Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Eric Thrane

Publications and source records attributed to Eric Thrane.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

How general relativity stacks up: Testing gravity by coherently combining gravitational-wave observations

A core mission of gravitational-wave astronomy is to test general relativity (GR) in the high-curvature, high-velocity regime. The field has already seen significant progress in this space, though a remaining challenge is how to combine data from a population of binary mergers. This can both boost the significance of potential GR violations, and develop a phenomenological picture of how deviations manifest in different mergers. We propose a framework to coherently combine gravitational-wave measurements to build a population-level test of physics beyond GR. We assume that deviations from GR are (i) strongest near the merger, (ii) vary smoothly with the total mass of the binary, and (iii) are most prominent in the $\ell=|m|=2$ mode. While these assumptions do not describe every possible deviation of GR, they provide us with a plausible starting point upon which a more general framework can be built. We apply our framework to 28 high signal-to-noise ratio binary black hole mergers from LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA's Fifth Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog, finding no evidence for deviations from GR. Our framework allows one to show how deviations could vary as a function of total mass of the system. We argue that such a reconstruction can be used to convincingly distinguish between systematic waveform errors and genuine GR violations.

gr-qc↗

Hostbusters: constraining $H_0$ and binary formation channels through gravitational-wave host galaxy associations

Gravitational-wave dark sirens can be combined with galaxy catalogues to provide a measurement of the Hubble constant. This inference requires assigning each potential host galaxy a probability of hosting a merger, but the appropriate weighting is uncertain because the binary merger rate may trace different galaxy properties, such as stellar mass or star formation rate, depending on the underlying formation channel. We introduce a flexible framework in which the dark-siren population is described as a mixture of two host-weighting prescriptions, with the mixing fraction inferred jointly with $H_0$. These components may be interpreted as subpopulations associated with distinct binary-formation environments. Using simulated catalogues, we show that marginalising over uncertainty in the host-population mixture preserves unbiased constraints on $H_0$, while allowing the gravitational-wave data to constrain the relative contribution of the two host populations. In particular, an A#-like detector network with $\mathcal{O}(10^3)$ dark sirens may be able to exclude scenarios in which the host population traces only one of the two weighting prescriptions. Dark-siren analyses may therefore provide robust cosmological measurements and new information about how merging compact binaries trace the galaxy population.

astro-ph.CO↗

Enhancing Event Reconstruction in Hyper-Kamiokande with Machine Learning: A ResNet Implementation

The forthcoming Hyper-Kamiokande experiment is expected to achieve unprecedented sensitivity to neutrino oscillations. Meeting these precision goals requires substantially larger Monte Carlo datasets than previous experiments to satisfy stringent systematic-uncertainty requirements. While traditional maximum-likelihood reconstruction provides high-quality event reconstruction, its per-event computational cost makes reconstruction of large, systematically varied Monte Carlo samples increasingly impractical. We demonstrate a neural-network-based reconstruction approach for the Hyper-Kamiokande far detector using simulated data with the experiment's detector geometry. Single-particle events are generated with kinetic energies from the Cherenkov threshold up to 2 GeV above threshold. The resulting PMT charge and timing information are mapped to $274\times144$ five-channel images that serve as inputs to ResNet models in the WatChMaL framework. These models (i) classify events into four particle hypotheses ($e$, $μ$, $γ$, $π^{0}$) and (ii) regress the interaction vertex, direction, and momentum of electrons and muons. The regression models achieve momentum resolutions of $1.27\%$ for muons and $2.21\%$ for electrons, angular resolutions of $0.91^\circ$ and $1.60^\circ$, and vertex resolutions of $13.6\,\mathrm{cm}$ and $17.0\,\mathrm{cm}$, better than those reported for traditional methods. The classifier improves $e$-$μ$, $e$-$γ$, and $e$-$π^{0}$ separation relative to the traditional baseline, with ROC AUC values of $0.9999995$, $0.642$, and $0.9659$. Our networks achieve inference times of 1-2 ms per event on a single GPU, yielding speed-ups of $3.2\times10^{4}$-$5.2\times10^{4}$ relative to likelihood-based reconstruction.

