SearcharxivSearch

arXiv subjects

Hakan Ergun

Publications and source records attributed to Hakan Ergun.

17 recordsLinked to original sources

Grid Topology Optimization for Congestion Management Under High Renewable Penetrations and Discrete Load Growth

Transmission grids are increasingly stressed by the fluctuating nature of renewable energy sources and by increasing electricity demand. Such grids were mainly built for a different generation fleet and load conditions. Grid topology optimization offers the possibility to redistribute power flows by modifying the busbar topology of substations in the grid. However, the combinatorial explosion of feasible busbar configurations makes topology optimization impractical for system operators. This paper proposes a methodology to identify a small subset of high-value busbar topologies to capture the economic benefit of topology optimization across a range of renewable-demand patterns. The optimization model is based on a LPAC approximation of the optimal power flow formulation, and AC-feasibility checks of the optimal topology applied to the IEEE 118-bus test case. In the test case, we select two distinct pairs of substations (46-49 and 24-69) and we optimize their topology separately over 365 clustered timesteps with different wind and load conditions. For each pair, we identify the four most recurrent optimal topologies and evaluate their performance under standard, and congested conditions, with and without a discrete load growth. Results show that selecting from this reduced set of topologies reduces total generation costs by up to 0.147% compared to a plain AC-OPF. In addition, we show the influence of topology optimization on the hosting capacity of selected busbars under discrete load growth. Our findings provide a practical methodology for system operators to select a subset of optimal busbar topologies to be used in their grid for different wind-load conditions, resulting in decreasing generation costs without the computational and operational risks of real-time switching decisions.

eess.SY

Identification of Technical Design Constraints and Considerations for Transmission Grid Expansion Planning Projects

The large-scale deployment of renewable energy sources, particularly offshore wind, requires large-scale transmission grid expansion projects to transmit the produced low-carbon power to the main demand centers. However, the planning and design of such complex projects currently lack a transparent and systematic process that system operators can follow when considering such investments in their grids. This paper identifies and classifies the main technical design constraints and considerations relevant to the planning of transmission grid expansion projects, and more specifically, electrical energy hubs. Seven key areas of interest are identified, namely network integration, HVDC technologies, costs (CAPEX, OPEX, and space requirements), electricity market design, future proofness and modular expandability, reliability-availability-maintainability, and sustainability. Each area of interest is analyzed in terms of its technical and operational relevance, with technical design constraints and considerations derived from such analysis. In addition, a hierarchical classification of the identified constraints and considerations (and therefore areas of interest) is introduced, distinguishing them between three criticality classes, namely hard constraints, main drivers, and key considerations. The dependencies between the different areas are discussed, too. Therefore, this work provides system operators and policymakers with a structured basis to support a transparent planning methodology with clear decision hierarchies for investments in transmission grid expansion projects.

eess.SY

Identifying Best Candidates for Busbar Splitting

Rising electricity demand and the growing integration of renewables are intensifying congestion in transmission grids. Grid topology optimization through busbar splitting (BuS) and optimal transmission switching can alleviate grid congestion and reduce the generation costs in a power system. However, BuS optimization requires a large number of binary variables, and analyzing all the substations for potential new topological actions is computationally intractable, particularly in large grids. To tackle this issue, we propose a set of metrics to identify and rank promising candidates for BuS, focusing on finding buses where topology optimization can reduce generation costs. To assess the effect of BuS on the identified buses, we use a combined mixed-integer convex-quadratic BuS model to compute the optimal topology and test it with the non-linear non-convex AC optimal power flow (OPF) simulation to show its AC feasibility. By testing and validating the proposed metrics on test cases of different sizes, we show that they are able to identify busbars that reduce the total generation costs when their topology is optimized. Thus, the metrics enable effective selection of busbars for BuS, with no need to test every busbar in the grid, one at a time.

