Richard Gaus | Searcharxiv

arXiv2025

Structured Prompts Improve Evaluation of Language Models

As language models (LMs) are increasingly adopted across domains, high-quality benchmarking frameworks are essential for guiding deployment decisions. In practice, however, frameworks such as Holistic Evaluation of Language Models (HELM) typically evaluate models under a single static prompt configuration, even though model behavior depends strongly on prompt choice. As a result, reported scores can reflect prompt choice as much as model capability. Declarative prompting frameworks such as DSPy offer a scalable way to evaluate models under a set of structured prompting strategies rather than a static prompt configuration. We present a reproducible DSPy+HELM framework for studying how prompt choice impacts reported benchmark outcomes. Using five prompting methods, we evaluate four frontier and two open-source LMs across seven benchmarks against existing HELM baseline scores. By evaluating LMs across a family of prompt configurations, we find that prompt choice can materially impact leaderboard outcomes. In particular, structured prompting improves performance (by 6% on average), alters comparisons (leaderboard rankings shift on 5/7 benchmarks), with most gains coming from introducing chain-of-thought, and little additional benefit from more advanced optimizers. To our knowledge, this is the first study to systematically integrate structured prompting into an established evaluation framework and quantify how prompt choice alone can impact benchmark conclusions. We open-source (i) DSPy+HELM Evaluation (https://github.com/stanford-crfm/helm/pull/3893) and (ii) Prompt Optimization Pipeline (https://github.com/StanfordMIMI/dspy-helm).

cs.CL↗

arXiv2022

Adaptive Personlization in Federated Learning for Highly Non-i.i.d. Data

Federated learning (FL) is a distributed learning method that offers medical institutes the prospect of collaboration in a global model while preserving the privacy of their patients. Although most medical centers conduct similar medical imaging tasks, their differences, such as specializations, number of patients, and devices, lead to distinctive data distributions. Data heterogeneity poses a challenge for FL and the personalization of the local models. In this work, we investigate an adaptive hierarchical clustering method for FL to produce intermediate semi-global models, so clients with similar data distribution have the chance of forming a more specialized model. Our method forms several clusters consisting of clients with the most similar data distributions; then, each cluster continues to train separately. Inside the cluster, we use meta-learning to improve the personalization of the participants' models. We compare the clustering approach with classical FedAvg and centralized training by evaluating our proposed methods on the HAM10k dataset for skin lesion classification with extreme heterogeneous data distribution. Our experiments demonstrate significant performance gain in heterogeneous distribution compared to standard FL methods in classification accuracy. Moreover, we show that the models converge faster if applied in clusters and outperform centralized training while using only a small subset of data.

cs.LG↗