Searcharxiv⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Gopinath Mishra

Publications and source records attributed to Gopinath Mishra.

36 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

On the Complexity of Triangle Counting using Emptiness Queries

Beame et al. [ITCS 2018 & TALG 2021] introduced and used the Bipartite Independent Set (BIS) and Independent Set (IS) oracle access to an unknown, simple, unweighted and undirected graph and solved the edge estimation problem. The introduction of this oracle set forth a series of works in a short span of time that either solved open questions mentioned by Beame et al. or were generalizations of their work as in Dell and Lapinskas [STOC 2018], Dell, Lapinskas and Meeks [SODA 2020], Bhattacharya et al. [ISAAC 2019 & Theory Comput. Syst. 2021], and Chen et al. [SODA 2020]. Edge estimation using BIS can be done using polylogarithmic queries, while IS queries need sub-linear but more than polylogarithmic queries. Chen et al. improved Beame et al.'s upper bound result for edge estimation using IS and also showed an almost matching lower bound. Beame et al. in their introductory work asked a few open questions out of which one was on estimating structures of higher order than edges, like triangles and cliques, using BIS queries. In this work, we completely resolve the query complexity of estimating triangles using BIS oracle. While doing so, we prove a lower bound for an even stronger query oracle called Edge Emptiness (EE) oracle, recently introduced by Assadi, Chakrabarty and Khanna [ESA 2021] to test graph connectivity.

cs.DS↗

Testing of Index-Invariant Properties in the Huge Object Model

The study of distribution testing has become ubiquitous in the area of property testing, both for its theoretical appeal, as well as for its applications in other fields of Computer Science. The original distribution testing model relies on samples drawn independently from the distribution to be tested. However, when testing distributions over the $n$-dimensional Hamming cube $\left\{0,1\right\}^{n}$ for a large $n$, even reading a few samples is infeasible. To address this, Goldreich and Ron [ITCS 2022] have defined a model called the huge object model, in which the samples may only be queried in a few places. In this work, we initiate a study of a general class of properties in the huge object model, those that are invariant under a permutation of the indices of the vectors in $\left\{0,1\right\}^{n}$, while still not being necessarily fully symmetric as per the definition used in traditional distribution testing. We prove that every index-invariant property satisfying a bounded VC-dimension restriction admits a property tester with a number of queries independent of n. To complement this result, we argue that satisfying only index-invariance or only a VC-dimension bound is insufficient to guarantee a tester whose query complexity is independent of n. Moreover, we prove that the dependency of sample and query complexities of our tester on the VC-dimension is tight. As a second part of this work, we address the question of the number of queries required for non-adaptive testing. We show that it can be at most quadratic in the number of queries required for an adaptive tester of index-invariant properties. This is in contrast with the tight exponential gap for general non-index-invariant properties. Finally, we provide an index-invariant property for which the quadratic gap between adaptive and non-adaptive query complexities for testing is almost tight.

cs.DS↗

Exploring the Gap between Tolerant and Non-tolerant Distribution Testing

The framework of distribution testing is currently ubiquitous in the field of property testing. In this model, the input is a probability distribution accessible via independently drawn samples from an oracle. The testing task is to distinguish a distribution that satisfies some property from a distribution that is far from satisfying it in the $\ell_1$ distance. The task of tolerant testing imposes a further restriction, that distributions close to satisfying the property are also accepted. This work focuses on the connection of the sample complexities of non-tolerant ("traditional") testing of distributions and tolerant testing thereof. When limiting our scope to label-invariant (symmetric) properties of distribution, we prove that the gap is at most quadratic. Conversely, the property of being the uniform distribution is indeed known to have an almost-quadratic gap. When moving to general, not necessarily label-invariant properties, the situation is more complicated, and we show some partial results. We show that if a property requires the distributions to be non-concentrated, then it cannot be non-tolerantly tested with $o(\sqrt{n})$ many samples, where $n$ denotes the universe size. Clearly, this implies at most a quadratic gap, because a distribution can be learned (and hence tolerantly tested against any property) using $\mathcal{O}(n)$ many samples. Being non-concentrated is a strong requirement on the property, as we also prove a close to linear lower bound against their tolerant tests. To provide evidence for other general cases (where the properties are not necessarily label-invariant), we show that if an input distribution is very concentrated, in the sense that it is mostly supported on a subset of size $s$ of the universe, then it can be learned using only $\mathcal{O}(s)$ many samples. The learning procedure adapts to the input, and works without knowing $s$ in advance.

