arXiv subjects

Robin Kaarsgaard

Publications and source records attributed to Robin Kaarsgaard.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

Free Quantum Computing

Quantum computing improves substantially on known classical algorithms for various important problems, but the nature of the relationship between quantum and classical computing is not yet fully understood. This relationship can be clarified by free models, that add to classical computing just enough physical principles to represent quantum computing and no more. Here we develop an axiomatisation of quantum computing that replaces the standard continuous postulates with a small number of discrete equations, as well as a free model that replaces the standard linear-algebraic model with a category-theoretical one. The axioms and model are based on reversible classical computing, isolate quantum advantage in the ability to take certain well-behaved square roots, and link to various quantum computing hardware platforms. This approach allows combinatorial optimisation, including brute force computer search, to optimise quantum computations. The free model may be interpreted as a programming language for quantum computers, that has the same expressivity and computational universality as the standard model, but additionally allows automated verification and reasoning.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2025

One rig to control them all

Controlled commands -- computations whose execution depends on a separate input -- play a central role in reversible Boolean circuits and quantum circuits. However, existing formalisms typically treat control only implicitly, entangled with other aspects of computation. From a semantic perspective, control is most naturally expressed in semisimple rig categories, which -- unlike standard circuit models such as props -- support both parallel and conditional composition. We present a construction that freely adjoins an explicit syntactic notion of control to a circuit theory specified as a suitable prop, subject to eight universally quantified equations. Our main result is that these equations are sound and complete for the intended semantics of control: the resulting theory satisfies a universal property, identifying it exactly as the circuit subtheory of the free semisimple rig completion. The proof combines coherence for rig categories with a new method based on induction over Gray codes. We illustrate the usefulness of the framework by showing that it simplifies several existing sound and complete axiomatisations of quantum circuits, isolating a small and conceptually clean set of generators and equations. In addition, the same equations yield a sound and complete axiomatisation of the multiply controlled Toffoli gate set, that is universal for reversible Boolean circuits.

cs.LO↗

arXiv2025

Universality of a standard two-qubit gate by catalytic embedding

We study the resources required to achieve universal quantum computing via the gate sets that provide the fundamental instructions from which quantum algorithms are built. While single-gate universal sets are known, they rely on precisely tuned irrational rotations, making them difficult to realize on near-term devices. We find that the controlled-$V$ gate, an elementary two-qubit interaction directly implementable on leading hardware, is universal and capable of simulating standard universal gate sets with minimal overhead. Specifically, we use catalytic embeddings to develop a constant-overhead algorithm that simulates standard universal gate sets, including Clifford$+T$ and Clifford$+$Toffoli. We combine this simulation algorithm with existing synthesis results to yield exact and approximate synthesis algorithms for unitaries with and without number-theoretic restrictions. The results highlight how full quantum computational power, complete with algorithms for synthesis and simulation, can emerge from unexpectedly simple ingredients.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2025

Hadamard-Pi: Equational Quantum Programming

Quantum computing offers advantages over classical computation, yet the precise features that set the two apart remain unclear. In the standard quantum circuit model, adding a 1-qubit basis-changing gate -- commonly chosen to be the Hadamard gate -- to a universal set of classical reversible gates yields computationally universal quantum computation. However, the computational behaviours enabled by this addition are not fully characterised. We give such a characterisation by introducing a small quantum programming language extending the universal classical reversible programming language $\Pi$ with a single primitive corresponding to the Hadamard gate. The language comes equipped with a sound and complete categorical semantics that is specified by a purely equational theory. Completeness is shown by means of a novel finite presentation, and a corresponding synthesis algorithm, for the groups of orthogonal matrices with entries in the ring $\mathbb{Z}[\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}]$.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2024