hep-ex↗

Joint inference for gravitational-wave signal and noise glitch: Method and application

Non-Gaussian noise transients ("glitches") in gravitational-wave observatories degrade our ability to accurately perform astrophysical inference. We present the analysis pipeline bilby_glitch, which allows for simultaneous Bayesian inference of gravitational-wave signals and glitches. Our framework is modular and built on top of the popular bilby framework, facilitating future extensions with additional glitch and signal models. We integrate transdimensional bilby into our framework and discuss three glitch models: a physically-motivated slow scattering model, and flexible sine-Gaussian and chirplet models. Using a combination of simulated and real data, we demonstrate that bilby_glitch produces reliable results. We then reanalyse two gravitational-wave events - GW191109 and GW200129 - which show signs of interesting black-hole spins, but which may also be affected by data-quality issues. Our results for GW191109 are consistent with previous analysis. For GW200129, we recover results consistent with [Payne $\textit{et al.}$, Phys. Rev. D $\textbf{106}$, 104017 (2022) ], where the evidence of spin-precession is much weaker when using the waveform approximant NRSur7dq4 in combination with wavelet-based glitch modeling. Furthermore, we show the evidence of spin precession of this event is dependent on the interplay between the waveform approximant and glitch model, since in contrast to NRSur7dq4 we find that inference with the waveform approximant IMRPhenomXPHM shows strong evidence of spin-precession when used in combination with wavelet-based glitch modeling.

gr-qc↗

Not just a phase: detecting nanohertz gravitational waves from phase alone

Unambiguously detecting a gravitational-wave background (GWB) in pulsar-timing data requires a robust detection statistic. The pulsar timing community currently relies heavily on the cross-correlation-based "optimal statistic." Its design was motivated to avoid false-positive detections from unmodeled pulsar red noise. However, recent work by van Haasteren (2025) suggests that the optimal statistic is not, in fact, optimal. Moreover, the optimal statistic is still susceptible to false positives from misspecified noise. To guard against this, analysts employ quasi-resampling methods such as phase shifts, in which complex phases are randomly assigned to each pulsar strain measurement, thereby destroying any gravitational-wave-induced correlations. Inspired by the concept of phase shifts, we introduce a formalism in which the GWB is measured entirely from phase measurements. We argue that this approach is robust against false positive detections without the need for ad hoc quasi-resampling methods. We demonstrate the feasibility of this formalism by measuring the amplitude and spectral index of a simulated GWB, injected to a simplified mock representation of a pulsar timing array data set. For this example, we use simulation-based-inference and model the phase-based likelihood using a neural circular spline flow. We show that it is possible to adequately recover the spectral parameters of the gravitational wave background signal using the phase-based likelihood. By comparing our results to ones obtained with the optimal statistic, we show how much resolving power comes from amplitude versus phase.

astro-ph.IM↗

$\texttt{BilbyFlow}$: user-friendly neural posterior estimation for gravitational-wave astronomy

Bayesian inference plays a central role in the new field of gravitational-wave astronomy. However, traditional Bayesian inference with stochastic samplers is computationally expensive, taking hours to days per event. Transformative changes are therefore required to enable the science of next-generation observatories whose event rates and signal-to-noise ratios will increase significantly over the current generation. Recent work has shown that neural posterior estimation (NPE) is a promising path forward. A neural net is trained to approximate the posterior distribution of gravitational-wave parameters, allowing generation of posterior samples in a fraction of the time required by stochastic samplers. In this work, we introduce $\texttt{BilbyFlow}$, which harnesses the power of NPE in the popular $\texttt{Bilby}$ code suite. We use $\texttt{BilbyFlow}$ to analyze a subset of 38 high-mass events from the third LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog (GWTC-3). For 29 events (76\%), we obtained an importance-sampling efficiency $>$1%, allowing us to produce reliable posterior distributions within 3 min - 1.5 hours. For the other events, with importance-sampling efficiency $\ll$1%, the run time can be as long as 35 hours. We achieve a median importance-sampling efficiency of 7%, which is roughly comparable to the $\texttt{DINGO}$ package. We aim to significantly improve this efficiency with further development to make the runtime more reliably $O(\text{min})$. $\texttt{BilbyFlow}$ is open source and $\texttt{pip}$-installable.

