SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Pascale Garaud

Publications and source records attributed to Pascale Garaud.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Fluxes through a uniform double-diffusive staircase at low Prandtl number

Double-diffusive convection in the diffusive regime is often observed to be in a long-lived layered state, well-known in the Arctic ocean and in volcanic lakes, and thought to exist in the interiors of giant planets. The density profile resembles a `staircase', with stacks of convective layers of uniform density separated by strongly stratified interfaces. The governing parameters are the Prandtl number $\mathrm{Pr}$, diffusivity ratio $\tau$, density ratio $R_\rho$, and Rayleigh number $\mathrm{Ra}$. In this work, we perform direct numerical simulations in triply periodic domains to systematically investigate the properties of statistically stationary double-diffusive staircases with $\tau \le \mathrm{Pr} \ll 1$. We demonstrate that they can exist for significantly larger density ratios than previously reported, and propose a new criterion for the existence of long-lived layered states. Notably, this criterion depends weakly on $\mathrm{Ra}$. In all simulations, we measure the total fluxes of density $F^{\mathrm{tot}}_\rho$, temperature $F^{\mathrm{tot}}_T$ and composition $F^{\mathrm{tot}}_C$, and the flux ratio $\gamma =F^{\mathrm{tot}}_C/F^{\mathrm{tot}}_T$. We confirm that $\gamma$ is approximately constant for moderate to large $R_\rho$ but also depends weakly on $\mathrm{Ra}$. We show that the Nusselt numbers for composition and temperature scale as $\mathrm{Ra}^{1/3}$ in this limit, which notably differs from the $(\mathrm{RaPr})^{1/3}$ scaling previously found at lower $R_\rho$. We propose a new model for these findings that is based on the rise and turbulent mixing of density anomalies that form at the edges of the interfaces. The model explains the existing low $\mathrm{Pr}$ data with reasonable accuracy.

physics.flu-dyn

Two pathways to diapycnal mixing in strongly stratified flows with no initial vertical shear

While vertically-sheared stratified flows have been studied extensively, their horizontally-sheared counterparts have received considerably less attention. Yet, horizontal shear instabilities remain active even when the mean Richardson number is large or even formally infinite, and can drive turbulence in strongly stratified (low Froude number) flows at sufficiently high Reynolds number. In this work, we combine linear theory with direct numerical simulations to investigate two pathways to turbulence in low Froude / high Reynolds number horizontally-sheared flow with no initial vertical shear. In the first pathway, vertical shear emerges directly from vertically-modulated eigenmodes of the primary horizontal shear instability, and becomes unstable to secondary small-scale Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instabilities on the buoyancy scale at sufficiently large buoyancy Reynolds number $Re_b$. In the second pathway, a vertically-invariant eigenmode of the primary horizontal shear instability initially dominates, causing the background flow to evolve nonlinearly into a long-lived time-dependent two-dimensional (columnar) vortical flow. The vortices are subsequently unstable to secondary three-dimensional hyperbolic instabilities from which vertical shear emerges, which is finally unstable to tertiary small-scale KH instabilities on the buoyancy scale at sufficiently large $Re_b$. This shows that the emergence of vertical shear driving small-scale KH instabilities is an inevitable by-product of horizontal shear instabilities in strongly stratified flows at sufficiently large $Re_b$. However, we also find that the two pathways excite different ranges of vertical scales, which results in different peak mixing efficiencies.

physics.flu-dyn

Conversion and Damping of Nonaxisymmetric Internal Gravity Waves in Magnetized Stellar Cores

Magnetism is thought to play an important role in the evolution and dynamics of stars, though little is known about magnetic fields deep within stellar interiors. A promising avenue for probing these fields uses asteroseismic observations of global oscillations that result from the coupling of acoustic waves in the convective zone to internal gravity waves (IGWs) in the radiative interior. Recent modeling efforts implicate deep magnetic fields in the suppression of dipole mixed modes observed in 20% of red giants and a number of high-mass main sequence stars. Previous numerical and theoretical work shows that core magnetic fields could suppress axisymmetric global modes by refracting down-going IGWs into slow-magnetosonic (SM) waves that damp at magnetic cutoff heights. Here, we extend these results to the nonaxisymmetric case, for which the IGWs and SM waves are coupled to a continuous spectrum of Alfven waves (AWs). We consider a Cartesian model of the radiative interior with uniform stratification and a spatially-varying, current-free magnetic field. Using a Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin approximation to solve for the vertical mode structure, corroborated with numerical simulations, we show that IGWs convert to up-going SM waves, which resonate with the Alfven spectrum and produce mixed SM-AW modes. We find cutoff heights (as in the axisymmetric case), above which the SM/SM-AWs convert to AWs. Latitudinal variations of the background magnetic field lead to phase mixing of the AWs, resulting in rapid damping. Our results suggest that energy in both axisymmetric and nonaxisymmetric IGWs is lost via interactions with a strong magnetic field.