Compositional Reversible Computation

Reversible computing is motivated by both pragmatic and foundational considerations arising from a variety of disciplines. We take a particular path through the development of reversible computation, emphasizing compositional reversible computation. We start from a historical perspective, by reviewing those approaches that developed reversible extensions of lambda-calculi, Turing machines, and communicating process calculi. These approaches share a common challenge: computations made reversible in this way do not naturally compose locally. We then turn our attention to computational models that eschew the detour via existing irreversible models. Building on an original analysis by Landauer, the insights of Bennett, Fredkin, and Toffoli introduced a fresh approach to reversible computing in which reversibility is elevated to the status of the main design principle. These initial models are expressed using low-level bit manipulations, however. Abstracting from the low-level of the Bennett-Fredkin-Toffoli models and pursuing more intrinsic, typed, and algebraic models, naturally leads to rig categories as the canonical model for compositional reversible programming. The categorical model reveals connections to type isomorphisms, symmetries, permutations, groups, and univalent universes. This, in turn, paves the way for extensions to reversible programming based on monads and arrows. These extensions are shown to recover conventional irreversible programming, a variety of reversible computational effects, and more interestingly both pure (measurement-free) and measurement-based quantum programming.

cs.LO↗

arXiv2023

With a Few Square Roots, Quantum Computing is as Easy as {\Pi}

Rig groupoids provide a semantic model of \PiLang, a universal classical reversible programming language over finite types. We prove that extending rig groupoids with just two maps and three equations about them results in a model of quantum computing that is computationally universal and equationally sound and complete for a variety of gate sets. The first map corresponds to an $8^{\text{th}}$ root of the identity morphism on the unit $1$. The second map corresponds to a square root of the symmetry on $1+1$. As square roots are generally not unique and can sometimes even be trivial, the maps are constrained to satisfy a nondegeneracy axiom, which we relate to the Euler decomposition of the Hadamard gate. The semantic construction is turned into an extension of \PiLang, called \SPiLang, that is a computationally universal quantum programming language equipped with an equational theory that is sound and complete with respect to the Clifford gate set, the standard gate set of Clifford+T restricted to $\le 2$ qubits, and the computationally universal Gaussian Clifford+T gate set.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2023

Tail recursion transformation for invertible functions

Tail recursive functions allow for a wider range of optimisations than general recursive functions. For this reason, much research has gone into the transformation and optimisation of this family of functions, in particular those written in continuation passing style (CPS). Though the CPS transformation, capable of transforming any recursive function to an equivalent tail recursive one, is deeply problematic in the context of reversible programming (as it relies on troublesome features such as higher-order functions), we argue that relaxing (local) reversibility to (global) invertibility drastically improves the situation. On this basis, we present an algorithm for tail recursion conversion specifically for invertible functions. The key insight is that functions introduced by program transformations that preserve invertibility, need only be invertible in the context in which the functions subject of transformation calls them. We show how a bespoke data type, corresponding to such a context, can be used to transform invertible recursive functions into a pair of tail recursive function acting on this context, in a way where calls are highlighted, and from which a tail recursive inverse can be straightforwardly extracted.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2023

The Quantum Effect: A Recipe for QuantumPi

Free categorical constructions characterise quantum computing as the combination of two copies of a reversible classical model, glued by the complementarity equations of classical structures. This recipe effectively constructs a computationally universal quantum programming language from two copies of Pi, the internal language of rig groupoids. The construction consists of Hughes' arrows. Thus answer positively the question whether a computational effect exists that turns reversible classical computation into quantum computation: the quantum effect. Measurements can be added by layering a further effect on top. Our construction also enables some reasoning about quantum programs (with or without measurement) through a combination of classical reasoning and reasoning about complementarity.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2022

Branching execution symmetry in Jeopardy by available implicit arguments analysis

