arXiv subjects

Seeun William Umboh

Publications and source records attributed to Seeun William Umboh.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

Online TCP Acknowledgment under General Delays

In a seminal work, Dooly, Goldman, and Scott (STOC 1998; JACM 2001) introduced the classic Online TCP Acknowledgment} problem: a sequence of $n$ packets arrives over time, and the objective is to minimize both the number of acknowledgments sent and the total delay experienced by the packets. They showed that a natural greedy algorithm, which acknowledges when the delay of pending packets equals the acknowledgment cost, is $2$-competitive. Online TCP Acknowledgment is the canonical online problem with delay, capturing the fundamental tradeoff between reducing service cost through batching and the delay incurred by pending requests. Prior work has largely focused on richer service-cost models, e.g., Multi-Level Aggregation. However, besides the work of Albers and Bals (SODA 2003), which studies maximum delay and similar objectives, not much is known beyond the sum of delay costs of requests. In this work, we study Online TCP Acknowledgment under two generalized delay-cost models. In the batch-aware model, each batch incurs a delay cost that depends on the packet delays within that batch. For the max-over-batches objective, we show that greedy remains $2$-competitive. For the sum-over-batches objective, the picture changes sharply: greedy is $Ω(n)$-competitive, and the optimal deterministic competitive ratio is $Θ(\log n)$. Our upper bounds only require the batch delay function to be monotone. In the batch-oblivious model, the delay cost is a function of the global packet-delay vector. We show that greedy is $2$-competitive for continuous submodular delay costs, and more generally under a weaker zero-coordinate diminishing-marginals condition. This yields $2$-competitive algorithms for ordered norms. Using the submodular-norm approximation of Patton, Russo, and Singla, we also obtain an $O(\log n)$-competitive algorithm for arbitrary symmetric norms.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2026

Improved Algorithms and Lower Bounds for Parametrized Metrical Service Systems

We consider the parametrized setting of the classical metrical service system (MSS) problem first studied by Bubeck and Rabani (APPROX/RANDOM 2020). In this setting, the adversary is restricted to a set of $m$ distinct request types, known to the algorithm in advance. The goal is to obtain competitive ratio bounds in terms of $m$. In this work, we make significant progress in understanding the landscape of parametrized MSS and resolve several open problems from Bubeck and Rabani. Our first main result is a tight bound for parametrized MSS on weighted stars. Previously, Bubeck and Rabani gave a randomized lower bound of $Ω(m)$ and deterministic upper bound of $O(2^m)$. We show that, surprisingly, a deterministic $O(m)$-competitive algorithm exists, matching the randomized lower bound. Our key insight is an interval covering formulation of MSS on weighted stars which enables an application of the primal-dual method. Our second main contribution is an improved lower bound construction for parametrized MSS on hierarchically separated trees (HSTs). Bubeck and Rabani's construction gave a $ω(1)$ lower bound when $m \geq 6$. Our improved lower bounds are tight for $2$-level HSTs and also rule out $O(1)$-competitive algorithms on HSTs when the parameter $m\geq 4$. We also complement these results by giving a deterministic $O(1)$-competitive algorithm on general metrics when $m=2$ while showing that it is impossible when $m\geq 3$.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2026

Online Matching with Size-Based and Convex Delays

We study the online min-cost perfect matching with delay (MPMD) problem where $m$ requests arrive in a metric space of $n$ points. In MPMD, an algorithm can choose to match a request or to delay, and the objective is to minimise the sum of connection and delay costs. The connection cost of a match is the distance between the locations of two matched requests in the metric, and the increase of the delay cost is a function of the set of unmatched requests at every moment. In this paper, we study two different types of delay functions, size-based (MPMD-Size) and convex delays (MPMD-Convex). The study of MPMD-Size was initiated by Deryckere and Umboh (APPROX/RANDOM 2023) where the instantaneous delay increment is a non-negative monotone function of the number of unmatched requests. Our bounds are in terms of $n$, as opposed to Deryckere and Umboh's bounds that depend on $m$. Our results settle the deterministic competitive ratio (up to constants). At the heart of these results is a succinct encoding scheme of MPMD-Size on a given $n$-point metric as a metrical task system problem on a $2^{n-1}$-point metric. We also consider MPMD-Convex proposed by Liu et al. (ISAAC 2018) where the delay cost incurred by each request is a uniform convex delay function of the time difference between its arrival time and the moment that it is matched by the algorithm. They focused on delay functions $f$ that are unbounded, non-decreasing, continuous, and satisfy $f(0)=f'(0)=0$, and showed that the deterministic competitive ratio is $Ω(n)$ for $n$-point uniform metrics. We show that, surprisingly, when $f$ is a non-negative, monotone polynomial with $f'(0)>0$, there is an $O(1)$-competitive deterministic algorithm for uniform metrics. Our result completes our understanding of MPMD-Convex on uniform metrics for a broad class of functions.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2026