astro-ph.IM↗

The properties of the first continuous gravitational waves: Optimizing pulsar timing observations for supermassive black hole binary detection

Several pulsar timing arrays have reported evidence for a nanohertz gravitational-wave background. This background is thought to arise from the superposition of signals from a population of inspiraling supermassive black hole binaries. A key test of this interpretation is the search for individually resolvable binaries whose signals emerge above this background. Here we investigate this possibility by addressing two related questions: (1) what are the most probable properties of the first resolvable binary; and (2) how can pulsar timing observations be optimized to maximize its prospects for electromagnetic identification? By simulating populations of supermassive black hole binaries constrained by evidence for the gravitational-wave background and studying the loudest binary in each simulation, we infer the expected properties of the first individually resolvable systems. If MeerKAT continues its current observing strategy for a total of 9 years, the probability of detecting an individual binary is $\approx10-27\%$. Improving the timing precision by a factor of two changes this probability to $\approx11-28\%$, whereas increasing the cadence by a factor of four gives $\approx12-30\%$. Combining both improvements yields a detection probability of $\approx12-33\%$. Furthermore, implementing a high-cadence observing campaign preferentially resolves higher-frequency systems ($\gtrsim\unit[10]{nHz}$), whose shorter orbital periods make them considerably easier to identify through electromagnetic observations than lower-frequency binaries that repeat infrequently. We discuss prospects of electromagnetic follow-up of gravitational-wave resolved binaries with current high-cadence all-sky optical surveys.

astro-ph.HE↗

Licence to Bin: Accurate and Scalable Inference for Binary Neutron Stars in Next-Generation Gravitational-Wave Detectors

Next-generation gravitational-wave observatories will observe binary neutron-star mergers with much higher signal-to-noise ratios, over much longer durations and across broader frequency bands than current detectors. These long-duration signals present a major computational challenge for Bayesian parameter estimation. Reduced-order quadrature is a promising approach for accelerating inference, but in this regime its standard construction encounters severe memory and accuracy limitations. We present a practical reduced-order quadrature construction for long binary neutron-star signals with time-dependent detector response and full effects of the observatories' free-spectral range. Our approach combines improved adaptive frequency sampling, disk-backed streaming, and subbanded reduced-order quadrature construction, enabling efficient and accurate reduced-order models for signals that were previously intractable. We demonstrate for the first time reduced-order Bayesian inference on an approximately 2 h binary neutron-star signal extending down to 5 Hz and with signal-to-noise ratio 2090. We show the resulting reduced-order quadrature remains sufficiently accurate for practical inference. The full analysis is carried out in about 48 h using 128 CPU cores. We also find that, when time-dependent detector-response effects are included, a single Cosmic Explorer detector can localize such a signal to a 90% credible sky area of approximately $41~\mathrm{deg}^2$, with important implications for multimessenger astronomy and cosmology. These results demonstrate that reduced-order methods can make next-generation binary neutron-star inference computationally feasible.

astro-ph.HE↗

Revealing Four Subpopulations of Binary Black-Hole Mergers with the Fifth Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog

