Wolfgang Sauerwein | Searcharxiv

arXiv2016

Comparison of Geant4 multiple Coulomb scattering models with theory for radiotherapy protons

Usually, Monte Carlo models are validated against experimental data. However, models of multiple Coulomb scattering (MCS) in the Gaussian approximation are exceptional in that we have theories which are probably more accurate than the experiments which have, so far, been done to test them. In problems directly sensitive to the distribution of angles leaving the target, the relevant theory is the Moliere/Fano/Hanson variant of Moliere theory. For transverse spreading of the beam in the target itself, the theory of Preston and Koehler holds. Therefore, in this paper we compare Geant4 simulations, using the Urban and Wentzel models of MCS, with theory rather than experiment, revealing trends which would otherwise be obscured by experimental scatter. For medium-energy (radiotherapy) protons, and low-Z (water-like) target materials, Wentzel appears to be better than Urban in simulating the distribution of outgoing angles. For beam spreading in the target itself, the two models are essentially equal.

physics.med-ph↗

arXiv2015

A geometrical model for the Monte Carlo simulation of the TrueBeam linac

Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of linacs depends on the accurate geometrical description of the head. The geometry of the Varian TrueBeam (TB) linac is not available to researchers. Instead, the company distributes phase-space files (PSFs) of the flattening-filter-free (FFF) beams tallied upstream the jaws. Yet, MC simulations based on third party tallied PSFs are subject to limitations. We present an experimentally-based geometry developed for the simulation of the FFF beams of the TB linac. The upper part of the TB linac was modeled modifying the Clinac 2100 geometry. The most important modification is the replacement of the standard flattening filters by ad hoc thin filters which were modeled by comparing dose measurements and simulations. The experimental dose profiles for the 6MV and 10MV FFF beams were obtained from the Varian Golden Data Set and from in-house measurements for radiation fields ranging from 3X3 to 40X40 cm2. Indicators of agreement between the experimental data and the simulation results obtained with the proposed geometrical model were the dose differences, the root-mean-square error and the gamma index. The same comparisons were done for dose profiles obtained from MC simulations using the second generation of PSFs distributed by Varian for the TB linac. Results of comparisons show a good agreement of the dose for the ansatz geometry similar to that obtained for the simulations with the TB PSFs for all fields considered, except for the 40X40 cm2 field where the ansatz geometry was able to reproduce the measured dose more accurately. Our approach makes possible to: (i) adapt the initial beam parameters to match measured dose profiles; (ii) reduce the statistical uncertainty to arbitrarily low values; and (iii) assess systematic uncertainties by employing different MC codes.

physics.med-ph↗