arXiv subjects

Z. Haiman

Publications and source records attributed to Z. Haiman.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

High-Spin BBH Subpopulation from AGN Accretion

The formation environments of merging binary black holes remain uncertain. While hierarchical assembly in dense stellar clusters has been widely explored as an explanation for black holes exceeding the stellar-mass limit, growth through gas accretion in active galactic nucleus (AGN) disks is an alternative that has received less observational scrutiny. Here we search for an accretion-origin subpopulation using only spin magnitudes, fitting a three-component mixture model to 166 binary black hole mergers from LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA with component shapes fixed from theoretical predictions and only the mixing fractions inferred from the data. We find strong evidence ($ln B = 5.7$) that $\sim 10\%$ (90% credible interval $[1\%, 14\%]$) of detected mergers belong to a subpopulation with primary spins clustered near $a_1 \approx 0.9$, consistent with the theoretical prediction for accretion spin-up. The hierarchical-merger prediction of $a_1 \approx 0.7$ is decisively disfavored as the location of the high-spin subpopulation ($ln B = 5.7$). Post hoc validation reveals that the accretion candidates have systematically higher masses (median $m_1 = 58\,M_\odot$) and aligned spins (median $\chi_{\rm eff} = 0.33$, vs. $0.04$ for standard-dominated events). The accretion subpopulation is not limited to systems above the pair-instability mass gap: GW190517 ($m_1 \approx 39 M_\odot$) is among the top candidates, demonstrating that accretion spin-up operates across a range of masses. GW190521, previously interpreted as a hierarchical merger, shows comparable support for an accretion origin. These results provide the first population-level observational evidence for an accretion-origin subpopulation in black hole mergers.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2025

ESO Expanding Horizons White Paper: Electromagnetic counterparts of massive BH mergers with LISA

The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), adopted by ESA and scheduled for the second half of the next decade, will drive a new revolution in the rapidly growing field of gravitational-wave astronomy, by extending GW observations into the hiterto unexplored millihertz regime. One of the key source classes of LISA is merging massive black hole binaries in the 1e4-1e7 Msun mass range detectable to very high redshifts $z\sim 15$. MBHBs lighter than 1e6 Msun can potentially be identified during their inspiral weeks before coalescence, allowing for complementary electromagnetic observations before, during, and after the two MBHs merge. This white paper aims at defining the optimal strategy to maximize the number of detected EM counterparts of LISA MBHB events.

astro-ph.IM↗

arXiv2024

The extremes of AGN variability: outbursts, deep fades, changing looks, exceptional spectral states, and semi-periodicities

The extremes of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) variability offer valuable new insights into the drivers and physics of AGN. We discuss some of the most extreme cases of AGN variability; the highest amplitudes, deep minima states, extreme spectral states, Seyfert-type changes, and semi-periodic signals, including new X-ray observations. The properties of changing-look (CL) AGN are briefly reviewed and a classification scheme is proposed which encompasses the variety of CL phenomena; distinguishing slow and fast events, repeat events, and frozen-look AGN which do not show any emission-line response. Long-term light curves that are densely covered over multiple years, along with follow-up spectroscopy, are utilized to gain insight into the underlying variability mechanisms including accretion disk and broad-line region physics. Remarkable differences are seen, for instance, in the optical spectral response to extreme outbursts, implying distinct intrinsic variability mechanisms. Furthermore, we discuss methods for distinguishing between CL AGN and CL look-alike events (tidal disruption events or supernovae in dense media). Finally, semi-periodic light curve variability is addressed and the latest multiwavelength (MWL) light curve of the binary supermassive black hole (SMBH) candidate OJ 287 from the MOMO project is presented. Recent results from that project have clearly established the need for new binary SMBH modelling matching the tight new constraints from observations, including the measurement of a low (primary) SMBH mass of ~10^8 Msun which also implies that OJ 287 is no longer in the regime of near-future pulsar timing arrays.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Absence of the predicted 2022 October outburst of OJ 287 and implications for binary SMBH scenarios