A Radius-Sensitive Approximation Algorithm for Connected Submodular Maximization

Connected Submodular Maximization (CSM) is a graph problem with important applications to wireless network deployment, path planning, epidemic outbreaks, and cancer genome studies. In CSM, we are given a graph $G$, a non-negative monotone submodular function $f$ on subsets of the vertex set of $G$, and an integer $k$. The goal is to select a tree in $G$, with $k$ edges, whose vertex set maximizes $f$. We also study the more general Directed and Directed Rooted variants of CSM (DCSM and DRCSM respectively). In both variants, $G$ is directed and the solution must be an out-tree in $G$, with $k$ edges, whose vertex set maximizes $f$; DRCSM further specifies a vertex to be the root of the selected out-tree. For CSM, several previous works have proposed polynomial time approximation algorithms; the state-of-the-art polynomial time algorithm achieves a $Ω(\frac{1}{\sqrt{k}})$-approximation. We can also parameterize the approximation factor by the radius of the optimal solution, denoted by $r$; the state-of-the-art polynomial time algorithm achieves a $Ω(\frac{1}{r})$-approximation. In this paper, we improve on the state-of-the-art approximation factor for CSM with respect to $r$ as well as $k$, noting that $r \leq k$. We propose a polynomial time framework that, for (Directed) CSM, achieves a $Ω(\frac{\varepsilon^{3}}{{r}^{\varepsilon}})$-approximation for every constant $\varepsilon \in (0, 1]$. For DRCSM, our framework achieves a $Ω(\frac{δ\varepsilon^{3}}{{r}^{\varepsilon}})$-approximation that violates the size constraint by at most a factor of $1 + δ$ for every $δ\in [\frac{1}{k}, 1]$. A key component of our framework is GreedyRadius, which is an algorithm for DRCSM that takes another algorithm with a bicriteria approximation factor in terms of $k$ and outputs a solution with the same bicriteria approximation factor (up to constants) in terms of $r$.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2026

Improved Online Algorithms for Inventory Management Problems with Holding and Delay Costs: Riding the Wave Makes Things Simpler, Stronger, & More General

The Joint Replenishment Problem (JRP) is a classical inventory management problem, that aims to model the trade-off between coordinating orders for multiple commodities (and their cost) with holding costs incurred by meeting demand in advance. Moseley, Niaparast and Ravi introduced a natural online generalization of the JRP in which inventory corresponding to demands may be replenished late, for a delay cost, or early, for a holding cost. They established that when the holding and delay costs are monotone and uniform across demands, there is a 30-competitive algorithm that employs a greedy strategy and a dual-fitting based analysis. We develop a 5-competitive algorithm that handles arbitrary monotone demand-specific holding and delay cost functions, thus simultaneously improving upon the competitive ratio and relaxing the uniformity assumption. Our primal-dual algorithm is in the spirit of the work Buchbinder, Kimbrel, Levi, Makarychev, and Sviridenko, which maintains a wavefront dual solution to decide when to place an order and which items to order. The main twist is in deciding which requests to serve early. In contrast to the work of Moseley et al., which ranks early requests in ascending order of desired service time and serves them until their total holding cost matches the ordering cost incurred for that item, we extend to the non-uniform case by instead ranking in ascending order of when the delay cost of a demand would reach its current holding cost. An important special case of the JRP is the single-item lot-sizing problem. Here, Moseley et al. gave a 3-competitive algorithm when the holding and delay costs are uniform across demands. We provide a new algorithm for which the competitive ratio is $ϕ+1 \approx 2.681$, where $ϕ$ is the golden ratio, which again holds for arbitrary monotone holding-delay costs.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Learning-Augmented Online Algorithms for Nonclairvoyant Joint Replenishment Problem with Deadlines

