Disentangling the effects of sea surface temperature and CO$_2$ in global machine learned weather-climate emulators

Abstract

While previous versions of the Ai2 Climate Emulator (ACE) have been trained with CO$_2$ as a forcing, they are only accurate within a narrow range of scenarios, for example climate over the last 80 years forced by observed sea surface temperature (SST), sea ice, and CO$_2$ (AMIP), or equilibrium or near-equilibrium climates with CO$_2$ concentrations ranging from 1x to 4x that of the present day. Attempting to simulate climate forced by AMIP SST perturbed by +4 K or the response to an abrupt quadrupling of CO$_2$, results in unphysical behavior. We attribute this to these models being trained on datasets where the SST and CO$_2$ are correlated, limiting their ability to accurately learn their separate effects. In this study we introduce a new class of "random-CO$_2$" reference simulations where the SST and CO$_2$ are prescribed to vary independently. Trained on a balance of AMIP, equilibrium-climate, and random-CO$_2$ data, and including a total energy conservation constraint for improved interpretability, we present a more data-efficient model that not only accurately emulates its reference model in scenarios in which previous models excelled, but also scenarios like AMIP +4 K and slab-ocean-coupled abrupt 4xCO$_2$ where they did not. Limitations are that it has simplified or prescribed representations of other Earth system components like the ocean, land, and sea ice; does not expose other known climate drivers as forcings; and relies solely on physics-based model output for training data, inheriting the biases relative to observations thereof. Each of these represent opportunities for future work.