cs.DS↗

Tolerant Bipartiteness Testing in Dense Graphs

Bipartite testing has been a central problem in the area of property testing since its inception in the seminal work of Goldreich, Goldwasser and Ron [FOCS'96 and JACM'98]. Though the non-tolerant version of bipartite testing has been extensively studied in the literature, the tolerant variant is not well understood. In this paper, we consider the following version of tolerant bipartite testing: Given a parameter $\varepsilon \in (0,1)$ and access to the adjacency matrix of a graph $G$, we can decide whether $G$ is $\varepsilon$-close to being bipartite or $G$ is at least $(2+Ω(1))\varepsilon$-far from being bipartite, by performing $\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{1}{\varepsilon ^3}\right)$ queries and in $2^{\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}(1/\varepsilon)}$ time. This improves upon the state-of-the-art query and time complexities of this problem of $\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{1}{\varepsilon ^6}\right)$ and $2^{\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}(1/\varepsilon^2)}$, respectively, from the work of Alon, Fernandez de la Vega, Kannan and Karpinski (STOC'02 and JCSS'03), where $\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}(\cdot)$ hides a factor polynomial in $\log \frac{1}{\varepsilon}$.

cs.DS↗

Efficiently Sampling and Estimating from Substructures using Linear Algebraic Queries

Given an unknown $n \times n$ matrix $A$ having non-negative entries, the \emph{inner product} (IP) oracle takes as inputs a specified row (or a column) of $A$ and a vector $v \in \mathbb{R}^{n}$, and returns their inner product. A derivative of IP is the induced degree query in an unknown graph $G=(V(G), E(G))$ that takes a vertex $u \in V(G)$ and a subset $S \subseteq V(G)$ as input and reports the number of neighbors of $u$ that are present in $S$. The goal of this paper is to understand the strength of the inner product oracle. Our results in that direction are as follows: (I) IP oracle can solve bilinear form estimation, i.e., estimate the value of ${\bf x}^{T}A\bf{y}$ given two vectors ${\bf x},\, {\bf y} \in \mathbb{R}^{n}$ with non-negative entries and can sample almost uniformly entries of a matrix with non-negative entries; (ii) We tackle for the first time weighted edge estimation and weighted sampling of edges that follow as an application to the bilinear form estimation and almost uniform sampling problems, respectively; (iii) induced degree query, a derivative of IP can solve edge estimation and an almost uniform edge sampling in induced subgraphs. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first set of Oracle-based query complexity results for induced subgraphs. We show that IP/induced degree queries over the whole graph can simulate local queries in any induced subgraph; (iv) Apart from the above, we also show that IP can solve several problems related to matrix, like testing if the matrix is diagonal, symmetric, doubly stochastic, etc.

cs.CC↗

Faster Counting and Sampling Algorithms using Colorful Decision Oracle

In this work, we consider $d$-{\sc Hyperedge Estimation} and $d$-{\sc Hyperedge Sample} problem in a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}(U(\mathcal{H}),\mathcal{F}(\mathcal{H}))$ in the query complexity framework, where $U(\mathcal{H})$ denotes the set of vertices and $\mathcal{F}(\mathcal{H})$ denotes the set of hyperedges. The oracle access to the hypergraph is called {\sc Colorful Independence Oracle} ({\sc CID}), which takes $d$ (non-empty) pairwise disjoint subsets of vertices $A_1,\ldots,A_d \subseteq U(\mathcal{H})$ as input, and answers whether there exists a hyperedge in $\mathcal{H}$ having (exactly) one vertex in each $A_i, i \in \{1,2,\ldots,d\}$. The problem of $d$-{\sc Hyperedge Estimation} and $d$-{\sc Hyperedge Sample} with {\sc CID} oracle access is important in its own right as a combinatorial problem. Also, Dell {\it{et al.}}~[SODA '20] established that {\em decision} vs {\em counting} complexities of a number of combinatorial optimization problems can be abstracted out as $d$-{\sc Hyperedge Estimation} problems with a {\sc CID} oracle access. The main technical contribution of the paper is an algorithm that estimates $m= \lvert {\mathcal{F}(\mathcal{H})}\rvert$ with $\widehat{m}$ such that { $$ \frac{1}{C_{d}\log^{d-1} n} \;\leq\; \frac{\widehat{m}}{m} \;\leq\; C_{d} \log ^{d-1} n . $$ by using at most $C_{d}\log ^{d+2} n$ many {\sc CID} queries, where $n$ denotes the number of vertices in the hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ and $C_{d}$ is a constant that depends only on $d$}. Our result coupled with the framework of Dell {\it{et al.}}~[SODA '21] implies improved bounds for a number of fundamental problems.

