arXiv subjects

Tom Kocmi

Publications and source records attributed to Tom Kocmi.

36 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

arXiv2023

Large Language Models Are State-of-the-Art Evaluators of Translation Quality

We describe GEMBA, a GPT-based metric for assessment of translation quality, which works both with a reference translation and without. In our evaluation, we focus on zero-shot prompting, comparing four prompt variants in two modes, based on the availability of the reference. We investigate nine versions of GPT models, including ChatGPT and GPT-4. We show that our method for translation quality assessment only works with GPT~3.5 and larger models. Comparing to results from WMT22's Metrics shared task, our method achieves state-of-the-art accuracy in both modes when compared to MQM-based human labels. Our results are valid on the system level for all three WMT22 Metrics shared task language pairs, namely English into German, English into Russian, and Chinese into English. This provides a first glimpse into the usefulness of pre-trained, generative large language models for quality assessment of translations. We publicly release all our code and prompt templates used for the experiments described in this work, as well as all corresponding scoring results, to allow for external validation and reproducibility.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2023

Poor Man's Quality Estimation: Predicting Reference-Based MT Metrics Without the Reference

Machine translation quality estimation (QE) predicts human judgements of a translation hypothesis without seeing the reference. State-of-the-art QE systems based on pretrained language models have been achieving remarkable correlations with human judgements yet they are computationally heavy and require human annotations, which are slow and expensive to create. To address these limitations, we define the problem of metric estimation (ME) where one predicts the automated metric scores also without the reference. We show that even without access to the reference, our model can estimate automated metrics ($ρ$=60% for BLEU, $ρ$=51% for other metrics) at the sentence-level. Because automated metrics correlate with human judgements, we can leverage the ME task for pre-training a QE model. For the QE task, we find that pre-training on TER is better ($ρ$=23%) than training for scratch ($ρ$=20%).

cs.CL↗

arXiv2022

Searching for a higher power in the human evaluation of MT

In MT evaluation, pairwise comparisons are conducted to identify the better system. In conducting the comparison, the experimenter must allocate a budget to collect Direct Assessment (DA) judgments. We provide a cost effective way to spend the budget, but show that typical budget sizes often do not allow for solid comparison. Taking the perspective that the basis of solid comparison is in achieving statistical significance, we study the power (rate of achieving significance) on a large collection of pairwise DA comparisons. Due to the nature of statistical estimation, power is low for differentiating less than 1-2 DA points, and to achieve a notable increase in power requires at least 2-3x more samples. Applying variance reduction alone will not yield these gains, so we must face the reality of undetectable differences and spending increases. In this context, we propose interim testing, an "early stopping" collection procedure that yields more power per judgment collected, which adaptively focuses the budget on pairs that are borderline significant. Interim testing can achieve up to a 27% efficiency gain when spending 3x the current budget, or 18% savings at the current evaluation power.

stat.AP↗

arXiv2022

The Reality of Multi-Lingual Machine Translation

Our book "The Reality of Multi-Lingual Machine Translation" discusses the benefits and perils of using more than two languages in machine translation systems. While focused on the particular task of sequence-to-sequence processing and multi-task learning, the book targets somewhat beyond the area of natural language processing. Machine translation is for us a prime example of deep learning applications where human skills and learning capabilities are taken as a benchmark that many try to match and surpass. We document that some of the gains observed in multi-lingual translation may result from simpler effects than the assumed cross-lingual transfer of knowledge. In the first, rather general part, the book will lead you through the motivation for multi-linguality, the versatility of deep neural networks especially in sequence-to-sequence tasks to complications of this learning. We conclude the general part with warnings against too optimistic and unjustified explanations of the gains that neural networks demonstrate. In the second part, we fully delve into multi-lingual models, with a particularly careful examination of transfer learning as one of the more straightforward approaches utilizing additional languages. The recent multi-lingual techniques, including massive models, are surveyed and practical aspects of deploying systems for many languages are discussed. The conclusion highlights the open problem of machine understanding and reminds of two ethical aspects of building large-scale models: the inclusivity of research and its ecological trace.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2021

To Ship or Not to Ship: An Extensive Evaluation of Automatic Metrics for Machine Translation

