Comparative analysis of fiber Bragg grating filter losses inscribed by continuous wave UV and femtosecond-IR lasers for astrophotonics
Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) filters have been demonstrated as promising components in astrophotonic instrumentation for near-infrared ground-based observations. Given the photon-starved nature of astronomical applications, it is critical to minimize insertion losses across astrophotonic components. In addition to the insertion loss (IL) introduced by specialty fibers and inscription techniques, FBGs exhibit cladding mode (CM) losses. In this work, we studied the loss characteristics of five filter lines in three photosensitive fibers, i.e., a low-numerical-aperture (NA) fiber, a high-NA bend-insensitive fiber, and a cladding-mode-suppressed (CMS) fiber, and in a non-photosensitive fiber, SMF-28. The filters were inscribed using two phase mask-based illumination methods: a continuous wave ultraviolet (UV) laser with a complex phase mask allowing for multi-channel filters, and a femtosecond infrared (fs-IR) laser with phase mask integrated shaping apertures for spectral profile control. Our results show that UV-inscribed gratings in high-NA bend-insensitive fiber yield the lowest CM losses ($\approx$ 0.5 dB) among photosensitive fibers, but exhibit the highest IL (4.6 dB), and FBGs in non-photosensitive SMF-28 fiber, inscribed with fs-IR, achieve the lowest IL (< 0.05 dB) with a comparatively higher CM loss (0.93 dB). To reduce the high IL in high-NA fiber, we explored tapering and bridging methods and report that bridging reduces IL by $\sim$ 3 dB. We show that both filter platforms remain viable for integration into an astrophotonic system, with IL below 1 dB. Finally, we propose a compact bridge-fiber scheme with the potential to further reduce IL to below 0.5 dB while reducing the number of bridging fibers and, consequently, the number of splice junctions by 50%.