cs.DS↗

A Faster Algorithm for Max Cut in Dense Graphs

We design an algorithm for approximating the size of \emph{Max Cut} in dense graphs. Given a proximity parameter $\varepsilon \in (0,1)$, our algorithm approximates the size of \emph{Max Cut} of a graph $G$ with $n$ vertices, within an additive error of $\varepsilon n^2$, with sample complexity $\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon^3} \log^2 \frac{1}{\varepsilon} \log \log \frac{1}{\varepsilon})$ and query complexity of $\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon^4} \log^3 \frac{1}{\varepsilon} \log \log \frac{1}{\varepsilon})$. Since Goldreich, Goldwasser and Ron (JACM 98) gave the first algorithm with sample complexity $\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon^5}\log \frac{1}{\varepsilon})$ and query complexity of $\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon^7}\log^2 \frac{1}{\varepsilon})$, there have been several efforts employing techniques from diverse areas with a focus on improving the sample and query complexities. Our work makes the first improvement in the sample complexity as well as query complexity after more than a decade from the previous best results of Alon, Vega, Kannan and Karpinski (JCSS 03) and of Mathieu and Schudy (SODA 08) respectively, both with sample complexity $\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}^4}{\log}\frac{1}{\varepsilon}\right)$. We also want to note that the best time complexity of this problem was by Alon, Vega, Karpinski and Kannan (JCSS 03). By combining their result with an approximation technique by Arora, Karger and Karpinski (STOC 95), they obtained an algorithm with time complexity of $2^{\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}^2} \log \frac{1}{\varepsilon})}$. In this work, we have improved this further to $2^{\mathcal{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon} \log \frac{1}{\varepsilon} )}$.

cs.DS↗

Distance Estimation Between Unknown Matrices Using Sublinear Projections on Hamming Cube

Using geometric techniques like projection and dimensionality reduction, we show that there exists a randomized sub-linear time algorithm that can estimate the Hamming distance between two matrices. Consider two matrices ${\bf A}$ and ${\bf B}$ of size $n \times n$ whose dimensions are known to the algorithm but the entries are not. The entries of the matrix are real numbers. The access to any matrix is through an oracle that computes the projection of a row (or a column) of the matrix on a vector in $\{0,1\}^n$. We call this query oracle to be an {\sc Inner Product} oracle (shortened as {\sc IP}). We show that our algorithm returns a $(1\pm ε)$ approximation to ${\bf D}_{\bf M} ({\bf A},{\bf B})$ with high probability by making ${\cal O}\left(\frac{n}{\sqrt{{\bf D}_{\bf M} ({\bf A},{\bf B})}}\mbox{poly}\left(\log n, \frac{1}ε\right)\right)$ oracle queries, where ${\bf D}_{\bf M} ({\bf A},{\bf B})$ denotes the Hamming distance (the number of corresponding entries in which ${\bf A}$ and ${\bf B}$ differ) between two matrices ${\bf A}$ and ${\bf B}$ of size $n \times n$. We also show a matching lower bound on the number of such {\sc IP} queries needed. Though our main result is on estimating ${\bf D}_{\bf M} ({\bf A},{\bf B})$ using {\sc IP}, we also compare our results with other query models.

cs.DS↗

Even the Easiest(?) Graph Coloring Problem is not Easy in Streaming!

