arXiv subjects

T. Roy Choudhury

Publications and source records attributed to T. Roy Choudhury.

At least 55 records · Page 3Linked to original sources

arXiv2009

The optimal redshift for detecting ionized bubbles in HI 21-cm maps

The detection of individual ionized bubbles in HI 21-cm maps is one of the most promising, direct probes of the epoch of reionization(EoR). Atleast 1000 hrs of observation would be required for such a detection with either the currently functioning GMRT or the upcoming MWA. Considering the large investment of telescope time it is essential to identify the``optimal redshift'' where the prospects of a detection are most favourable. We find that the optimal redshift is determined by a combination of instrument dependent factors and the evolution of the neutral fraction x_HI. We find that the redshift range 8.1 +/- 1.1 and 9.8 +/- 1 are optimum for detecting ionized bubbles with the GMRT and MWA respectively. The prospects of a detection, we find, are more favourable in a scenario with late reionization with x_HI \approx 0.5 at z \approx 7.5 as compared to an early reionization model where x_HI \approx 0.5 at z \approx 10. In the late reionization scenario, for both instruments a 3 σdetection is possible for bubbles of comoving radius R_b>= 30 Mpc with 1000 hrs of observation. Future observations will either lead to the detection of ionized bubbles, or in the event of non-detection, lead to constraints on the product x_HI R_b^γfor the observational volume, where γ=1.5 and 2 for GMRT and MWA respectively.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2009

Analytical Models of the Intergalactic Medium and Reionization

Reionization is a process whereby hydrogen (and helium) in the Universe is ionized by the radiation from first luminous sources. Theoretically, the importance of the reionization lies in its close coupling with the formation of first cosmic structures and hence there is considerable effort in modelling the process. We give a pedagogic overview of different analytical approaches used for modelling reionization. We also discuss different observations related to reionization and show how to use them for constraining the reionization history.

astro-ph.CO↗

arXiv2008

Inside-out or Outside-in: The topology of reionization in the photon-starved regime suggested by Lyman-alpha forest data

We use a set of semi-numerical simulations based on Zel'dovich approximation, friends-of-friends algorithm and excursion set formalism to generate reionization maps of high dynamic range with a range of assumptions regarding the distribution and luminosity of ionizing sources and the spatial distribution of sinks for the ionizing radiation. We find that ignoring the inhomogeneous spatial distribution of regions of high gas density where recombinations are important -- as is often done in studies of this kind -- can lead to misleading conclusions regarding the topology of reionization, especially if reionization occurs in the photon-starved regime suggested by Lya forest data. The inhomogeneous spatial distribution of recombinations significantly reduces the mean free path of ionizing photons and the typical size of coherently ionized regions. Reionization proceeds then much more as an outside-in process. Low-density regions far from ionizing sources become ionized before regions of high gas density not hosting sources of ionizing radiation. The spatial distribution of sinks of ionization radiation also significantly affects shape and amplitude the power spectrum of fluctuations of 21cm emission. The slope of the 21cm power spectrum as measured by upcoming 21cm experiments should be able to distinguish to what extent the topology of reionization proceeds outside-in or inside-out while the evolution of the amplitude of the power spectrum with increasing ionized mass fraction should be sensitive to the spatial distribution and the luminosity of ionizing sources.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2008

Simulating the impact of HI fluctuations on matched filter search for ionized bubbles in redshifted 21 cm maps

Extending the formalism of Datta, Bharadwaj & Choudhury (2007) for detecting ionized bubbles in redshifted 21 cm maps using a matched-filtering technique, we use different simulations to analyze the impact of HI fluctuations outside the bubble on the detectability of the bubble. In the first three kinds of simulations there is a spherical bubble of comoving radius R_b, the one that we are trying to detect, located at the center, and the neutral hydrogen (HI) outside the bubble traces the underlying dark matter distribution. We consider three different possible scenarios of reionization, i.e., (i) there is a single bubble (SB) in the field of view (FoV) and the hydrogen neutral fraction is constant outside this bubble (ii) patchy reionization with many small ionized bubbles in the FoV (PR1) and (iii) many spherical ionized bubbles of the same radius $R_b$ (PR2). The fourth kind of simulation uses more realistic maps based on semi-numeric modelling (SM) of ionized regions. We find that for both the SB and PR1 scenarios the fluctuating IGM restricts bubble detection to size R_b<= 6 Mpc and R_b<= 12 Mpc for the GMRT and the MWA respectively, however large be the integration time. These results are well explained by analytical predictions. Large uncertainty due to the HI fluctuations restricts bubble detection in the PR2 scenario for neutral fraction x_HI<0.6. The matched-filter technique works well even when the targeted ionized bubble is non-spherical due to surrounding bubbles and inhomogeneous recombination (SM). We find that determining the size and positions of the bubbles is not limited by the HI fluctuations in the SB and PR1 scenario but limited by the instrument's angular resolution instead, and this can be done more precisely for larger bubble (abridged).

