SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Peter Gmeiner

Publications and source records attributed to Peter Gmeiner.

3 recordsLinked to original sources

Information-Theoretic Approximation to Causal Models

Inferring the causal direction and causal effect between two discrete random variables X and Y from a finite sample is often a crucial problem and a challenging task. However, if we have access to observational and interventional data, it is possible to solve that task. If X is causing Y, then it does not matter if we observe an effect in Y by observing changes in X or by intervening actively on X. This invariance principle creates a link between observational and interventional distributions in a higher dimensional probability space. We embed distributions that originate from samples of X and Y into that higher dimensional space such that the embedded distribution is closest to the distributions that follow the invariance principle, with respect to the relative entropy. This allows us to calculate the best information-theoretic approximation for a given empirical distribution, that follows an assumed underlying causal model. We show that this information-theoretic approximation to causal models (IACM) can be done by solving a linear optimization problem. In particular, by approximating the empirical distribution to a monotonic causal model, we can calculate probabilities of causation. We can also use IACM for causal discovery problems in the bivariate, discrete case. However, experimental results on labeled synthetic data from additive noise models show that our causal discovery approach is lagging behind state-of-the-art approaches because the invariance principle encodes only a necessary condition for causal relations. Nevertheless, for synthetic multiplicative noise data and real-world data, our approach can compete in some cases with alternative methods.

stat.ML

Properties of Persistent Mutual Information and Emergence

The persistent mutual information (PMI) is a complexity measure for stochastic processes. It is related to well-known complexity measures like excess entropy or statistical complexity. Essentially it is a variation of the excess entropy so that it can be interpreted as a specific measure of system internal memory. The PMI was first introduced in 2010 by Ball, Diakonova and MacKay as a measure for (strong) emergence. In this paper we define the PMI mathematically and investigate the relation to excess entropy and statistical complexity. In particular we prove that the excess entropy is an upper bound of the PMI. Furthermore we show some properties of the PMI and calculate it explicitly for some example processes. We also discuss to what extend it is a measure for emergence and compare it with alternative approaches used to formalize emergence.

math-ph

Equality conditions for internal entropies of certain classical and quantum models

Mathematical models use information from past observations to generate predictions about the future. If two models make identical predictions the one that needs less information from the past to do this is preferred. It is already known that certain classical models (certain Hidden Markov Models called ε-machines which are often optimal classical models) are not in general the preferred ones. We extend this result and show that even optimal classical models (models with minimal internal entropy) in general are not the best possible models (called ideal models). Instead of optimal classical models we can construct quantum models which are significantly better but not yet the best possible ones (i.e. they have a strictly smaller internal entropy). In this paper we show conditions when the internal entropies between classical models and specific quantum models coincide. Furthermore it turns out that this situation appears very rarely. An example shows that our results hold only for the specific quantum model construction and in general not for alternative constructions. Furthermore another example shows that classical models with minimal internal entropy need not to be related to quantum models with minimal internal entropy.

quant-ph