Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Ugo Dal Lago

Publications and source records attributed to Ugo Dal Lago.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Probabilistic Simple Types for Almost-Sure Termination (Extended Version)

We present a type system for almost-sure termination (AST) in higher-order probabilistic computation. Our vehicle is the recent Functional Machine Calculus (FMC), which combines the lambda-calculus with effectful imperative computation. Importantly for our purpose, it models branching and looping computation with sum types and a typed iterator construct. Our key observation is that by replacing sum types with probability distributions, types ensure that iteration has a non-zero chance of exiting, which then gives AST in a simple and natural way. Concretely, our type system assigns explicit probability distributions to termination outcomes, allowing probabilistic behaviour to be tracked compositionally at the type level. Types then soundly guarantee almost-sure termination, even in the presence of higher-order functions. The fragment of ground terms, which consists purely of the branching and iteration constructs with probabilistic sampling, is equivalent to finite Markov chains and is positively AST (expected evaluation time is finite). The full calculus is more expressive, which we demonstrate through an example term with infinite expected evaluation time.

cs.LO↗

Staying Productive Under the Palm Trees: On Graded Coeffect Typing in the Tropical Semiring

We give a temporal reading of graded coeffects: tropical grades carry guards on infinite computation. To illustrate it, we first define $G_T$, a polymorphic calculus with guarded recursive types that guarantees productive infinite computation, in the form of hereditary head normalisation. The calculus supports stream computing via the Scott encoding, and embeds Nakano's later modality. We then introduce $I_T$, a graded intersection type system with guarded infinitary types for the pure λ-calculus, whose typability allows for an exact characterisation of hereditary head normalisation. We prove that the characterising typability predicate is $Π_0^2$, matching the recursion-theoretic complexity of the characterised property.

cs.LO↗

Graded Intersection Types

We introduce graded intersection types, in which arrow domains are multisets of types with coefficients in a semiring. Boolean and natural number grades recover idempotent and non-idempotent intersection types. We give algebraic conditions on the semiring for subject reduction and expansion in finite systems and in locally finite systems with guarded infinite types. We construct a lifting to multisets of grades corresponding, in this general setting, to lifting the idempotent system to the non-idempotent one. We recall the main existing operational characterisations from the literature, and show some general extensions.

cs.LO↗

(Implicitly) Characterizing Probabilistic Polynomial Time as Used in Cryptography

In this paper, we show how a recently introduced $λ$-calculus for randomized computation, called $λ\mathbf{BLL}$, can accurately capture the notions of first- and second-order polytime computations used in cryptographic definitions and proofs. These results, spelled out in the style of so-called \emph{implicit computational complexity}, imply that $λ\mathbf{BLL}$ is sufficiently powerful to express experiments and adversaries as used in cryptography, and that reductions, when formulated within the calculus, are guaranteed to be complexity-preserving. Remarkably, while polynomial-time soundness holds for the full calculus, polynomial-time completeness already follows in presence of a minimal finite set of basic functions.

cs.PL↗

Coinductive reasoning for parametrized functors and monads

Lax extensions (also called relators or relation liftings) are a categorical notion to reason about functors acting on functions and relations in a compatible way. They play a central role to develop sound proof principles for behavioral equivalence of state-based systems and are also important for establishing contextual equivalence for effectful programs. In this paper, we develop the theory of lax extensions for parametrized functors and monads and consider notions of behavioral preorders, equivalence relations or metrics which can now be modulated by additional parameters. From an operational viewpoint, we replace standard contextual equivalence where we quantify over all possible contexts by a refined notion of equivalence where the user can regulate the allowed contexts via chosen parameters.

cs.LO↗

When Types Intersect and Effects Get Handled

We introduce a novel intersection type system for a $λ$-calculus with algebraic effects and handlers. The system, inherently behavioral in nature, enjoys the classical properties of intersection type systems, in particular subject reduction and expansion. It thus characterizes the set of terms whose evaluation process terminates and, at the same time, allows reducing the reachability problem to type inference. This new system, the first with these features for a calculus with handlers, induces a system of simple types which, although not guaranteeing termination, is type sound and admits a decidable HOMC problem, unlike similar type systems like Dal Lago and Ghyselen's HEPCF.