The project MOMO (Multiwavelength Observations and Modelling of OJ 287) was set up to test predictions of binary supermassive black hole (SMBH) scenarios and to understand disk-jet physics of the blazar OJ 287. After a correction, the precessing binary (PB) SMBH model predicted the next main outburst of OJ 287 in 2022 October, no longer in July, making the outburst well observable and the model testable. We have densely covered this period in our ongoing multi-frequency radio, optical, UV, and X-ray monitoring. The predicted outburst was not detected. Instead, OJ 287 was at low optical-UV emission levels, declining further into November. The predicted thermal bremsstrahlung spectrum was not observed either, at any epoch. Further, applying scaling relations, we estimate a SMBH mass of OJ 287 of 10^8 M_sun. The latest in a sequence of deep low-states that recur every 1-2 yrs is used to determine an upper limit on the Eddington ratio and on the accretion-disk luminosity. This limit is at least a factor of 10 lower than required by the PB model with its massive primary SMBH of >10^{10} M_sun. All these results favor alternative binary SMBH models of OJ 287 that neither require strong orbital precession nor a very large mass of the primary SMBH.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2023

Gravitational wave source populations: Disentangling an AGN component

The astrophysical origin of the over 90 compact binary mergers discovered by the LIGO and Virgo gravitational wave observatories is an open question. While the unusual mass and spin of some of the discovered objects constrain progenitor scenarios, the observed mergers are consistent with multiple interpretations. A promising approach to solve this question is to consider the observed distributions of binary properties and compare them to expectations from different origin scenarios. Here we describe a new hierarchical population analysis framework to assess the relative contribution of different formation channels simultaneously. For this study we considered binary formation in AGN disks along with phenomenological models, but the same framework can be extended to other models. We find that high-mass and high-mass-ratio binaries appear more likely to have an AGN origin compared to the same origin as lower-mass events. Future observations of high-mass black hole mergers could further disentangle the AGN component from other channels.

gr-qc↗

arXiv2022

AGN as Potential Factories for Eccentric Black Hole Mergers

There is some weak evidence that the black hole merger named GW190521 had a non-zero eccentricity. In addition, the component black holes' masses exceeded the limit predicted by stellar evolution. The large masses can be explained by successive mergers, which may be efficient in gas disks surrounding active galactic nuclei (AGN), but it is difficult to maintain an eccentric orbit all the way to the merger, as basic physics would argue for circularization. Here we show that AGN-disk environments can lead to an excess of eccentric mergers, if the interactions between single and binary black holes are frequent, and occur with mutual inclinations of less than a few degrees. We further illustrate that this eccentric population has a different distribution of the inclination between the spin vectors of the black holes and their orbital angular momentum at merger, referred to as the spin-orbit tilt, compared to the remaining circular mergers.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2021

Micro Tidal Disruption Events in Active Galactic Nuclei

Active galactic nuclei (AGNs) can act as black hole assembly lines, funneling some of the stellar-mass black holes from the vicinity of the galactic center into the inner plane of the AGN disk where the black holes can merge through dynamical friction and gravitational wave emission. Here, we show that stars near the galactic center are also brought into the AGN disk, where they can be tidally disrupted by the stellar-mass black holes in the disk. Such micro-tidal disruption events (micro-TDEs) could be useful probe of stellar interaction with the AGN disk. We find that micro-TDEs in AGNs occur at a rate of $\sim170$ Gpc$^{-3}$yr$^{-1}$. Their cleanest observational probe may be the detection of tidal disruption in AGNs by heavy supermassive black holes ($M_{\bullet}\gtrsim10^{8}$ M$_{\odot}$) so that cannot tidally disrupt solar-type stars. We discuss two such TDE candidates observed to date (ASASSN-15lh and ZTF19aailpwl).

