SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Federico Crippa

Publications and source records attributed to Federico Crippa.

5 recordsLinked to original sources

Manipulation Testing in Boundary Discontinuity Designs

We propose the first manipulation test designed for boundary discontinuity designs (BDDs) with general boundary shapes. A BDD is a multidimensional extension of the regression discontinuity design (RDD) in which treatment assignment is determined by whether the multidimensional running variable crosses a lower-dimensional boundary set. The test avoids multivariate density estimation and builds on the observation that, in the absence of manipulation, observations near the boundary should be approximately evenly split between treatment and control within arbitrary groups defined by their projections onto the boundary. We test this implication using a collection of binomial balance tests on observations near the boundary, with groups formed by k-means clustering. We establish the asymptotic validity of the test under suitable regularity conditions. We also evaluate finite-sample performance through Monte Carlo simulations and illustrate the test in three empirical applications.

econ.EM

Complementarities in Sparse Two-Sided Interaction Models

This paper studies complementarities in two-sided interaction models when only a sparse subset of potential matches is realized. I introduce the Tukey model, adding one complementarity parameter to two-way fixed effects. Variation within a four-cycle in the observed matching network identifies this parameter, while connectedness permits identification of agent productivities. I propose a cycle-based estimator that avoids estimating latent productivities. The estimator is consistent and asymptotically normal under sparse-network asymptotics, yielding a formal test of no complementarities. An application to World Bank manager-country assignments finds negative complementarities, suggesting that more capable managers are especially valuable in more complex environments.

econ.EM

Partially Identified Rankings from Pairwise Interactions

This paper considers the problem of ranking objects based on their latent merits using data from pairwise interactions. We allow for incomplete observation of these interactions and study what can be inferred about rankings in such settings. First, we show that identification of the ranking depends on a trade-off between the tournament graph and the interaction function: in parametric models, such as the Bradley-Terry-Luce, rankings are point identified even with sparse graphs, whereas nonparametric models require dense graphs. Second, moving beyond point identification, we characterize the identified set in the nonparametric model under any tournament structure and represent it through moment inequalities. Finally, we propose a likelihood-based statistic to test whether a ranking belongs to the identified set. We study two testing procedures: one is finite-sample valid but computationally intensive; the other is easy to implement and valid asymptotically. We illustrate our results using Brazilian employer-employee data to study how workers rank firms when moving across jobs.

econ.EM

Regret Analysis in Threshold Policy Design

Threshold policies are decision rules that assign treatments based on whether an observable characteristic exceeds a certain threshold. They are widespread across multiple domains, including welfare programs, taxation, and clinical medicine. This paper examines the problem of designing threshold policies using experimental data, when the goal is to maximize the population welfare. First, I characterize the regret - a measure of policy optimality - of the Empirical Welfare Maximizer (EWM) policy, popular in the literature. Next, I introduce the Smoothed Welfare Maximizer (SWM) policy, which improves the EWM's regret convergence rate under an additional smoothness condition. The two policies are compared by studying how differently their regrets depend on the population distribution, and investigating their finite sample performances through Monte Carlo simulations. In many contexts, the SWM policy guarantees larger welfare than the EWM. An empirical illustration demonstrates how the treatment recommendations of the two policies may differ in practice.

econ.EM

Manipulation Test for Multidimensional RDD

The causal inference model proposed by Lee (2008) for the regression discontinuity design (RDD) relies on assumptions that imply the continuity of the density of the assignment (running) variable. The test for this implication is commonly referred to as the manipulation test and is regularly reported in applied research to strengthen the design's validity. The multidimensional RDD (MRDD) extends the RDD to contexts where treatment assignment depends on several running variables. This paper introduces a manipulation test for the MRDD. First, it develops a theoretical model for causal inference with the MRDD, used to derive a testable implication on the conditional marginal densities of the running variables. Then, it constructs the test for the implication based on a quadratic form of a vector of statistics separately computed for each marginal density. Finally, the proposed test is compared with alternative procedures commonly employed in applied research.

econ.EM