We study a graph coloring problem that is otherwise easy but becomes quite non-trivial in the one-pass streaming model. In contrast to previous graph coloring problems in streaming that try to find an assignment of colors to vertices, our main work is on estimating the number of conflicting or monochromatic edges given a coloring function that is streaming along with the graph; we call the problem {\sc Conflict-Est}. The coloring function on a vertex can be read or accessed only when the vertex is revealed in the stream. If we need the color on a vertex that has streamed past, then that color, along with its vertex, has to be stored explicitly. We provide algorithms for a graph that is streaming in different variants of the one-pass vertex arrival streaming model, viz. the {\sc Vertex Arrival} ({\sc VA}), {Vertex Arrival With Degree Oracle} ({\sc VAdeg}), {\sc Vertex Arrival in Random Order} ({\sc VArand}) models, with special focus on the random order model. We also provide matching lower bounds for most of the cases. The mainstay of our work is in showing that the properties of a random order stream can be exploited to design streaming algorithms for estimating the number of conflicting edges. We have also obtained a lower bound, though not matching the upper bound, for the random order model. Among all the three models vis-a-vis this problem, we can show a clear separation of power in favor of the {\sc VArand} model.

cs.DS↗

Grid Obstacle Representation of Graphs

The grid obstacle representation, or alternately, $\ell_1$-obstacle representation of a graph $G=(V,E)$ is an injective function $f:V \rightarrow \mathbb{Z}^2$ and a set of point obstacles $\mathcal{O}$ on the grid points of $\mathbb{Z}^2$ (where no vertex of $V$ has been mapped) such that $uv$ is an edge in $G$ if and only if there exists a Manhattan path between $f(u)$ and $f(v)$ in $\mathbb{Z}^2$ avoiding the obstacles of $\mathcal{O}$ and points in $f(V)$. This work shows that planar graphs admit such a representation while there exist some non-planar graphs that do not admit such a representation. Moreover, we show that every graph admits a grid obstacle representation in $\mathbb{Z}^3$. We also show NP-hardness result for the point set embeddability of an $\ell_1$-obstacle representation.

cs.CG↗

Hyperedge Estimation using Polylogarithmic Subset Queries

In this work, we estimate the number of hyperedges in a hypergraph ${\cal H}(U({\cal H}), {\cal F}({\cal H}))$, where $U({\cal H})$ denotes the set of vertices and ${\cal F}({\cal H}))$ denotes the set of hyperedges. We assume a query oracle access to the hypergraph ${\cal H}$. Estimating the number of edges, triangles or small subgraphs in a graph is a well studied problem. Beame \etal~and Bhattacharya \etal~gave algorithms to estimate the number of edges and triangles in a graph using queries to the {\sc Bipartite Independent Set} ({\sc BIS}) and the {\sc Tripartite Independent Set} ({\sc TIS}) oracles, respectively. We generalize the earlier works by estimating the number of hyperedges using a query oracle, known as the {\bf Generalized $d$-partite independent set oracle ({\sc GPIS})}, that takes $d$ (non-empty) pairwise disjoint subsets of vertices $A_1,\ldots,A_d \subseteq U({\cal H})$ as input, and answers whether there exists a hyperedge in ${\cal H}$ having (exactly) one vertex in each $A_i, i \in \{1,2,\ldots,d\}$. We give a randomized algorithm for the hyperedge estimation problem using the {\sc GPIS} query oracle to output $\widehat{m}$ for $m({\cal H})$ satisfying $(1-ε) \cdot m({\cal H}) \leq \widehat{m} \leq (1+ε) \cdot m({\cal H})$. The number of queries made by our algorithm, assuming $d$ to be a constant, is polylogarithmic in the number of vertices of the hypergraph.

