillimeter Array

We have mapped the proto-binary source IRAS 16293-2422 in CO 2-1, 13CO 2-1, and CO 3-2 with the Submillimeter Array (SMA). The maps with resolution of 1".5-5" reveal a single small scale (~3000 AU) bipolar molecular outflow along the east-west direction. We found that the blueshifted emission of this small scale outflow mainly extends to the east and the redshifted emission to the west from the position of IRAS 16293A. A comparison with the morphology of the large scale outflows previously observed by single-dish telescopes at millimeter wavelengths suggests that the small scale outflow may be the inner part of the large scale (~15000 AU) E-W outflow. On the other hand, there is no clear counterpart of the large scale NE-SW outflow in our SMA maps. Comparing analytical models to the data suggests that the morphology and kinematics of the small scale outflow can be explained by a wide-angle wind with an inclination angle of ~30-40 degrees with respect to the plane of the sky. The high resolution CO maps show that there are two compact, bright spots in the blueshifted velocity range. An LVG analysis shows that the one located 1" to the east of source A is extremely dense, n(H_2)~10^7 cm^-3, and warm, T_kin >55 K. The other one located 1" southeast of source B has a higher temperature of T_kin >65 K but slightly lower density of n(H_2)~10^6 cm^-3. It is likely that these bright spots are associated with the hot core-like emission observed toward IRAS 16293. Since both two bright spots are blueshifted from the systemic velocity and are offset from the protostellar positions, they are likely formed by shocks.

astro-ph↗

An evolved disk surrounding the massive main sequence star MWC 297?

We present the results of the interferometric observations of the circumstellar disk surrounding MWC 297 in the continuum at 230 GHz (1.3 mm) and in the (J=2-1) rotational transitions of $^{12}$CO,$^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O using the Submillimeter Array. At a distance of 250 pc, MWC 297 is one of the closest, young massive stars (M$_{\star}$ $\sim$10 M$_{\odot}$) to us. Compact continuum emission is detected towards MWC 297 from which we estimate a disk mass (gas+dust) of 0.07 M$_{\odot}$ and a disk radius of $\le$ 80 AU. Our result demonstrates that circumstellar disks can survive around massive stars well into their main sequence phase even after they have become optically visible. Complementing our observations with the data compiled from the literature, we find the submm dust opacity index $β$ to be between 0.1 and 0.3. If the emission is optically thin, the low value of $β$ indicates the presence of relatively large grains in the disk, possibly because of grain growth. We do not detect any CO emission associated with the continuum source. We argue that the $^{13}$CO emission from the disk is likely optically thin, in which case, we derive an upper limit to the gas mass which implies significant depletion of molecular gas in the disk. The mass of this disk and the evolutionary trends observed are similar to those found for intermediate mass Herbig Ae stars and low mass T Tauri stars.

astro-ph↗

PROSAC: A Submillimeter Array Survey of Low-Mass Protostars. I. Overview of Program: Envelopes, Disks, Outflows and Hot Cores

This paper presents a large spectral line and continuum survey of 8 deeply embedded, low-mass protostellar cores using the Submillimeter Array. Each source was observed in high excitation lines of some of the most common molecular species, CO, HCO+, CS, SO, H2CO, CH3OH and SiO. Line emission from 11 species originating from warm and dense gas have been imaged at high angular resolution (1-3"; typically 200-600 AU) together with continuum emission at 230 GHz (1.3 mm) and 345 GHz (0.8 mm). Compact continuum emission is observed for all sources which likely originates in marginally optically thick circumstellar disks, with typical lower limits to their masses of 0.1 M_sun (1-10% of the masses of their envelopes) and having a dust opacity law with beta approximately 1. Prominent outflows are present in CO 2-1 observations in all sources: the most diffuse outflows are found in the sources with the lowest ratios of disk-to-envelope mass, and it is suggested that these sources are in a phase where accretion of matter from the envelope has almost finished and the remainder of the envelope material is being dispersed by the outflows. Other characteristic dynamical signatures are found with inverse P Cygni profiles indicative of infalling motions seen in the 13CO 2-1 lines toward NGC1333-IRAS4A and -IRAS4B. Outflow-induced shocks are present on all scales in the protostellar environments and are most clearly traced by the emission of CH3OH in NGC1333-IRAS4A and -IRAS4B. These observations suggest that the emission of CH3OH and H2CO from these proposed "hot corinos" are related to the shocks caused by the protostellar outflows. Only one source, NGC1333-IRAS2A, has evidence for hot, compact CH3OH emission coincident with the embedded protostar.