astro-ph↗

arXiv2008

Testing Reionization with Gamma Ray Burst Absorption Spectra

We propose to study cosmic reionization using absorption line spectra of high-redshift Gamma Ray Burst (GRB) afterglows. We show that the statistics of the dark portions (gaps) in GRB absorption spectra represent exquisite tools to discriminate among different reionization models. We then compute the probability to find the largest gap in a given width range [Wmax, Wmax + dW] at a flux threshold Fth for burst afterglows at redshifts 6.3 < z < 6.7. We show that different reionization scenarios populate the (Wmax, Fth) plane in a very different way, allowing to distinguish among different reionization histories. We provide here useful plots that allow a very simple and direct comparison between observations and model results. Finally, we apply our methods to GRB 050904 detected at z = 6.29. We show that the observation of this burst strongly favors reionization models which predict a highly ionized intergalactic medium at z~6, with an estimated mean neutral hydrogen fraction xHI = 6.4 \pm 0.3 \times 10^-5 along the line of sight towards GRB 050904.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

CMB polarization constraints on radiative feedback

We compute the imprints left on the CMB by two cosmic reionization models consistent with current observations but characterized by alternative radiative feedback prescriptions (suppression and filtering) resulting in a different suppression of star formation in low-mass halos. The models imply different ionization and thermal histories and 21 cm background signals. The derived Comptonization, u, and free-free distortion, y_B, parameters are below current observational limits for both models. However, the value of u = 1.69 * 10^-7 (9.65 * 10^-8) for the suppression (filtering) model is in the detectability range of the next generation of CMB spectrum experiments. Through the dedicated Boltzmann code CMBFAST, modified to include the above ionization histories, we compute the CMB angular power spectrum (APS) of the TT, TE, and EE modes. For the EE mode the differences between these models are significantly larger than the cosmic and sampling variance over the multipole range l = 5-15, leaving a good chance of discriminating between these feedback mechanisms with forthcoming/future CMB polarization experiments. The main limitations come from foreground contamination: it should be subtracted at per cent level in terms of APS, a result potentially achievable by novel component separation techniques and mapping of Galactic foreground.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

On the minimum mass of reionization sources

By means of carefully calibrated semi-analytical reionization models, we estimate the minimum mass of star-forming haloes required to match the current data. Models which do not include haloes of total mass M < 10^9 M_sun fail at reproducing the Gunn-Peterson and electron scattering optical depths simultaneously, as they contribute too few (many) photons at high (low, z \approx 6) redshift. Marginally acceptable solutions require haloes with M \approx 5 \times 10^7 M_sun at z \approx 10, corresponding to virial temperatures (\sim 10^4K) for which cooling can be ensured by atomic transitions. However, a much better match to the data is obtained if minihaloes (M \sim 10^6 M_sun) are included in the analysis. We have critically examined the assumptions made in our model and conclude that reionization in the large-galaxies-only scenario can remain viable only if metal-free stars and/or some other exotic sources at z > 6 are included.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

Detectable Signatures of Cosmic Radiative Feedback

We use a semi-analytical model to study the impact of reionization, and the associated radiative feedback, on galaxy formation. Two feedback models have been considered: (i) a standard prescription, according to which star formation is totally suppressed in galaxies with circular velocity below a critical threshold (model CF06) and (ii) a characterization based on the filtering scale (model G00), allowing for a gradual reduction of the gas available for star formation in low-mass galaxies. In model CF06 reionization starts at z ~ 15-20, is 85% complete by z ~ 10; at the same z, the ionized fraction is 16% in model G00. The models match SDSS constraints on the evolution of the neutral hydrogen fraction at z < 7, but predict different Thomson optical depths, tau_e = 0.1017 (CF06), and 0.0631 (G00); such values are within 1 sigma of the WMAP 3-yr determination. Both models are in remarkable good agreement with additional existing data (evolution of Lyman-limit systems, cosmic star formation history, high-z galaxy counts, IGM thermal history), which therefore cannot be used to discriminate among different feedback models. Deviations among radiative feedback prescriptions emerge when considering the expected HI 21 cm background signal, where a ~ 15 mK absorption feature in the range 75-100 MHz is present in model G00 and a global shift of the emission feature preceding reionization towards larger frequencies occurs in the same model. Single dish observations with existing or forthcoming low-frequency radio telescopes can achieve mK sensitivity, allowing the identification of these features provided that foregrounds can be accurately subtracted.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