Gravitational-wave data are beginning to reveal a structured landscape of black-hole masses and spins, suggesting multiple formation processes are now being resolved observationally. We analyze data from LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA's (LVK's) fifth Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog and find that the population is naturally described by four distinct subpopulations. The dominant component, contributing $\simeq70\%$ of the astrophysical merger rate, is characterised by a low-mass population centred near $10M_\odot$ and is separated from heavier systems by a depletion near $14M_\odot$. This component may be associated with black holes formed from failed supernovae. Above this depletion, we find two intermediate-mass components: an unequal-mass branch pairing the lower-mass, $\simeq10M_\odot$ black hole with a heavier black hole, perhaps associated with isolated-binary/stable-mass-transfer formation, and a nearly equal-mass branch peaking near $30$--$35M_\odot$ whose low spins and mass distribution favour first-generation systems possibly born in dense stellar environments. A fourth, percent-level component extends to higher masses and is characterized by a broad mass-ratio distribution and large spin magnitudes, consistent with a hierarchical-merger population. Our four-component model is overwhelmingly preferred over a standard LVK population model by a natural-log Bayes factor of $\ln(\mathrm{BF}) = 19.2$. Our work observationally unveils a new subpopulation of black-hole mergers utilising a new hybrid data-driven and parametric-model discovery method, bringing us one step closer to understanding stellar-mass black-hole archaeology.

astro-ph.HE↗

Fortifying gravitational-wave population inference with normalizing flows

As the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaboration's (LVK's) gravitational-wave transient catalog grows, we are learning a wealth of information from the population properties of binary black hole mergers. Events in the catalog are represented with posterior samples describing the astrophysical parameters for each event. Population studies combine these samples to measure the distribution of astrophysical parameters such as black hole masses and spins. However, the posterior-sample representation of each event is only approximate. We construct a mock population with masses drawn from an astrophysically-motivated distribution with sharp features. Using this, we demonstrate that when $\gtrsim 300$ events are combined, even with each event's posterior represented by $1 \times 10^4 {-} 2 \times 10^4$ samples, the numerical error can become large enough that the resulting population inference is unreliable. We consider two solutions. In the short term, we show that nested samples (already produced by LVK analyses) can be used to more accurately describe each event in population studies. But this will only grant a temporary reprieve until the nested-sample representation becomes inadequate. In the longer term, we propose to represent each event with a normalizing flow. In order to represent each event with sufficient accuracy, each normalizing flow can be used to generate an arbitrarily large number of new posterior samples with a significantly reduced computational cost relative to traditional sampling methods. When compared to nested sampling, our normalizing flows produce posterior draws with a median of $\approx 80\%$ fewer likelihood evaluations per sample, while also providing greater opportunity for parallelization. We believe refinement of normalizing flow architectures and training techniques in future works could further reduce this per-sample cost significantly.

astro-ph.HE↗

Evidence for Three Subpopulations of Merging Binary Black Holes at Different Primary Masses

With the release of the fourth LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA gravitational-wave catalog (GWTC-4), we are starting to gain a detailed view of the population of merging binary black holes. The formation channels of these black holes is not clearly understood, but different formation mechanisms may lead to subpopulations with different properties visible in gravitational-wave data. Adopting a phenomenological approach, we find GWTC-4 data supports the presence of at least three subpopulations, each associated with a different range of black hole mass and with sharp transition boundaries between them. Each subpopulation is characterized by different distributions for either the mass ratios, the black-hole spin magnitudes or both. Subpopulation A with primary mass $m_1 \leq 27.7^{+4.1}_{-3.4} M_{\odot}$ ($90 \%$ credibility), is characterized by a nearly flat mass ratio distribution $q=m_2/m_1$, and by small spin magnitudes ($χ\leq 0.5^{+0.1}_{-0.1}$). Subpopulation B with $27.7^{+4.1}_{-3.4} M_{\odot} \leq m_1 \leq 40.2^{+4.7}_{-3.2} M_{\odot}$, has a much sharper preference for mass ratio $q \approx 1$. Subpopulation C, with $m_1 \geq 40.2^{+4.7}_{-3.2} M_{\odot}$, has support for large spin magnitudes, and tentative support for mass ratios $q\approx0.5$. We interpret these transitions as evidence for multiple subpopulations, each potentially associated with a different formation pathways. We suggest potential formation scenarios for each subpopulations, and suggest that Subpopulation B may be associated with chemically homogeneous evolution or population III stars. Our findings for Subpopulation C are largely consistent with recent claims of hierarchical mergers, but with some curious differences in properties.