cs.LO↗

On the Termination Problem for Probabilistic Higher-Order Recursive Programs

In the last two decades, there has been much progress on model checking of both probabilistic systems and higher-order programs. In spite of the emergence of higher-order probabilistic programming languages, not much has been done to combine those two approaches. In this paper, we initiate a study on the probabilistic higher-order model checking problem, by giving some first theoretical and experimental results. As a first step towards our goal, we introduce PHORS, a probabilistic extension of higher-order recursion schemes (HORS), as a model of probabilistic higher-order programs. The model of PHORS may alternatively be viewed as a higher-order extension of recursive Markov chains. We then investigate the probabilistic termination problem -- or, equivalently, the probabilistic reachability problem. We prove that almost sure termination of order-2 PHORS is undecidable. We also provide a fixpoint characterization of the termination probability of PHORS, and develop a sound (but possibly incomplete) procedure for approximately computing the termination probability. We have implemented the procedure for order-2 PHORSs, and confirmed that the procedure works well through preliminary experiments that are reported at the end of the article.

cs.PL↗

Multi types and reasonable space

Accattoli, Dal Lago, and Vanoni have recently proved that the space used by the Space KAM, a variant of the Krivine abstract machine, is a reasonable space cost model for the lambda-calculus accounting for logarithmic space, solving a longstanding open problem. In this paper, we provide a new system of multi types (a variant of intersection types) and extract from multi type derivations the space used by the Space KAM, capturing into a type system the space complexity of the abstract machine. Additionally, we show how to capture also the time of the Space KAM, which is a reasonable time cost model, via minor changes to the type system.

cs.PL↗

On Jumps, Interactions, and Intersection Types

The Jumping Abstract Machine (JAM), an evaluation mechanism for the $λ$-calculus, was introduced by Danos and Regnier as an optimization of the Interaction Abstract Machine (IAM), itself an operational counterpart to Girard's Geometry of Interaction and Abramsky $\textit{et al}$. game semantics. Moreover, the JAM is isomorphic to the Pointer Abstract Machine (PAM), the syntactical counterpart of Hyland and Ong's game semantics. We study a generalization of the JAM, that we call the Parametric Jumping Abstract Machine (PaJAM) and show that there is a tight correspondence between the PaJAM and non-idempotent intersection types: given a normalizing term $t$, the number of steps taken by the PaJAM when evaluating $t$ can be extracted from its non-idempotent intersection type derivation. Remarkably, fixing the backtracking depth of the PaJAM, one can easily recover both the JAM/PAM, when the depth is constrained to be zero, and the IAM, when it is instead unconstrained. Exploiting type-theoretic machinery, we analyze the complexity of the PaJAM, showing that it is $\textit{polynomial}$ in the number of weak head $β$ steps, giving rise to a $\textit{reasonable}$ cost model, for each $\textit{finite}$ bound on the backtracking depth.

cs.LO↗

On Higher-Order Probabilistic Verification via the Weighted Relational Model of Linear Logic

The problem of determining whether a probabilistic program terminates almost surely (i.e.~with probability one) is undecidable, and actually $Π^0_2$-complete. For this reason, a growing literature has explored classes of programs for which this and related problems can be shown (semi-)decidable. In this work we consider the termination problem for the language of Probabilistic Higher-Order Recursion Schemes (PHORS). Using the weighted relational semantics of linear logic, we translate this problem into the computation of suitable generating functions associated with the program interpreted. This way, we establish the decidability of almost sure termination for a class of programs that extends Li et al.'s affine PHORS via a type discipline with bounded exponentials. To achieve this, we show that the generating functions for such programs are always algebraic, that is, solutions of polynomial equations, yielding an effective method to answer the termination problem.

cs.LO↗

On the Metric Nature of (Differential) Logical Relations

Differential logical relations are methods to measure distances between higher-order programs where distances between functional programs are themselves \emph{functions}, relating errors in inputs with errors in outputs. This way, differential logical relations provide a more fine-grained and contextual information of program distances. This paper aims to clarify the metric nature of differential logical relations. We introduce the notion of quasi-quasi-metrics and observe that the cartesian closed category of quasi-quasi-metric spaces reflects the construction of differential logical relations in the literature. The cartesian closed structure induces a fundamental lemma, which can be seen as a compositional reasoning principle for program distances. Furthermore, we investigate the quasi-quasi-metric spaces arising from the interpretation of types, and we prove that they satisfy variants of the strong transitivity condition and indistancy condition, as well as a weak form of the symmetry condition. In the last part of this paper, we introduce a notion of differential prelogical relations arising as a quantitative counterpart of the framework of prelogical relations. Roughly speaking, differential prelogical relations are quasi-quasi-metrics on the collection of programs. The poset of differential prelogical relations has the finest differential prelogical relation presented as a formal quantitative equational theory, while the poset lacks a coarsest differential prelogical relation. The absence of a coarsest differential prelogical relation contrasts with the situations of typed lambda calculi, where the contextual equivalences serve as the coarsest program equivalences.

