Coexistence of phases and the observability of random graphs

Abstract

In a recent Letter, Yang et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 258701 (2012)] introduced the concept of observability transitions: the percolation-like emergence of a macroscopic observable component in graphs in which the state of a fraction of the nodes, and of their first neighbors, is monitored. We show how their concept of depth-L percolation---where the state of nodes up to a distance L of monitored nodes is known---can be mapped unto multitype random graphs, and use this mapping to exactly solve the observability problem for arbitrary L. We then demonstrate a non-trivial coexistence of an observable and of a non-observable extensive component. This coexistence suggests that monitoring a macroscopic portion of a graph does not prevent a macroscopic event to occur unbeknown to the observer. We also show that real complex systems behave quite differently with regard to observability depending on whether they are geographically-constrained or not.