SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Robert F. Penna

Publications and source records attributed to Robert F. Penna.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

A nonlocal charge for cylindrical gravitational waves

The classical scattering of cylindrical gravitational waves is exactly solvable. The motivation for this paper is to understand if the quantum scattering problem is also exactly solvable. The classical dynamics is governed by a two dimensional sigma model. We study this sigma model's $S$-matrix. We construct a conserved nonlocal charge and derive the associated tree-level $S$-matrix conservation law. We check our conservation law directly using Feynman diagrams. The existence of this symmetry is a hint that cylindrical gravitational waves might have an exactly solvable $S$-matrix.

hep-th

Gravitational Pulse Wave Scattering and the Geroch group

Cylindrical gravitational pulse waves are cylindrical gravitational waves with a pulse profile in the radial direction. The dynamics of cylindrical gravitational pulse waves is governed by a two dimensional integrable sigma model with an infinite dimensional hidden symmetry called the Geroch group. Piran, Safier, and Katz obtained an exact solution for a single pulse wave by making a double analytic continuation of the Kerr metric. Their solution describes a pulse wave that arrives from infinity, bounces off the symmetry axis, and returns to infinity. In this note, we obtain an exact solution for a double pulse wave by making a double analytic continuation of the double Kerr metric. The new solution describes a pair of pulse waves that arrive from infinity, scatter through each other, and return to infinity. The pulses pass through each other and emerge with their shapes intact, as in ordinary soliton scattering. Unlike ordinary soliton scattering, there is no time delay. The metric is free of the conical singularity that appears in the double Kerr metric. In the future, it would be interesting to understand how the Geroch group manifests in the quantum version of gravitational pulse wave scattering.

gr-qc

The Geroch Group in One Dimension

We study the dimensional reduction of general relativity to a single null spacetime dimension. The dimensionally reduced theory is a theory of six scalar fields governed by three constraints. It has an infinite dimensional symmetry which is an enhanced version of the Geroch group. To get a local action of the symmetry on solution space, we need to introduce an infinite tower of new fields and new constraints. The symmetry appears to be a hyperbolic Kac-Moody algebra, with the caveat that some of the defining relations of the hyperbolic Kac-Moody algebra are only checked ``order by order'' on the infinite tower of new fields. This is a very mysterious Lie algebra with no known geometrical interpretation. It is not even clear how to enumerate a basis. We explore this problem using the action of the algebra on solution space and find an intriguing connection to the representation theory of the symmetric group. The symmetry described here might be related to the dynamics of gravity near spacelike singularities.

hep-th

A Lax Operator for $d=2$ $N=2$ Supergravity

General relativity and supergravity become integrable systems after dimensional reduction to two spacetime dimensions. This means the equations of motion can be encoded in the flatness condition for a Lax operator. Nicolai and Warner found Lax operators for dimensionally reduced supergravity. They gave explicit formulas primarily for the case with $N=16$ supersymmetry in two dimensions (which corresponds to $N=8$ supergravity in four dimensions). In this note, we derive analogous results for the case with $N=2$ supersymmetry in two dimensions (which corresponds to $N=1$ supergravity in four dimensions). This is the simplest example of the general fact that supergravity becomes an integrable system after dimensional reduction to two dimensions.

hep-th

Twistor Actions for Integrable Systems

Many integrable systems can be reformulated as holomorphic vector bundles on twistor space. This is a powerful organizing principle in the theory of integrable systems. One shortcoming is that it is formulated at the level of the equations of motion. From this perspective, it is mysterious that integrable systems have Lagrangians. In this paper, we study a Chern-Simons action on twistor space and use it to derive the Lagrangians of some integrable sigma models. Our focus is on examples that come from dimensionally reduced gravity and supergravity. The dimensional reduction of general relativity to two spacetime dimensions is an integrable coset sigma model coupled to a dilaton and 2d gravity. The dimensional reduction of supergravity to two spacetime dimensions is an integrable coset sigma model coupled to matter fermions, a dilaton, and 2d supergravity. We derive Lax operators and Lagrangians for these 2d integrable systems using the Chern-Simons theory on twistor space. In the supergravity example, we use an extended setup in which twistor Chern-Simons theory is coupled to a pair of matter fermions.

