Non-orientable order and non-Abelian response in frustrated metamaterials

Abstract

From atomic crystals to bird flocks, most forms of order are captured by the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking. This paradigm was challenged by the discovery of topological order, in materials where the number of accessible states is not solely determined by the number of broken symmetries, but also by space topology. Until now however, the concept of topological order has been linked to quantum entanglement and has therefore remained out of reach in classical systems. Here, we show that classical systems whose global geometry frustrates the emergence of homogeneous order realise an unanticipated form of topological order defined by non-orientable order-parameter bundles: non-orientable order. We validate experimentally and theoretically this concept by designing frustrated mechanical metamaterials that spontaneously break a discrete symmetry under homogeneous load. While conventional order leads to a discrete ground-state degeneracy, we show that non-orientable order implies an extensive ground-state degeneracy -- in the form of topologically protected zero-nodes and zero-lines. Our metamaterials escape the traditional classification of order by symmetry breaking. Considering more general stress distributions, we leverage non-orientable order to engineer robust mechanical memory and achieve non-Abelian mechanical responses that carry an imprint of the braiding of local loads. We envision this principle to open the way to designer materials that can robustly process information across multiple areas of physics, from mechanics to photonics and magnetism.