astro-ph↗

654 GHz Continuum and C18O (6-5) Observations of G240.31+0.07 with the Submillimeter Array

We report a dual-band observation at 223 and 654 GHz (460 micron) toward an ultracompact (UC) HII region, G240.31+0.07, with the Submillimeter Array. With a beam size of 1"5 X 0"8, the dust continuum emission is resolved into two clumps, with clump A coincident well with an H2O maser and the UC HII region. The newly discovered clump, B, about 1"3 (~8.3 X 10^3 AU) to the southwest of clump A, is also associated with H2O masers and may be a more recent star-forming site. The continuum flux densities imply an opacity spectral index of β= 1.5 +- 0.3, suggestive of a value lower than the canonical 2.0 found in the interstellar medium and in cold, massive cores. The presence of hot (~100 K) molecular gas is derived by the brightness ratio of two H2CO lines in the 223 GHz band. A radial velocity difference of 2.5 +- 0.4 km/s is found between the two clumps in C18O (6-5) emission. The total (nebular and stellar) mass of roughly 58 Msun in the central region is close to, but not by far larger than, the minimum mass required for the two clumps to be gravitationally bound for binary rotation. Our continuum data do not suggest a large amount of matter associated with the H2 knots that were previously proposed to arise from a massive disk or envelope.

astro-ph↗

Possible Molecular Spiral Arms in the Protoplanetary Disk of AB Aur

The circumstellar dust disk of the Herbig Ae star AB Aur has been found to exhibit complex spiral-like structures in the near-IR image obtained with the Subaru Telescope. We present maps of the disk in both 12CO (3-2) and dust continuum at 345 GHz with the SMA at an angular resolution of 1.0"x0.7" (144AU x 100AU). The continuum emission traces a dust disk with a central depression and a maximum overall dimension of 450AU (FWHM). This dust disk exhibits several distinct peaks that appear to coincide with bright features in the near-IR image, in particular the brightest inner spiral arm. The CO emission traces a rotating gas disk of size 530AU x 330AU with a deprojected maximum velocity of 2.8km/s at 450AU. In contrast to the dust disk, the gas disk exhibits an intensity peak at the stellar position. Furthermore, the CO emission in several velocity channels traces the innermost spiral arm seen in the near-IR. We compare the observed spatial-kinematic structure of the CO emission to a simple model of a disk in Keplerian rotation, and find that only the emission tracing the main spiral arm clearly lies outside the confines of our model. This emission has a net outward radial motion compared with the radial velocity predicted by the model at the location of the main spiral arms. The disk of AB Aur is therefore quite different from the Keplerian disks seen around many Herbig Ae stars. The spiral-like structures of the disk with non-Keplerian motions we revealed in 12CO (3-2), together with the central depression of the dust disk, may be explained to be driven by the possible existence of a giant planet forming in the disk.

astro-ph↗

Submillimeter Array Observations of L1551 IRS 5 in CS (J=7-6)

We have imaged the circumstellar envelope around the binary protostar L1551 IRS 5 in CS (J=7-6) and 343 GHz continuum emission at ~ 3 arcsec resolution using the Submillimeter Array. The continuum emission shows an elongated structure (~ 220 x 100 AU) around the binary perpendicular to the axis of the associated radio jet. The CS emission extends over ~ 400 AU, appears approximately circularly symmetric, and shows a velocity gradient from southeast (blueshifted) to northwest (redshifted). The direction of the velocity gradient is different from that observed in C18O (J=1-0). This may be because rotation is more dominant in the CS envelope than the C18O envelope, in which both infall and rotation exist. The CS emission may be divided into two velocity components: (1) a "high" velocity disk-like structure surrounding the protostar, +-1.0 - 1.5 km s-1 from the systemic velocity, and (2) a "low" velocity structure, located southwest of the protostar, < 1.0 km s -1 from the systemic velocity. The high-velocity component traces warm and dense gas with kinematics consistent with rotation around the protostar. The low-velocity component may arise from dense gas entrained in the outflow. Alternatively, this component may trace infalling and rotating gas in an envelope with a vertical structure.

astro-ph↗

Molecular Evolution in Collapsing Prestellar Cores II: The Effect of Grain-surface Reactions

The molecular evolution that occurs in collapsing prestellar cores is investigated. To model the dynamics, we adopt the Larson-Penston (L-P) solution and analogues with slower rates of collapse. For the chemistry, we utilize the new standard model (NSM) with the addition of deuterium fractionation and grain-surface reactions treated via the modified rate approach. The use of surface reactions distinguishes the present work from our previous model. We find that these reactions efficiently produce H2O, H2CO, CH3OH, N2, and NH3 ices. In addition, the surface chemistry influences the gas-phase abundances in a variety of ways. The current reaction network along with the L-P solution allows us to reproduce satisfactorily most of the molecular column densities and their radial distributions observed in L1544. The agreement tends to worsen with models that include strongly delayed collapse rates. Inferred radial distributions in terms of fractional abundances are somewhat harder to reproduce. In addition to our standard chemical model, we have also run a model with the UMIST gas-phase chemical network. The abundances of gas-phase S-bearing molecules such as CS and CCS are significantly affected by uncertainties in the gas-phase chemical network. In all of our models, the column density of N2H+ monotonically increases as the central density of the core increases during collapse from 3 10^4 cm-3 to 3 10^7 cm-3. Thus, the abundance of this ion can be a probe of evolutionary stage. Molecular D/H ratios in assorted cores are best reproduced in the L-P picture with the conventional rate coefficients for fractionation reactions. If we adopt the newly measured and calculated rate coefficients, the D/H ratios, especially N2D+/N2H+, become significantly lower than the observed values.

astro-ph↗