When the inverse of an algorithm is well-defined -- that is, when its output can be deterministically transformed into the input producing it -- we say that the algorithm is invertible. While one can describe an invertible algorithm using a general-purpose programming language, it is generally not possible to guarantee that its inverse is well-defined without additional argument. Reversible languages enforce deterministic inverse interpretation at the cost of expressibility, by restricting the building blocks from which an algorithm may be constructed. Jeopardy is a functional programming language designed for writing invertible algorithms \emph{without} the syntactic restrictions of reversible programming. In particular, Jeopardy allows the limited use of locally non-invertible operations, provided that they are used in a way that can be statically determined to be globally invertible. However, guaranteeing invertibility in Jeopardy is not obvious. One of the central problems in guaranteeing invertibility is that of deciding whether a program is symmetric in the face of branching control flow. In this paper, we show how Jeopardy can solve this problem, using a program analysis called available implicit arguments analysis, to approximate branching symmetries.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2022

Jeopardy: An Invertible Functional Programming Language

Algorithms are ways of mapping problems to solutions. An algorithm is invertible precisely when this mapping is injective, such that the initial problem can be uniquely inferred from its solution. While invertible algorithms can be described in general-purpose languages, no guarantees are generally made by such languages as regards invertibility, so ensuring invertibility requires additional (and often non-trivial) proof. On the other hand, while reversible programming languages guarantee that their programs are invertible by restricting the permissible operations to those which are locally invertible, writing programs in the reversible style can be cumbersome, and may differ significantly from conventional implementations even when the implemented algorithm is, in fact, invertible. In this paper we introduce Jeopardy, a functional programming language that guarantees program invertibility without imposing local reversibility. In particular, Jeopardy allows the limited use of uninvertible -- and even nondeterministic! -- operations, provided that they are used in a way that can be statically determined to be invertible. To this end, we outline an \emph{implicitly available arguments analysis} and three further approaches that can give a partial static guarantee to the (generally difficult) problem of guaranteeing invertibility.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2022

Combinatory Adjoints and Differentiation

We develop a compositional approach for automatic and symbolic differentiation based on categorical constructions in functional analysis where derivatives are linear functions on abstract vectors rather than being limited to scalars, vectors, matrices or tensors represented as multi-dimensional arrays. We show that both symbolic and automatic differentiation can be performed using a differential calculus for generating linear functions representing Fr\'echet derivatives based on rules for primitive, constant, linear and bilinear functions as well as their sequential and parallel composition. Linear functions are represented in a combinatory domain-specific language. Finally, we provide a calculus for symbolically computing the adjoint of a derivative without using matrices, which are too inefficient to use on high-dimensional spaces. The resulting symbolic representation of a derivative retains the data-parallel operations from the input program. The combination of combinatory differentiation and computing formal adjoints turns out to be behaviorally equivalent to reverse-mode automatic differentiation. In particular, it provides opportunities for optimizations where matrices are too inefficient to represent linear functions.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2022

The Programming of Algebra

We present module theory and linear maps as a powerful generalised and computationally efficient framework for the relational data model, which underpins today's relational database systems. Based on universal constructions of modules we obtain compact and computationally efficient data structures for data collections corresponding to union and deletion, repeated union, Cartesian product and key-indexed data. Free modules naturally give rise to polysets, which generalise multisets and facilitate expressing database queries as multilinear maps with asymptotically efficient evaluation on polyset constructors. We introduce compact maps as a way of representing infinite (poly)sets constructible from an infinite base set and its elements by addition and subtraction. We show how natural joins generalise to algebraic joins, while intersection is implemented by a novel algorithm on nested compact maps that carefully avoids visiting parts of the input that do not contribute to the eventual output. Our algebraic framework leads to a worst-case optimal evaluation of cyclic relational queries, which is known to be impossible using textbook query optimisers that operate on lists of records only.

cs.PL↗

arXiv2022

Universal Properties of Partial Quantum Maps

We provide a universal construction of the category of finite-dimensional C*-algebras and completely positive trace-nonincreasing maps from the rig category of finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces and unitaries. This construction, which can be applied to any dagger rig category, is described in three steps, each associated with their own universal property, and draws on results from dilation theory in finite dimension. In this way, we explicitly construct the category that captures hybrid quantum/classical computation with possible nontermination from the category of its reversible foundations. We discuss how this construction can be used in the design and semantics of quantum programming languages.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2021