astro-ph.SR

Regimes of stratified turbulence at low Prandtl number

Quantifying transport by strongly stratified turbulence in low Prandtl number ($Pr$) fluids is critically important for the development of better models for the structure and evolution of stellar and planetary interiors. Motivated by recent numerical simulations showing strongly anisotropic flows suggestive of scale-separated dynamics, we perform a multiscale asymptotic analysis of the governing equations. We find that, in all cases, the resulting slow-fast systems take a quasilinear form. Our analysis also reveals the existence of several distinct dynamical regimes depending on the emergent buoyancy Reynolds and Péclet numbers, $Re_b = α^2 Re$ and $Pe_b = Pr Re_b$, respectively, where $α$ is the aspect ratio of the large-scale turbulent flow structures, and $Re$ is the outer scale Reynolds number. Scaling relationships relating the aspect ratio, the characteristic vertical velocity, and the strength of the stratification (measured by the Froude number $Fr$) naturally emerge from the analysis. When $Pe_b \ll α$, the dynamics at all scales is dominated by buoyancy diffusion, and our results recover the scaling laws empirically obtained from direct numerical simulations by Cope et al. (2020). For $Pe_b \ge O(1)$, diffusion is negligible (or at least subdominant) at all scales and our results are consistent with those of Chini et al. (2022) for strongly stratified geophysical turbulence at $Pr = O(1)$. Finally, we have identified a new regime for $α\ll Pe_b \ll 1$, in which slow, large scales are diffusive while fast, small scales are not. We conclude by presenting a map of parameter space that clearly indicates the transitions between isotropic turbulence, non-diffusive stratified turbulence, diffusive stratified turbulence and viscously-dominated flows, and by proposing parameterisations of the buoyancy flux, mixing efficiency and turbulent diffusion coefficient.

physics.flu-dyn

Numerical validation of scaling laws for stratified turbulence

Recent theoretical progress using multiscale asymptotic analysis has revealed various possible regimes of stratified turbulence. Notably, buoyancy transport can either be dominated by advection or diffusion, depending on the effective Péclet number of the flow. Two types of asymptotic models have been proposed, which yield measurably different predictions for the characteristic vertical velocity and length scale of the turbulent eddies in both diffusive and non-diffusive regimes. The first, termed a `single-scale model', is designed to describe flow structures having large horizontal and small vertical scales, while the second, termed a `multiscale model', additionally incorporates flow features with small horizontal scales, and reduces to the single-scale model in their absence. By comparing predicted vertical velocity scaling laws with direct numerical simulation data, we show that the multiscale model correctly captures the properties of strongly stratified turbulence within regions dominated by small-scale isotropic motions, whose volume fraction decreases as the stratification increases. Meanwhile its single-scale reduction accurately describes the more orderly, layer-like, quiescent flow outside those regions.

physics.flu-dyn

Magnetized fingering convection in stars

Fingering convection (also known as thermohaline convection) is a process that drives the vertical transport of chemical elements in regions of stellar radiative zones where the mean molecular weight increases with radius. Recently, Harrington & Garaud (2019) used three-dimensional direct numerical simulations to show that a vertical magnetic field can dramatically enhance the rate of chemical mixing by fingering convection. Furthermore, they proposed a so-called "parasitic saturation" theory to model this process. Here, we test their model over a broad range of parameter space, using a suite of direct numerical simulations of magnetized fingering convection varying the magnetic Prandtl number, magnetic field strength, and composition gradient. We find that the rate of chemical mixing measured in the simulations is not always predicted accurately by their existing model, in particular when the magnetic diffusivity is large. We then present an extension of the Harrington & Garaud (2019) model which resolves this issue. When applied to stellar parameters, it recovers the results of Harrington & Garaud (2019) except in the limit where fingering convection becomes marginally stable, where the new model is preferred. We discuss the implications of our findings for stellar structure and evolution.