eess.SY

Optimal Transmission Switching and Busbar Splitting in Hybrid AC/DC Grids

Driven by global climate goals, an increasing amount of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) is currently being installed worldwide. Especially in the context of offshore wind integration, hybrid AC/DC grids are considered to be the most effective technology to transmit this RES power over long distances. As hybrid AC/DC systems develop, they are expected to become increasingly complex and meshed as the current AC system. Nevertheless, there is still limited literature on how to optimize hybrid AC/DC topologies while minimizing the total power generation cost. For this reason, this paper proposes a methodology to optimize the steady-state switching states of transmission lines and busbar configurations in hybrid AC/DC grids. The proposed optimization model includes optimal transmission switching (OTS) and busbar splitting (BS), which can be applied to both AC and DC parts of hybrid AC/DC grids. To solve the problem, a scalable and exact nonlinear, non-convex model using a big M approach is formulated. In addition, convex relaxations and linear approximations of the model are tested, and their accuracy, feasibility, and optimality are analyzed. The numerical experiments show that a solution to the combined OTS/BS problem can be found in acceptable computation time and that the investigated relaxations and linearisations provide AC feasible results.

eess.SY

Security-Constrained AC/DC Grid Optimal Power Flow Considering Asymmetrical HVDC Grid Operation using Sparse Tableau Formulation

This paper presents a security-constrained optimal power flow (SCOPF) model for HVDC grids that optimizes the asymmetrical operation of bipolar converter stations, i.e., different current injections of the positive and negative converter poles, to minimize operational costs under post-contingency conditions caused by single converter pole outages. The optimization model allows the selection of the number of converter stations that operate asymmetrically. The results indicate that increasing the number of asymmetrical stations lowers operational costs. The analysis also provides insight into the sensitivity of these costs to the level of asymmetrical operation. However, increased asymmetrical operation leads to higher DC neutral voltage offsets that can rise to undesired levels. Imposing limits on these offsets can, in turn, increase operational costs. To mitigate these effects, a neutral line switching (NLS) strategy is proposed for the post-contingency state.

eess.SY

Day-Ahead Transmission Grid Topology Optimization Considering Renewable Energy Sources' Uncertainty

The increasing renewable penetration introduces significant uncertainty in power system operations. At the same time, the existing transmission grid is often already congested, and urgently needed reinforcements are frequently delayed due to several constraints. To address these challenges, adjusting the grid topology based on congestion patterns is considered a non-costly remedy to guarantee efficient power transmission. Based on this idea, this paper proposes a grid topology optimization model combining optimal transmission switching and busbar splitting for AC and hybrid AC/DC grids. The methodology incorporates RES forecast uncertainty through a scenario-based stochastic optimization approach, using real offshore wind data and K-means clustering to generate representative forecast error scenarios. The proposed model includes several formulations to be compared with a plain optimal power flow (OPF) model: hourly optimizing the topology, one topology for 24 hours, or a limited number of switching actions over a day. The grid topology optimization model is formulated as a Mixed-Integer Quadratic Convex Problem, optimized based on the day-ahead (D-1) RES forecast and validated for AC-feasibility via an AC-OPF formulation. Based on the generation setpoints of the feasibility check, a redispatch simulation based on the measured (D) RES realization is then computed. The methodology is tested on an AC 30-bus test case and a hybrid AC/DC 50-bus test case, for a 24-hours (30-bus) and a 14-days (both test cases) time series. The results highlight the economic benefits brought by grid topology optimization for congested test cases with high penetration of RES. In addition, the results demonstrate that accounting for RES uncertainty with at least 6 to 8 scenarios leads to lower or comparable total costs to deterministic day-ahead forecasts, even when limiting the frequency of topological actions.

eess.SY

Review, Definition and Challenges of Electrical Energy Hubs

To transition towards a carbon-neutral power system, considerable amounts of renewable energy generation capacity are being installed in the North Sea area. Consequently, projects aggregating many gigawatts of power generation capacity and transmitting renewable energy to the main load centers are being developed. Given the electrical challenges arising from having bulk power capacity in a compact geographical area with several connections to the main grid, and a lack of a robust definition identifying the type of system under study, this paper proposes a general technical definition of such projects introducing the term Electrical Energy Hub (EEH). The concept, purpose, and functionalities of EEHs are introduced in the text, emphasizing the importance of a clear technical definition for future planning procedures, grid codes, regulations, and support schemes for EEHs and multiterminal HVDC (MTDC) grids in general. Furthermore, the unique electrical challenges associated with integrating EEHs into the power system are discussed. Three research areas of concern are identified, namely control, planning, and protection. Through this analysis, insights are provided into the effective implementation of multi-GW scale EEH projects and their integration into the power grid through multiple interconnections. Finally, a list of ongoing and planned grid development projects is evaluated to assess whether they fall within the EEH category