This paper considers using predictions in the context of the online Joint Replenishment Problem with Deadlines (JRP-D). Prior work includes asymptotically optimal competitive ratios of $O(1)$ for the clairvoyant setting and $O(\sqrt{n})$ of the nonclairvoyant setting, where $n$ is the number of items. The goal of this paper is to significantly reduce the competitive ratio for the nonclairvoyant case by leveraging predictions: when a request arrives, the true deadline of the request is not revealed, but the algorithm is given a predicted deadline. The main result is an algorithm whose competitive ratio is $O(\min(η^{1/3}\log^{2/3}(n), \sqrtη, \sqrt{n}))$, where $n$ is the number of item types and $η\leq n^2$ quantifies how flawed the predictions are in terms of the number of ``instantaneous item inversions.'' Thus, the algorithm is robust, i.e., it is never worse than the nonclairvoyant solution, and it is consistent, i.e., if the predictions exhibit no inversions, then the algorithm behaves similarly to the clairvoyant algorithm. Moreover, if the error is not too large, specifically $η< o(n^{3/2}/\log^2(n))$, then the algorithm obtains an asymptotically better competitive ratio than the nonclairvoyant algorithm. We also show that all deterministic algorithms falling in a certain reasonable class of algorithms have a competitive ratio of $Ω(η^{1/3})$, so this algorithm is nearly the best possible with respect to this error metric.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Local Computation Algorithms for Knapsack: impossibility results, and how to avoid them

Local Computation Algorithms (LCA), as introduced by Rubinfeld, Tamir, Vardi, and Xie (2011), are a type of ultra-efficient algorithms which, given access to a (large) input for a given computational task, are required to provide fast query access to a consistent output solution, without maintaining a state between queries. This paradigm of computation in particular allows for hugely distributed algorithms, where independent instances of a given LCA provide consistent access to a common output solution. The past decade has seen a significant amount of work on LCAs, by and large focusing on graph problems. In this paper, we initiate the study of Local Computation Algorithms for perhaps the archetypal combinatorial optimization problem, Knapsack. We first establish strong impossibility results, ruling out the existence of any non-trivial LCA for Knapsack as several of its relaxations. We then show how equipping the LCA with additional access to the Knapsack instance, namely, weighted item sampling, allows one to circumvent these impossibility results, and obtain sublinear-time and query LCAs. Our positive result draws on a connection to the recent notion of reproducibility for learning algorithms (Impagliazzo, Lei, Pitassi, and Sorrell, 2022), a connection we believe to be of independent interest for the design of LCAs.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Colorful Vertex Recoloring of Bipartite Graphs

In vertex recoloring, we are given $n$ vertices with their initial coloring, and edges arrive in an online fashion. The algorithm must maintain a valid coloring by recoloring vertices, at a cost. The problem abstracts a scenario of job placement in machines (possibly in the cloud), where vertices represent jobs, colors represent machines, and edges represent ``anti affinity'' (disengagement) constraints. Online recoloring is a hard problem. One family of instances which is fairly well-understood is bipartite graphs, in which two colors are sufficient to satisfy all constraints. In this case it is known that the competitive ratio of vertex recoloring is $Θ(\log n)$. We propose a generalization of the problem, which allows using additional colors (possibly at a higher cost), to improve overall performance. We analyze the simple case of bipartite graphs of bounded largest \emph{bond} (a bond of a connected graph is an edge-cut that partitions the graph into two connected components). First, we propose two algorithms. One exhibits a trade-off for the uniform-cost case: given $Ω(\logβ)\le c\le O(\log n)$ colors, the algorithm guarantees that its cost is at most $O(\frac{\log n}{c})$ times the optimal offline cost for two colors, where $n$ is the number of vertices and $β$ is the size of the largest bond. The other algorithm is for the case where the additional colors come at a higher cost, $D>1$: given $Δ$ additional colors, where $Δ$ is the maximum degree in the graph, the algorithm guarantees $O(\log D)$ competitiveness. As to lower bounds, we show that if the cost of the extra colors is $D>1$, no (randomized) algorithm can achieve a competitive ratio of $o(\log D)$. We also show that for bipartite graphs of unbounded bond size, any deterministic online algorithm has competitive ratio $Ω(\min(D,\log n))$.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Optimal bounds on a tree inference algorithm