astro-ph.HE↗

A universal framework to identify eccentric binary mergers: GW200105 case study

Orbital eccentricity in gravitational-wave signals from merging compact object binaries is a powerful indicator of their formation channel. Several binary black hole mergers and a neutron star--black hole merger have been reported to exhibit signs of eccentricity, but which events are identified and the significance of the eccentricity differs between studies. Measurements of eccentricity can change depending on the choice of prior. The choice of prior is subtle: eccentricity is commonly measured at an arbitrary reference frequency, which varies from study to study. We use the candidate eccentric neutron star--black hole merger GW200105_162426 as a case study, employing a range of priors and reference frequencies, and find the results to be strongly prior-driven. We show that the varied results reported across different studies can be partially reconciled by accounting for the evolution of eccentricity with reference frequency. In order to make conclusive statements about eccentricity, we propose a detection statistic that does not depend on reference frequency, and which marginalises over astrophysically-motivated distributions in eccentricity. Using this detection statistic, we find reduced support for the eccentric hypothesis for GW200105_162426: we obtain a natural log Bayes factor ln B $\leq$ 0.9 comparing the eccentric, aligned-spin hypothesis to the quasi-circular, precessing hypothesis. Our results cast doubt on the eccentric interpretation of GW200105_162426 and underscore the importance of modelling the astrophysical distributions of eccentricity in nature.

astro-ph.HE↗

Evidence of the pair instability gap from black hole masses

Stellar theory predicts a forbidden range of black-hole masses between ${\sim}50$--$130\,M_\odot$ due to pair-instability supernovae, but evidence for such a gap in the mass distribution from gravitational-wave astronomy has proved elusive. Early hints of a cutoff in black-hole masses at ${\sim} 45\,M_\odot$ disappeared with the subsequent discovery of more massive binary black holes. Here, we report evidence of the pair-instability gap in LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA's fourth gravitational wave transient catalog (GWTC-4), with a lower boundary of $44_{-4}^{+5} M_\odot$ (90\% credibility). While the gap is not present in the distribution of \textit{primary} masses $m_1$ (the bigger of the two black holes in a binary system), it appears unambiguously in the distribution of \textit{secondary} masses $m_2$, where $m_2 \leq m_1$. The location of the gap lines up well with a previously identified transition in the binary black-hole spin distribution; binaries with primary components in the gap tend to spin more rapidly than those below the gap. We interpret these findings as evidence for a subpopulation of hierarchical mergers: binaries where the primary component is the product of a previous black-hole merger and thus populates the gap. Our measurement of the location of the pair-instability gap constrains the $S$-factor for $^{12}\rm{C}(α,γ)^{16}\rm{O}$ at 300keV to $260_{-108}^{+190}$ keV barns.

astro-ph.HE↗

Are all models wrong? Falsifying binary formation models in gravitational-wave astronomy

As the catalogue of gravitational-wave transients grows, several entries appear "exceptional" within the population. Tipping the scales with a total mass of $\approx 150 M_\odot$, GW190521 likely contained black holes in the pair-instability mass gap. The event GW190814, meanwhile, is unusual for its extreme mass ratio and the mass of its secondary component. A growing model-building industry has emerged to provide explanations for such exceptional events, and Bayesian model selection is frequently used to determine the most informative model. However, Bayesian methods can only take us so far. They provide no answer to the question: does our model provide an adequate explanation for the data? If none of the models we are testing provide an adequate explanation, then it is not enough to simply rank our existing models - we need new ones. In this paper, we introduce a method to answer this question with a frequentist $p$-value. We apply the method to different models that have been suggested to explain GW190521: hierarchical mergers in active galactic nuclei and globular clusters. We show that some (but not all) of these models provide adequate explanations for exceptionally massive events like GW190521.

astro-ph.HE↗

A Gaussian process framework for testing general relativity with gravitational waves