eess.SY

Unified Power Flow Model for Bipolar HVDC Grids in Unbalanced Operation

In the near future, point-to-point High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) systems are expected to evolve into multi-terminal and meshed HVDC grids, predominantly adopting a bipolar HVDC configuration. Normally, bipolar HVDC systems operate in balanced mode, i.e., near zero current flows through metallic or ground return. However, bipolar HVDC systems can also be operated in an unbalanced mode in case of a single converter pole or line conductor outage. A steady-state analysis of the unbalanced DC network requires solving a power flow problem including various converter control modes, as the steady-state behavior of the converters is governed by their control modes. This paper presents a comprehensive and unified power flow model for the balanced and unbalanced operation of bipolar HVDC grids, including various converter control modes on the AC and DC sides of the converter, in a hybrid AC/DC system. It extends the basic control modes, developed for monopolar HVDC grids, to support the balanced as well as unbalanced operation of bipolar HVDC grids. Additionally, an AC-droop control, which defines a droop relationship between voltage magnitude and reactive power at the AC side of the converter, is incorporated into the modeling of bipolar HVDC systems. The functionality of the proposed model is demonstrated through a test case, and the power flow results are validated using PSCAD simulations. The impact of converter control modes on post-contingency system states is also investigated for single-pole contingencies. The proposed model is implemented as an open-source tool in the Julia/JuMP framework, where larger test cases demonstrate the robustness of the model and tool.

eess.SY

AC-DC Power Systems Optimization with Droop Control Smooth Approximation

This paper addresses the challenges of embedding common droop control characteristics in ac-dc power system steady-state simulation and optimization problems. We propose a smooth approximation methodology to construct differentiable functions that encode the attributes of piecewise linear droop control with saturation. We transform the nonsmooth droop curves into smooth nonlinear equality constraints, solvable with Newton methods and interior point solvers. These constraints are then added to power flow, optimal power flow, and security-constrained optimal power flow problems in ac-dc power systems. The results demonstrate significant improvements in accuracy in terms of power sharing response, voltage regulation, and system efficiency, while outperforming existing mixed-integer formulations in computational efficiency.

math.OC

Real-Value Power-Voltage Formulations of, and Bounds for, Three-Wire Unbalanced Optimal Power Flow

Unbalanced optimal power flow refers to a class of optimization problems subject to the steady state physics of three-phase power grids with nonnegligible phase unbalance. Significant progress on this problem has been made on the mathematical modelling side of unbalanced OPF, however there is a lack of information on implementation aspects as well as data sets for benchmarking. One of the key problems is the lack of definitions of current and voltage bounds across different classes of representations of the power flow equations. Therefore, this tutorial-style paper summarizes the structural features of the unbalanced (optimal) power problem for three-phase systems. The resulting nonlinear complex-value matrix formulations are presented for both the bus injection and branch flow formulation frameworks, which typically cannot be implemented as-is in optimization toolboxes. Therefore, this paper also derives the equivalent real-value formulations, and discusses challenges related to the implementation in optimization modeling toolboxes. The derived formulations can be re-used easily for continuous and discrete optimization problems in distribution networks for a variety of operational and planning problems. Finally, bounds are derived for all variables involved, to further the development of benchmarks for unbalanced optimal power flow, where consensus on bound semantics is a pressing need. We believe benchmarks remain a cornerstone for the development and validation of scalable and reproducible optimization models and tools. The soundness of the derivations is confirmed through numerical experiments, validated w.r.t. OpenDSS for IEEE test feeders with 3x3 impedance matrices.

math.OC

Perspectives on distribution network flexible and curtailable resource activation and needs assessment