This paper tightens the best known analysis of Hein's 1989 algorithm to infer the topology of a weighted tree based on the lengths of paths between its leaves. It shows that the number of length queries required for a degree-$k$ tree of $n$ leaves is $O(n k \log_k n)$, which is the lower bound. It also presents a family of trees for which the performance is asymptotically better, and shows that no such family exists for a competing $O(n k \log_k n)$ algorithm.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Optimal Dynamic Parameterized Subset Sampling

In this paper, we study the Dynamic Parameterized Subset Sampling (DPSS) problem in the Word RAM model. In DPSS, the input is a set,~$S$, of~$n$ items, where each item,~$x$, has a non-negative integer weight,~$w(x)$. Given a pair of query parameters, $(α, β)$, each of which is a non-negative rational number, a parameterized subset sampling query on~$S$ seeks to return a subset $T \subseteq S$ such that each item $x \in S$ is selected in~$T$, independently, with probability $p_x(α, β) = \min \left\{\frac{w(x)}{α\sum_{x\in S} w(x)+β}, 1 \right\}$. More specifically, the DPSS problem is defined in a dynamic setting, where the item set,~$S$, can be updated with insertions of new items or deletions of existing items. Our first main result is an optimal algorithm for solving the DPSS problem, which achieves~$O(n)$ pre-processing time, $O(1+μ_S(α,β))$ expected time for each query parameterized by $(α, β)$, given on-the-fly, and $O(1)$ time for each update; here, $μ_S(α,β)$ is the expected size of the query result. At all times, the worst-case space consumption of our algorithm is linear in the current number of items in~$S$. Our second main contribution is a hardness result for the DPSS problem when the item weights are~$O(1)$-word float numbers, rather than integers. Specifically, we reduce Integer Sorting to the deletion-only DPSS problem with float item weights. Our reduction implies that an optimal algorithm for deletion-only DPSS with float item weights (achieving all the same bounds as aforementioned) implies an optimal algorithm for Integer Sorting. The latter remains an important open problem. Last but not least, a key technical ingredient for our first main result is an efficient algorithm for generating Truncated Geometric random variates in $O(1)$ expected time in the Word RAM model.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Online Probabilistic Metric Embedding: A General Framework for Bypassing Inherent Bounds

Probabilistic metric embedding into trees is a powerful technique for designing online algorithms. The standard approach is to embed the entire underlying metric into a tree metric and then solve the problem on the latter. The overhead in the competitive ratio depends on the expected distortion of the embedding, which is logarithmic in $n$, the size of the underlying metric. For many online applications, such as online network design problems, it is natural to ask if it is possible to construct such embeddings in an online fashion such that the distortion would be a polylogarithmic function of $k$, the number of terminals. Our first main contribution is answering this question negatively, exhibiting a \emph{lower bound} of $\tildeΩ(\log k \log Φ)$, where $Φ$ is the aspect ratio of the set of terminals, showing that a simple modification of the probabilistic embedding into trees of Bartal (FOCS 1996), which has expected distortion of $O(\log k \log Φ)$, is \emph{nearly-tight}. Unfortunately, this may result in a very bad dependence in terms of $k$, namely, a power of $k$. Our second main contribution is a general framework for bypassing this limitation. We show that for a large class of online problems this online probabilistic embedding can still be used to devise an algorithm with $O(\min\{\log k\log (kλ),\log^3 k\})$ overhead in the competitive ratio, where $k$ is the current number of terminals, and $λ$ is a measure of subadditivity of the cost function, which is at most $r$, the current number of requests. In particular, this implies the first algorithms with competitive ratio $\operatorname{polylog}(k)$ for online subadditive network design (buy-at-bulk network design being a special case), and $\operatorname{polylog}(k,r)$ for online group Steiner forest.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Online Computation of String Net Frequency

