What the "Spotless" Mind Remembers: How Knowledge Entanglement Shapes What Leaks After Unlearning in LLMs

Abstract

Unlearning in large language models (LLMs) is usually evaluated as whether an "unlearned" fact can be recovered. We instead ask whether a fact's structural entanglement with the rest of a model's knowledge predicts whether it leaks after unlearning, whether this relationship changes systematically, and whether it is causal. Across varied unlearning algorithms (WHP and GA+KL), two domains (both fictional Harry Potter and non-fictional U.S. Senators, 2000-2010), and four models (2.7B-13B parameters), we find that before unlearning, more entangled facts are recalled more often (r = +0.39 to +0.51). WHP weakens this relationship but stays positive (r = +0.16 to +0.33); GA+KL inverts it in every domain and model size (r = -0.14 to -0.25). To our knowledge, this is the first report of this specific reversal in the unlearning literature. To confirm this is causal beyond correlation, we directly manipulate a prompt's entanglement score, holding its content, target model fixed, and show recall moves in the predicted direction and reverses sign under GA+KL in the same direction as the correlational analysis. This manipulation is our central evidence that unlearning acts on the underlying knowledge structure, not just its output. Building on this, we train a predictive model that estimates a prompt's post-unlearning factuality/hallucination profile before unlearning is run, creating a unique way of model auditing in triaging which prompts are likely to leak.