{A curtailable and flexible resource activation framework for solving distribution network (DN) voltage and thermal congestions is used to quantify three important aspects with respect to modelling low voltage networks.} This framework utilizes the network states in the absence of such flexible or curtailable resources as the input for calculating flexibility activation signal (FAS). The FAS has some similarities with optimal power flow duals {associated with power balance constraint}. FAS due to drooping design, {incentivize corrective flexibility activation} prior to any network limit violations. {The nonlinear resource dispatch optimal power flow (RDOPF) utilizes FAS for the activation of flexible and curtailable resources. Solving the OPF problem for a large system is computationally intensive, and second-order cone (SOC) relaxation is often applied in the literature.} {First,} we highlight the multi-objective nature of SOC relaxed RDOPF. A Pareto front tuning mechanism {is proposed for choosing loss penalty factor} while reducing the optimality gap of the SOC relaxed RDOPF. {Secondly, we} present a methodology for evaluating temporal and locational flexibility needs assessment of a DN, which DSO's can utilize for flexibility planning {in operational timescales and procurement in the flexibility market}. {Lastly, we} quantify the impact of reactive power flexibility for a DN with varying load power factors. {Numerical simulations indicate that the presence of reactive flexibility reduces the active power flexibility needs by 50\% for the test feeder with 0.8 aggregated load power factor.}

eess.SY

Optimal Grid Layouts for Hybrid Offshore Assets in the North Sea under Different Market Designs

This work examines the Generation and Transmission Expansion (GATE) planning problem of offshore grids under different market clearing mechanisms: a Home Market Design (HMD), a zonal cleared Offshore Bidding Zone (zOBZ) and a nodal cleared Offshore Bidding Zone (nOBZ). It aims at answering two questions. 1) Is knowing the market structure a priori necessary for effective generation and transmission expansion planning? 2) Which market mechanism results in the highest overall social welfare? To this end a multi-period, stochastic GATE planning formulation is developed for both nodal and zonal market designs. The approach considers the costs and benefits among stake-holders of Hybrid Offshore Assets (HOA) as well as gross consumer surplus (GCS). The methodology is demonstrated on a North Sea test grid based on projects from the European Network of Transmission System Operators' (ENTSO-E) Ten Year Network Development Plan (TYNDP). An upper bound on potential social welfare in zonal market designs is calculated and it is concluded that from a generation and transmission perspective, planning under the assumption of an nOBZ results in the best risk adjusted return.

eess.SP

Unbalanced OPF Modelling for Mixed Monopolar and Bipolar HVDC Grid Configurations

HVDC is a critically important technology for the large-scale integration of renewable resources such as offshore wind farms. Currently, only point-to-point and multi-terminal HVDC connections exist in real-life operation. However, with the advancement of VSC-based converter technologies, future HVDC systems are foreseen to develop into meshed HVDC grids. Bipolar HVDC grids can be operated in an unbalanced way during single pole outages or in form of mixed monopolar and bipolar grids. However, currently, there are no (optimal) power flow tools to study the feasibility of such systems. Therefore, we develop an optimal power flow (OPF) model for hybrid AC-DC grids to capture the DC side unbalances and allowing to efficiently plan and operate such future grids. In this paper, we present a multi-conductor OPF model with separate modeling of the positive pole, negative pole, metallic return conductors, and ground return. The capabilities of the model are demonstrated on a small test case, including monopolar tapping over a bipolar DC link. It is demonstrated that the developed OPF model can capture the loop flows between the different poles in unbalanced conditions, as opposed to the existing single-wire representations in the literature. Further, numerical results are presented for multiple test cases with various system sizes, starting from an 11-bus system to a 3120-bus system to demonstrate the computational tractability of the chosen model formulation.

eess.SY

Chance constrained day-ahead robust flexibility needs assessment for low voltage distribution network

For market-based procurement of low voltage (LV) flexibility, DSOs identify the amount of flexibility needed for resolving probable distribution network (DN) voltage and thermal congestion. A framework is required to avoid over or under procurement of flexibility in the presence of uncertainty. To this end, we propose a scenario-based robust chance-constrained (CC) day-ahead flexibility needs assessment (FNA) framework. The CC level is analogous to the risk DSO is willing to take in flexibility planning. Multi-period optimal power flow is performed to calculate the amount of flexibility needed to avoid network issues. Flexibility is defined in terms of nodal power ramp-up and ramp-down and cumulative energy needs over a full day for each node. Future uncertainties are considered as multiple scenarios generated using multivariate Gaussian distribution and Cholesky decomposition. These scenarios are utilized to solve the flexibility needs assessment optimal power flow (FNA-OPF) problem. Zonal clustering of an LV feeder is performed using electrical distance as a measure and spatial partitioning. The FNA tool calculates ramp-up and ramp-down flexibility's power and energy requirements. Energy and power needs are often valued differently in many energy markets. We identify the marginal value of flexibility associated with energy and power needs separately. From numerical results for an LV feeder, it is observed that zonal flexibility needs assessment is more immune to uncertainty than nodal flexibility needs, making it more useful for DSOs to evaluate day-ahead flexibility procurement. We also propose a Pareto optimal mechanism for selecting CC level to reduce flexibility needs while reducing DN congestion.