cs.DS↗

Query Complexity of Global Minimum Cut

In this work, we resolve the query complexity of global minimum cut problem for a graph by designing a randomized algorithm for approximating the size of minimum cut in a graph, where the graph can be accessed through local queries like {\sc Degree}, {\sc Neighbor}, and {\sc Adjacency} queries. Given $ε\in (0,1)$, the algorithm with high probability outputs an estimate $\hat{t}$ satisfying the following $(1-ε) t \leq \hat{t} \leq (1+ε) t$, where $m$ is the number of edges in the graph and $t$ is the size of minimum cut in the graph. The expected number of local queries used by our algorithm is $\min\left\{m+n,\frac{m}{t}\right\}\mbox{poly}\left(\log n,\frac{1}ε\right)$ where $n$ is the number of vertices in the graph. Eden and Rosenbaum showed that $Ω(m/t)$ many local queries are required for approximating the size of minimum cut in graphs. These two results together resolve the query complexity of the problem of estimating the size of minimum cut in graphs using local queries. Building on the lower bound of Eden and Rosenbaum, we show that, for all $t \in \mathbb{N}$, $Ω(m)$ local queries are required to decide if the size of the minimum cut in the graph is $t$ or $t-2$. Also, we show that, for any $t \in \mathbb{N}$, $Ω(m)$ local queries are required to find all the minimum cut edges even if it is promised that the input graph has a minimum cut of size $t$. Both of our lower bound results are randomized, and hold even if we can make {\sc Random Edge} query apart from local queries.

cs.DS↗

On Triangle Estimation using Tripartite Independent Set Queries

Estimating the number of triangles in a graph is one of the most fundamental problems in sublinear algorithms. In this work, we provide an algorithm that approximately counts the number of triangles in a graph using only polylogarithmic queries when \emph{the number of triangles on any edge in the graph is polylogarithmically bounded}. Our query oracle {\em Tripartite Independent Set} (TIS) takes three disjoint sets of vertices $A$, $B$ and $C$ as inputs, and answers whether there exists a triangle having one endpoint in each of these three sets. Our query model generally belongs to the class of \emph{group queries} (Ron and Tsur, ACM ToCT, 2016; Dell and Lapinskas, STOC 2018) and in particular is inspired by the {\em Bipartite Independent Set} (BIS) query oracle of Beame {\em et al.} (ITCS 2018). We extend the algorithmic framework of Beame {\em et al.}, with \tis replacing \bis, for approximately counting triangles in graphs.

cs.DS↗

Disjointness through the Lens of Vapnik-Chervonenkis Dimension: Sparsity and Beyond

The disjointness problem - where Alice and Bob are given two subsets of $\{1, \dots, n\}$ and they have to check if their sets intersect - is a central problem in the world of communication complexity. While both deterministic and randomized communication complexities for this problem are known to be $Θ(n)$, it is also known that if the sets are assumed to be drawn from some restricted set systems then the communication complexity can be much lower. In this work, we explore how communication complexity measures change with respect to the complexity of the underlying set system. The complexity measure for the set system that we use in this work is the Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension. More precisely, on any set system with VC dimension bounded by $d$, we analyze how large can the deterministic and randomized communication complexities be, as a function of $d$ and $n$. In this paper, we construct two natural set systems of VC dimension $d$, motivated from geometry. Using these set systems we show that the deterministic and randomized communication complexity can be $\widetildeΘ\left(d\log \left( n/d \right)\right)$ for set systems of VC dimension $d$ and this matches the deterministic upper bound for all set systems of VC dimension $d$. We also study the deterministic and randomized communication complexities of the set intersection problem when sets belong to a set system of bounded VC dimension. We show that there exists set systems of VC dimension $d$ such that both deterministic and randomized (one-way and multi-round) complexity for the set intersection problem can be as high as $Θ\left( d\log \left( n/d \right) \right)$, and this is tight among all set systems of VC dimension $d$.