The net frequency (NF) of a string, of length $m$, in a text, of length $n$, is the number of occurrences of the string in the text with unique left and right extensions. Recently, Guo et al. [CPM 2024] showed that NF is combinatorially interesting and how two key questions can be computed efficiently in the offline setting. First, SINGLE-NF: reporting the NF of a query string in an input text. Second, ALL-NF: reporting an occurrence and the NF of each string of positive NF in an input text. For many applications, however, facilitating these computations in an online manner is highly desirable. We are the first to solve the above two problems in the online setting, and we do so in optimal time, assuming, as is common, a constant-size alphabet: SINGLE-NF in $O(m)$ time and ALL-NF in $O(n)$ time. Our results are achieved by first designing new and simpler offline algorithms using suffix trees, proving additional properties of NF, and exploiting Ukkonen's online suffix tree construction algorithm and results on implicit node maintenance in an implicit suffix tree by Breslauer and Italiano.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Universal Optimization for Non-Clairvoyant Subadditive Joint Replenishment

The online joint replenishment problem (JRP) is a fundamental problem in the area of online problems with delay. Over the last decade, several works have studied generalizations of JRP with different cost functions for servicing requests. Most prior works on JRP and its generalizations have focused on the clairvoyant setting. Recently, Touitou [Tou23a] developed a non-clairvoyant framework that provided an $O(\sqrt{n \log n})$ upper bound for a wide class of generalized JRP, where $n$ is the number of request types. We advance the study of non-clairvoyant algorithms by providing a simpler, modular framework that matches the competitive ratio established by Touitou for the same class of generalized JRP. Our key insight is to leverage universal algorithms for Set Cover to approximate arbitrary monotone subadditive functions using a simple class of functions termed \textit{disjoint}. This allows us to reduce the problem to several independent instances of the TCP Acknowledgement problem, for which a simple 2-competitive non-clairvoyant algorithm is known. The modularity of our framework is a major advantage as it allows us to tailor the reduction to specific problems and obtain better competitive ratios. In particular, we obtain tight $O(\sqrt{n})$-competitive algorithms for two significant problems: Multi-Level Aggregation and Weighted Symmetric Subadditive Joint Replenishment. We also show that, in contrast, Touitou's algorithm is $Ω(\sqrt{n \log n})$-competitive for both of these problems.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Maximum Unique Coverage on Streams: Improved FPT Approximation Scheme and Tighter Space Lower Bound

We consider the Max Unique Coverage problem, including applications to the data stream model. The input is a universe of $n$ elements, a collection of $m$ subsets of this universe, and a cardinality constraint, $k$. The goal is to select a subcollection of at most $k$ sets that maximizes unique coverage, i.e, the number of elements contained in exactly one of the selected sets. The Max Unique Coverage problem has applications in wireless networks, radio broadcast, and envy-free pricing. Our first main result is a fixed-parameter tractable approximation scheme (FPT-AS) for Max Unique Coverage, parameterized by $k$ and the maximum element frequency, $r$, which can be implemented on a data stream. Our FPT-AS finds a $(1-ε)$-approximation while maintaining a kernel of size $\tilde{O}(k r/ε)$, which can be combined with subsampling to use $\tilde{O}(k^2 r / ε^3)$ space overall. This significantly improves on the previous-best FPT-AS with the same approximation, but a kernel of size $\tilde{O}(k^2 r / ε^2)$. In order to achieve our result, we show upper bounds on the ratio of a collection's coverage to the unique coverage of a maximizing subcollection; this is by constructing explicit algorithms that find a subcollection with unique coverage at least a logarithmic ratio of the collection's coverage. We complement our algorithms with our second main result, showing that $Ω(m / k^2)$ space is necessary to achieve a $(1.5 + o(1))/(\ln k - 1)$-approximation in the data stream. This dramatically improves the previous-best lower bound showing that $Ω(m / k^2)$ is necessary to achieve better than a $e^{-1+1/k}$-approximation.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2023

