Matrix Extreme Points and Free extreme points of Free spectrahedra

Abstract

A spectrahedron is a convex set defined by a linear matrix inequality, i.e., the set of all $x \in \mathbb{R}^g$ such that \[ L_A(x) = I + A_1 x_1 + A_2 x_2 + \dots + A_g x_g \succeq 0 \] for some symmetric matrices $A_1,\ldots,A_g$. This can be extended to matrix spaces by taking $X$ to be a tuple of real symmetric matrices of any size and using the Kronecker product $$L_A(X) = I_n \otimes I_d + A_1 \otimes X_1 + A_2 \otimes X_2 + \dots + A_g \otimes X_g.$$ The solution set of $L_A (X) \succeq 0$ is called a \textit{free spectrahedron}. Free spectrahedra are important in systems engineering, operator algebras, and the theory of matrix convex sets. Matrix and free extreme points of free spectrahedra are of particular interest. While many authors have studied matrix and free extreme points of free spectrahedra, it has until now been unknown if these two types of extreme points are actually different. The results of this paper fall into three categories: theoretical, algorithmic, and experimental. Firstly, we prove the existence of matrix extreme points of free spectrahedra that are not free extreme. This is done by producing exact examples of matrix extreme points that are not free extreme. We also show that if the $A_i$ are $2 \times 2$ matrices, then matrix and free extreme points coincide. Secondly, we detail methods for constructing matrix extreme points of free spectrahedra that are not free extreme, both exactly and numerically. We also show how a recent result due to Kriel (Complex Anal.~Oper.~Theory 2019) can be used to efficiently test whether a point is matrix extreme. Thirdly, we provide evidence that a substantial number of matrix extreme points of free spectrahedra are not free extreme. Numerical work in another direction shows how to effectively write a given tuple in a free spectrahedron as a matrix convex combination of its free extreme points.