astro-ph.SR

The combined effects of vertical and horizontal shear instabilities

Shear instabilities can be the source of significant amounts of turbulent mixing in stellar radiative zones. Past attempts at modeling their effects (either theoretically or using numerical simulations) have focused on idealized geometries where the shear is either purely vertical or purely horizontal. In stars, however, the shear can have arbitrary directions with respect to gravity. In this work, we use direct numerical simulations to investigate the nonlinear saturation of shear instabilities in a stably stratified fluid, where the shear is sinusoidal in the horizontal direction, and either constant or sinusoidal in the vertical direction. We find that, in the parameter regime studied here (non-diffusive, fully turbulent flow), the mean vertical shear does not play any role in controlling the dynamics of the resulting turbulence unless its Richardson number is smaller than one (approximately). As most stellar radiative regions have a Richardson number much greater than one, our result implies that the vertical shear can essentially be ignored in the computation of the vertical mixing coefficient associated with shear instabilities for the purpose of stellar evolution calculations, even when it is much larger than the horizontal shear (as in the solar tachocline, for instance).

astro-ph.SR

Magnetized oscillatory double-diffusive convection

We study the properties of oscillatory double-diffusive convection (ODDC) in the presence of a uniform vertical background magnetic field. ODDC takes place in stellar regions that are unstable according to the Schwarzschild criterion and stable according to the Ledoux criterion (sometimes called semiconvective regions), which are often predicted to reside just outside the core of intermediate-mass main sequence stars. Previous hydrodynamic studies of ODDC have shown that the basic instability saturates into a state of weak wave-like convection, but that a secondary instability can sometimes transform it into a state of layered convection, where layers then rapidly merge and grow until the entire region is fully convective. We find that magnetized ODDC has very similar properties overall, with some important quantitative differences. A linear stability analysis reveals that the fastest-growing modes are unaffected by the field, but that other modes are. Numerically, the magnetic field is seen to influence the saturation of the basic instability, overall reducing the turbulent fluxes of temperature and composition. This in turn affects layer formation, usually delaying it, and occasionally suppressing it entirely for sufficiently strong fields. Further work will be needed, however, to determine the field strength above which layer formation is actually suppressed in stars. Potential observational implications are briefly discussed.

astro-ph.SR

Resistive instabilities in sinusoidal shear flows with a streamwise magnetic field

We investigate the linear stability of a sinusoidal shear flow with an initially uniform streamwise magnetic field in the framework of incompressible magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) with finite resistivity and viscosity. This flow is known to be unstable to the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability in the hydrodynamic case. The same is true in ideal MHD, where dissipation is neglected, provided the magnetic field strength does not exceed a critical threshold beyond which magnetic tension stabilizes the flow. Here, we demonstrate that including viscosity and resistivity introduces two new modes of instability. One of these modes, which we call a resistively-unstable Alfvén wave due to its connection to shear Alfvén waves, exists for any nonzero magnetic field strength as long as the magnetic Prandtl number $Pm < 1$. We present a reduced model for this instability that reveals its excitation mechanism to be the negative eddy viscosity of periodic shear flows described by Dubrulle & Frisch (1991). Finally, we demonstrate numerically that this mode saturates in a quasi-stationary state dominated by counter-propagating solitons.

physics.flu-dyn

Modeling coexisting GSF and shear instabilities in rotating stars

Zahn's widely-used model for turbulent mixing induced by rotational shear has recently been validated (with some caveats) in non-rotating shear flows. It is not clear, however, whether his model remains valid in the presence of rotation, even though this was its original purpose. Furthermore, new instabilities arise in rotating fluids, such as the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability. Which instability dominates when more than one can be excited, and how they influence each other, were open questions that this paper answers. To do so, we use direct numerical simulations of diffusive stratified shear flows in a rotating triply-periodic Cartesian domain located at the equator of a star. We find that either the GSF instability or the shear instability tends to take over the other in controlling the system, suggesting that stellar evolution models only need to have a mixing prescription for each individual instability, together with a criterion to determine which one dominates. However, we also find that it is not always easy to predict which instability "wins" for given input parameters, because the diffusive shear instability is subcritical, and only takes place if there is a finite-amplitude turbulence ``primer'' to seed it. Interestingly, we find that the GSF instability can in some cases play the role of this primer, thereby providing a pathway to excite the subcritical shear instability. This can also drive relaxation oscillations, that may be observable. We conclude by proposing a new model for mixing in the equatorial regions of stellar radiative zones due to differential rotation.