Detecting ionized bubbles in redshifted 21 cm maps

The reionization of the Universe, it is believed, occurred by the growth of ionized regions (bubbles) in the neutral intergalactic medium (IGM). We study the possibility of detecting these bubbles in radio-interferometric observations of redshifted neutral hydrogen (HI) 21 cm radiation. The signal 1 mJy will be buried in noise and foregrounds, the latter being at least a few orders of magnitude stronger than the signal. We develop a visibility based formalism that uses a filter to optimally combine the entire signal from a bubble while minimizing the noise and foreground contributions. This formalism makes definite predictions on the ability to detect an ionized bubble or conclusively rule out its presence in a radio- interferometric observation. We make predictions for the currently functioning GMRT and a forthcoming instrument, the MWA at a frequency of 150 MHz (corresponding to a redshift of 8.5). For both instruments, we show that a 3 sigma detection will be possible for a bubble of comoving radius R_b > 40 Mpc (assuming it to be spherical) in 100 hrs of observation and R_b 22 Mpc in 1000 hrs of observation, provided the bubble is at the center of the field of view. In both these cases the filter effectively removes the expected foreground contribution so that it is below the signal, and the system noise is the deciding criteria. We find that there is a fundamental limitation on the smallest bubble that can be detected arising from the statistical fluctuations in the HI distribution. Assuming that the HI traces the dark matter we find that it will not be possible to detect bubbles with R_b < 8 Mpc using the GMRT and R_b < 16 Mpc using the MWA, however large be the integration time.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

Searching for the reionization sources

Using a reionization model simultaneously accounting for a number of experimental data sets, we investigate the nature and properties of reionization sources. Such model predicts that hydrogen reionization starts at z \approx 15, is initially driven by metal-free (PopIII) stars, and is 90% complete by z \approx 8. We find that a fraction f_γ>80% of the ionizing power at z > 7 comes from haloes of mass M<10^9 M_sun predominantly harbouring PopIII stars; a turnover to a PopII-dominated phase occurs shortly after, with this population, residing in M>10^9 M_sun haloes, yielding f_γ\approx 60% at z=6. Using Lyman-break broadband dropout techniques, J-band detection of sources contributing to 50% (90%) of the ionizing power at z \sim 7.5 requires to reach a magnitude J_{110,AB} = 31.2 (31.7), where about 15 (30) (PopIII) sources/arcmin^2 are predicted. We conclude that z>7 sources tentatively identified in broadband surveys are relatively massive (M \approx 10^9 M_sun) and rare objects which are only marginally (\approx 1%) adding to the reionization photon budget.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2007

The multi-frequency angular power spectrum of the epoch of reionization 21 cm signal

Observations of redshifted 21cm radiation from HI at high redshifts is an important future probe of reionization. We consider the Multi-frequency Angular Power Spectrum (MAPS) to quantify the statistics of the HI signal as a joint function of the angular multipole l and frequency separation Δν. The signal at two different frequencies is expected to get decorrelated as Δνis increased, and quantifying this decorrelation is particularly important in deciding the frequency resolution for future HI observations. This is also expected to play a very crucial role in extracting the signal from foregrounds as the signal is expected to decorrelate much faster than the foregrounds (which are largely continuum sources) with increasing Δν. In this paper we develop formulae relating the MAPS to different components of the three dimensional HI power spectrum taking into account HI peculiar velocities. We show that the flat-sky approximation provides a very good representation over the angular scales of interest, and a final expression which is very simple to calculate and interpret. We present results considering two models for the HI distribution, namely, (i) DM: where the HI traces the dark matter and (ii) PR: where the effects of patchy reionization are incorporated through two parameters. We find that while the DM signal is largely featureless, the PR signal peaks at the angular scales of the individual bubbles, and the signal is considerably enhanced for large bubble size. For most cases of interest at l \sim 100 the signal is uncorrelated beyond Δν\sim 1 MHz or even less, whereas it occurs around \sim 0.1 MHz at l \sim 10^3. The Δνdependence also carries an imprint of the bubble size and the bias, and is expected to be an important probe of the reionization scenario (abridged).