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2021

Black hole mergers of AGN origin in LIGO/Virgo's O1-O3a observing periods

The origin of the black hole mergers detected by LIGO and Virgo remains an open question. While the unusual mass and spin of a few events constrain their possible astrophysical formation mechanisms, it is difficult to classify the bulk of the observed mergers. Here we consider the distribution of masses and spins in LIGO/Virgo's first and second observing catalogs, and find that for a significant fraction (25%) of these detected events, an AGN-disk origin model is preferred over a parametric mass-spin model fit to the full GWTC-2 merger sample (Bayes factor $\mathcal{B}>10$). We use this to estimate the black hole merger rate in AGNs to be about $2.8\pm 1.8$\, Gpc$^{-3}$yr$^{-1}$, comparable to theoretical expectations. We find that AGNs can explain the rate and mass distribution of the observed events with primary black hole mass in the pair-instability mass gap ($M\gtrsim50$\, M$_\odot$).

gr-qc↗

arXiv2021

Evolution of gas disc-embedded intermediate mass ratio inspirals in the LISA band

Among the potential milliHz gravitational wave (GW) sources for the upcoming space-based interferometer LISA are extreme- or intermediate-mass ratio inspirals (EMRI/IMRIs). These events involve the coalescence of supermassive black holes in the mass range $10^5 M_{\odot} \lesssim M \lesssim 10^7 M_{\odot}$ with companion BHs of much lower masses. A subset of E/IMRIs are expected to occur in the accretion discs of active galactic nuclei (AGN), where torques exerted by the disc can interfere with the inspiral and cause a phase shift in the GW waveform. Here we use a suite of two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations with the moving-mesh code DISCO to present a systematic study of disc torques. We measure torques on an inspiraling BH and compute the corresponding waveform deviations as a function of the binary mass ratio $q\equiv M_2/M_1$, the disc viscosity ($α$), and gas temperature (or equivalently Mach number; $\mathcal{M}$). We find that the absolute value of the gas torques is within an order of magnitude of previously determined planetary migration torques, but their precise value and sign depends non-trivially on the combination of these parameters. The gas imprint is detectable by LISA for binaries embedded in AGN discs with surface densities above $Σ_0\ge10^{4-6} \rm \, g cm^{-2}$, depending on $q$, $α$ and $\mathcal{M}$. Deviations are most pronounced in discs with higher viscosities, and for E/IMRIs detected at frequencies where LISA is most sensitive. Torques in colder discs exhibit a noticeable dependence on the GW-driven inspiral rate as well as strong fluctuations at late stages of the inspiral. Our results further suggest that LISA may be able to place constraints on AGN disc parameters and the physics of disc-satellite interaction.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2020

Black Hole Formation in the Lower Mass Gap through Mergers and Accretion in AGN Disks

The heaviest neutron stars and lightest black holes expected to be produced by stellar evolution leave the mass-range $2.2$ M$_{\odot}\lesssim m \lesssim 5$ M$_\odot$ largely unpopulated. Objects found in this so-called lower mass gap likely originate from a distinct astrophysical process. Such an object, with mass $2.6$ M$_\odot$ was recently detected in the binary merger GW190814 through gravitational waves by LIGO/Virgo. Here we show that black holes in the mass gap are naturally assembled through mergers and accretion in AGN disks, and can subsequently participate in additional mergers. We compute the properties of AGN-assisted mergers involving neutron stars and black holes, accounting for accretion. We find that mergers in which one of the objects is in the lower mass gap represent up to $4$% of AGN-assisted mergers detectable by LIGO/Virgo. The lighter object of GW190814, with mass $2.6$ M$_\odot$, could have grown in an AGN disk through accretion. We find that the unexpectedly high total mass of 3.4 M$_\odot$ observed in the neutron star merger GW190425 may also be due to accretion in an AGN disk.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2020

Cosmic Evolution of Stellar-mass Black Hole Merger Rate in Active Galactic Nuclei

Binary black hole mergers encode information about their environment and the astrophysical processes that led to their formation. Measuring the redshift dependence of their merger rate will help probe the formation and evolution of galaxies and the evolution of the star formation rate. Here we compute the cosmic evolution of the merger rate for stellar-mass binaries in the disks of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs). We focus on recent evolution out to redshift $z=2$, covering the accessible range of current Earth-based gravitational-wave observatories. On this scale, the AGN population density is the main contributor to redshift-dependence. We find that the AGN-assisted merger rate does not meaningfully evolve with redshift, differentiating this channel from field binaries and some other dynamical formation scenarios.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2020