hep-th

Einstein-Rosen Waves and the Geroch Group

Under the action of the Geroch group, the Minkowski metric can be transformed into any vacuum metric with two commuting Killing vectors. In principle, this reduces the problem of deriving vacuum metrics with two commuting Killing vectors to pure algebra. In this short note, we use these facts to give a purely algebraic derivation of the Einstein-Rosen metric, which describes a cylindrical gravitational wave. Our derivation has a straightforward extension to gravitational pulse waves.

gr-qc

${\rm SDiff}(S^2)$ and the orbit method

The group of area preserving diffeomorphisms of the two sphere, ${\rm SDiff}(S^2)$, is one of the simplest examples of an infinite dimensional Lie group. It plays a key role in incompressible hydrodynamics and it recently appeared in general relativity as a subgroup of two closely related, newly defined symmetry groups. We investigate its representation theory using the method of coadjoint orbits. We describe the Casimir functions and the Cartan algebra. Then we evaluate the trace of a simple ${\rm SDiff}(S^2)$ operator using the Atiyah-Bott fixed point formula. The trace is divergent but we show that it has well-defined truncations related to the structure of ${\rm SDiff}(S^2)$. Finally, we relate our results back to the recent appearances of ${\rm SDiff}(S^2)$ in black hole physics.

hep-th

Near-horizon Carroll symmetry and black hole Love numbers

According to the black hole membrane paradigm, the black hole event horizon behaves like a 2+1 dimensional fluid. The fluid has nonzero momentum density but zero velocity. As a result, it does not respond to tidal forces in the usual way. In this note, we point out that this unusual behavior can be traced back to an emergent, near-horizon Carroll symmetry (the Carroll group is the $c\rightarrow 0$ limit of the Poincaré group). For Schwarzschild black holes in $d=4$ general relativity, we relate the vanishing of the black hole fluid's velocity to vanishing of the black hole's Love numbers. This suggests near-horizon Carroll symmetry may have a role to play in explaining black hole Love numbers.

hep-th

Kinematic space and the orbit method

Kinematic space has been defined as the space of codimension-$2$ spacelike extremal surfaces in anti de Sitter (AdS$_{d+1}$) spacetime which, by the Ryu-Takayanagi proposal, compute the entanglement entropy of spheres in the boundary CFT$_d$. It has recently found many applications in holography. Coadjoint orbits are symplectic manifolds that are the classical analogues of a Lie group's unitary irreducible representations. We prove that kinematic space is a particular coadjoint orbit of the $d$-dimensional conformal group $SO(d,2)$. In addition, we show that the Crofton form on kinematic space associated to AdS$_3$, that was shown to compute the lengths of bulk curves, is equal to the standard Kirillov-Kostant symplectic form on the coadjoint orbit. Since kinematic space is Kähler in addition to symplectic, it can be quantized. The orbit method extends the kinematic space dictionary, which was originally motivated through connections to integral geometry, by directly translating geometrical properties of holographic auxiliary spaces into statements about the representation theory of the conformal group.

hep-th

Asymptotic symmetries of three dimensional gravity and the membrane paradigm

The asymptotic symmetry group of three-dimensional (anti) de Sitter space is the two dimensional conformal group with central charge $c=3\ell/2G$. Usually the asymptotic charge algebra is derived using the symplectic structure of the bulk Einstein equations. Here, we derive the asymptotic charge algebra by a different route. First, we formulate the dynamics of the boundary as a 1+1-dimensional dynamical system. Then we realize the boundary equations of motion as a Hamiltonian system on the dual Lie algebra, $\mathfrak{g}^*$, of the two-dimensional conformal group. Finally, we use the Lie-Poisson bracket on $\mathfrak{g}^*$ to compute the asymptotic charge algebra. This streamlines the derivation of the asymptotic charge algebra because the Lie-Poisson bracket on the boundary is significantly simpler than the symplectic structure derived from the bulk Einstein equations. It also clarifies the analogy between the infinite dimensional symmetries of gravity and fluid dynamics.