astro-ph.SR

Journey to the center of stars: the realm of low Prandtl number fluid dynamics

The dynamics of fluids deep in stellar interiors is a subject that bears many similarities with geophysical fluid dynamics, with one crucial difference: the Prandtl number. The ratio of the kinematic viscosity to the thermal diffusivity is usually of order unity or more on Earth, but is always much smaller than one in stars. As a result, viscosity remains negligible on scales that are thermally diffusive, which opens the door to a whole new region of parameter space, namely the turbulent low Péclet number regime (where the Péclet number is the product of the Prandtl number and the Reynolds number). In this review, I focus on three instabilities that are well known in geophysical fluid dynamics, and have an important role to play in stellar evolution, namely convection, stratified shear instabilities, and double-diffusive convection. I present what is known of their behavior at low Prandtl number, highlighting the differences with their moderate and high Prandtl number counterparts.

physics.flu-dyn

Double-diffusive processes in stellar astrophysics

The past 20 years have witnessed a renewal of interest in the subject of double-diffusive processes in astrophysics, and their impact on stellar evolution. This lecture aims to summarize the state of the field as of early 2019, although the reader should bear in mind that it is rapidly evolving. An Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics article entitled "Double-diffusive convection at low Prandtl number" (Garaud, 2018) contains a reasonably comprehensive review of the topic, up to the summer of 2017. I focus here on presenting what I hope are clear derivations of some of the most important results with an astrophysical audience in mind, and discuss their implications for stellar evolution, both in an observational context, and in relation to previous work on the subject.

astro-ph.SR

Preferential concentration by mechanically-driven turbulence in the two-fluid formalism

Preferential concentration is thought to play a key role in promoting particle growth, which is crucial to processes such as warm rain formation in clouds, planet formation, and industrial sprays. In this work, we investigate preferential concentration using 3D Direct Numerical Simulations adopting the Eulerian-Eulerian two-fluid approach, where the particles are treated as a continuum field with its own momentum and mass conservation laws. We consider particles with Stokes number $St \lesssim O(0.01)$ in moderately turbulent flows with fluid Reynolds number $Re \leq 600$. In our previous work (Nasab & Garaud, Physical Review Fluids. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevFluids.5.114308, 2020), we established scaling laws to predict maximum and typical particle concentration enhancements in the context of the particle-driven convective instability. Here we verify that the same results apply when turbulence is externally driven, extending the relevance of our model to a wider class of particle-laden flows. We find in particular that (i) the maximum particle concentration enhancement above the mean scales as $u_{rms}^2 τ_p / κ_p$, where $u_{rms}$ is the rms fluid velocity, $τ_p$ is the particle stopping time, and $κ_p$ is the assumed particle diffusivity from the two-fluid equations; (ii) the typical particle concentration enhancement over the mean scales as $(u_{rms}^2 τ_p / κ_p)^{1/2}$; and (iii) the probability distribution function of the particle concentration enhancement over the mean has an exponential tail whose slope scales like $(u_{rms}^2 τ_p /κ_p)^{-1/2}$. We conclude by discussing the caveats of our model and its implications in a relevant cloud application.

physics.flu-dyn

On the dynamical interaction between overshooting convection and an underlying dipole magnetic field -- I. The non-dynamo regime

Motivated by the dynamics in the deep interiors of many stars, we study the interaction between overshooting convection and the large-scale poloidal fields residing in radiative zones. We have run a suite of 3D Boussinesq numerical calculations in a spherical shell that consists of a convection zone with an underlying stable region that initially compactly contains a dipole field. By varying the strength of the convective driving, we find that, in the less turbulent regime, convection acts as turbulent diffusion that removes the field faster than solely molecular diffusion would do. However, in the more turbulent regime, turbulent pumping becomes more efficient and partially counteracts turbulent diffusion, leading to a local accumulation of the field below the overshoot region. These simulations suggest that dipole fields might be confined in underlying stable regions by highly turbulent convective motions at stellar parameters. The confinement is of large-scale field in an average sense and we show that it is reasonably modeled by mean-field ideas. Our findings are particularly interesting for certain models of the Sun, which require a large-scale, poloidal magnetic field to be confined in the solar radiative zone in order to explain simultaneously the uniform rotation of the latter and the thinness of the solar tachocline.