GW170817A as a Hierarchical Black Hole Merger

Despite the rapidly growing number of stellar-mass binary black hole mergers discovered through gravitational waves, the origin of these binaries is still not known. In galactic centers, black holes can be brought to each others' proximity by dynamical processes, resulting in mergers. It is also possible that black holes formed in previous mergers encounter new black holes, resulting in so-called hierarchical mergers. Hierarchical events carry signatures such as higher-than usual black hole mass and spin. Here we show that the recently reported gravitational-wave candidate, GW170817A, could be the result of such a hierarchical merger. In particular, its chirp mass $\sim40$ M$_\odot$ and effective spin of $χ_{\rm eff}\sim0.5$ are the typically expected values from hierarchical mergers within the disks of active galactic nuclei. We find that the reconstructed parameters of GW170817A strongly favor a hierarchical merger origin over having been produced by an isolated binary origin (with an Odds ratio of $>10^3$, after accounting for differences between the expected rates of hierarchical versus isolated mergers)

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2019

Probing gas disc physics with LISA: simulations of an intermediate mass ratio inspiral in an accretion disc

The coalescence of a compact object with a $10^{4}-10^{7} {\rm M_\odot}$ supermassive black hole (SMBH) produces mHz gravitational waves (GWs) detectable by the future Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). If such an inspiral occurs in the accretion disc of an active galactic nucleus (AGN), the gas torques imprint a small deviation in the GW waveform. Here we present two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations with the moving-mesh code DISCO of a BH inspiraling at the GW rate in a binary system with a mass ratio $q\!=\!M_2/M_1\!=\!10^{-3}$, embedded in an accretion disc. We assume a locally isothermal equation of state for the gas (with Mach number $\mathcal{M}=20$) and implement a standard $α$-prescription for its viscosity (with $α= 0.03$). We find disc torques on the binary that are weaker than in previous semi-analytic toy models, and are in the opposite direction: the gas disc slows down, rather than speeds up the inspiral. We compute the resulting deviations in the GW waveform, which scale linearly with the mass of the disc. The SNR of these deviations accumulates mostly at high frequencies, and becomes detectable in a 5-year LISA observation if the total phase shift exceeds a few radians. We find that this occurs if the disc surface density exceeds $Σ_0 \gtrsim 10^{2-3}\rm g\,cm^{-2}$, as may be the case in thin discs with near-Eddington accretion rates. Since the characteristic imprint on the GW signal is strongly dependent on disc parameters, a LISA detection of an intermediate mass ratio inspiral would probe the physics of AGN discs and migration.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2019

AGN Disks Harden the Mass Distribution of Stellar-mass Binary Black Hole Mergers

The growing number of stellar-mass binary black hole mergers discovered by Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo are starting to constrain the binaries' origin and environment. However, we still lack sufficiently accurate modeling of binary formation channels to obtain strong constraints, or to identify sub-populations. One promising formation mechanism that could result in different black hole properties is binaries merging within the accretion disks of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Here we show that the black holes' orbital alignment with the AGN disks preferentially selects heavier black holes. We carry out Monte Carlo simulations of orbital alignment with AGN disks, and find that AGNs harden the initial black hole mass function. Assuming an initial power law mass distribution $M_{\rm bh}^{-β}$, we find that the power law index changes by $Δβ\sim1.3$, resulting in a more top-heavy population of merging black holes. This change is independent of the mass of, and accretion rate onto, the supermassive black hole in the center of the AGN. Our simulations predict an AGN-assisted merger rate of $\sim4$Gpc$^{-3}$yr$^{-1}$. With its hardened mass spectra, the AGN channel could be responsible for $10-50$% of gravitational-wave detections.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2018

Target of Opportunity Observations of Gravitational Wave Events with LSST

The discovery of the electromagnetic counterparts to the binary neutron star merger GW170817 has opened the era of GW+EM multi-messenger astronomy. Exploiting this breakthrough requires increasing samples to explore the diversity of kilonova behaviour and provide more stringent constraints on the Hubble constant, and tests of fundamental physics. LSST can play a key role in this field in the 2020s, when the gravitational wave detector network is expected to detect higher rates of merger events involving neutron stars ($\sim$10s per year) out to distances of several hundred Mpc. Here we propose comprehensive target-of-opportunity (ToOs) strategies for follow-up of gravitational-wave sources that will make LSST the premiere machine for discovery and early characterization for neutron star mergers and other gravitational-wave sources.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2018