hep-th

${\rm BMS}_3$ invariant fluid dynamics at null infinity

We revisit the boundary dynamics of asymptotically flat, three dimensional gravity. The boundary is governed by a momentum conservation equation and an energy conservation equation, which we interpret as fluid equations, following the membrane paradigm. We reformulate the boundary's equations of motion as Hamiltonian flow on the dual of an infinite-dimensional, semi-direct product Lie algebra equipped with a Lie-Poisson bracket. This gives the analogue for boundary fluid dynamics of the Marsden-Ratiu-Weinstein formulation of the compressible Euler equations on a manifold, $M$, as Hamiltonian flow on the dual of the Lie algebra of ${\rm Diff}(M)\ltimes C^\infty(M)$. The Lie group for boundary fluid dynamics turns out to be ${\rm Diff}(S^1) \ltimes_{\rm Ad} {\rm \mathfrak{vir}}$, with central charge $c=3/G$. This gives a new derivation of the centrally extended, three-dimensional Bondi-van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs (${\rm BMS}_3$) group. The relationship with fluid dynamics helps to streamline and physically motivate the derivation. For example, the central charge, $c=3/G$, is simply read off of a fluid equation in much the same way as one reads off a viscosity coefficient. The perspective presented here may useful for understanding the still mysterious four-dimensional BMS group.

hep-th

Near-horizon BMS symmetries as fluid symmetries

The Bondi-van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs (BMS) group is the asymptotic symmetry group of asymptotically flat gravity. Recently, Donnay et al. have derived an analogous symmetry group acting on black hole event horizons. For a certain choice of boundary conditions, it is a semidirect product of ${\rm Diff}(S^2)$, the smooth diffeomorphisms of the two-sphere, acting on $C^\infty(S^2)$, the smooth functions on the two-sphere. We observe that the same group appears in fluid dynamics as symmetries of the compressible Euler equations. We relate these two realizations of ${\rm Diff}(S^2)\ltimes C^\infty(S^2)$ using the black hole membrane paradigm. We show that the Lie-Poisson brackets of membrane paradigm fluid charges reproduce the near-horizon BMS algebra. The perspective presented here may be useful for understanding the BMS algebra at null infinity.

hep-th

Strong-field tidal distortions of rotating black holes: III. Embeddings in hyperbolic 3-space

In previous work, we developed tools for quantifying the tidal distortion of a black hole's event horizon due to an orbiting companion. These tools use techniques which require large mass ratios (companion mass $μ$ much smaller than black hole mass $M$), but can be used for arbitrary bound orbits, and for any black hole spin. We also showed how to visualize these distorted black holes by embedding their horizons in a global Euclidean 3-space, ${\mathbb{E}}^3$. Such visualizations illustrate interesting and important information about horizon dynamics. Unfortunately, we could not visualize black holes with spin parameter $a_* > \sqrt{3}/2 \approx 0.866$: such holes cannot be globally embedded into ${\mathbb{E}}^3$. In this paper, we overcome this difficulty by showing how to embed the horizons of tidally distorted Kerr black holes in a hyperbolic 3-space, ${\mathbb{H}}^3$. We use black hole perturbation theory to compute the Gaussian curvatures of tidally distorted event horizons, from which we build a two-dimensional metric of their distorted horizons. We develop a numerical method for embedding the tidally distorted horizons in ${\mathbb{H}}^3$. As an application, we give a sequence of embeddings into ${\mathbb{H}}^3$ of a tidally interacting black hole with spin $a_*=0.9999$. A small amplitude, high frequency oscillation seen in previous work shows up particularly clearly in these embeddings.

gr-qc

BMS invariance and the membrane paradigm

The Bondi-van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs (BMS) group is the asymptotic symmetry group of asymptotically flat spacetime. It is infinite dimensional and entails an infinite number of conservation laws. According to the black hole membrane paradigm, null infinity (in asymptotically flat spacetime) and black hole event horizons behave like fluid membranes. The fluid dynamics of the membrane is governed by an infinite set of symmetries and conservation laws. Our main result is to point out that the infinite set of symmetries and conserved charges of the BMS group and the membrane paradigm are the same. This relationship has several consequences. First, it sheds light on the physical interpretation of BMS conservation laws. Second, it generalizes the BMS conservation laws to arbitrary subregions of arbitrary null surfaces. Third, it clarifies the identification of the superrotation subgroup of the BMS group. We briefly comment on the black hole information problem.