astro-ph.SR

The tachocline revisited

The solar tachocline is a shear layer located at the base of the solar convection zone. The horizontal shear in the tachocline is likely turbulent, and it is often assumed that this turbulence would be strongly anisotropic as a result of the local stratification. What role this turbulence plays in the tachocline dynamics, however, remains to be determined. In particular, it is not clear whether it would result in a turbulent eddy diffusivity, or anti-diffusivity, or something else entirely. In this paper, we present the first direct numerical simulations of turbulence in horizontal shear flows at low Prandtl number, in an idealized model that ignores rotation and magnetic fields. We find that several regimes exist, depending on the relative importance of the stratification, viscosity and thermal diffusivity. Our results suggest that the tachocline is in the stratified turbulence regime, which has very specific properties controlled by a balance between buoyancy, inertia, and thermal diffusion.

astro-ph.SR

Preferential concentration in the particle-induced convective instability

Heavy particles in turbulent flows have been shown to accumulate in regions of high strain rate or low vorticity, a process otherwise known as preferential concentration. This can be observed in geophysical flows, and is inferred to occur in astrophysical environments, often resulting in rapid particle growth which is critical to physical processes such as rain or planet formation. Here we study the effects of preferential concentration in a two-way coupled system in the context of the particle-driven convective instability. To do so, we use Direct Numerical Simulations and adopt the two-fluid approximation. We focus on a particle size range for which the latter is valid, namely when the Stokes number is $\lesssim O(0.1)$. For Stokes number above $\sim 0.01$, we find that the maximum particle concentration enhancement over the mean scales with the rms fluid velocity $u_{\rm{rms}}$, the particle stopping time $τ_p$, and the particle diffusivity $κ_p$, as $u_{\rm{rms}}^2 τ_p / κ_p$. We show that this scaling can be understood from simple arguments of dominant balance. We also show that the typical particle concentration enhancement over the mean scales as $(u_{\rm{rms}}^2 τ_p/ κ_p)^{1/2}$. We finally find that the probability distribution function of the particle concentration enhancement over the mean has an exponential tail whose slope scales as $(u_{\rm{rms}}^2 τ_p / κ_p)^{-1/2}$. We apply our model to geophysical and astrophysical examples, and discuss its limitations.

physics.flu-dyn

Mixing via Thermocompositional Convection in Hybrid C/O/Ne White Dwarfs

Convective overshooting in super asymptotic giant branch stars has been suggested to lead to the formation of hybrid white dwarfs with carbon-oxygen cores and oxygen-neon mantles. As the white dwarf cools, this core-mantle configuration becomes convectively unstable and should mix. This mixing has been previously studied using stellar evolution calculations, but these made the approximation that convection did not affect the temperature profile of the mixed region. In this work, we perform direct numerical simulations of an idealized problem representing the core-mantle interface of the hybrid white dwarf. We demonstrate that, while the resulting structure within the convection zone is somewhat different than what is assumed in the stellar evolution calculations, the two approaches yield similar results for the size and growth of the mixed region. These hybrid white dwarfs have been invoked as progenitors of various peculiar thermonuclear supernovae. This lends further support to the idea that if these hybrid white dwarfs form then they should be fully mixed by the time of explosion. These effects should be included in the progenitor evolution in order to more accurately characterize the signatures of these events.

astro-ph.SR

Enhanced mixing in magnetized fingering convection, and implications for RGB stars

Double-diffusive convection has been well studied in geophysical contexts, but detailed investigations of the regimes characteristic of stellar or planetary interiors have only recently become feasible. Since most astrophysical fluids are electrically conducting, it is possible that magnetic fields play a role in either enhancing or suppressing double-diffusive convection, but to date there have been no numerical investigations of such possibilities. Here we study the effects of a vertical background magnetic field (aligned with the gravitational axis) on the linear stability and nonlinear saturation of fingering (thermohaline) convection, through a combination of theoretical work and direct numerical simulations (DNSs). We find that a vertical magnetic field rigidifies the fingers along the vertical direction which has the remarkable effect of enhancing vertical mixing. We propose a simple analytical model for mixing by magnetized fingering convection, and argue that magnetic effects may help explain discrepancies between theoretical and observed mixing rates in low-mass red giant branch (RGB) stars. Other implications of our findings are also discussed.

astro-ph.SR