Second-Order Least Squares as a Special Case of the Polynomial Maximization Method

Abstract

We prove that optimally weighted second-order least squares (SLS) and the degree-two generalized polynomial maximization method (PMM) are the same population estimating equation for linear regression with conditionally homoskedastic non-Gaussian errors: they choose the same optimal linear combination of the first two centered residual moments, solve one population normal system, share one influence function, and attain the common asymptotic variance $c_2g_2/N$ -- the ordinary-least-squares slope-variance factor $c_2$ scaled by the PMM variance-reduction coefficient $g_2=1-\gamma_3^2/(2+\gamma_4)$ (with $\gamma_3,\gamma_4$ the error skewness and excess kurtosis). Feasible plug-in implementations are therefore first-order equivalent, with only higher-order finite-sample differences. The identity is sharp: under heteroskedasticity the unconditional PMM body and the conditional SLS weighting separate, costing efficiency for symmetric errors and consistency for asymmetric errors. Beyond degree two, PMM holds an efficiency reserve that SLS cannot reach within its second-moment span. For symmetric platykurtic errors SLS collapses to ordinary least squares for the slope, while degree-three PMM exploits kurtosis information outside the SLS moment span through a closed-form coefficient $g_3$; for canonical asymmetric laws this reserve is $30$--$50\%$ within the degree-three polynomial moment class. The Lean 4 development machine-checks the degree-specific algebraic core -- the closed forms for $g_2$ and $g_3$, the $g_2\le1$ result, the design cancellations, and the symmetric collapse -- while the general monotonicity $g_{S+1}\le g_S\le1$ is proved analytically by nesting. A Monte Carlo study illustrates the equivalence, the reserve, and the heteroskedastic boundary at finite samples.