Searcharxiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2610.00013

A Systematic Literature Review of Survey Research on Engineering Identity

Amdad Ahmed Awsaf·Heidi Cian·Remy Dou
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Over the last several years, engineering identity research has gained prominence in education research circles, motivated by connections between "identity" and widely-desired outcomes such as career pursuits and selection of STEM college majors. However, quantitative research on engineering identity remains limited, with most studies focusing on qualitative research. This systematic literature review examines 85 research papers from 2007 to 2022, concentrating on survey measures related to engineering identity. Results of the review show a) a concentration of research at the postsecondary levels, with K-12 students underrepresented, and b) heavy male gender representation in survey samples. The analysis also revealed that several theoretical frameworks are frequently employed to operationalize engineering identity, but with a preference for the Engineering Identity Development Scale, the Physics Identity Scale, and the Critical Engineering Agency Framework. Drawing from our analysis, we consider the consequences of both 1) existing age and gender gaps in quantitative engineering identity research and 2) preferences of particular identity frameworks within and across age and gender categories. We discuss how these possible consequences point to focal areas in engineering identity survey-based research.

Explore related subjects

physics.ed-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Amdad Ahmed Awsaf, Heidi Cian, Remy Dou. 2026-07-12. A Systematic Literature Review of Survey Research on Engineering Identity. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.00013

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Measuring the Speed of Light with a Time-of-Flight Setup: An Authentic Experiment for High School

Students often perceive scientific experiments as clean, straightforward procedures with predictable outcomes. Students' beliefs about the nature of experimental physics typically remain inconsistent through the initial stages of undergraduate education. In reality, experimental work in physics involves hands-on activities such as soldering circuits, assembling provisional setups, and building functional mock-ups from simple materials before reliable measurements can be achieved. To address this gap, we designed a laboratory activity in which students were completely involved in the experiment design, construction and operation with the final goal of measuring the speed of light with a low-cost and compact setup. The educational objective of this activity was double: firstly, to make students aware of the importance of experimental choices and constraints in the setup design and secondly, to discover the potentiality of semiconductor technologies. As far back as the 1990s, with the spread of compact disk players, laser diodes and photodiodes capable of fast timing performance in the order of nanoseconds became largely available. In the last decades, consumer electronic devices made high performance technologies ubiquitous. Nevertheless, the idea of measuring ultrashort time intervals and the relevance of such measurements in science and technology remain unknown to most students. Nowadays, digital instruments with significant performance such as waveform generators and oscilloscopes are affordable for high school physics labs, paving the way to a closer contact with the world of experimental physics.

physics.ed-ph↗
arXiv2026

Using Learning Analytics to Study Novice Learners' Work on Quantum Circuit Simulator Tasks

Interactive quantum circuit simulators are increasingly used to support introductory quantum computing education for learners from varied disciplinary backgrounds. These environments can also generate detailed response logs of submitted circuits, but such data are rarely transformed into evidence that instructors can use for course redesign and development. We present a learning analytics framework for quantum circuit simulator tasks and report its task-level branch on anonymised logs from an introductory quantum computing course delivered in the TIM learning environment. The task branch characterises exercises through participation, completion, first-attempt accuracy, valid-attempt counts, sessionised active time, and observed answer-space reporting of common correct and incorrect constructions. The dataset covers the 2024-2025 cohort of 492 learners, 47,533 valid submissions, and 21 obligatory quantum circuit exercises. The framework identifies bottleneck tasks, broad solution spaces, and recurring wrong-answer patterns that are not visible from final scores alone. Its most distinctive output is a plain-text representation of the observed answer space, designed to make open-ended circuit submissions directly interpretable to instructors. We show how response logs can reveal actionable task-design issues and support concrete course redesign. A learner-level branch is retained only as an ongoing research extension and is not a central empirical contribution of the present paper.

physics.ed-ph↗
arXiv2026

Stable levitation of ring magnets: A low-cost, 3D-printed experiment on the magnetic force-distance law

Magnetic levitation is one of the most captivating phenomena in physics, combining a striking visual appeal with the rich underlying physics of forces and interactions in equilibrium. Bringing it into undergraduate laboratories in a quantitative way is nevertheless often hindered by the intrinsic instability of static magnetic systems and by the high cost of active control systems. Here we present a simple, safe, and very low-cost experiment that uses ring-shaped ferrite magnets together with a mechanical stabilization system fabricated by 3D printing in a male--female configuration. The apparatus lets undergraduate students explore directly and quantitatively the relationship between the magnitude of the magnetic force and the separation distance. We assess the robustness of the device through experimental tests, whose results show excellent quantitative agreement with the equivalent current-loop model. Furthermore, we validate this model through a complementary, independent first-principles-based methodology based on axial magnetic field profiling. To support reproducibility, the 3D design files are made available in a public, open-access repository.

physics.ed-ph↗