Searcharxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 1908.02003

Reply to "Comment on `R\'enyi entropy yields artificial biases not in the data and incorrect updating due to the finite-size data' "

Thomas Oikonomou·G. Baris Bagci
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

We reply to the Comment by Jizba and Korbel [arXiv:1905.00729v1] by first pointing out that the Schur-concavity proposed by them falls short of identifying the correct intervals of normalization for the optimum probability distribution even though normalization is a must ingredient in the entropy maximization procedure. Secondly, their treatment of the subset independence axiom requires a modification of the Lagrange multipliers one begins with thereby rendering the optimization less trustworthy. We also explicitly demonstrate that the R\'enyi entropy violates the subset independence axiom and compare it with the Shannon entropy. Thirdly, the new composition rule offered by Jizba and Korbel are shown to yield probability distributions even without a need for the entropy maximization procedure at the expense of creating artificial bias in the data.

Explore related subjects

cond-mat.stat-mech

Keep this discovery

BibTeXRIS

Thomas Oikonomou, G. Baris Bagci. 2019-08-06. Reply to "Comment on `R\'enyi entropy yields artificial biases not in the data and incorrect updating due to the finite-size data' ". https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.100.026102

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Universal sampling of spin systems across quenched disorder

Statistical physics extracts macroscopic laws by averaging over the many microscopic degrees of freedom of a system. Disordered systems demand a second and far harder average, one over the quenched randomness itself. The classic analytical routes, the replica and cavity methods, become uncontrolled outside mean-field or tree-like limits, and conventional numerical algorithms like parallel tempering require expensive, independent equilibration for every disorder realization. In this work, we introduce a universal neural variational framework that amortizes inference across the disorder ensemble, eliminating both the need for per-instance Markov chain equilibration and the cost of retraining instance-specific variational ansatzes. Built on an encoder-decoder Transformer architecture, after training once, it produces an explicit approximation to the Boltzmann distribution given previously unseen disorder realizations without further optimization. We validate this framework on 2D Edwards-Anderson models, and apply it to the random-bond Ising model, successfully capturing the Binder cumulant crossings near the Nishimori multicritical point. These results shift the object of variational inference from the single instance to the disorder ensemble, opening a route to frustrated many-body systems where instance-by-instance computation is prohibitive.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗
arXiv2026

Information-Theoretic Characterization of Macroscopic Chaos Emerging from the Chemical Master Equation

Open chemical reaction networks exhibit stochastic concentration dynamics at finite system sizes, whereas their macroscopic limit is governed by deterministic rate equations that can display chaos. In this Letter, we show theoretically that a rate of information loss constructed from two-time mutual information recovers the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy in the deterministic limit. We verify this result through numerical simulations of a Markov jump process for a three-species system involving seven reactions.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗
arXiv2026

Orientational order on non-orientable domains

We study the statistical properties of passive and active many-body systems with orientational degrees of freedom on non-orientable domains. By rephrasing topological constraints as non-local symmetry relations on an orientable double-cover, we show that non-orientability eliminates global rotational soft modes without acting like an external field. In a passive XY model, this results in topological caging, where orientational fluctuations that exhibit conventional diffusive behavior on a torus saturate on a Klein bottle to a finite value that we compute exactly in the thermodynamic limit. In models of active self-propelled particles with orientational degrees of freedom, topological caging persists despite continuously changing interaction neighborhoods. In an active Ising spin model, non-orientability enforces the coexistence of ordered anti-parallel domains with vanishing global polar order, a state that is absent on orientable domains.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