H2 self-shielding with non-LTE rovibrational populations: implications for cooling in protogalaxies

The abundance of molecular hydrogen (H2), the primary coolant in primordial gas, is critical for the thermodynamic evolution and star-formation histories in early protogalaxies. Determining the photodissociation rate of H2 by an incident Lyman-Werner (LW) flux is thus crucial, but prohibitively expensive to calculate on the fly in simulations. The rate is sensitive to the H2 rovibrational distribution, which in turn depends on the gas density, temperature, and incident LW radiation field. We use the publicly available cloudy package to model primordial gas clouds and compare exact photodissociation rate calculations to commonly-used fitting formulae. We find the fit from Wolcott-Green et al. (2011) is most accurate for moderate densities n~10^3 cm^{-3} and temperatures, T~10^3K, and we provide a new fit, which captures the increase in the rate at higher densities and temperatures, owing to the increased excited rovibrational populations in this regime. Our new fit has typical errors of a few percent percent up to n =<10^7 cm^{-3}, T =< 8000K, and H2 column density NH2 =<10^{17} cm^{-2}, and can be easily utilized in simulations. We also show that pumping of the excited rovibrational states of H2 by a strong LW flux further modifies the level populations when the gas density is low, and noticeably decreases self-shielding for J_21 > 10^3 and n < 10^2 cm^{-3}. This may lower the "critical flux" at which primordial gas remains H2-poor in some protogalaxies, enabling massive black hole seed formation.

astro-ph.GA↗

arXiv2018

On stellar-mass black hole mergers in AGN disks detectable with LIGO

Black hole mergers detectable with LIGO can occur in active galactic nucleus (AGN) disks. Here we parameterize the merger rates, the mass spectrum and the spin spectrum of black holes (BH) in AGN disks. The predicted merger rate spans $\sim 10^{-4}-10^{4} \rm{Gpc}^{-1} \rm{yr}^{-1}$, so upper limits from LIGO ($<212\rm{Gpc}^{-1}\rm{yr}^{-1}$) already constrain it. The predicted mass spectrum has the form of a broken power-law consisting of a pre-existing BH powerlaw mass spectrum and a harder powerlaw mass spectrum resulting from mergers. The predicted spin spectrum is multi-peaked with the evolution of retrograde spin BH in the gas disk playing a key role. We outline the large uncertainties in each of these LIGO observables for this channel and we discuss ways in which they can be constrained in the future.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2018

Testing the relativistic Doppler boost hypothesis for supermassive black hole binary candidates

Supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) should be common in galactic nuclei as a result of frequent galaxy mergers. Recently, a large sample of sub-parsec SMBHB candidates was identified as bright periodically variable quasars in optical surveys. If the observed periodicity corresponds to the redshifted binary orbital period, the inferred orbital velocities are relativistic (v/c~0.1). The optical and UV luminosities are expected to arise from gas bound to the individual BHs, and would be modulated by the relativistic Doppler effect. The optical and UV light curves should vary in tandem with relative amplitudes which depend on the respective spectral slopes. We constructed a control sample of 42 quasars with aperiodic variability, to test whether this Doppler colour signature can be distinguished from intrinsic chromatic variability. We found that the Doppler signature can arise by chance in ~20% (~37%) of quasars in the nUV (fUV) band. These probabilities reflect the limited quality of the control sample and represent upper limits on how frequently quasars mimic the Doppler brightness+colour variations. We performed separate tests on the periodic quasar candidates, and found that for the majority, the Doppler boost hypothesis requires an unusually steep UV spectrum or an unexpectedly large BH mass and orbital velocity. We conclude that at most ~1/3rd of these periodic candidates can harbor Doppler-modulated SMBHBs.

astro-ph.GA↗