hep-th

Black hole jet power from impedance matching

Black hole jet power depends on the angular velocity of magnetic field lines, $Ω_F$. Force-free black hole magnetospheres typically have $Ω_F/Ω_H \approx 0.5$, where $Ω_H$ is the angular velocity of the horizon. We give a streamlined proof of this result using an extension of the classical black hole membrane paradigm. The proof is based on an impedance-matching argument between membranes at the horizon and infinity. Then we consider a general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulation of an accreting, spinning black hole and jet. We find that the theory correctly describes the simulation in the jet region. However, the field lines threading the horizon near the equator have much smaller $Ω_F/Ω_H$ because the force-free approximation breaks down in the accretion flow.

astro-ph.HE

Energy extraction from boosted black holes: Penrose process, jets, and the membrane at infinity

Numerical simulations indicate that black holes carrying linear momentum and/or orbital momentum can power jets. The jets extract the kinetic energy stored in the black hole's motion. This could provide an important electromagnetic counterpart to gravitational wave searches. We develop the theory underlying these jets. In particular, we derive the analogues of the Penrose process and the Blandford-Znajek jet power prediction for boosted black holes. The jet power we find is $(v/2M)^2 Φ^2/(4π)$, where $v$ is the hole's velocity, $M$ is its mass, and $Φ$ is the magnetic flux. We show that energy extraction from boosted black holes is conceptually similar to energy extraction from spinning black holes. However, we highlight two key technical differences: in the boosted case, jet power is no longer defined with respect to a Killing vector, and the relevant notion of black hole mass is observer dependent. We derive a new version of the membrane paradigm in which the membrane lives at infinity rather than the horizon and we show that this is useful for interpreting jets from boosted black holes. Our jet power prediction and the assumptions behind it can be tested with future numerical simulations.

astro-ph.HE

MITEoR: A Scalable Interferometer for Precision 21 cm Cosmology

We report on the MIT Epoch of Reionization (MITEoR) experiment, a pathfinder low-frequency radio interferometer whose goal is to test technologies that improve the calibration precision and reduce the cost of the high-sensitivity 3D mapping required for 21 cm cosmology. MITEoR accomplishes this by using massive baseline redundancy, which enables both automated precision calibration and correlator cost reduction. We demonstrate and quantify the power and robustness of redundancy for scalability and precision. We find that the calibration parameters precisely describe the effect of the instrument upon our measurements, allowing us to form a model that is consistent with $χ^2$ per degree of freedom < 1.2 for as much as 80% of the observations. We use these results to develop an optimal estimator of calibration parameters using Wiener filtering, and explore the question of how often and how finely in frequency visibilities must be reliably measured to solve for calibration coefficients. The success of MITEoR with its 64 dual-polarization elements bodes well for the more ambitious Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) project and other next-generation instruments, which would incorporate many identical or similar technologies.

astro-ph.IM

The Black Hole Meissner Effect and Blandford-Znajek Jets

Spinning black holes tend to expel magnetic fields. In this way they are similar to superconductors. It has been a persistent concern that this black hole "Meissner effect" could quench jet power at high spins. This would make it impossible for the rapidly rotating black holes in Cyg X-1 and GRS 1915+105 to drive Blandford-Znajek jets. We give a simple geometrical argument why fields which become entirely radial near the horizon are not expelled by the Meissner effect and may continue to power jets up to the extremal limit. A simple and natural example is a split-monopole field. We stress that ordinary Blandford-Znajek jets are impossible if the Meissner effect operates and expels the field. Finally, we note that in our general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of black hole jets, there is no evidence that jets are quenched by the Meissner effect. The simulated jets develop a large split monopole component spontaneously which supports our proposal for how the Meissner effect is evaded and jets from rapidly rotating black holes are powered in nature.

astro-ph.HE