Quantum Information Effects

We study the two dual quantum information effects to manipulate the amount of information in quantum computation: hiding and allocation. The resulting type-and-effect system is fully expressive for irreversible quantum computing, including measurement. We provide universal categorical constructions that semantically interpret this arrow metalanguage with choice, starting with any rig groupoid interpreting the reversible base language. Several properties of quantum measurement follow in general, and we translate (noniterative) quantum flow charts into our language. The semantic constructions turn the category of unitaries between Hilbert spaces into the category of completely positive trace-preserving maps, and they turn the category of bijections between finite sets into the category of functions with chosen garbage. Thus they capture the fundamental theorems of classical and quantum reversible computing of Toffoli and Stinespring.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2021

Join Inverse Rig Categories for Reversible Functional Programming, and Beyond

Reversible computing is a computational paradigm in which computations are deterministic in both the forward and backward direction, so that programs have well-defined forward and backward semantics. We investigate the formal semantics of the reversible functional programming language Rfun. For this purpose, we introduce join inverse rig categories, the natural marriage of join inverse categories and rig categories, which we show can be used to model the language Rfun, under reasonable assumptions. These categories turn out to be a particularly natural fit for reversible computing as a whole, as they encompass models for other reversible programming languages, notably Theseus and reversible flowcharts. This suggests that join inverse rig categories really are the categorical models of reversible computing.

cs.LO↗

arXiv2021

Graph Traversals as Universal Constructions

We exploit a decomposition of graph traversals to give a novel characterization of depth-first and breadth-first traversals as universal constructions. Specifically, we introduce functors from two different categories of edge-ordered directed graphs into two different categories of transitively closed edge-ordered graphs; one defines the lexicographic depth-first traversal and the other the lexicographic breadth-first traversal. We show that each functor factors as a composition of universal constructions, and that the usual presentation of traversals as linear orders on vertices can be recovered with the addition of an inclusion functor. Finally, we raise the question of to what extent we can recover search algorithms from the categorical description of the traversal they compute.

math.CT↗

arXiv2021

Bennett and Stinespring, Together at Last

We present a universal construction that relates reversible dynamics on open systems to arbitrary dynamics on closed systems: the restriction affine completion of a monoidal restriction category quotiented by well-pointedness. This categorical completion encompasses both quantum channels, via Stinespring dilation, and classical computing, via Bennett's method. Moreover, in these two cases, we show how our construction can be essentially 'undone' by a further universal construction. This shows how both mixed quantum theory and classical computation rest on entirely reversible foundations.

quant-ph↗

arXiv2019

Condition/Decision Duality and the Internal Logic of Extensive Restriction Categories

In flowchart languages, predicates play an interesting double role. In the textual representation, they are often presented as conditions, i.e., expressions which are easily combined with other conditions (often via Boolean combinators) to form new conditions, though they only play a supporting role in aiding branching statements choose a branch to follow. On the other hand, in the graphical representation they are typically presented as decisions, intrinsically capable of directing control flow yet mostly oblivious to Boolean combination. While categorical treatments of flowchart languages are abundant, none of them provide a treatment of this dual nature of predicates. In the present paper, we argue that extensive restriction categories are precisely categories that capture such a condition/decision duality, by means of morphisms which, coincidentally, are also called decisions. Further, we show that having these categorical decisions amounts to having an internal logic: Analogous to how subobjects of an object in a topos form a Heyting algebra, we show that decisions on an object in an extensive restriction category form a De Morgan quasilattice, the algebraic structure associated with the (three-valued) weak Kleene logic $\mathbf{K}^w_3$. Full classical propositional logic can be recovered by restricting to total decisions, yielding extensive categories in the usual sense, and confirming (from a different direction) a result from effectus theory that predicates on objects in extensive categories form Boolean algebras. As an application, since (categorical) decisions are partial isomorphisms, this approach provides naturally reversible models of classical propositional logic and weak Kleene logic.

cs.LO↗