astro-ph↗

arXiv2006

Updating reionization scenarios after recent data

The recent release of data on (i) high redshift source counts from NICMOS HUDF, and (ii) electron scattering optical depth from 3-year WMAP, require a re-examination of reionization scenarios. Using an improved self-consistent model, based on Choudhury & Ferrara (2005), we determine the range of reionization histories which can match a wide variety of data sets simultaneously. From this improved analysis we find that hydrogen reionization starts around z = 15, driven by the metal-free stars (with normal Salpeter-like IMF), and is 90% complete by z = 10. The photoionizing power of PopIII stars fades for z < 10 because of the concomitant action of radiative and chemical feedbacks, which causes the reionization process to stretch considerably and to end only by z = 6. The combination of different data sets still favours a non-zero contribution from metal-free stars, forming with efficiencies > 2%.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2006

Constraining the reionization history with QSO absorption spectra

We use a semi-analytical approach to simulate absorption spectra of QSOs at high redshifts with the aim of constraining the cosmic reionization history. We consider two physically motivated and detailed reionization histories: (i) an Early Reionization Model (ERM) in which the intergalactic medium is reionized by PopIII stars at $z\approx 14$, and (ii) a more standard Late Reionization Model (LRM) in which overlapping, induced by QSOs and normal galaxies, occurs at $z\approx 6$. From the analysis of current Ly$α$ forest data at $z < 6$, we conclude that it is impossible to disentangle the two scenarios, which fit equally well the observed Gunn-Peterson optical depth, flux probability distribution function and dark gap width distribution. At $z>6$, however, clear differences start to emerge which are best quantified by the dark gap and peak width distributions. We find that 35 (zero) per cent of the lines of sight within $5.7< z <6.3$ show dark gaps widths $>50$ Angstrom in the rest frame of the QSO if reionization is not (is) complete at $z \gtrsim 6$. Similarly, the ERM predicts peaks of width $\sim 1$ Angstrom in 40 per cent of the lines of sight in the redshift range $6.0-6.6$; in the same range, LRM predicts no peaks of width $>0.8$ Angstrom. We conclude that the dark gap and peak width statistics represent superb probes of cosmic reionization if about ten QSOs can be found at $z > 6$. We finally discuss strengths and limitations of our method.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2006

Physics of Cosmic Reionization

The study of cosmic reionization has acquired increasing significance over the last few years because of various reasons. On the observational front, we now have good quality data of different types at high redshifts (quasar absorption spectra, radiation backgrounds at different frequencies, cosmic microwave background polarization, Ly-alpha emitters and so on). Theoretically, the importance of the reionization lies in its close coupling with the formation of first cosmic structures, and there have been numerous progresses in modelling the process. In this article, we review the current status of our understanding of the physical processes governing the cosmic reionization based on available observational data.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2005

A very extended reionization epoch ?

The recent observations of cross temperature-polarization power spectra of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) made by the WMAP satellite are in better agreement with a high value of the Thomson scattering optical depth τ\approx 0.17. This value is close to τ= 0.3, which is taken as the upper limit in the parameter extraction analysis made by the WMAP team. However, models with τ\sim 0.3 provide a good fit to current CMB data and are not significantly excluded when combined with Large Scale Structure data. By making use of a self-consistent reionization model, we verify the astrophysical feasibility of models with τ\sim 0.3. It turns out that current data on various observations related to the thermal and ionization history of the intergalactic medium are not able to rule out τ\sim 0.3. The possibility of a very extended reionization epoch can significantly undermine the WMAP constraints on crucial cosmological parameters such as the Hubble constant, the spectral index of primordial fluctuations and the amplitude of dark matter clustering.