cs.CC↗

Structural Parameterization for Graph Deletion Problems over Data Streams

The study of parameterized streaming complexity on graph problems was initiated by Fafianie et al. (MFCS'14) and Chitnis et al. (SODA'15 and SODA'16). Simply put, the main goal is to design streaming algorithms for parameterized problems such that $O\left(f(k)\log^{O(1)}n\right)$ space is enough, where $f$ is an arbitrary computable function depending only on the parameter $k$. However, in the past few years, very few positive results have been established. Most of the graph problems that do have streaming algorithms of the above nature are ones where localized checking is required, like Vertex Cover or Maximum Matching parameterized by the size $k$ of the solution we are seeking. Many important parameterized problems that form the backbone of traditional parameterized complexity are known to require $Ω(n)$ bits for any streaming algorithm; e.g., Feedback Vertex Set, Even/Odd Cycle Transversal, Triangle Deletion or the more general ${\cal F}$-Subgraph Deletion when parameterized by solution size $k$. Our main conceptual contribution is to overcome the obstacles to efficient parameterized streaming algorithms by utilizing the power of parameterization. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work in parameterized streaming complexity that considers structural parameters instead of the solution size as a parameter. We focus on the vertex cover size $K$ as the parameter for the parameterized graph deletion problems we consider. At the same time, most of the previous work in parameterized streaming complexity was restricted to the EA (edge arrival) or DEA (dynamic edge arrival) models. In this work, we consider the above mentioned graph deletion problems in the four most well-studied streaming models, i.e., the EA, DEA, VA (vertex arrival) and AL (adjacency list) models.

cs.CC↗

FPT algorithms for embedding into low complexity graphic metrics

The Metric Embedding problem takes as input two metric spaces $(X,D_X)$ and $(Y,D_Y)$, and a positive integer $d$. The objective is to determine whether there is an embedding $F:X \rightarrow Y$ such that $d_{F} \leq d$, where $d_{F}$ denotes the distortion of the map $F$. Such an embedding is called a distortion $d$ embedding. The bijective Metric Embedding problem is a special case of the Metric Embedding problem where $|X| = |Y|$. In parameterized complexity, the Metric Embedding problem, in full generality, is known to be W-hard and therefore, not expected to have an FPT algorithm. In this paper, we consider the Gen-Graph Metric Embedding problem, where the two metric spaces are graph metrics. We explore the extent of tractability of the problem in the parameterized complexity setting. We determine whether an unweighted graph metric $(G,D_G)$ can be embedded, or bijectively embedded, into another unweighted graph metric $(H,D_H)$, where the graph $H$ has low structural complexity. For example, $H$ is a cycle, or $H$ has bounded treewidth or bounded connected treewidth. The parameters for the algorithms are chosen from the upper bound $d$ on distortion, bound $Δ$ on the maximum degree of $H$, treewidth $α$ of $H$, and the connected treewidth $α_{c}$ of $H$. Our general approach to these problems can be summarized as trying to understand the behavior of the shortest paths in $G$ under a low distortion embedding into $H$, and the structural relation the mapping of these paths has to shortest paths in $H$.

cs.CG↗

On the streaming complexity of fundamental geometric problems

In this paper, we focus on lower bounds and algorithms for some basic geometric problems in the one-pass (insertion only) streaming model. The problems considered are grouped into three categories: (i) Klee's measure (ii) Convex body approximation, geometric query, and (iii) Discrepancy Klee's measure is the problem of finding the area of the union of hyperrectangles. Under convex body approximation, we consider the problems of convex hull, convex body approximation, linear programming in fixed dimensions. The results for convex body approximation implies a property testing type result to find if a query point lies inside a convex polyhedron. Under discrepancy, we consider both the geometric and combinatorial discrepancy. For all the problems considered, we present (randomized) lower bounds on space. Most of our lower bounds are in terms of approximating the solution with respect to an error parameter $ε$. We provide approximation algorithms that closely match the lower bound on space for most of the problems.

cs.CG↗

Improved Algorithms for the Evacuation Route Planning Problem

Emergency evacuation is the process of movement of people away from the threat or actual occurrence of hazards such as natural disasters, terrorist attacks, fires and bombs. In this paper, we focus on evacuation from a building, but the ideas can be applied to city and region evacuation. We define the problem and show how it can be modeled using graphs. The resulting optimization problem can be formulated as an integer linear program. Though this can be solved exactly, this approach does not scale well for graphs with thousands of nodes and several hundred thousands of edges. This is impractical for large graphs. We study a special case of this problem, where there is only a single source and a single sink. For this case, we give an improved algorithm \emph{Single Source Single Sink Evacuation Route Planner (SSEP)}, whose evacuation time is always at most that of a famous algorithm \emph{Capacity Constrained Route Planner (CCRP)}, and whose running time is strictly less than that of CCRP. We prove this mathematically and give supporting results by extensive experiments. We also study randomized behavior model of people and give some interesting results.

cs.DS↗