eess.SY

Flexible and curtailable resource activation in three-phase unbalanced distribution networks

The need for flexibility and curtailable resources is crucial for ensuring the healthy operation of future distribution networks (DN). In this work, we propose a network-state driven framework that distribution system operators (DSOs) can utilize for activating flexible and curtailable resources for alleviating network voltage and thermal issues, while accounting for network voltage and current imbalances. This approach assumes the availability of dynamic network state information and uses nodal sensitivities for calculating a flexibility activation signal (FAS). The signal design is motivated by volt-Var and volt-watt inverter control, and thus bounded. The FAS also considers network voltage and current imbalances and incentivizes activation of active and reactive power flexibilities for reducing imbalance in addition to mitigating voltage and thermal imbalances in a three-phase unbalanced distribution network. The FAS design resembles optimal power flow duals, often used as locational marginal prices. The gains associated with the imbalance component of the objective function of three-phase unbalanced resource activation (TPU-RA) is performed using Pareto optimality. A numerical case study is presented showing the efficacy of the proposed framework in avoiding network issues while reducing voltage unbalance factor by more than 80\%. Further, DN's flexibility needs are quantified for location and time of day.

eess.SY

Congestion Mitigation in Unbalanced Residential Networks with OPF-based Demand Management

This paper proposes a novel congestion mitigation strategy for low voltage residential feeders in which the rising power demand due to the electrification of the transport and heating systems leads to congestion problems. The strategy is based on requiring residential customers to limit their demand for a certain amount of time in exchange for economic benefits. The main novelty of the method consists of combining a thorough representation of the network physics with advanced constraints that ensure the comfort of residential users, in a scalable manner that suits real systems. The mitigation strategy is presented from a DSO perspective, and takes the form of contracts between users and system operator. The focus on user comfort aims to make the contracts appealing, encouraging users to voluntarily enroll in the proposed mitigation scheme. The presented solution is implemented as a mixed-integer multi-period optimal power flow problem which relies on a linearized three-phase power flow formulation. Calculations on 100 real-life distribution feeders are performed, to analyze the congestion-relieving potential of several possible system operator-user contracts. From a planning perspective, the results can help the system operator define contractual terms that make a specific congestion mitigation scheme effective and viable. From an operational perspective, the same calculations can be used to optimally schedule power reduction on a day-ahead basis.

eess.SY

Evaluation of voltage magnitude based unbalance metric for low voltage distribution networks

Voltage unbalance in distribution networks (DN) is expected to grow with increasing penetration of single-phase distributed generation and single-phase loads such as electric vehicle chargers. Unbalance mitigation will be a significant concern as voltage unbalance leads to increased losses, reduced motor and inverter efficiency, and becomes a limiting factor for DN operation. The true definition of the unbalance metric needs phasor measurements of network voltage and current. However, such phasor measurements are generally not available in real life and as such approximate definitions are widely used due to their simplicity. This work aims to compare the true voltage unbalance definition and approximate unbalance metrics derived from phase voltage magnitude, as phase voltage magnitudes are commonly measured by digital metering infrastructure. For the comparison, multi-period power flow simulations are performed for 161 Spanish distribution feeders with R/X ratios varying from 2.87 to 14.68. We observe that phase magnitude-based unbalance metrics reasonably approximate the true unbalance for higher R/X ratios with a varying load power factor in a DN. Furthermore, the approximate unbalance metrics slightly improve for a low DN power factor due to the increase in DN unbalance. Therefore, the phase magnitude-based unbalance metric can be utilized for approximating DN unbalance.

eess.SY