astro-ph↗

arXiv2005

Experimental Constraints on Self-consistent Reionization Models

A self-consistent formalism to jointly study cosmic reionization and thermal history of the IGM is presented. The model implements most of the relevant physics governing these processes, such as the inhomogeneous IGM density distribution, three different sources of ionizing photons (PopIII stars, PopII stars and QSOs), and radiative feedback. By constraining the free parameters with available data on redshift evolution of Lyman-limit systems, Gunn-Peterson and electron scattering optical depths, Near InfraRed Background (NIRB), and cosmic star formation history, we select a fiducial model, whose main predictions are: (i) H was completely reionized at z \approx 15, while HeII must have been reionized by z \approx 12. At z \approx 7, HeIII suffered an almost complete recombination as a result of the extinction of PopIII stars, as required by the interpretation of the NIRB. (ii) A QSO-induced complete HeII reionization occurs at z=3.5; a similar double H reionization does not take place due to the large number of photons above 1 Ryd from PopII stars and QSOs, even after PopIII stars have disappeared. (iii) Following reionization, the temperature of the IGM corresponding to the mean gas density is boosted to 15000 K. Observations of T_0 are consistent with the fact that He is singly ionized at z > 3.5, while they are consistent with He being doubly ionized at z < 3.5. This might be interpreted as a signature of (second) HeII reionization. (iv) Only 0.3% of the stars produced by z=2 need to be PopIII stars in order to achieve the hydrogen reionization. Such model not only relieves the tension between the Gunn-Peterson optical depth and WMAP observations, but also accounts self-consistently for all known observational constraints (abridged).

astro-ph↗

arXiv2004

Cosmological parameters from supernova observations: A critical comparison of three data sets

We extend our previous analysis of cosmological supernova data (Padmanabhan & Choudhury 2003) to include three recent compilation of data sets. Our analysis ignores systematic effects in the data and concentrates on some key theoretical issues. The first data set consists of 194 points while the second discards some of the points from the first one because of large uncertainties and thus consists of 142 points. The third data set is obtained from the second by adding the latest 14 points observed through HST. A careful comparison of these different data sets help us to draw the following conclusions: (i) All the data sets strongly rule out non-accelerating models. Interestingly, the first and the second sets favour a closed universe; i.e., the probability P(Omega_{tot} > 1) \gtrsim 0.97. Hence these sets are in mild disagreement with the ``concordance'' flat model. However, this disagreement is reduced [P(Omega_{tot} > 1) \approx 0.9] for the third data set, which includes the points observed by HST around 1 < z < 1.6. (ii) When the first data set is divided into two separate subsets consisting of low (z < 0.34) and high (z > 0.34) redshift supernova, it turns out that these two subsets, individually, admit non-accelerating models. However, these models seem to be ruled out using only the low redshift data for the other two data sets, which have less uncertainties. (iii) It is quite difficult to measure the evolution of the dark energy equation of state w_X though its present value can be constrained quite well. The best-fit value seems to mildly favour a dark energy component with current equation of state w_X < -1, thus opening the possibility of existence of more exotic forms of matter. However, the data is still consistent with the the standard cosmological constant at 99% confidence level (abridged).

astro-ph↗

arXiv2004

Concept of temperature in multi-horizon spacetimes: Analysis of Schwarzschild-De Sitter metric

In case of spacetimes with single horizon, there exist several well-established procedures for relating the surface gravity of the horizon to a thermodynamic temperature. Such procedures, however, cannot be extended in a straightforward manner when a spacetime has multiple horizons. In particular, it is not clear whether there exists a notion of global temperature characterizing the multi-horizon spacetimes. We examine the conditions under which a global temperature can exist for a spacetime with two horizons using the example of Schwarzschild-De Sitter (SDS) spacetime. We systematically extend different procedures (like the expectation value of stress tensor, response of particle detectors, periodicity in the Euclidean time etc.) for identifying a temperature in the case of spacetimes with single horizon to the SDS spacetime. This analysis is facilitated by using a global coordinate chart which covers the entire SDS manifold. We find that all the procedures lead to a consistent picture characterized by the following features: (a) In general, SDS spacetime behaves like a non-equilibrium system characterized by two temperatures. (b) It is not possible to associate a global temperature with SDS spacetime except when the ratio of the two surface gravities is rational (c) Even when the ratio of the two surface gravities is rational, the thermal nature depends on the coordinate chart used. There exists a global coordinate chart in which there is global equilibrium temperature while there exist other charts in which SDS behaves as though it has two different temperatures. The coordinate dependence of the thermal nature is reminiscent of the flat spacetime in Minkowski and Rindler coordinate charts. The implications are discussed.

gr-qc↗