Online Matching with Set and Concave Delays

We initiate the study of online problems with set delay, where the delay cost at any given time is an arbitrary function of the set of pending requests. In particular, we study the online min-cost perfect matching with set delay (MPMD-Set) problem, which generalises the online min-cost perfect matching with delay (MPMD) problem introduced by Emek et al. (STOC 2016). In MPMD, $m$ requests arrive over time in a metric space of $n$ points. When a request arrives the algorithm must choose to either match or delay the request. The goal is to create a perfect matching of all requests while minimising the sum of distances between matched requests, and the total delay costs incurred by each of the requests. In contrast to previous work we study MPMD-Set in the non-clairvoyant setting, where the algorithm does not know the future delay costs. We first show no algorithm is competitive in $n$ or $m$. We then study the natural special case of size-based delay where the delay is a non-decreasing function of the number of unmatched requests. Our main result is the first non-clairvoyant algorithms for online min-cost perfect matching with size-based delay that are competitive in terms of $m$. In fact, these are the first non-clairvoyant algorithms for any variant of MPMD. Furthermore, we prove a lower bound of $Ω(n)$ for any deterministic algorithm and $Ω(\log n)$ for any randomised algorithm. These lower bounds also hold for clairvoyant algorithms. Finally, we also give an $m$-competititve deterministic algorithm for uniform concave delays in the clairvoyant setting.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2022

Nested Active-Time Scheduling

The active-time scheduling problem considers the problem of scheduling preemptible jobs with windows (release times and deadlines) on a parallel machine that can schedule up to $g$ jobs during each timestep. The goal in the active-time problem is to minimize the number of active steps, i.e., timesteps in which at least one job is scheduled. In this way, the active time models parallel scheduling when there is a fixed cost for turning the machine on at each discrete step. This paper presents a 9/5-approximation algorithm for a special case of the active-time scheduling problem in which job windows are laminar (nested). This result improves on the previous best 2-approximation for the general case.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2021

On the Extended TSP Problem

We initiate the theoretical study of Ext-TSP, a problem that originates in the area of profile-guided binary optimization. Given a graph $G=(V, E)$ with positive edge weights $w: E \rightarrow R^+$, and a non-increasing discount function $f(\cdot)$ such that $f(1) = 1$ and $f(i) = 0$ for $i > k$, for some parameter $k$ that is part of the problem definition. The problem is to sequence the vertices $V$ so as to maximize $\sum_{(u, v) \in E} f(|d_u - d_v|)\cdot w(u,v)$, where $d_v \in \{1, \ldots, |V| \}$ is the position of vertex~$v$ in the sequence. We show that \prob{Ext-TSP} is APX-hard to approximate in general and we give a $(k+1)$-approximation algorithm for general graphs and a PTAS for some sparse graph classes such as planar or treewidth-bounded graphs. Interestingly, the problem remains challenging even on very simple graph classes; indeed, there is no exact $n^{o(k)}$ time algorithm for trees unless the ETH fails. We complement this negative result with an exact $n^{O(k)}$ time algorithm for trees.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2020

The Online Broadcast Range-Assignment Problem

Let $P=\{p_0,\ldots,p_{n-1}\}$ be a set of points in $\mathbb{R}^d$, modeling devices in a wireless network. A range assignment assigns a range $r(p_i)$ to each point $p_i\in P$, thus inducing a directed communication graph $G_r$ in which there is a directed edge $(p_i,p_j)$ iff $\textrm{dist}(p_i, p_j) \leq r(p_i)$, where $\textrm{dist}(p_i,p_j)$ denotes the distance between $p_i$ and $p_j$. The range-assignment problem is to assign the transmission ranges such that $G_r$ has a certain desirable property, while minimizing the cost of the assignment; here the cost is given by $\sum_{p_i\in P} r(p_i)^α$, for some constant $α>1$ called the distance-power gradient. We introduce the online version of the range-assignment problem, where the points $p_j$ arrive one by one, and the range assignment has to be updated at each arrival. Following the standard in online algorithms, resources given out cannot be taken away -- in our case this means that the transmission ranges will never decrease. The property we want to maintain is that $G_r$ has a broadcast tree rooted at the first point $p_0$. Our results include the following. - For $d=1$, a 1-competitive algorithm does not exist. In particular, for $α=2$ any online algorithm has competitive ratio at least 1.57. - For $d=1$ and $d=2$, we analyze two natural strategies: Upon the arrival of a new point $p_j$, Nearest-Neighbor increases the range of the nearest point to cover $p_j$ and Cheapest Increase increases the range of the point for which the resulting cost increase to be able to reach $p_j$ is minimal. - We generalize the problem to arbitrary metric spaces, where we present an $O(\log n)$-competitive algorithm.

cs.CG↗