Gravitational-wave astronomy provides a promising avenue for the discovery of new physics beyond general relativity as it probes extreme curvature and ultra-relativistic dynamics. However, in the absence of a compelling alternative to general relativity, it is difficult to carry out an analysis that allows for a wide range of deviations. To that end, we introduce a Gaussian process framework to search for deviations from general relativity in gravitational-wave signals from binary black hole mergers with minimal assumptions. We employ a kernel that enforces our prior beliefs that - if gravitational waveforms deviate from the predictions of general relativity - the deviation is likely to be localised in time near the merger with some characteristic frequency. We demonstrate this formalism with simulated data and apply it to events from Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog 3. We find no evidence for a deviation from general relativity. We limit the fractional deviation in gravitational-wave strain to as low as 7% (90% credibility) of the strain of GW190701_203306.

gr-qc↗

A comprehensive framework for phase-coherent mapping of the gravitational-wave sky with pulsar timing arrays

We present a practical implementation of a phase-coherent mapping technique for pulsar timing arrays that resolves the full complex polarisation state of the gravitational-wave sky as a function of direction and frequency. Unlike standard cross-correlation methods, this approach preserves the amplitude, phase, and polarisation of the signal in every sky pixel. The resulting maps constitute a compact, minimally processed summary of the data from which all subsequent analyses -- characterisation of a stochastic background, searches for anisotropy, and identification of individual sources -- can be derived within a single unified framework. Our implementation is fully compatible with established pulsar timing data analysis methods. We validate the framework through a series of realistic simulations with varying array configurations, noise properties, and signal types. We demonstrate robust recovery of source amplitudes and sky locations across different scenarios, and discuss the impact of polarisation leakage, noise, and direction-dependent array sensitivity on the recovery of astrophysical signals.

astro-ph.HE↗

Is GW231123 a hierarchical merger?

The binary black hole merger GW231123 is both the most massive gravitational-wave event observed and has the highest component spins measured to date. The dimensionless spins of the more massive (primary) and less massive (secondary) black holes are measured to be $χ_1 = 0.90^{+0.10}_{-0.19}$ and $χ_2 = 0.80^{+0.20}_{-0.51}$ ($90\%$ credible intervals), respectively. Its large mass and extremal spins are challenging to explain through standard binary stellar physics, though a flurry of hypothetical scenarios have been proposed. Hierarchical assembly - i.e., mergers of black holes that are themselves formed from previous generations of mergers - is generally a promising way to explain massive and rapidly spinning black holes. Here, we investigate the possibility that GW231123 was assembled hierarchically in a dense star cluster as the merger of two second-generation black holes. Taking the inferred spin values at face value, we find that it is possible ($p\approx 5\%$) that a compact binary with component spins like GW231123 could form in a cluster from hierarchical assembly.

astro-ph.HE↗

A transdimensional sampling framework for pulsar timing noise modelling

A careful characterisation of the noise processes in pulsar timing data is a prerequisite for pulsar timing array experiments. While single-pulsar noise analyses are crucial for both gravitational-wave searches and astrophysical studies, they are often computationally intensive and rely on running and comparing multiple fixed noise models. We present tPTABilby, a transdimensional Bayesian inference framework for single-pulsar noise analysis built on the Bilby library. The method flexibly models a wide range of noise processes like radiometer noise, pulse-phase jitter, intrinsic red noise, dispersion measure variations, and chromatic interstellar medium effects. By employing transdimensional sampling, tPTABilby simultaneously infers the number and type of active noise sources, providing a unified treatment of model selection and parameter estimation. We validate the methodology through simulations with known injected noise models, demonstrating accurate recovery of model probabilities and calibrated posterior distributions. We then apply this approach to a single pulsar, PSR J1713+0747, from a MeerKAT Pulsar Timing Array (MPTA) dataset, analysing the data with both tPTABilby and Enterprise, and subsequently compare the results with existing MPTA analyses through posterior predictive checks of the inferred noise spectra. Our results highlight the flexibility of transdimensional approaches to single-pulsar noise analysis, demonstrating consistency with standard fixed-model methods while providing a more statistically robust framework, and present tPTABilby as a simple and reproducible approach for PTA inference.

astro-ph.IM↗