cs.LO↗

Compiling Quantum Lambda-Terms into Circuits via the Geometry of Interaction

We present an algorithm turning any term of a linear quantum $λ$-calculus into a quantum circuit. The essential ingredient behind the proposed algorithm is Girard's geometry of interaction, which, differently from its well-known uses from the literature, is here leveraged to perform as much of the classical computation as possible, at the same time producing a circuit that, when evaluated, performs all the quantum operations in the underlying $λ$-term. We identify higher-order control flow as the primary obstacle towards efficient solutions to the problem at hand. Notably, geometry of interaction proves sufficiently flexible to enable efficient compilation in many cases, while still supporting a total compilation procedure. Finally, we characterize through a type system those $λ$-terms for which compilation can be performed efficiently.

cs.LO↗

On Circuit Description Languages, Indexed Monads, and Resource Analysis

In this paper, a monad-based denotational model is introduced and shown adequate for the Proto-Quipper family of calculi, themselves being idealized versions of the Quipper programming language. The use of a monadic approach allows us to separate the value to which a term reduces from the circuit that the term itself produces as a side effect. In turn, this enables the denotational interpretation and validation of rich type systems in which the size of the produced circuit can be controlled. Notably, the proposed semantic framework, through the novel concept of circuit algebra, suggests forms of effect typing guaranteeing quantitative properties about the resulting circuit, even in presence of optimizations.

cs.PL↗

A Characterization of Basic Feasible Functionals Through Higher-Order Rewriting and Tuple Interpretations

The class of type-two basic feasible functionals ($\mathtt{BFF}_2$) is the analogue of $\mathtt{FP}$ (polynomial time functions) for type-2 functionals, that is, functionals that can take (first-order) functions as arguments. $\mathtt{BFF}_2$ can be defined through Oracle Turing machines with running time bounded by second-order polynomials. On the other hand, higher-order term rewriting provides an elegant formalism for expressing higher-order computation. We address the problem of characterizing $\mathtt{BFF}_2$ by higher-order term rewriting. Various kinds of interpretations for first-order term rewriting have been introduced in the literature for proving termination and characterizing first-order complexity classes. In this paper, we consider a recently introduced notion of cost-size interpretations for higher-order term rewriting and see second order rewriting as ways of computing type-2 functionals. We then prove that the class of functionals represented by higher-order terms admitting polynomially bounded cost-size interpretations exactly corresponds to $\mathtt{BFF}_2$.

cs.LO↗

On The Metric Nature of (Differential) Logical Relations

Differential logical relations are a method to measure distances between higher-order programs. They differ from standard methods based on program metrics in that differences between functional programs are themselves functions, relating errors in input with errors in output, this way providing a more fine grained, contextual, information. The aim of this paper is to clarify the metric nature of differential logical relations. While previous work has shown that these do not give rise, in general, to (quasi-)metric spaces nor to partial metric spaces, we show that the distance functions arising from such relations, that we call quasi-quasi-metrics, can be related to both quasi-metrics and partial metrics, the latter being also captured by suitable relational definitions. Moreover, we exploit such connections to deduce some new compositional reasoning principles for program differences.

cs.LO↗

Linearization via Rewriting (Long Version)

We introduce the structural resource lambda-calculus, a new formalism in which strongly normalizing terms of the lambda-calculus can naturally be represented, and at the same time any type derivation can be internally rewritten to its linearization. The calculus is shown to be normalizing and confluent. Noticeably, every strongly normalizable lambda-term can be represented by a type derivation. This is the first example of a system where the linearization process takes place internally, while remaining purely finitary and rewrite-based.

cs.LO↗

Reasonable Space for the $λ$-Calculus, Logarithmically

Can the $λ$-calculus be considered a reasonable computational model? Can we use it for measuring the time $\textit{and}$ space consumption of algorithms? While the literature contains positive answers about time, much less is known about space. This paper presents a new reasonable space cost model for the $λ$-calculus, based on a variant over the Krivine abstract machine. For the first time, this cost model is able to accommodate logarithmic space. Moreover, we study the time behavior of our machine and show how to transport our results to the call-by-value $λ$-calculus.

cs.LO↗

On Computational Indistinguishability and Logical Relations

A $λ$-calculus is introduced in which all programs can be evaluated in probabilistic polynomial time and in which there is sufficient structure to represent sequential cryptographic constructions and adversaries for them, even when the latter are oracle-based. A notion of observational equivalence capturing computational indistinguishability and a class of approximate logical relations are then presented, showing that the latter represent a sound proof technique for the former. The work concludes with the presentation of an example of a security proof in which the encryption scheme induced by a pseudorandom function is proven secure against active adversaries in a purely equational style.

cs.PL↗