Automatic metrics are commonly used as the exclusive tool for declaring the superiority of one machine translation system's quality over another. The community choice of automatic metric guides research directions and industrial developments by deciding which models are deemed better. Evaluating metrics correlations with sets of human judgements has been limited by the size of these sets. In this paper, we corroborate how reliable metrics are in contrast to human judgements on -- to the best of our knowledge -- the largest collection of judgements reported in the literature. Arguably, pairwise rankings of two systems are the most common evaluation tasks in research or deployment scenarios. Taking human judgement as a gold standard, we investigate which metrics have the highest accuracy in predicting translation quality rankings for such system pairs. Furthermore, we evaluate the performance of various metrics across different language pairs and domains. Lastly, we show that the sole use of BLEU impeded the development of improved models leading to bad deployment decisions. We release the collection of 2.3M sentence-level human judgements for 4380 systems for further analysis and replication of our work.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2021

On User Interfaces for Large-Scale Document-Level Human Evaluation of Machine Translation Outputs

Recent studies emphasize the need of document context in human evaluation of machine translations, but little research has been done on the impact of user interfaces on annotator productivity and the reliability of assessments. In this work, we compare human assessment data from the last two WMT evaluation campaigns collected via two different methods for document-level evaluation. Our analysis shows that a document-centric approach to evaluation where the annotator is presented with the entire document context on a screen leads to higher quality segment and document level assessments. It improves the correlation between segment and document scores and increases inter-annotator agreement for document scores but is considerably more time consuming for annotators.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2021

THEaiTRE 1.0: Interactive generation of theatre play scripts

We present the first version of a system for interactive generation of theatre play scripts. The system is based on a vanilla GPT-2 model with several adjustments, targeting specific issues we encountered in practice. We also list other issues we encountered but plan to only solve in a future version of the system. The presented system was used to generate a theatre play script planned for premiere in February 2021.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

CUNI Systems for the Unsupervised and Very Low Resource Translation Task in WMT20

This paper presents a description of CUNI systems submitted to the WMT20 task on unsupervised and very low-resource supervised machine translation between German and Upper Sorbian. We experimented with training on synthetic data and pre-training on a related language pair. In the fully unsupervised scenario, we achieved 25.5 and 23.7 BLEU translating from and into Upper Sorbian, respectively. Our low-resource systems relied on transfer learning from German-Czech parallel data and achieved 57.4 BLEU and 56.1 BLEU, which is an improvement of 10 BLEU points over the baseline trained only on the available small German-Upper Sorbian parallel corpus.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

Gender Coreference and Bias Evaluation at WMT 2020

Gender bias in machine translation can manifest when choosing gender inflections based on spurious gender correlations. For example, always translating doctors as men and nurses as women. This can be particularly harmful as models become more popular and deployed within commercial systems. Our work presents the largest evidence for the phenomenon in more than 19 systems submitted to the WMT over four diverse target languages: Czech, German, Polish, and Russian. To achieve this, we use WinoMT, a recent automatic test suite which examines gender coreference and bias when translating from English to languages with grammatical gender. We extend WinoMT to handle two new languages tested in WMT: Polish and Czech. We find that all systems consistently use spurious correlations in the data rather than meaningful contextual information.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

Announcing CzEng 2.0 Parallel Corpus with over 2 Gigawords

We present a new release of the Czech-English parallel corpus CzEng 2.0 consisting of over 2 billion words (2 "gigawords") in each language. The corpus contains document-level information and is filtered with several techniques to lower the amount of noise. In addition to the data in the previous version of CzEng, it contains new authentic and also high-quality synthetic parallel data. CzEng is freely available for research and educational purposes.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

THEaiTRE: Artificial Intelligence to Write a Theatre Play

We present THEaiTRE, a starting project aimed at automatic generation of theatre play scripts. This paper reviews related work and drafts an approach we intend to follow. We plan to adopt generative neural language models and hierarchical generation approaches, supported by summarization and machine translation methods, and complemented with a human-in-the-loop approach.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

Efficiently Reusing Old Models Across Languages via Transfer Learning

Recent progress in neural machine translation is directed towards larger neural networks trained on an increasing amount of hardware resources. As a result, NMT models are costly to train, both financially, due to the electricity and hardware cost, and environmentally, due to the carbon footprint. It is especially true in transfer learning for its additional cost of training the "parent" model before transferring knowledge and training the desired "child" model. In this paper, we propose a simple method of re-using an already trained model for different language pairs where there is no need for modifications in model architecture. Our approach does not need a separate parent model for each investigated language pair, as it is typical in NMT transfer learning. To show the applicability of our method, we recycle a Transformer model trained by different researchers and use it to seed models for different language pairs. We achieve better translation quality and shorter convergence times than when training from random initialization.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2020

