Hardware Density Reduction To Avoid Proximal Junction Failure In Adult Spine Surgery: In Silico Case Studies and Virtual Cohort

Abstract

Background: Proximal Junctional Failure (PJF) is a post-operative complication in adult spine surgery, often requiring reoperation. Osteotomy is often used in revision surgeries, leading to 34.8% complications. Hence, suboptimal decisions might be extending hardware without osteotomy, which yields to severe Global Alignment and Proportion (GAP) scores. High GAPs increase PJF risk, but Hardware Density Reduction (HDR) might limit it. Methods: Two clinical cases were evaluated: 1) Initially operated with hardware extended to T10, GAP 10; 2) PJF at T11 and hardware extended to T3, GAP 11. Two patient-personalized spine FE models were constructed through Statistical Shape Modelling (SSM) and mesh morphing. Intervertebral Disk (IVD) fiber strain, screw pull-out force, and rod stress were evaluated for the cases 1) and 2), also for 91 virtual HDR scenarios with different GAP scores, using Finite Element (FE) simulations. Different rod and bone material properties were also assessed. Results: HDR could decrease IVD fiber strain (-70% at most) and increase screw pull-out forces (+142% at most) for cases with Ti rod and normal bone. Cr-Co rod and osteopenia, and osteoporotic bones had high PJF risk. Trade-off analyses could determine the best configurations avoiding PJF. Virtual cohort study showed that GAP 12 and 13 could not avoid PJF in any HDR scenarios either with Ti or Cr-Co rods. HDR in a UIV T10 virtual patient with GAP 11 could not de-risk in case of Cr-Co rods. UIV T3 with GAP 13 could not benefit any HDR strategy, independently of rod properties. In contrast, Ti rods might allow HDR to de-risk GAP 12 patients with UIV T3. Conclusions: HDR could avoid PJF in the patients with medium high GAP scores, depending on the screw reduction pattern, and bone and rod material properties. Remarkably, HDR technique might avoid excessive spine surgeries and minimize the surgery cost.