arXiv subjects

Phil Rose

Publications and source records attributed to Phil Rose.

4 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

The Voiceprint Fallacy: Why Voices Are Not Unique Biometric Imprints

In recent years, the term voiceprint has regained attention, particularly in technological applications and policy-making contexts, often carrying the assumption that a person's voice constitutes a stable and unique biometric trace analogous to a fingerprint. Yet this conception has been repeatedly criticized and rejected by forensic voice experts throughout the decades since its introduction. Although voices undoubtedly contain speaker-related information, this simplified conception obscures the highly dynamic and context-dependent nature of speech. This article revisits the voiceprint fallacy and reconsiders what can count as evidence of speaker identity by reviewing the historical development of voiceprint identification, evidence on human voice variability, developments in forensic voice comparison, research on human and automatic speaker recognition, and the recent challenge posed by deepfake speech to speaker identity. We point out that the voiceprint metaphor and its underlying implications are scientifically misleading because they transform a probabilistic source of speaker information into an imagined stable object of identity. We argue that speaker identity assessment does not require, and current evidence does not support, the existence of a stable and individually unique voiceprint. For speaker recognition and voice biometrics, this distinction motivates interpreting learned speaker representations with respect to the conditions under which they are trained and evaluated, and explicitly assessing their robustness to relevant sources of within-speaker variability, domain mismatch, and synthetic manipulation.

eess.AS↗

arXiv2026

Acoustic and perceptual differences between standard and accented speech and their voice clones

Voice cloning is often evaluated in terms of overall quality, but less is known about accent preservation and its perceptual consequences. We compare standard and heavily accented Mandarin speech and their voice clones using a combined computational and perceptual design. Embedding-based analyses showed larger original-clone distances for accented speakers in several speaker-discriminative embedding spaces, but this difference disappeared after normalizing against each speaker's within-original baseline variability. In the perception study, clones are rated as more similar to their originals for standard than for accented speakers, and intelligibility increases from original to clone, with a larger gain for accented speech. These results show that accent variation can shape perceived identity match and intelligibility in voice cloning even when it is not reflected in baseline-normalized speaker-embedding distance, and they motivate treating accent preservation as an explicit component of speaker identity preservation, rather than assuming that it is fully captured by off-the-shelf speaker-discriminative embeddings.

cs.SD↗

arXiv2026

Assessing the Ability of Neural TTS Systems to Model Consonant-Induced F0 Perturbation

This study proposes a segmental-level prosodic probing framework to evaluate neural TTS models' ability to reproduce consonant-induced f0 perturbation, a fine-grained segmental-prosodic effect that reflects local articulatory mechanisms. We compare synthetic and natural speech realizations for thousands of words, stratified by lexical frequency, using Tacotron 2 and FastSpeech 2 trained on the same speech corpus (LJ Speech). These controlled analyses are then complemented by a large-scale evaluation spanning multiple advanced TTS systems. Results show accurate reproduction for high-frequency words but poor generalization to low-frequency items, suggesting that the examined TTS architectures rely more on lexical-level memorization than on abstract segmental-prosodic encoding. This finding highlights a limitation in such TTS systems' ability to generalize prosodic detail beyond seen data. The proposed probe offers a linguistically informed diagnostic framework that may inform future TTS evaluation methods, and has implications for interpretability and authenticity assessment in synthetic speech.

cs.CL↗

arXiv2025

Forensic deepfake audio detection using segmental speech features

This study explores the potential of using acoustic features of segmental speech sounds to detect deepfake audio. These features are highly interpretable because of their close relationship with human articulatory processes and are expected to be more difficult for deepfake models to replicate. The results demonstrate that certain segmental features commonly used in forensic voice comparison (FVC) are effective in identifying deep-fakes, whereas some global features provide little value. These findings underscore the need to approach audio deepfake detection using methods that are distinct from those employed in traditional FVC, and offer a new perspective on leveraging segmental features for this purpose. In addition, the present study proposes a speaker-specific framework for deepfake detection, which differs fundamentally from the speaker-independent systems that dominate current benchmarks. While speaker-independent frameworks aim at broad generalization, the speaker-specific approach offers advantages in forensic contexts where case-by-case interpretability and sensitivity to individual phonetic realization are essential.

cs.SD↗