Exploring Benefits of Transfer Learning in Neural Machine Translation

Neural machine translation is known to require large numbers of parallel training sentences, which generally prevent it from excelling on low-resource language pairs. This thesis explores the use of cross-lingual transfer learning on neural networks as a way of solving the problem with the lack of resources. We propose several transfer learning approaches to reuse a model pretrained on a high-resource language pair. We pay particular attention to the simplicity of the techniques. We study two scenarios: (a) when we reuse the high-resource model without any prior modifications to its training process and (b) when we can prepare the first-stage high-resource model for transfer learning in advance. For the former scenario, we present a proof-of-concept method by reusing a model trained by other researchers. In the latter scenario, we present a method which reaches even larger improvements in translation performance. Apart from proposed techniques, we focus on an in-depth analysis of transfer learning techniques and try to shed some light on transfer learning improvements. We show how our techniques address specific problems of low-resource languages and are suitable even in high-resource transfer learning. We evaluate the potential drawbacks and behavior by studying transfer learning in various situations, for example, under artificially damaged training corpora, or with fixed various model parts.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2018

Trivial Transfer Learning for Low-Resource Neural Machine Translation

Transfer learning has been proven as an effective technique for neural machine translation under low-resource conditions. Existing methods require a common target language, language relatedness, or specific training tricks and regimes. We present a simple transfer learning method, where we first train a "parent" model for a high-resource language pair and then continue the training on a lowresource pair only by replacing the training corpus. This "child" model performs significantly better than the baseline trained for lowresource pair only. We are the first to show this for targeting different languages, and we observe the improvements even for unrelated languages with different alphabets.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2018

SubGram: Extending Skip-gram Word Representation with Substrings

Skip-gram (word2vec) is a recent method for creating vector representations of words ("distributed word representations") using a neural network. The representation gained popularity in various areas of natural language processing, because it seems to capture syntactic and semantic information about words without any explicit supervision in this respect. We propose SubGram, a refinement of the Skip-gram model to consider also the word structure during the training process, achieving large gains on the Skip-gram original test set.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2017

An Exploration of Word Embedding Initialization in Deep-Learning Tasks

Word embeddings are the interface between the world of discrete units of text processing and the continuous, differentiable world of neural networks. In this work, we examine various random and pretrained initialization methods for embeddings used in deep networks and their effect on the performance on four NLP tasks with both recurrent and convolutional architectures. We confirm that pretrained embeddings are a little better than random initialization, especially considering the speed of learning. On the other hand, we do not see any significant difference between various methods of random initialization, as long as the variance is kept reasonably low. High-variance initialization prevents the network to use the space of embeddings and forces it to use other free parameters to accomplish the task. We support this hypothesis by observing the performance in learning lexical relations and by the fact that the network can learn to perform reasonably in its task even with fixed random embeddings.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2017

LanideNN: Multilingual Language Identification on Character Window

In language identification, a common first step in natural language processing, we want to automatically determine the language of some input text. Monolingual language identification assumes that the given document is written in one language. In multilingual language identification, the document is usually in two or three languages and we just want their names. We aim one step further and propose a method for textual language identification where languages can change arbitrarily and the goal is to identify the spans of each of the languages. Our method is based on Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Networks and it performs well in monolingual and multilingual language identification tasks on six datasets covering 131 languages. The method keeps the accuracy also for short documents and across domains, so it is ideal for off-the-shelf use without preparation of training data.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2017

Curriculum Learning and Minibatch Bucketing in Neural Machine Translation

We examine the effects of particular orderings of sentence pairs on the on-line training of neural machine translation (NMT). We focus on two types of such orderings: (1) ensuring that each minibatch contains sentences similar in some aspect and (2) gradual inclusion of some sentence types as the training progresses (so called "curriculum learning"). In our English-to-Czech experiments, the internal homogeneity of minibatches has no effect on the training but some of our "curricula" achieve a small improvement over the baseline.

cs.CL↗