arXiv subjects

Saad Aamir

Publications and source records attributed to Saad Aamir.

2 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

No Usable Linear "Capitulation Direction" in Two Small LLMs: A Validation Protocol for Activation-Steering Claims, and a Cross-Family Behavioral Study of Sycophancy Under Pushback

Language models frequently abandon correct answers when users push back. We study this in two small instruction-tuned models from different families, Qwen2.5-1.5B and Llama-3.2-1B, over TriviaQA: the model answers, is challenged with one of four scripted pushback styles, and answers again. Conditioned on an initially correct answer, the models flip to a wrong answer in 41.8% and 43.1% of episodes. Which pressure works is a property of the model, not the pressure: the same within-question paired comparison (bare doubt vs. emotional appeal), specified in advance, is Bonferroni-significant in opposite directions across families (Qwen: bare doubt > emotional, OR 2.5, p=.040; Llama: emotional > bare doubt, OR 4.0, p=.001). Failure mode is also model-dependent: Llama abandons answers without recommitting at six times Qwen's rate (8.2% vs. 1.4%). Identical pushback repairs initially wrong answers only ~13% of the time; pushback is net epistemically destructive. We then ask whether capitulation is linearly decodable from the pre-response residual stream, a prerequisite for steering-vector interventions at that locus. A naive difference-in-means probe appears to succeed (in-sample AUROC 0.81/0.71), but a validation protocol combining question-level cross-validation, shuffled-label nulls, and a known-direction positive control shows the signal is overfitting: the best cross-validated AUROC is 0.582 in Qwen and 0.548 in Llama, both near or below their permutation thresholds and far under a pre-registered usability bar of 0.70, while the identical pipeline recovers a pushback-presence control direction at AUROC 1.000 in both. We further quantify a measurement hazard: substring grading underestimates capitulation by 18-24 percentage points. Code, prompts, transcripts, and analysis are released.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2026

modelDNA: Calibrated Lineage Verification and Merge Decomposition from Sampled Weight Fingerprints

The lineage graph of open-weight language models is self-reported: Hugging Face's base_model metadata field is optional and unverified, and over 60% of Hub models document no parentage at all. Methods for detecting lineage from weights exist in the research literature, but each ships as paper code tied to one signal and one experiment; when a provenance dispute breaks, the analysis is redone by hand. This report describes modelDNA, a tool that fingerprints a model from roughly 100-300 MB of ranged HTTP reads (instead of a full 15 GB download for a 7B model), compares the fingerprint against a reference database of foundation models across four published signal families, and returns one of eight verdict classes with a calibrated probability, preferring honest abstention to confident error. On a benchmark of 15 real Hub models with org-documented parentage, judged against 8 candidate bases (13 positives, 107 hard negatives), the system achieves AUROC 1.0, zero false positives at its reporting threshold, and 13/13 correct top-1 parent attribution. The report's second contribution is merge decomposition. Every mainstream weight-merging method is (near-)linear per tensor, and fingerprint sample positions are deterministic functions of tensor identity, so a merged model's fingerprint is the same linear combination of its parents' fingerprints. Mixture weights can therefore be recovered from fingerprints alone by sum-to-one constrained least squares. Against merges with published mergekit configurations as ground truth, the method recovers a slerp merge's layer-interpolation curves at r = 0.999 and a dare_ties merge's mixture weights to within 0.011 of the published values, without downloading any weights beyond the fingerprints. All fingerprints, benchmarks, and the inferred lineage graph of 55 models are public and reproducible offline.

cs.LG↗